Exterminating Parasites of Emunah The Halachos of Believing in Mashiach EMUNAH #2 The Seven Wonders of Judaism: A series of Lectures that enrich the Emunah Series #1.
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 24 Pocket Guide p. 72 English 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav teaches that doubts in emunah are defeated by ignoring them, and then learns the Rambam's halachos of Moshiach, explaining why one who does not wait for him is a kofer and why a Moshiach without miracles is the greatest wonder of all.
The Rav begins by comparing doubts in emunah to mazikim, harmful spirits that are real but have no true power. Following Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, he says one must not argue with them but ignore them, as one nullifies chametz and as Avraham Avinu threw dust at the kings. Pushing such thoughts away fulfills the mitzvah of emunah, and like the geulah, a person's private exile has an end that Hashem can hasten. He then turns to the Rambam's Hilchos Melachim, chapters 11 and 12. He asks why one who believes in Moshiach but does not wait for him is a kofer, and answers that real belief in the promised good would bring longing, as with the Yismach Moshe. He shows Moshiach in the Torah, explains Rabbi Akiva and Ben Koziva, the difference between presumed and certain Moshiach, and argues that the Rambam's Moshiach without miracles is the greater wonder.
Topics: Awaiting Moshiach · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Ignoring the mazikim of doubt listed in the guide
The Rav compares thoughts of doubt to mazikim, real but powerless, and brings the advice of Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk to ignore them rather than argue. He links this to the strictness of chametz, which symbolizes the yetzer hara and is removed by declaring it nothing.
-
4:24 Dust on the kings and a private geulah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Avraham Avinu defeated the kings by throwing dust, treating them as nothing, and says the doubts will pass and emunah will shine brighter. Ignoring them fulfills 'lo sasuru' and the mitzvah of emunah, and Hashem can shorten a person's trial as with the geulah; he closes with a brachah for Yom Tov.
-
10:18 The Rambam's halachos of Moshiach listed in the guide
Opening a new shiur, the Rav notes that the Rambam ends his Yad HaChazakah with the halachos of Moshiach in Hilchos Melachim chapters 11 and 12, so that one knows how to fulfill the belief in Moshiach and how to recognize him. He reads that one who does not believe in him or does not wait for him is a kofer.
-
13:53 Why not waiting makes one a kofer listed in the guide
The Rav asks why a comfortable man who believes in Moshiach but is not interested is called a kofer, and answers from the Rambam's description of the bounty of the days of Moshiach: one who truly believed would long for him. He tells of the Yismach Moshe and the Chafetz Chaim waiting for Moshiach and points to the words of davening.
-
19:14 Moshiach in the Torah listed in the guide
Following the Rambam, the Rav shows the promise of Moshiach in Parshas Nitzavim and in Bilaam's prophecy in Balak, noting that the Torah does not fear to predict. He remarks that Balak is read as the Three Weeks begin, mentions the three added cities of refuge, and says one should not think Moshiach must perform miracles.
-
23:19 Rabbi Akiva and Ben Koziva Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells how Rabbi Akiva declared Ben Koziva, a powerful and righteous king who fought Rome, to be Moshiach, and how his death showed he was not. He explains that Rabbi Akiva did not truly err: in every generation there is a potential Moshiach, as the Gemara says of Chizkiyahu, and the people's sins spoiled it.
-
27:07 Presumed Moshiach and certain Moshiach listed in the guide
The Rav notes that the next lines of the Rambam were removed by censors and restored from uncensored editions and manuscripts. Explaining chazakah with examples of meat and shechitah, he shows that a king from Beis David who learns Torah and fights Hashem's wars is presumed Moshiach, while one who builds the Beis HaMikdash and gathers Jewry is certainly Moshiach.
-
33:41 The greater wonder of the Rambam's Moshiach listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Raavad's dispute that Moshiach will show miracles and clarifies that the Rambam only says miracles are not required. He then argues that a Moshiach whom all Jews follow to Yerushalayim, and who settles the exact place of the mizbeach so that all accept it, is the greatest wonder, and closes with wishes for the summer.
The shiur, written up
Ignoring the mazikim of doubt
The Rav compares thoughts of doubt to mazikim, harmful spirits that are real though unseen, as the Gemara at the beginning of Berachos describes them wearing out clothes. The advice of Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk is to ignore them: one argues only with logic, so one does not argue with them but says Shema Yisrael. a
Dust on the kings and a private geulah
Avraham Avinu, the Rav explains, threw dust at the kings to show they were nothing. So too these thoughts pass, perhaps after years, and emunah then shines brighter than before. Refusing to explore them, unlike the meraglim, fulfills 'lo sasuru' and the mitzvah of 'Anochi Hashem', a tikkun for all sins. e,f
The Rambam's halachos of Moshiach
Opening a new shiur, the Rav notes that the Rambam closes his work with the halachos of Moshiach in Hilchos Melachim chapters 11 and 12, so one knows how to fulfill this belief and recognize Moshiach. The Rambam rules that one who does not believe in him, or does not wait for him, is a kofer in the Torah and the Nevi'im. h,i
Why not waiting makes one a kofer
The Rav asks why a man with a thriving business and a summer home, who believes but is simply not interested, is a kofer. He answers from the end of the Rambam: in the days of Moshiach there will be bounty, health and peace. A man told he would be elected president tomorrow would wait; one who does not wait does not truly believe. j
Moshiach in the Torah
The Rambam shows Moshiach in the Torah: in Nitzavim Hashem promises to gather the scattered even from the end of the heavens, and Bilaam in Balak speaks of two Meshichim. The Torah, the Rav notes, does not fear to predict, and Balak is read as the Three Weeks begin. One should not think Moshiach must perform miracles. m,n
Rabbi Akiva and Ben Koziva
Rabbi Akiva declared Ben Koziva, a righteous king in Beitar who fought Rome, to be Moshiach, though he made no miracles; when he was killed it was clear he was not. The Rav says Rabbi Akiva saw the soul of Moshiach in him, but the people's sins spoiled it, as the Gemara says Hashem wished to make Chizkiyahu Moshiach. Every generation has such a Jew prepared. p,q
Presumed Moshiach and certain Moshiach
The next lines of the Rambam were removed by the censors and are restored from uncensored editions and manuscripts. To explain them, the Rav describes chazakah: meat that is presumed kosher stays kosher despite a doubt, and one may even make a brachah on it, yet a chazakah is not a guarantee, and a proven fact overrides it.
So the Rambam rules that a king of Beis David who learns Torah, compels Jews to keep it and fights Hashem's wars is presumed Moshiach, as Ben Koziva was until he was killed. One who builds the Beis HaMikdash and gathers all Jews is certainly Moshiach. The Kesef Mishneh brings the Rambam's sources. r,s
The greater wonder of the Rambam's Moshiach
The Raavad disputes the Rambam and holds that Moshiach will show miracles, even lions eating straw. The Rav clarifies that the Rambam only says miracles are not required to establish him, as lesser men like the Ba'al Shem Tov showed them. Still, the Raavad's Moshiach seems more exciting, and the Rambam's seems pale. t
Yet the Rav argues the Rambam's Moshiach makes the biggest miracle. Everyone will leave the stores of 47th Street and the marble homes of Flatbush to run after him. And the Rambam in Hilchos Beis HaBechirah requires the mizbeach on its exact spot, which today is disputed. u
Today every rav would hold a different opinion about such a question. When Moshiach speaks, all Jews will listen and agree, worshipping in one Beis HaMikdash; that, says the Rav, is the greatness of the Rambam's Moshiach. He closes with wishes for a summer of Torah.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
- c apparently Tosafos, beginning of Pesachim (2a) index In the write-up: 2:56
- h apparently Hilchos Melachim ch. 11-12 index In the write-up: 10:43
- i Hilchos Melachim 11:1 text index In the write-up: 10:43
- j apparently Hilchos Melachim 12:5 index In the write-up: 14:13
- p apparently Hilchos Melachim 11:3 index In the write-up: 23:55
- r apparently Hilchos Melachim 11:4 index In the write-up: 27:55
- t Raavad's glosses on the Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:58
- u apparently Hilchos Beis HaBechirah 2:1-2 index In the write-up: 36:43
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:08 Doubts in emunah are like mazikim: one defeats them by ignoring them and declaring them nothing, not by arguing with them.
- 7:02 Pushing away such thoughts is not a sin but a chance to fulfill the mitzvah of emunah, which is a tikkun for all sins.
- 14:09 According to the Rambam, one who does not wait for Moshiach is a kofer, because true belief in the promised good would make a person long for it.
- 24:14 In every generation there is a Jew who could be Moshiach if the people merit it; Ben Koziva was such a person, and his death showed he was not Moshiach.
- 32:27 The Rambam distinguishes between one who is presumed to be Moshiach and one who is certainly Moshiach, like the halachic difference between a chazakah and certain knowledge.
- 39:44 The Rav argues that a Moshiach who gathers all of Jewry and builds the Beis HaMikdash, with everyone accepting his word, is a greater wonder than the miracles the Raavad expects.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:58 Why are we so stringent with chametz, requiring search and nullification even for a tiny amount, more than for any other prohibition?
Answer: 3:37 Because chametz symbolizes the yetzer hara, and the main removal is to nullify it, declaring it nothing.
-
Question: 14:09 Why is one who believes in Moshiach but does not wait for him a kofer?
Answer: 17:00 Because if he really believed in the bounty the Rambam describes, he would long for Moshiach; not waiting shows he does not truly believe.
-
Question: 24:07 Did Rabbi Akiva make a mistake in declaring Ben Koziva Moshiach?
Answer: 24:10 Not really: Ben Koziva could have been Moshiach and had the soul of Moshiach, but the sins of the people spoiled it.
-
Question: 36:10 Does the Rambam's view that Moshiach need not perform miracles make him a lesser Moshiach than the Raavad's?
Answer: 36:40 No: gathering every Jew to Eretz Yisrael and building the Beis HaMikdash with all accepting his word is the greatest miracle of all.
Stories
-
17:37 The Yismach Moshe runs from the mikvah
The Yismach Moshe was expecting his son, who later succeeded him, to visit for Yom Tov, and went to the mikvah. As he came out, the gabbai told him that 'he came'. He grabbed his clothes and ran out without putting on his socks, asking where he was; when they pointed out his son, he burst out crying, for he had thought Moshiach had come.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe
-
23:28 Rabbi Akiva and Ben Koziva
Ben Koziva was a powerful king and a tzaddik who ruled from the city of Beitar, had an army and went to war against the Romans. Rabbi Akiva, the greatest of the Tanna'im, was his right-hand man and announced that he was Moshiach. The Romans captured and destroyed Beitar and Ben Koziva was killed, and then it became known that he was not Moshiach. He had performed no miracles.
In the story: Rabbi Akiva, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva)
Insights
- 3:43 The Rav reads the strictness of chametz, nullified by declaring it nothing, as the model for handling thoughts of doubt: the best removal is to treat them as a 'minus quantity' rather than to engage them.
- 4:25 He explains Avraham Avinu throwing dust at the kings as a way of declaring them nothing, the same weapon one uses against doubts.
- 6:42 He reads 'lo sasuru' as a warning not to scout out such thoughts the way the meraglim scouted, trying to explore them and argue against them.
- 8:32 Like the 'be'itah' and 'achishenah' of the general geulah, an individual's trial has a fixed end, but Hashem can shorten it for one who stands firm in emunah, as the exile in Mitzrayim was shortened from 400 to 210 years.
- 17:12 Not waiting for Moshiach shows a lack of belief: a man who knew he would be elected president tomorrow would surely wait for it, so one who truly believed in the promised good would long for Moshiach.
- 24:10 Rabbi Akiva did not truly err about Ben Koziva: he saw in him the soul of Moshiach, and it was the sins of the generation that spoiled it.
- 39:34 The Rambam's Moshiach, who would have every Jew leave his business to follow him and would settle disputes over the place of the mizbeach so that all accept it, is a greater miracle than the wonders the Raavad expects.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 1:47 The Rav says not to argue with thoughts of doubt in emunah but to ignore them and say Shema Yisrael.
- 5:21 He says one should not worry when such thoughts come; they will pass, even if it takes weeks or years, and emunah will be brighter than before.
- 18:47 He says one who says 'ki lishuascha kivinu' in davening must truly long for Moshiach, not say a falsehood before Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Bilaam, Dovid HaMelech, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, Sancheiriv, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Raavad, the Rambam, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu
Terms בחזקת משיח, ביעור חמץ, בעתה אחישנה, ימות המשיח, יצר הרע, כפירה, מזבח, מזיקים, נסיון