פרקי אבות The Evils of a תלמיד חכם with Bad מדות

צד א: כל הלומד תורה לשמה וכו' נקרא ריע, אהוב, אוהב 'את המקום וכו צד ב: משמח את המקום' משמח את הבריאות

Catalog entry: MISCELLANEOUS (English) no. ⁨11⁩ Pocket Guide p. 69 תשל"ז (1976–77) English 1 hr 18 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 18 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains the Mishnah in Avos that one who learns Torah lishmah is a friend and beloved of Hashem and of people, and warns that Torah learning without good middos makes a person worse.

The Rav opens with the Mishnah that one who learns Torah lishmah is called a friend and beloved, loving Hashem and people. Every person longs to love and be loved, and the Torah channels this through two mitzvos: loving one's fellow and loving Hashem. All creatures deserve love because Hashem made them. Love between friends is the precondition for love of Hashem, as a story of two friends and a king shows, and shirah, like the malachim's, needs harmony. Through the Medrash on Shir HaShirim and a mashal of a car dealer he shows how priceless Hashem's love for a tzaddik is. He explains how love can be commanded, how Torah clothes a person in anavah and conditions him to be a tzaddik, with stories of tzaddikim kept from forbidden food. On the second side he stresses that learning without menschlichkeit makes a person worse, bringing the four animals with one kosher sign and the yetzer hara disguised as 'Yesh'.

Topics: Pirkei Avos · Middos Tovos · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah · Ahavas Yisroel and Achdus

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The Mishnah and the human need to love listed in the guide

    The Rav reads the Mishnah that one who learns Torah lishmah is called a friend and beloved, and explains that tzaddikim use the inborn desire to love and be loved for its true purpose. He explains why one must love all creatures, even a non-Jew and even insects, because Hashem made them.

  2. 5:46 Love of friends and the king who joined

    The Rav says there can be no love of Hashem without love between friends, and tells of two friends in Rome, each ready to die for the other, whom the king asked to take into their friendship. He adds that malachim can sing shirah only because they love each other, since shirah means harmony.

  3. 9:54 Malachim, the classroom, and the shirah at the Yam Suf

    The Rav contrasts competition in a classroom with the malachim who give each other permission to sing out of love. At the splitting of the sea the Yidden sang shirah in place of the malachim, so they too needed that love, which is the key to a connection with Hashem.

  4. 13:17 A love no wealth can buy listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the passuk in Shir HaShirim that many waters cannot extinguish the love between Hashem and Klal Yisrael, and the Medrash of a tzaddik's coffin that floated in the air. With a mashal of a customer offering a few dollars for an expensive car, he explains why offering all one's wealth for that love would be scorned, and says one reaches it through Torah lishmah.

  5. 19:16 Can love be commanded; anavah as a garment listed in the guide

    The Rav answers the bochurim's question how the Torah can command a feeling: every Jew has the love in potential, and Torah lishmah makes it flare up. He then explains that Torah clothes a person in anavah, which is like a coat that can be put on and taken off, and that it takes da'as to know when to use it.

  6. 22:31 Torah prepares a person to be a tzaddik listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Torah lishmah prepares a person to be a tzaddik even in matters beyond his control, such as forbidden food that dulls his feeling for kedushah. Since one cannot be careful enough, tzaddikim need siyata dishmaya, and he tells of a tzaddik who sensed any doubt in his food and would not eat a questionable piece of chicken.

  7. 26:05 The pancake that squirted Story

    The Rav tells of a gadol who, at a Rav's lunch, became absorbed in pilpul and did not eat a pancake that turned out to have been made with butter in a fleishig pan. He said it was not ruach hakodesh: the hot fat squirted into his face while he learned, so he concluded it could not be kosher.

  8. 29:12 A Rebbe and the untoveled dishes Story

    The Rav retells a story he heard from an elderly Yerushalmi in his shul in Williamsburg: a Rebbe in Yerushalayim came to eat at a beardless yerei shamayim, did not touch the fish, and discovered that the dishes, borrowed from a chassid with a beard and peyos, had not been toveled. The Rebbe told the host what each would be asked in the next world.

  9. 33:49 The gabbai and the knife Story

    The Rav tells a story he heard from Mr. Singer, a man in the shul of his youth: a Rebbe's gabbai, a great tzaddik, stayed with Mr. Singer's father for Shabbos, and refused a new knife that the boy had claimed to tovel but had not, because the river was frozen. The Rav concludes that Torah conditions a person to be a tzaddik and gives him all the help he needs.

  10. 38:27 Gladdening people: the chassidim's love listed in the guide

    On the second side the Rav returns to the Mishnah: one who learns Torah lishmah gladdens Hashem and people. He brings a letter printed at the end of the Noam Elimelech in which a man describes to his father-in-law, who feared the chassidim, how they love each other like brothers, so that one cannot tell whose children are whose. He then notes the Gemara's harsh words about learning not lishmah.

  11. 43:49 Power misused: the four animals listed in the guide

    After a long poorly recorded stretch, the Rav compares Torah to a great power that blesses when used well and destroys when misused, and notes that when people are pleased with a person Hashem is pleased with him. He brings the Medrash that the four animals with one kosher sign stand for the four exiles, and explains that a good sign used for evil makes them worse, as with one who learns without good middos.

  12. 54:14 Rachamim after the ir hanidachas

    The Rav brings the passuk in this week's parsha that after destroying an ir hanidachas Hashem will give rachamim, and the Ohr HaChaim's account of the king's executioners who said killing gives them pleasure. He applies it: if one is not a mensch, his learning makes him worse, and a talmid chacham must let others live as long as they do no harm.

  13. 59:32 The yetzer hara called 'Yesh'

    The Rav tells a parable: the yetzer hara, the original serpent, complained that nobody listens to him because everyone recognizes him, so he changed his name, finally to 'Yesh', and went around the batei midrash and yeshivos, so that the more people learned the more of a 'yesh' they became. He concludes that Torah is meant to bring anavah and make a person a mensch, and that a real oved Hashem never has bad middos.

  14. 1:05:09 Before Moshiach: throwing off restraint

    The Rav describes how just before Moshiach people want to throw off every moral restraint and do whatever they want, citing the Gemara that before Moshiach chutzpah will increase and the generation will be like a dog. Against this he praises the refined speech and conduct of a talmid chacham as the Rambam defines it.

  15. 1:13:14 Unusable audio at the end (Unclear audio)

The shiur, written up

The Mishnah and the human need to love

0:17

The Rav opens with the Mishnah in Avos 6:1: one who learns Torah lishmah is called a friend and beloved, he loves Hashem and loves people. Every human being, he explains, has a desire to love and to be loved, and tzaddikim use it for the purpose Hashem created it for, through two mitzvos: loving one's fellow as oneself, and above that, loving Hashem. Love is never a one-way street; the tzaddik who loves Hashem is loved by Him, and a person who does not use this trait is very lonely. a,b,c

4:01

Why love all creatures? Because Hashem made them, and He creates only what He likes; if He appreciates something, so should we. The Rav brings the Arizal that one should love even a non-Jew for his tzelem Elokim, while hating what in him comes from the other side, and even animals and insects deserve a measure of love.

Love of friends and the king who joined

6:00

Without love between friends, the Rav says, there can be no love of Hashem. He illustrates with a story from Rome: when a man was taken to be hanged for burning the king's palace, his friend claimed the crime, and then each insisted he was the guilty one. The king, seeing they would die for each other, asked to be taken into their friendship.

8:11

Every person needs to feel loved, he adds, and the malachim who sing shirah are all beloved, since shirah means harmony and only beings in harmony can sing together.

Malachim, the classroom, and the shirah at the sea

10:00

The Rav contrasts a classroom where bochurim compete, one shooting out the answer to a question asked of another, with the malachim, who lovingly give each other permission to sing, as the siddur's blessing of Yotzer Or describes them all as beloved. At the splitting of the sea the malachim were silenced so that the Yidden's shirah alone would fill creation, so the Yidden too needed this love, as the blessing after Shema says, 'al zos shibchu ahuvim'. Such love is the key to a connection with Hashem. d,e

A love no wealth can buy

13:25

Everyone recognizes that the one who learns Torah lishmah is beloved by Hashem. The Rav brings the passuk in Shir HaShirim 8:7 that many waters, all the forces of the Satan, the yetzer hara and the nations, cannot extinguish the love between Hashem and Klal Yisrael. The Medrash on that passuk tells that when a great Amora of Eretz Yisrael passed away his coffin floated in the air, and the people recited that if a man gave all his wealth for this love he would be scorned. f,g

15:36

To explain 'scorned', the Rav gives a mashal: a customer who offers a little less for a ten-thousand-dollar car gets an argument, but one who offers thirty-five dollars is thrown out with insults. Even a millionaire's whole fortune is that kind of offer for Hashem's love of a tzaddik, which one reaches through much learning, until he learns lishmah. f

Can love be commanded; anavah as a garment

19:16

Bochurim ask: the Shema in this week's parsha commands love of Hashem, but how can anyone be told what to feel? The Rav answers that every Jew has this love in potential, and learning Torah lishmah makes it flare up. c

21:25

Torah then clothes a person in anavah, which is like a coat: a leader sometimes must show authority, and knowing when takes da'as. a

Torah prepares a person to be a tzaddik

22:51

Torah lishmah prepares a person to be a tzaddik even in what lies beyond his choice. Forbidden food clogs a person's feeling for kedushah, and in camp tiny insects are everywhere, so with all one's care one needs siyata dishmaya. Hashem guards tzaddikim from stumbling unknowingly; one tzaddik sensed any shaylah in his food and would not eat a questionable piece of chicken. a

The pancake that squirted

26:21

A gadol, invited to lunch by a city's Rav, cut into a pancake, then went into a long pilpul and would not eat. The Rebbetzin ran in, relieved: she had made it with butter in a fleishig pan. He denied ruach hakodesh; the hot fat had squirted into his face as he learned, and such brazenness could not come from kosher food. So Hashem gives tzaddikim da'as and siyata dishmaya.

Yid, where is your beard?

29:27

An elderly Yerushalmi in the Rav's shul in Williamsburg told him of a beardless but sincere yerei shamayim whom a Rebbe in Yerushalayim loved. The Rebbe came to eat with him, followed by many chassidim, but did not touch the fish and asked for one big plate. The host looked at a chassid with beard and peyos, from whom he had borrowed the dishes, and the Rebbe asked that chassid why they were not toveled; he excused himself that he had just bought them.

33:18

The Rebbe told the host that in the next world he will be asked, 'Yid, where is your beard?', but the other, 'Beard, where is your Yid?'

The gabbai and the knife

34:06

Mr. Singer, from the shul of the Rav's youth, told him that a Rebbe's gabbai, a great tzaddik, came for Shabbos to his wealthy father, who sent the boy to tovel a new knife in the river. The river was frozen, so the boy said he had toveled it. After kiddush the gabbai put the knife down, saying 'Sakin, sakin', and the boy admitted the truth. The Rav concludes that Torah conditions a person to be a tzaddik and gives him all the help he needs.

Gladdening people: the chassidim's love

38:55

Returning to the Mishnah, the Rav says the one who learns Torah lishmah also gladdens Hashem and gladdens people. He brings a letter printed at the end of the Noam Elimelech, written by a man to his father-in-law, who feared the chassidim, describing their devotion: they love each other like brothers, so that one cannot tell whose children are whose. a,h

43:27

He then notes the Gemara's harsh words about one who learns not lishmah, that it would have been better had he not been born. i

Power misused: the four animals

46:26

Much of this stretch is barely audible. The Rav compares Torah to a great power that is a blessing when used well, and notes that when people are pleased with a person, Hashem is pleased with him. j

50:00

He brings the Medrash that the four animals with only one kosher sign stand for the four exiles, and asks why they, rather than animals with no sign at all. The pig at least has split hooves, yet a good sign put to evil use makes it worse; so too one who learns Torah without good middos. k

Rachamim after the ir hanidachas

54:15

In this week's parsha the Torah promises rachamim to those who destroy an ir hanidachas, because killing, even as a mitzvah, can make a person cruel. The Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim, who lived among the Arabs and spoke with the king's executioners; they told him that killing gives them pleasure, awakening an animal instinct. l,m

55:55

So too, one can sway over the Gemara all he wants, but if he is not a mensch his learning makes him worse, and the Rav says he could not say this had the Gemara not said it. People should see a decent human being who lets others live, as long as they harm no one. n

The yetzer hara called 'Yesh'

1:01:10

The Rav tells a parable: the yetzer hara, the original serpent, complained to Hashem that nobody listens to him because everyone knows who he is. Told to change his name, he finally took the name 'Yesh' and went around the batei midrash and yeshivos, so that the more people learned, the more of a 'yesh' they became.

1:03:39

Torah, he explains, is supposed to bring anavah; if it does not, something is wrong. Its aim is to be a mensch, and one who toils in avodas Hashem becomes good: a real oved Hashem never has bad middos.

Before Moshiach: throwing off restraint

1:06:23

Just before Moshiach, the Rav says, people want to tear off the age-old ropes of morality and decency and do whatever they want. He brings the Gemara that before Moshiach chutzpah will increase and the generation will be like a dog, pointing to students who strike teachers without consequence. o

1:12:33

Against this he praises the refined speech of a talmid chacham, which is more like a mensch, and says it is a delight to see his conduct, as the Rambam defines a talmid chacham.

Sources

Torah

  1. b Vayikra 19:18 text index In the write-up: 0:17
  2. c Devarim 6:5 text index In the write-up: 0:17, 19:16
  3. l Devarim 13:18 text index In the write-up: 54:15

Kesuvim

  1. f Shir HaShirim 8:7 text index In the write-up: 13:25, 15:36

Mishnah

  1. a Avos 6:1 text index In the write-up: 0:17, 21:25, 22:51, 38:55
  2. j apparently Avos 3:10 index In the write-up: 46:26

Talmud Bavli

  1. i apparently Berachos 17a index In the write-up: 43:27
  2. n Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 55:55
  3. o apparently Sotah 49b index In the write-up: 1:06:23

Midrash

  1. g apparently Shir HaShirim Rabbah on 8:7 index In the write-up: 13:25
  2. k apparently Vayikra Rabbah 13:5 index In the write-up: 50:00

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. h Noam Elimelech (place not identified) index In the write-up: 38:55
  2. m apparently Ohr HaChaim on Devarim 13:18 index In the write-up: 54:15

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. d apparently Shacharis, blessing of Yotzer Or index In the write-up: 10:00
  2. e apparently Shacharis, blessing after Shema (Ga'al Yisrael) index In the write-up: 10:00

Key points

  1. 2:17 The Rav says every person has a built-in need to love and be loved, and the Torah turns it into avodas Hashem through the mitzvos of loving one's fellow and loving Hashem.
  2. 4:01 Love of creatures flows from the fact that Hashem created them, since He creates only what He likes; this reaches even a non-Jew, who has a tzelem Elokim, and even animals and insects.
  3. 5:56 Without love between friends there can be no love of Hashem, and shirah, which means harmony, is possible only among beings who love each other.
  4. 18:50 Hashem's love for one who learns Torah lishmah is beyond any price, and every Jew has this love in potential, which Torah learning brings out.
  5. 21:29 Torah lishmah clothes a person in anavah and prepares him to be a tzaddik, and Hashem guards tzaddikim from stumbling even unknowingly.
  6. 56:55 The Rav stresses that learning without being a mensch makes a person worse, and that a talmid chacham must be seen by people as a decent human being.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 19:25 How can the Torah command a person to love Hashem, when love is a feeling and not up to him?

    Answer: 19:52 Every Jew has this love in potential; he only has to bring it out, and learning Torah lishmah makes the natural, inborn love flare up.

  2. Question: 14:46 Why does the passuk say that one who offers all his wealth for this love would be scorned, and not merely refused?

    Answer: 16:32 Like a customer who offers a few dollars for an expensive car and is thrown out rather than bargained with, any offer for Hashem's love of the tzaddik is so far from its worth that it is an insult.

  3. Question: 50:19 Why are the four animals that have one kosher sign the symbols of the four worst exiles, rather than animals with no sign at all?

    Answer: 51:21 A good feature used for evil makes something worse, and in the same way one who learns Torah without good middos is worse.

  4. Question: 54:24 Why does the Torah promise rachamim to those who carry out the destruction of an ir hanidachas?

    Answer: 54:18 Killing, even as a mitzvah, can make a person cruel, as the king's executioners admitted that they take pleasure in it; so Hashem gives a special gift of rachamim.

Stories

  1. 6:16 Two friends in Rome and the king

    In Rome the king's palace burned down, and a man suspected of setting it was taken to the gallows. His close friend ran up and said he had done it, so they untied the first and tied the second, whereupon the first claimed he was the guilty one. The officials brought the case to the king, who saw that each was ready to give his life for the other, and asked them to take him into their friendship so he could enjoy such love too.

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 14:22 The coffin that floated

    The Rav brings the Medrash that when a great tzaddik, an Amora of Eretz Yisrael, passed away, his coffin floated in mid-air with nobody carrying it, as if malachim were carrying it. The people who saw it recited the passuk that if a man gave all his wealth for this love he would be scorned, showing how Hashem's love for the tzaddik was revealed to all.

  3. 26:16 The pancake made in a fleishig pan

    A gadol visited a city and was invited to lunch by its Rav, whose wife served a pancake. He began cutting it, then raised a strong kashya and went into a long pilpul, and did not eat even when the host urged him. The Rebbetzin then ran in, relieved it was untouched: she had baked it with butter in a pan that was fleishig. Asked whether he had ruach hakodesh, the guest said no: while he cut it, hot fat squirted into his face in the middle of learning, and he concluded that food with such brazenness could not be kosher.

    told in 6 other shiurim →

  4. 29:29 Yid, where is your beard? Beard, where is your Yid?

    An elderly Yerushalmi in the Rav's shul in Williamsburg told him of a beardless but sincere yerei shamayim in Yerushalayim whom a Rebbe loved, and at whose home the Rebbe came to eat with many chassidim. Fish was served, but the Rebbe did not eat and asked for one big plate; the host looked at a chassid with a beard and peyos from whom he had borrowed the dishes. The Rebbe asked the chassid why the dishes had not been toveled, and he excused himself that he had just bought them and had no time. The Rebbe told the host that in the next world he will be asked, 'Yid, Yid, where is your beard?', but the other will be asked, 'Beard, beard, where is your Yid?'

    In the story: Reb Leib Osofsky

    told in 6 other shiurim →

  5. 34:06 The knife that was not toveled

    Mr. Singer, a man in the shul where the Rav davened as a boy, told him that a Rebbe's gabbai, himself a great tzaddik, came to his wealthy father for Shabbos, and the father bought a new knife and sent his young son to tovel it in the river. The river was frozen and the boy could not break the ice, so he came back and said he had toveled it. Friday night after kiddush the gabbai took the knife, put it down and said, 'Sakin, sakin', and asked for the old knife; when the father said he had sent his boy to tovel it, the boy admitted that he had not.

    In the story: Mr. Singer

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  6. 1:01:10 The serpent who changed his name

    The yetzer hara, the original serpent, complained to Hashem that nobody listens to him because everyone knows who he is. He was told to change his name, and when his first new name too became known as evil, he took the name 'Yesh'. As 'Mr. Yesh' he went around the batei midrash and yeshivos, and the more Torah people learned, the more of a 'yesh' they became.

Insights

  1. 9:19 Shirah means harmony: beings who are not at peace in their feelings cannot sing together, so the malachim's love for each other is what makes their song possible, and the Yidden who sang at the sea in their place needed that same love.
  2. 4:10 Hashem creates only what He likes, so nothing in the world lacks a reason to be loved; if Hashem appreciates it, a person should too.
  3. 7:39 The king who begged two devoted friends to take him into their friendship illustrates that where friends love each other as themselves, Hashem wants to be there too.
  4. 21:43 Anavah is described as a garment: it can be put on and taken off, since a leader sometimes has to show authority, and knowing when and how much takes da'as of kedushah.
  5. 28:33 A pancake that squirted hot fat into a tzaddik's face in the middle of learning was itself the sign that it was treif: such brazenness could not come from kosher food.
  6. 1:02:57 The yetzer hara enters the batei midrash disguised as 'Yesh', so that learning turns into a source of ego instead of anavah.
  7. 50:37 The four animals with one kosher sign symbolize the worst exiles precisely because a good feature used for evil makes something worse, and so learning without menschlichkeit makes a person worse.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 10:19 The Rav says there should not be competition in a class to the point where bochurim try to outdo and damage each other, such as shooting out the answer to a question asked of someone else.
  2. 23:53 The Rav says one must be very careful about what one eats, for example the tiny insects flying around in camp, and that even with all one's care one needs siyata dishmaya.
  3. 56:55 The Rav says a talmid chacham should be a mensch, so that people point to him as a decent human being who lets others live.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Rabbi Meir, Reb Leib Osofsky, the Arizal, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam

Terms אהבת חברים, גאוה, טבילת כלים, כנסת ישראל, סייעתא דשמיא, עזות דקדושה, עיר הנדחת, ענוה, צלם אלקים, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שירה, תורה לשמה, תלמיד חכם

Report an error on this page