Remembering the Forgotten Jew

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) פקודי no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 58 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 13 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 13 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Moshe forgot what he made from the surplus silver because it came from the Jews outside the 600,000, the 'forgotten' ones, and that Rabbi Akiva, who expounds even the crowns on the letters, reconnects them, as Purim of the thirteenth month does.

The Rav opens with the accounting of Pekudei: the half-shekels of 600,000 Jews became the hundred sockets, and the 1,775 surplus shekels became hooks for the pillars. Mocked by the scoffers of the generation, Moshe gave a full reckoning but forgot what he did with the surplus until, per the Megaleh Amukos, Rabbi Akiva's soul reminded him. A long detour explains why the akeida was the great test: Hashem seemed distant and the promise seemed broken, and Avraham believed anyway. Following the Ramban's rule that the fathers' lives foreshadow their children's, the last test before Moshiach is the same, a generation of double concealment, the thirteenth month. The surplus donors are the Jews outside the camp, forgotten, so their silver was forgotten too and hung outside the curtains. Rabbi Akiva, who expounded the crowns on the letters, reconnects them; the hooks are vavim, connectors. Purim, in a thirteenth month this year, is the day for these Jews.

Topics: Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · The Mishkan and the Kohanim · Akeidas Yitzchak

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The accounting of the Mishkan's silver

    The Rav reads the opening of Pekudei, notes that Betzalel of Yehudah was joined by Oholiav of Dan, and goes through the count of the silver: the half-shekels of 600,000 made a hundred sockets, and the 1,775 surplus shekels became hooks for the pillars.

  2. 6:19 The scoffers, and the silver Moshe forgot listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Midrash that the scoffers of the generation said Moshe got rich from the donations, warns of the danger of ridicule, and tells how Moshe, giving a full accounting, forgot what he did with the surplus silver until, per the Megaleh Amukos, Rabbi Akiva's soul reminded him.

  3. 12:37 Eikev: the test of the last generation

    Going off on what he calls a tangent, the Rav reads 'v'haya eikev tishme'un' as the end of days, when everyone will listen, and as a joy reserved for the last generation, whose test is holding on to emunah in a world built on atheism; he tells of the Ba'al Shem Tov leaving a wagon driver who had no faith at all.

  4. 18:12 Why the akeida is called the test

    The Rav asks why only the akeida is called a test, contrasts it with Avraham's first test in Ur Kasdim, explains that nisayon means both test and raising up, and asks why the last test should be harder when the first, before Avraham had prophecy, seems the harder one.

  5. 26:23 Seeing Hashem from afar

    Answering from the Zohar, the Rav explains that at the akeida Hashem seemed distant: the command contradicted the promise of Yitzchak, and Avraham had to believe with questions he could not answer. He asks why Avraham did not see the angel's simple answer himself and answers that in a test Hashem closes even a wise man's eyes.

  6. 33:45 The akeida test of our generation

    The Rav brings the Ramban's rule that what happened to the fathers foretells the children, and concludes that the nation's last test before Moshiach is the akeida's test of believing amid questions, such as those after the Holocaust. Only Torah and mitzvos nourish emunah, and the answers will be clear when Moshiach comes, as in the Chazon Ish's parable of the tailor.

  7. 42:13 Double concealment and those outside the camp listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the ten tests recur in place and time, that our generation is the double concealment of 'haster astir', the thirteenth month, and that there is a thirteenth group outside the tribes, expelled from the Clouds of Glory and exposed to Amalek. He then describes the Mishkan's holy courtyard and how the half-shekels of the 600,000 became the sockets on which it all rested.

  8. 49:29 The forgotten Jews and their hooks listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the surplus Jews beyond the 600,000 were not worthy to be the sockets; their silver became hooks protruding outside the curtains, where the Shechinah does not rest. They are 'forgotten' because they forgot Hashem, so Moshe forgot their silver. The tzaddik connects them to the letters, like the crowns on the letters shin, ayin, tes, nun, zayin, gimel, tzadi.

  9. 56:40 Rabbi Akiva expounds the crowns listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara in Menachos where Moshe sees Rabbi Akiva expounding the crowns of the letters, and the Maharal's explanation: Moshe, the soul that includes all 600,000, holds to the body of the Torah, while Rabbi Akiva expounds the extensions. So Rabbi Akiva reaches the rejected Jews, connects them and neutralizes the Satan's hold, and he reminded Moshe that the surplus became vavim, connectors.

  10. 1:05:22 Purim in the thirteenth month listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Purim, this year in a thirteenth month outside the twelve, is the day of the rejected, when many became Jews. He tells how Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld answered Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer about going to the mikveh, applies it to Purim, and explains drinking on Purim as showing that even in his lowest state a Jew is loved by Hashem.

The shiur, written up

The accounting of the Mishkan's silver

0:00

The Rav opens with the first words of Pekudei, the accounting of the Mishkan (Shemos 38:21). Its builder was Betzalel of Yehudah, the most prominent tribe, joined by Oholiav of Dan, the lowest of the tribes (Shemos 38:22-23). Despite the unflattering things said about Dan, he remains part of Klal Yisroel, leaning on his brother. a,b

3:23

Moshe then counts the silver (Shemos 38:25-28). The half-shekels of 600,000 Jews made a hundred kikar, one for each of a hundred sockets. Since there were more than 600,000, 1,775 shekels were left over, and from them Moshe made hooks for the pillars and silver bands around them. c

The scoffers, and the silver Moshe forgot

6:21

The Rav brings the Midrash that the scoffers of the generation joked that Moshe, the collector, grew rich from the donations, though no one truly doubted him; while others gathered Egypt's wealth, Moshe sought Yosef's bones. One belittling remark, the Rav warns, can rob a person of his stature, and the Gemara counts scoffers among the four groups who do not greet the Shechinah (Sotah 42a). d,e

10:15

Moshe answered with a full accounting, but forgot what he had done with the surplus silver until, according to the Megaleh Amukos, Rabbi Akiva's soul reminded him: the hooks. The Alshich hears an exclamation of remembering in the cantillation over 'the thousand'. f,g

Eikev: the test of the last generation

12:38

Going off on a tangent, the Rav reads 'v'haya eikev tishme'un' (Devarim 7:12) as 'in the end you will listen': after all the troubles everyone will do teshuvah, so why wait? A second reading takes 'v'haya' as joy, reserved for the eikev, the last generation before Moshiach, the heel of the body. h

14:42

That generation's test, he says, is to cling to emunah in a world set up to confuse the believer, with whole governments built on atheism. He recalls the Ba'al Shem Tov, who left a wagon driver who did not cross himself before a priest, since he had no faith at all.

Why the akeida is called the test

18:22

Turning to the akeida, the Rav notes that only here does the Torah say outright that Hashem tested Avraham (Bereishis 22:1), so this tenth test must be special. In the first test, in Ur Kasdim, Avraham reached by pure reasoning the conviction that one G-d created everything, preached it against Nimrod, and came out of the furnace unharmed; only then did Hashem reveal Himself in prophecy. i

23:03

Nisayon, he explains, means both a test and raising up, like a banner: a test exists to promote, and after ten tests Avraham graduated. So the last should be hardest, yet it seems the reverse. Anyone who saw Hashem would obey Him, while giving one's life from conviction alone is far harder. Why then the stress on the akeida?

Seeing Hashem from afar

26:25

The Rav answers from the Zohar that Avraham saw Hashem from afar: at the akeida Hashem seemed distant. Hashem never goes back on His word, as 'G-d is not a man that He should lie' (Bamidbar 23:19), yet after promising a nation from Yitzchak He commanded his slaughter. Avraham shut out the doubts; when the Satan claimed a ram would replace Yitzchak, he refused to believe him, as the Midrash relates. j,k,l

30:04

His test was to believe without understanding, whereas in the furnace he had felt Hashem near. The Rav asks why Avraham missed the angel's simple answer, that he was only told to bring Yitzchak up, which a six-year-old grasps. When Hashem tests, he answers, He closes even a wise man's eyes.

The akeida test of our generation

33:54

The Rav brings the Ramban's rule that what happened to the fathers is a sign for the children (Ramban on Bereishis 12:6): Avraham's descent to Egypt in famine, Sarah's captivity, Pharaoh's plagues and her release with gifts foretold the nation's history. So the nation also faces ten tests, and the last before Moshiach is the akeida's test of believing amid questions. m

36:57

No generation had as many questions as ours, he says: why the six million, why was He silent. Those whose Judaism is theory and articles fail, because only Torah and mitzvos nourish emunah; each mitzvah, page of Gemara, tefillin and Shabbos is a pill of emunah. When Moshiach comes the answer will be so simple that we will laugh, as in the Chazon Ish's parable of the tailor cutting silk. Now, in the tenth test, the heel feels nothing.

Double concealment and those outside the camp

42:16

The ten tests run from light to darkness, the Rav says, and recur in places and on the calendar. The darkest is the double concealment the Gemara finds in 'haster astir' (Chullin 139b): a thirteenth month, farthest from Nisan's redemption. Our generation is that thirteenth month. n

45:19

So too there is a thirteenth group beyond the twelve tribes: sinners expelled from the Clouds of Glory, whom Amalek could strike. The Mishkan mirrors this. Its curtains divided holy from mundane, the donations went inside, and the half-shekels of 600,000 became the sockets on which it rested; each gave exactly a half so that each would be counted before Hashem.

The forgotten Jews and their hooks

49:33

The Jews beyond the 600,000, the Rav explains, were not worthy to support the Mishkan. Their half-shekels expressed who they were, people outside the camp, so their silver became hooks protruding outside the curtains, where the Shechinah does not rest. In David HaMelech's language they are forgotten by Hashem, having forgotten Him, and since money extends the soul, Moshe, who forgot nothing of the Torah, forgot their silver. o

54:10

There are 600,000 letters for 600,000 souls, and these Jews are not among the letters. Yet the tzaddik connects them, like the crowns on the letters shatnez gatz: thin strokes attached to a letter without spoiling it.

Rabbi Akiva expounds the crowns

56:57

The Rav brings the Gemara in Menachos (29b): Moshe saw Rabbi Akiva expounding the crowns, did not understand, and was comforted when Rabbi Akiva called it a halachah from Sinai. The Maharal explains that this was no lack in Moshe: as the soul including all 600,000, he is the letters of the Torah and holds to its body, while Rabbi Akiva went to the extensions. q

1:00:06

So Rabbi Akiva knows the secret of every Jew, even the expelled, and attaches them to Klal Yisroel; at times they hold deeper secrets than the letters. The Satan rules the seven crowned letters, and joining the crowns neutralizes him; so the rejected Jews, once reached, express kedushah the letters alone do not.

1:03:47

This is why Rabbi Akiva reminded Moshe: the surplus became vavim, and a vav connects, meaning 'and'. Outside, yet connected and crowned, a sign of Hashem's love for these Jews.

Purim in the thirteenth month

1:05:31

Purim, this year in a thirteenth month outside the twelve, is the month of the rejected, the Rav says, when Hashem opens the gates of mercy. Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld told Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, who questioned his daily mikveh, that if a mikveh makes a gentile a Jew it can make a Jew a better Jew. Likewise, since many became Jews through Purim (Esther 8:17), Purim can make a Jew a better Jew; the sefarim say one climbs up to Yom Kippur, while Purim comes down. r

1:09:29

Drinking is discouraged throughout the Torah, as when Shlomo's mother rebuked him (Sanhedrin 70b), and drunkenness is the lowest state. On Purim, the Rav explains, it shows that even then a Jew is a Jew, loved by Hashem, though he does not advocate drinking for his listeners. s

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 38:21 text index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. b apparently Shemos 38:22-23 index In the write-up: 0:00
  3. c Shemos 38:25-28 text index In the write-up: 3:23
  4. h Devarim 7:12 text index In the write-up: 12:38
  5. i Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 18:22
  6. k apparently Bamidbar 23:19 index In the write-up: 26:25

Kesuvim

  1. o Tehillim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 49:33
  2. r Esther 8:17 text index In the write-up: 1:05:31

Talmud Bavli

  1. e apparently Sotah 42a index In the write-up: 6:21
  2. n apparently Chullin 139b index In the write-up: 42:16
  3. p Gemara (place not identified) 53:25 index
  4. q Menachos 29b text index In the write-up: 56:57
  5. s apparently Sanhedrin 70b index In the write-up: 1:09:29

Midrash

  1. d Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 6:21
  2. l Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 26:25

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. j Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 26:25

Rishonim

  1. m apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:6 index In the write-up: 33:54

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. f Megaleh Amukos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:15
  2. g Alshich (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:15

Key points

  1. 3:23 The silver of the half-shekels of 600,000 Jews became the hundred sockets on which the Mishkan stood; the 1,775 surplus shekels became the hooks of the pillars.
  2. 26:32 The akeida was the greatest test because Avraham had to believe while Hashem seemed distant and His promise seemed contradicted.
  3. 33:54 By the Ramban's rule that the fathers' lives are a sign for the children, the last test before Moshiach is the test of the akeida: believing when it is hard to believe.
  4. 49:33 The Jews beyond the 600,000 stand outside the Mishkan and are 'forgotten', so Moshe forgot what became of their silver.
  5. 1:00:06 Rabbi Akiva, who expounded the crowns on the letters, reconnects the rejected Jews to Klal Yisroel and reminded Moshe where their silver went.
  6. 1:05:31 Purim, falling this year in the thirteenth month, is the day for the Jews who seem outside; it reaches down to a Jew in his lowest state.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 19:01 Why does the Torah call only the akeida a test, when the first test in Ur Kasdim, before Avraham had prophecy, seems harder?

    Answer: 26:25 At the akeida Hashem seemed distant and the command contradicted His promise; Avraham had to believe despite questions he could not answer.

  2. Question: 32:06 If a six-year-old understands the angel's answer that Avraham was told only to bring Yitzchak up, why didn't Avraham think of it before the akeida?

    Answer: 32:40 When Hashem tests a person He can close even a wise man's eyes; in a test one does not know the answer.

  3. Question: 52:49 Why did Moshe Rabbeinu, who never forgot anything of the Torah, forget what he did with the surplus silver?

    Answer: 52:52 Its donors were Jews outside the 600,000 who had forgotten Hashem and were 'forgotten'; what happens to them happens to their money.

  4. Question: 57:54 Why didn't Moshe understand Rabbi Akiva's derashos on the crowns of the letters?

    Answer: 58:38 According to the Maharal, not from inadequacy: Moshe is the letters of the Torah, the soul that includes all 600,000, so he holds to the body of the Torah and does not go off to the extensions.

  5. Question: 1:09:09 Why do people drink on Purim, when the Torah and Chazal discourage drinking so strongly?

    Answer: 1:10:58 To show that even in the lowest, most degraded state a Jew is still a Jew, favored and loved by Hashem.

Stories

  1. 15:16 The Ba'al Shem Tov and the faithless wagon driver

    The Ba'al Shem Tov was traveling with a wagon driver when the town's priest came toward them. It was the custom for a gentile to cross himself at such a sight, and the driver did not. The Ba'al Shem Tov jumped off the wagon: he would not travel with someone who had no faith at all, not even a gentile's faith.

    In the story: the Baal Shem Tov

    told in 4 other shiurim →

  2. 39:13 The Chazon Ish and the tailor

    Someone asked the Chazon Ish why Hashem destroyed so much of Klal Yisroel. He answered with a parable: one who sees a tailor cut up an expensive piece of silk would think him mad, but only because he does not know how a silk garment is made. The Rav adds that when Moshiach comes and the finished product is seen, everyone will understand.

    In the story: the Chazon Ish

    told in 3 other shiurim →

  3. 1:06:38 Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's mikveh

    Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the Rav of Yerushalayim, went to the mikveh every day to daven and learn in purity. Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, the rosh yeshiva and father-in-law of Rabbi Aharon Kotler, asked him why he spent those minutes on the mikveh instead of learning. He answered that a convert becomes a Jew through immersion in a mikveh; if a mikveh can turn a gentile into a Jew, it can surely make a Jew a better Jew. Rabbi Isser Zalman then began going to the mikveh himself.

    In the story: Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, Rabbi Aharon Kotler

    told in 4 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 52:49 Moshe forgot what he did with the surplus silver because its donors were 'forgotten' souls outside the Mishkan, and a person's money, an extension of his soul, shares his fate.
  2. 23:03 The word nisayon means both a test and raising up, like a banner; a test exists to promote, and after ten tests Avraham 'graduated'.
  3. 30:17 The akeida was harder than the furnace of Ur Kasdim because there Avraham felt Hashem near, while at the akeida Hashem seemed far and Avraham had to act against his own understanding.
  4. 17:54 Eikev, the heel, is the least sensitive part of the body; the generation of ikvesa d'Meshicha is in the dark and insensitive, and that is its test.
  5. 1:00:06 The rejected Jews are like the crowns on the letters: outside the letter itself, yet expounded by Rabbi Akiva, and they can express nuances of holiness that the letters alone do not.
  6. 1:04:15 The hooks are called vavim because a vav connects: the surplus Jews may be outside, but they are connected, and their hooks were crowned.
  7. 1:08:37 Unlike Yom Kippur, where one must go up, Purim comes down to the Jew; if it made non-Jews into Jews it can make a Jew a better Jew.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 7:58 The Rav says humor can be used for good, to cheer someone up, but once it ridicules a person or a thing it is dangerous and destructive.
  2. 14:42 The Rav says the mission of this generation is to hold on to emunah with mesiras nefesh and to believe even when there are questions.
  3. 37:20 The Rav says that learning Torah and keeping mitzvos nourish emunah: every mitzvah, every page of Gemara, tefillin and Shabbos strengthen it.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Betzalel, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Noach, Oholiav ben Achisamach, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rav Aharon Kotler, Shlomo HaMelech, the Alshich, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Maharal of Prague, the Megaleh Amukos, the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אדנים, אור כשדים, אותיות, גרות, הלכה למשה מסיני, הסתר פנים, ווי העמודים, יום הכפורים, ליצנות, מחצית השקל, מסירות נפש, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, נבואה, נסיון, נשמה כללית, ענני הכבוד, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, רבונו של עולם, שכחה, תגין

Report an error on this page