The Wonders of the World Point to a Creator
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 25 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav shows that the wonders of creation, down to the human body, plainly point to a Maker, and that denial of Him comes from rationalization, not from knowledge.
The Rav opens by recalling that emunah is an inheritance from the Avos and that a Jew believes instinctively unless he tries to deny it. Such denial is rationalization: Esav blamed his wives for losing the brachos, idol worshippers sought permission for forbidden relations, and Chazal read 'do not stray after your heart and your eyes' as heresy and immorality, because lust leads a person to justify himself with kefirah. He tells the story he once told ten-year-olds about two Africans who explained a watch with bugs chasing cheese, likening it to scientists' changing theories, while the Maker's own account is in the Torah. The kashas are weak; the Chovos Halevavos's mashal of a painting made by a splash of paint shows the absurdity, and Dovid HaMelech sings of creation's wonders. From the human body, the foot and the S-shaped spine, one sees the Creator. He ends with a Yemenite woman who doubted a spaceship, showing there is no conflict between absolute knowledge and Torah, only between theories and Torah.
Topics: Creation and Its Wonders · Foundations of Emunah · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Denial as rationalization
The Rav recalls that emunah is inherited from the Avos and that a Jew believes instinctively. He shows that denial is rationalization: Esav blamed his wives for losing the brachos, and Chazal read 'after your heart and your eyes' as heresy and immorality, since desire leads a person to justify himself with kefirah.
-
4:40 The Africans and the watch Story
The Rav tells the story he once told ten-year-olds who had been taught evolution: two Africans explained a watch with bugs chasing cheese and 'proved' it by hearing them stamp. He likens this to scientists who publish ever-changing theories of how the world came by itself.
-
10:36 The Maker's own book and the painting listed in the guide
As Rabbi Pinkus told the Africans to read the watchmaker's book, the Rav says the Maker wrote the account of creation in Sefer Bereishis, but people avoid it because it obligates them. The kashas are weak; he brings the Chovos Halevavos's mashal of a masterpiece made by a splash of paint, and Dovid HaMelech's song of the wonders of creation.
-
16:15 Seeing the Creator in the human body listed in the guide
Citing Iyov's 'from my flesh I see G-d', the Rav describes a diagram of the foot at a doctor's office and an anatomy textbook full of wonders, and explains why the spine is shaped like an S. Medicine assumes everything in the body has a purpose; such wonders cannot come from an explosion.
-
21:47 The Yemenite woman and the spaceship listed in the guide
The Rav tells of a Yemenite Jewish woman who denied the first spaceship because the gates of heaven are in Yerushalayim, having not learned Rashi. He concludes that absolute knowledge never conflicts with the Torah, only theories do, and that denying the Creator is rationalization by people too weak to keep the Torah.
The shiur, written up
Denial as rationalization
The Rav recalls that emunah is an inheritance from the Avos, and a Jew believes in the Ribono shel Olam instinctively unless he tries to deny it. Esav, who the Midrash says committed the gravest sins the day he turned fifteen, saw Yaakov get the brachos and decided his wives were to blame, so he married Machalas from Yishmael's family. That, the Rav says, is rationalization. b,a
The Africans and the watch
Over forty years earlier, ten-year-olds he taught had been given a smattering of evolution, and the Rav told them a story. Two illiterate but intelligent Africans in Rabbi Pinkus's office saw a watch for the first time. One concluded that inside were tubes of bugs chasing cheese on splinters, each tied by a string to a hand, the big bugs pulling the second hand and the tiny ones the hour hand. The other 'proved' it: hold the watch to your ear and you hear the bugs stamping.
So too, the Rav says, scientists, who are no more often unbelievers than butchers or bakers but have journals, publish theories of a big blast and millions of years, and change them every ten years.
The Maker's own book
The Creator in the human body
Iyov says 'from my flesh I see G-d'. The Rav describes a foot doctor's diagram where every nerve and vein has its place; one item out of place would cripple a person. Medicine assumes nothing in the body is extra, and an anatomy book he read had wonders on every page. j
The spine is shaped like an S so it bends like a spring; a straight one would crack in a fall. Such wonders cannot come from an explosion.
The Yemenite woman and the spaceship
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 0:00
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Key points
- 0:00 A Jew believes in Hashem instinctively; denial comes only when he tries to deny it.
- 4:19 Kefirah is rationalization: a person who wants to follow his desires looks for a justification and finds it in denying the Torah.
- 10:02 Scientists' theories of how the world came about keep changing, while the Maker Himself wrote the account of creation in the Torah.
- 13:20 Every part of the world, and every detail of the human body, shows that there is a Maker who made it and controls it.
- 23:45 There is no contradiction between absolute scientific knowledge and the Torah, only between changing theories and the Torah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:27 Why do Chazal connect heresy with 'your eyes', when the eyes are drawn to immorality, not to heresy?
Answer: 4:16 Because one who follows his lusts will justify himself by saying the Torah is no good; desire brings him to kefirah.
-
Question: 11:14 If there is a book written by the Maker explaining how the world was made, why don't the scientists go to it?
Answer: 11:24 Because reading further they would find 'do not murder, do not commit adultery, do not steal', which they cannot accept, so they rationalize.
-
Question: 19:26 Why is the human spine shaped like an S rather than straight?
Answer: 19:45 So that it works like a spring and absorbs pressure; a straight spine would crack when one jumps from a height.
Stories
-
4:40 The Africans who explained a watch
Over forty years earlier, when the Rav taught ten-year-olds who had been taught evolution, he told them this story. Two illiterate but intelligent Africans, working in the principal's office of Rabbi Pinkus, saw a watch for the first time and wondered what made it go. One declared that inside were tubes with bugs, each with cheese before its nose and a string from its tail to a hand, the big bugs pulling the second hand and the smaller ones the minute and hour hands. The other 'proved' it by holding the watch to his ear and hearing the bugs stamp. Rabbi Pinkus told them their theory was very smart, but once they could read they should find the watchmaker's book in the library.
In the story: Rabbi Shimshon Pincus
-
21:50 The Yemenite woman and the spaceship
When the first spaceship was sent around the world, the Rav read in the New York Times an interview with a Jewish woman from Yemen about the Russians' feat. She said it could not be true, because she had heard from her father that the gates of heaven are in Yerushalayim, so a spaceship could not reach the heavens without passing through Yerushalayim. The Rav says she knew the Chumash but had not learned Rashi, who explains that tefillos go up through Yerushalayim, not that a ride to the heavens must pass there.
Insights
- 3:35 The Rav reads Chazal's linking of 'after your eyes' with heresy as cause and effect: a person does not become a heretic and then sin; he wants to sin and becomes a heretic to justify it.
- 2:07 Esav's claim that his wives cost him the brachos is the Rav's model of rationalization: he decides he himself is worthy and looks for something else to blame.
- 11:24 People avoid the Torah's account of creation not because of its content but because reading on leads to 'do not murder, do not steal', and one cannot drive through life with the brakes on.
- 17:57 Medical science itself assumes that every detail in the body has a purpose and searches for it, which is an admission of design.
- 21:31 Apparent conflicts between science and Torah resemble the Yemenite woman's kasha: they come from knowing Chumash without its meforshim, and are answered by learning more Torah, not less.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Iyov, Machalas, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Shimshon Pincus, Rivka Imeinu, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה, כפירה, מינות, עולם הבריאה, עם הארץ, עריות, קושיא, רבונו של עולם