The Basis of Jewish Faith

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) בא no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 57 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 7 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 7 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains, through the Rambam, that Jewish faith rests on the mass revelation at Har Sinai and its unbroken transmission, why this makes Hachodesh hazeh lachem the first mitzvah, and that this first mitzvah teaches renewal.

The Rav opens with Rashi's question on the first passuk of the Torah: why not begin with Hachodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah? But Mila and gid hanasheh came earlier. He recalls that belief in Hashem is instinctive to a Jew, yet since the Rambam counts belief as a mitzvah, it has halachos. He reads the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8: the Jews did not believe in Moshe because of his miracles, which could be magic, but because at Har Sinai millions of people were themselves prophets and heard Hashem command them to believe Moshe. A fact witnessed by a multitude and handed down cannot be refuted, which is why even Christians and Muslims accept it. Therefore every mitzvah, even Mila, is kept only because Moshe told us, and Hachodesh was the first mitzvah heard from him. As the first, it carries the quality of beginning: the new moon teaches a Jew always to renew himself.

Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Foundations of Emunah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Rashi's question: the first mitzvah

    The Rav opens with the mitzvah of Kiddush HaChodesh and Rashi's question why the Torah does not begin with it. He asks how it can be called the first mitzvah when Mila and gid hanasheh were given earlier, and finds the usual answer, that it was the first given to the whole nation, hard to accept.

  2. 5:13 Instinctive belief, and a mitzvah needs halachos listed in the guide

    The Rav recalls that belief in Hashem is hereditary in the children of Avraham, can be spoiled like bodily health and restored, and that Hashem can be seen in nature and history. He then tells of a neighbor who sat in a sukkah with a plastic roof, to show that a mitzvah done without its halachos is not the mitzvah.

  3. 10:27 The Rambam: not belief through miracles listed in the guide

    Since the Rambam counts belief as a mitzvah, the Rav turns to Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8 and translates it. The Jews did not believe in Moshe because of his miracles, which could be magic and which he did only for a need; a supernatural feat proves nothing. They believed because of what they themselves saw and heard at Har Sinai.

  4. 15:16 At Har Sinai every Jew was a prophet listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Jewish faith, unlike Christianity and Islam, is not built on one charismatic person. At Har Sinai several million people each became a prophet, Hashem spoke to each face to face and commanded them to believe Moshe, and he brings the pesukim that show the covenant was with those alive and that the people would believe in Moshe forever.

  5. 20:59 A fact seen by millions cannot be refuted listed in the guide

    The Rav argues that a public event cannot be invented: just as no one could deny George Washington or Julius Caesar, whom multitudes knew, the revelation seen by millions could not have been made up. He adds that the Sefer Torah was written forty years later while women, Levi'im and the young of Matan Torah were still alive to check it.

  6. 27:26 One Torah everywhere; the nations' claim listed in the guide

    The Rav points out that Jews scattered across the world for thousands of years have an identical Sefer Torah, differing only in one letter, and that the mitzvos differ only in small machlokesin. Therefore even Christians and Muslims accept Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah; he dismisses their claim that Hashem changed His mind, since Hashem knows the future, and says they watered the Torah down.

  7. 33:03 The third wall and the churches in Yerushalayim Story

    The Rav tells what he learned while in Yerushalayim: archaeologists found an ancient city wall beyond the present Old City walls, which would put the Christian burial site of their founder inside Yerushalayim, where the Gemara says no one but the house of David and Chuldah was buried. He relates that the Church then bought the land and built churches so no one would dig, and kept a plaque off the exposed stones; he calls this a tangent showing the falsity of their faith.

  8. 41:38 Halachah of emunah: believing a navi listed in the guide

    The Rav stresses that in the Yad HaChazakah, unlike the Moreh Nevuchim, the Rambam gives the halachos of emunah: we believe because of the mesorah going back to Har Sinai, where Hashem appointed Moshe. He then asks why we should believe Avraham Avinu about Mila, since the Rambam rejects belief in individuals, and explains that even a navi like Eliyahu is obeyed only because Hashem commanded it, like the command to accept witnesses.

  9. 47:39 Even Mila comes through Moshe listed in the guide

    The Rav answers that we keep Mila and gid hanasheh and believe the stories of the Avos not because of Avraham or Yaakov or old records, but because Moshe, whom Hashem told us to believe, wrote them in the Torah. He adds that all religions fight over Yerushalayim because they cannot refute its holiness, and compares the absurdity of denying Sinai to a congressional resolution or to Holocaust denial.

  10. 51:34 The answer: the first mitzvah from Moshe listed in the guide

    The Rav returns to Rashi: Hachodesh hazeh lachem is the first mitzvah heard from Moshe, and once Hashem commanded belief in Moshe it became, retroactively, the first mitzvah. Mesorah alone is the uncontestable basis, though instinct and tzaddikim help. As the first, it has the quality of reishis, like the head that directs the body, so the Torah should have begun with it.

  11. 55:39 Kiddush HaChodesh: a mitzvah of beginning

    The Rav explains that the mitzvah itself is about beginning: the new moon's rebirth, the first month, given to the nation at its birth at Yetzias Mitzrayim. Since Eretz Yisrael and Yerushalayim were created first, the month is declared only there by the high court, unless a greater chacham is outside the land, because the neshamah outweighs geography.

  12. 59:02 Renew yourself like the moon

    The Rav draws the lesson that the first mitzvah is renewal: one who has darkened himself should not let old memories say he cannot serve Hashem, but start anew like the moon. The nation was told to count its times by the moon, not the sun, and in Kiddush Levanah the moon is called a crown for those who will renew themselves like it.

  13. 1:03:03 Always new: Nisan and the new Mizbeach

    The Rav contrasts the secular New Year, stale by mid-January, with the Jewish count of every day as part of the new month, and says each morning a Jew should start again with new fervor and simcha. Nisan, when all of nature renews itself, is the head of the months; this power of renewal kept the Jews alive in Galus, and he closes with the new Mizbeach of the Rosh Chodesh Mussaf.

The shiur, written up

Rashi's question: the first mitzvah

0:30

The Rav opens with this week's mitzvah of Kiddush HaChodesh, that this month is the first of the months (Shemos 12:2), and with Rashi's question at the start of Bereishis: since the Torah comes to teach mitzvos, why does it not begin with Hachodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah? a,b

3:01

He finds the question itself difficult. Mila was given to Avraham, and gid hanasheh, according to some Tanna'im, to Yaakov after the angel touched him (Bereishis 32:33). The usual answer, that Hachodesh was the first given to the whole nation, does not satisfy him, since Avraham was himself the first Jew. c

Instinctive belief, and a mitzvah needs halachos

5:36

The Rav recalls that every child of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov believes in Hashem by instinct; it is part of his spiritual organism. Like bodily health it can be spoiled, by forbidden food, immorality or avarice, and restored, and Hashem can be seen in nature, in history and in daily life.

8:18

Yet every mitzvah has halachos. He tells of a neighbor who spent Sukkos in a sukkah with a plastic roof, arguing that if rain came in no one could sit there seven days. The argument was convincing, the Rav says, but the man did not have the mitzvah of sukkah.

The Rambam: not belief through miracles

10:50

Since the Rambam counts belief as a mitzvah, it too has halachos, so the Rav translates Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8. The Jews did not believe in Moshe because of his miracles, for such belief leaves a doubt that it was magic; he split the sea and brought the mon and water only for a need. A supernatural feat, the Rav adds, gives no one a claim to be believed. They believed because of Har Sinai, where their own eyes saw and their own ears heard. d

At Har Sinai every Jew was a prophet

15:53

The Rav explains that Jewish faith, unlike others, is not built on one person who did great feats. Christianity began with individuals who, as the Gemara relates, showed tricks through impure powers, and Islam with Mohammed, and the masses followed them. h

17:44

At Har Sinai several million people did not listen to a prophet; each one became a prophet, and Hashem told each directly to believe Moshe. So the Torah says Hashem spoke face to face (Devarim 5:4), and the covenant was made not with the forefathers but with those alive (Devarim 5:3). Before Sinai Hashem told Moshe that the people would hear Him and believe in Moshe forever (Shemos 19:9); until then, the Rav notes, their belief had flaws. e,f,g

A fact seen by millions cannot be refuted

21:22

A fact witnessed by a multitude, the Rav argues, cannot be refuted. A tale like Rip Van Winkle rests on one author, but no one could claim there was never a George Washington or a Julius Caesar: hundreds of thousands knew them and passed it on, and an invention would have met protest in the first generation.

25:35

So too at Sinai Hashem spoke to millions, who gave it over to their children. When Moshe wrote the Sefer Torah forty years later, those who died after the Golden Calf were gone, but the women, Shevet Levi and those then under twenty were alive and could check it.

One Torah everywhere; the nations' claim

27:44

For thousands of years, the Rav adds, Jews lived scattered and cut off, yet every community has an identical Sefer Torah; Ashkenazim and Sefardim differ only whether one word in Ki Seitzei ends with a hei or an aleph. The mitzvos differ only by small machlokesin that came from the troubles of Galus.

30:30

Therefore Christians and Muslims accept Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah. Their claim that Hashem later changed His mind is absurd, since He knows the future; they made their own books because the Torah was too hard, and watered it down.

The third wall of Yerushalayim

33:24

The Rav tells that in Yerushalayim he lived near the edge of East Yerushalayim, by a street with far more new churches than its Christians need, and he inquired. Archaeologists had found, hundreds of yards beyond the Old City walls, an ancient wall of the same stones as the Kosel. That would place the garden where Christians say their founder is buried inside Yerushalayim, though the Gemara, a tradition they share, says no one was buried there except the house of David and Chuldah (Bava Kamma 82b). i

39:22

So the Church bought the land and built churches, where no one would dig. The wall surfaces only in front of the American consulate, fenced with no plaque, and he was told the Pope struck a bargain to keep it quiet, granting Golda Meir an audience. The Rav calls this a tangent, one of many things that show the falsity of their faith.

The halachah of emunah: believing a navi

42:38

This, the Rav says, is the mitzvah of emunah. In the Yad HaChazakah the Rambam gives halachos, while in the Moreh Nevuchim he philosophizes. We believe because of the mesorah reaching back to the millions at Har Sinai, where Hashem told the Jews to listen to Moshe. d,j

45:17

But then, he asks, if the Rambam rejects belief in individuals, why believe Avraham about Mila, or Yaakov about gid hanasheh? Even a navi like Eliyahu, who brought an offering on the Carmel (Melachim I 18), is obeyed not for his miracles but because Hashem commanded it, just as He commanded accepting two witnesses. Belief in Sinai itself, however, rests on fact. k

Even Mila comes through Moshe

47:46

So, the Rav answers, we keep Mila not because we believe Avraham, nor gid hanasheh because of Yaakov, but because Moshe told us they were given to them and wrote it in the Chumash. The stories of the Avos too are believed because Moshe wrote them, not from old records. All religions fight over Yerushalayim because they cannot refute its holiness, and denying Sinai would be as absurd as a congressional resolution that something never happened.

The answer: the first mitzvah from Moshe

51:55

This is Rashi's meaning: not Mila or gid hanasheh, but Hachodesh hazeh lachem was the first mitzvah heard from Moshe, and once Hashem commanded belief in Moshe it became, retroactively, the first. Instinct and the tzaddikim, whose holy words pierced Jewish hearts, help, but the mesorah alone cannot be contested. b

54:02

Being first, the Rav explains, it has the quality of reishis, like the head from which every motion of the body comes; so it should have opened the Torah, but for the reason Rashi gives Hashem chose otherwise. b

Kiddush HaChodesh: a mitzvah of beginning

55:40

The mitzvah itself is about beginning: the moon's rebirth, given to the nation at its birth at Yetzias Mitzrayim. Since Eretz Yisrael and Yerushalayim were created first, the month is declared only there by the high court, unless a chacham abroad surpasses those in Eretz Yisrael, since the neshamah outweighs geography. l

Renew yourself like the moon

59:20

The lesson, the Rav says, is renewal. If a person's light went out through something he did, he should not let old memories tell him he cannot serve Hashem; the moon too goes dark and renews itself. The first mitzvah told the nation to count its times by the moon, not the sun, and in Kiddush Levanah the moon is called a crown for those who will renew themselves like it. m

Always new: Nisan and the new Mizbeach

1:03:17

The nations' New Year is old by the twelfth of January, the Rav notes, but Jews call even the thirtieth day part of the new month. So each morning a Jew should forget yesterday and start with new fervor and simcha. Nisan, when all nature renews itself, is the head of the months, and this power of renewal kept the Jews alive in Galus. He closes with the new Mizbeach in Tziyon of the Rosh Chodesh Mussaf. n

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 12:2 text index In the write-up: 0:30
  2. c apparently Bereishis 32:33 index In the write-up: 3:01
  3. e Devarim 5:4 text index In the write-up: 17:44
  4. f apparently Devarim 5:3 index In the write-up: 17:44
  5. g Shemos 19:9 text index In the write-up: 17:44

Nevi'im

  1. k apparently Melachim I 18 index In the write-up: 45:17

Talmud Bavli

  1. h Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:53
  2. i apparently Bava Kamma 82b index In the write-up: 33:24
  3. m apparently Sanhedrin 42a index In the write-up: 59:20

Rishonim

  1. b Rashi, Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 0:30, 51:55, 54:02
  2. d Rambam, Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 8:1 text index In the write-up: 10:50, 42:38
  3. j Moreh Nevuchim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:38
  4. l apparently Rambam, Hilchos Kiddush HaChodesh 1:8 index In the write-up: 55:40

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. n Siddur (Mussaf of Rosh Chodesh) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:03:17

Key points

  1. 10:09 Since the Rambam counts belief as a mitzvah, belief is not only an instinct; like every mitzvah it has halachos that must be learned.
  2. 12:09 Following the Rambam, the Jews believed in Moshe not because of his miracles but because at Har Sinai every one of them was a prophet and heard Hashem command them to believe him.
  3. 21:22 An event witnessed by a multitude and passed down through the generations cannot be invented or refuted, unlike claims that rest on individuals.
  4. 26:03 The Sefer Torah, written while hundreds of thousands of witnesses of Matan Torah were still alive, has stayed identical in every Jewish community.
  5. 47:45 Every mitzvah, even Mila and gid hanasheh, is kept only because Moshe told it to us, so Hachodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah heard from Moshe, is the first mitzvah.
  6. 57:02 The first mitzvah, given at the birth of the nation, is a mitzvah of renewal: like the moon, a Jew who has darkened himself can always begin anew.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:58 How can Rashi call Hachodesh hazeh lachem the first mitzvah, when Mila and gid hanasheh were given earlier?

    Answer: 52:05 All mitzvos, including those, are kept only because Moshe told them to us, and Hachodesh was the first mitzvah heard from Moshe; retroactively it is the first.

  2. Question: 12:09 Why did the Jews' belief in Moshe not rest on his miracles?

    Answer: 12:16 Miracles can be done by magic and leave doubt; Moshe did them only for a need, and the belief rested on what they themselves saw and heard at Har Sinai.

  3. Question: 45:17 If the Rambam rejects belief in individuals, why should we believe Avraham Avinu about Mila?

    Answer: 47:45 We do not keep Mila because of Avraham but because Moshe told us it was given to Avraham and wrote it in the Chumash.

  4. Question: 31:01 If Christians and Muslims accept Matan Torah, why is their religion different?

    Answer: 31:14 They claim Hashem changed His mind, which is absurd since Hashem knows the future; really they made their own books to make things easier and watered the Torah down.

  5. Question: 46:05 Why do we obey a navi such as Eliyahu, even when he brought an offering outside the Beis HaMikdash?

    Answer: 46:28 Not because of his miracles but because Hashem commanded us to listen to a navi, just as He commanded us to accept witnesses.

Stories

  1. 8:37 The neighbor's plastic-roofed sukkah

    The Rav tells of a neighbor in his previous apartment, whose porch adjoined his, who built a sukkah with a plastic roof and hardly left it for all seven days. He later learned the man was one of those who do not accept the oral law. When he told him the sukkah was not kosher without schach, the neighbor argued that the Torah says to live in the sukkah seven days, which is impossible if rain can come in. The Rav says the argument sounded convincing, but the man did not have the mitzvah of sukkah.

  2. 33:44 The third wall of Yerushalayim

    The Rav relates that, staying near the edge of East Yerushalayim, he wondered at the many new churches along one street and inquired. He was told that archaeologists had found, hundreds of yards beyond the Old City walls, an ancient wall of the same stones as the Kosel, showing that Yerushalayim once reached there. This would place the site the Christians believe is their founder's grave inside the city, contradicting the tradition, which they also hold, that no one was buried in Yerushalayim besides the house of David and Chuldah. The Church bought up the land and built churches so no one would dig, kept any plaque off the one exposed section in front of the American consulate, and, he was told, the Pope made a bargain with the Israeli government that included an audience with Golda Meir.

    In the story: Golda Meir

Insights

  1. 52:22 Hachodesh hazeh lachem is the first mitzvah only retroactively: once Hashem at Har Sinai commanded belief in all that Moshe says, it became the first mitzvah received through Moshe.
  2. 47:46 Even the mitzvos of the Avos and the stories of Bereishis are not believed on the authority of the Avos or of historical records, but only because Moshe, appointed at Sinai, wrote them.
  3. 46:31 The Rav compares the obligation to heed a navi to the obligation to accept two witnesses: in both, belief rests on Hashem's command, not on the person's feats, while belief in Sinai itself rests on fact.
  4. 30:30 The other religions' acceptance of Matan Torah, and their fight over Yerushalayim, are themselves evidence that the Jewish mesorah cannot be refuted.
  5. 54:02 Something first carries the quality of reishis, like the head from which every action of the body comes; that is why Rashi expects the Torah's opening to be the first mitzvah.
  6. 57:51 Kiddush HaChodesh belongs to Eretz Yisrael because it was the first land created, yet a greater chacham abroad may declare the month, since the neshamah outweighs geography.
  7. 1:03:29 Jews count every day as part of the new month, even the thirtieth, when the moon is dark: a Jew is always within renewal.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 10:09 The Rav says that to do a mitzvah one must first learn its halachos, as one must learn how to make a sukkah or tzitzis.
  2. 59:16 The Rav says that when things go wrong and one's light is extinguished, one should renew oneself like the moon and start again.
  3. 59:58 The Rav says not to let past deeds convince one that he cannot serve Hashem; the moon too is darkened and renews itself.
  4. 1:04:00 The Rav says that each morning one should renew oneself, forget yesterday and start with new fervor and simcha in serving Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Chuldah the prophetess, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Golda Meir, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu

Terms אמונה, גיד הנשה, החודש הזה לכם, יצר הרע, כישוף, לשכת הגזית, מילה, מיעוט הירח, מסורה, מעמד הר סיני, מתן תורה, ספר תורה, קידוש החודש, קידוש לבנה, ראשית, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page