אליהו הנביא will Resolve the Difficulties in תורה by inspiring אידן to do תשובה

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) שמיני no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 58 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 52 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 52 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Eliyahu HaNavi will resolve the difficulties in Torah because every kashya in Torah corresponds to a Jewish soul, and by answering it he brings that soul to teshuvah.

The Rav opens with the Gemara on the verse in Yechezkel about kohanim not eating neveilah and treifah, which Rabbi Yochanan says Eliyahu will expound, and asks why mila opens Parshas Tazria among the tumos. He develops the theme of four klipos: the shells of a walnut, the four kingdoms, the four non-kosher animals, the four layers removed at a bris, and the four kinds of tzaraas, which Sefiras HaOmer comes to break. A bris is a miniature geulah, so Eliyahu, whose name he links by gematria to tzaraas, comes to it. Using the Ohr HaChaim, he teaches that a kashya is a klipah hiding a gem, and that every passage of Torah holds a Jewish soul: answering a kashya helps that Jew do teshuvah. This is why Eliyahu, of whom Teiku is said, will answer all kashyos. He ends with the Erev Rav, the Igra dePirka and Chodesh Iyar.

Topics: Eliyahu HaNavi · Neshamos and Gilgulim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Mila in Tazria and the passage Eliyahu will expound listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why mila appears at the start of a parsha about tumos, and brings the Gemara on Yechezkel's verse that kohanim may not eat neveilah and treifah. Rabbi Yochanan says Eliyahu will expound it, while Ravina later answers it simply; the Rav says Rabbi Yochanan knew that answer but saw something deeper.

  2. 3:15 The four klipos and their many forms

    The Rav describes the four shells of a walnut around the four chambers that stand for the four letters of Hashem's Name, and shows the same four klipos in the four kingdoms, Avraham's war with the four kings, the four elements, the four non-kosher animals of Shemini, the four layers removed at a bris, and the four kinds of tzaraas.

  3. 9:30 Tzaraas includes all; Sefirah and Yechezkel's vision

    The Rav explains why the chazir gets its own verse and why tzaraas, like Edom, includes all four. Sefiras HaOmer is for breaking the four root middos that come from the four elements, and on Shavuos one reaches Hashem as Yechezkel broke through the four klipos in his vision.

  4. 12:58 Why Eliyahu comes to every bris listed in the guide

    The Rav gives a gematria linking the four negaim to Yechezkel's verse, then explains that every bris is a miniature geulah that cuts away the four klipos, so Eliyahu comes to it. Eliyahu, the malach habris, equals tzaraas in gematria, and mila overrides even tzaraas.

  5. 18:18 A kashya is a klipah hiding a diamond

    The Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim on 'Shmor veshamata' that a kashya in Torah is a klipah broken by learning lishmah. He explains that Hashem is present everywhere, even within the klipos, and compares a kashya to a hidden diamond that one must first locate and then extract; learning thus frees the sparks of holiness held captive.

  6. 26:07 Midrash peliah, souls in the Torah, and Teiku listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Yismach Moshe about explaining a midrash peliah, such as the Midrash on Vayidom Aharon, and explains that every Jew is a letter in the Sefer Torah: answering a kashya in a passage helps the Jew rooted there do teshuvah. This is why Eliyahu, of whom Teiku is said, answers all kashyos, since he brings Jews to teshuvah; he adds a gematria of the four negaim.

  7. 33:36 Clarifying a halacha is greater than seeing Eliyahu

    The Rav brings the Igra dePirka that bringing out a halacha clearly is a greater merit than seeing Eliyahu, proven from the Gemara about Rabbi Evyasar: meeting Eliyahu would not prove his greatness, but Eliyahu's confirming his halacha did.

  8. 37:06 Eliyahu with a body and as a soul

    The Rav says there are levels in gilui Eliyahu. He brings the question how halachos could be learned from Eliyahu, as in the Gemara's seven teachings he said in two batei medrash, when Torah is not in heaven, and the answer that when Eliyahu comes in a body he is a link in the mesorah from Moshe Rabbeinu, but not when he comes as a soul alone.

  9. 40:56 Good Torah thoughts come from Eliyahu listed in the guide

    The Rav says every good piece of Torah comes from Eliyahu's power entering a person, and tells how Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver sent his son to see Eliyahu in the street, where he learned a lesson about parnassah from tied oxen. A good thought is Eliyahu using one's own body; behind every midrash peliah stands a neshama peliah, and Eliyahu HaNavi equals neshama peliah in gematria.

  10. 44:16 Neveilah and treifah: the Erev Rav listed in the guide

    Returning to Rabbi Yochanan, the Rav explains that beyond the four impure animals that oppress the Jews there are kosher animals that became neveilah and treifah: the Erev Rav, Jews who, as the Zohar says, will lead before Moshiach and are worse. Eliyahu will find their merit and bring them to teshuvah.

  11. 47:28 Grieving for Yerushalayim and Chodesh Iyar listed in the guide

    The Rav brings that one who has a kashya should pause and grieve over the churban Yerushalayim, since all Jews together are called Yerushalayim, and their teshuvah is its rebuilding. He links Eliyahu's seven teachings to Sefirah and to building Yerushalayim, and closes with the Bnei Yissaschar on Iyar as a month of Torah and tikkun.

The shiur, written up

Mila in Tazria and the passage Eliyahu will expound

0:35

The Rav asks why the parsha, which deals entirely with tumos, opens with mila. He brings the verse in Yechezkel that kohanim may not eat neveilah and treifah, and the Gemara's question why kohanim would need this. Rabbi Yochanan says Eliyahu will expound it; Ravina, centuries later, answers simply. The Rav says Rabbi Yochanan surely knew that answer but saw something deeper. a,b,c

The four klipos

3:25

The Rav describes the walnut: a bitter green peel, a hard woody shell, a thin membrane, and the brown coating of the kernel. Its four chambers stand for the four letters of Hashem's Name, and the four shells for the klipos that separate a Jew from Him. The Midrash compares Klal Yisrael to a nut. d

5:55

The same four appear as the four kingdoms, which the Ramban sees in Avraham's war with the four kings, and as the four elements of the Tanya. In Shemini come the four non-kosher animals, which the Ramban calls the four kingdoms, the chazir being Esav. At a bris four layers are removed, and Tazria lists four kinds of tzaraas. e,f,g,h

Tzaraas includes all; Sefirah and Yechezkel's vision

9:49

After listing the four, the Torah calls them all tzaraas, because tzaraas is Edom, which includes all the others, as the chazir gets its own verse. The weeks of Sefirah are for breaking the four root middos that come from the four elements, so that on Shavuos one reaches Hashem, as Yechezkel broke through the four klipos in his vision. i

Why Eliyahu comes to every bris

13:09

The Rav says the four kinds of nega equal Yechezkel's verse in gematria. Tzaraas is the harshest tumah of the parsha. Why is Eliyahu at a bris? Every bris is a miniature geulah: just as the geulah comes when the four kingdoms are subdued, the bris cuts off the four klipos of the orlah, so it is a time for Eliyahu. i

16:39

Eliyahu, the malach habris, equals tzaraas in gematria, for he comes to remove it. This is why mila stands in this parsha: the Gemara learns that mila is done even where there is a baheres, though removing tzaraas is otherwise forbidden. j

A kashya is a klipah hiding a diamond

20:47

On 'Shmor veshamata', the Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim: a kashya in Torah is a klipah, and one who learns lishmah breaks it and reaches the Torah. To avoid a misconception, he explains that Hashem's power is in every place, even in the klipos, but there it is hidden. k,l

24:05

The Torah holds treasures like diamonds, found in two stages: locating the field, then extracting the stone. One who learns superficially finds no kashyos; one who learns in depth finds one, a klipah hiding the truth, and by answering it brings up a diamond, each according to his level. Such learning frees captive holiness, a kind of pidyon shvuyim.

Souls in the Torah, and Teiku

26:19

The Rav brings the Yismach Moshe on a midrash peliah, like the Midrash on Vayidom Aharon asking what he should have said. Rashi explains that saying pshat brings two distant things together, and the Yismach Moshe calls this a great thing. m,n

28:21

He explains: every Jew is a letter in the Sefer Torah. A habitual speaker of lashon hara is a letter in the parsha of tzaraas. There are Jews with a kashya on them, like one who talks during chazaras hashatz; a tzaddik who answers a difficult Rambam in which that Jew is rooted brings out its gem and leads him to teshuvah.

31:41

So the Gemara's Teiku means Tishbi will answer the kashyos: Eliyahu brings Jews to teshuvah, and the Rav gives a gematria linking the four negaim to these words. o

Clarifying a halacha is greater than seeing Eliyahu

34:53

The Igra dePirka says that bringing out a halacha clearly is greater than gilui Eliyahu. He proves it from the Gemara: Eliyahu told Rabbi Evyasar's halacha, and the Gemara deduces Rabbi Evyasar's greatness not from meeting Eliyahu but from Eliyahu confirming his halacha. p,q

Eliyahu with a body and as a soul

37:36

The Rav says gilui Eliyahu has levels. Eliyahu taught seven halachos in two distant batei medrash, but how can one learn from him, when Torah is not in heaven? A Midrash says he sometimes comes as a soul, as to a bris, and sometimes clothed in his body. In a body he is a student of Achiya HaShiloni from Moshe Rabbeinu, so one may learn from him, as with Tanna Devei Eliyahu. r,s,t,u

Good Torah thoughts come from Eliyahu

41:11

Every good piece of Torah comes from Eliyahu's power. Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver told his son Eliyahu was in the street; the son saw tied animals straining to eat, saw that all would be fed together, and learned that straining for parnassah gains nothing. His father said this was gilui Eliyahu.

43:28

Behind every midrash peliah stands a neshama peliah, and Eliyahu HaNavi equals neshama peliah in gematria.

Neveilah and treifah: the Erev Rav

44:54

Back to Rabbi Yochanan: beyond the four animals oppressing the Jews, the Zohar says the Erev Rav, Jews who are worse, will lead before Moshiach. Neveilah and treifah are kosher animals gone bad; keep away from them. Eliyahu will find their merit and bring them to teshuvah, which is why Rabbi Yochanan left the verse for him. v

Grieving for Yerushalayim and Chodesh Iyar

48:24

The Rav brings the Igra dePirka that one stuck on a kashya should grieve over Yerushalayim and the Torah will open. All Jews together are called Yerushalayim, and their teshuvah is its building. He ends with the Bnei Yissaschar that Iyar is a month of Torah and tikkun, to be used for teshuvah, learning and answering kashyos. w,x

Sources

Torah

  1. a Vayikra 12:3 text index In the write-up: 0:35
  2. g Vayikra 11:4-7 text index In the write-up: 5:55
  3. k Devarim 12:28 text index In the write-up: 20:47
  4. s apparently Devarim 30:12 index In the write-up: 37:36

Nevi'im

  1. b Yechezkel 44:31 text index In the write-up: 0:35
  2. i Yechezkel 1:4 text index In the write-up: 9:49, 13:09

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Menachos 45a index In the write-up: 0:35
  2. j apparently Shabbos 132b index In the write-up: 16:39
  3. q apparently Gittin 6b index In the write-up: 34:53
  4. r Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 37:36

Midrash

  1. d Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 3:25
  2. n Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 26:19
  3. o Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 31:41
  4. t Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 37:36
  5. u Tanna Devei Eliyahu (place not identified) index In the write-up: 37:36

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. v Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 44:54

Rishonim

  1. e apparently Ramban on Bereishis 14:1 index In the write-up: 5:55
  2. h Ramban (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:55

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. f apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 5:55
  2. l apparently Ohr HaChaim on Devarim 12:28 index In the write-up: 20:47
  3. m apparently Yismach Moshe, Parshas Mishpatim index In the write-up: 26:19
  4. x Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:24

Other

  1. p Igra dePirka (place not identified) index In the write-up: 34:53
  2. w Igra dePirka (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:24

Key points

  1. 4:42 There are four klipos that separate a Jew from Hashem, and the theme recurs in the four kingdoms, the four non-kosher animals, the four layers of the orlah and the four kinds of tzaraas.
  2. 8:55 Tzaraas corresponds to Edom, which includes all the other kingdoms, so the Torah calls all four kinds of nega by the one name tzaraas.
  3. 14:47 Every bris mila is a miniature geulah, since it cuts away the four klipos, and therefore Eliyahu, the herald of the geulah, comes to it.
  4. 21:10 A kashya in Torah is a klipah that hides the truth; learning in depth breaks it and brings out the gem inside.
  5. 28:21 Every Jewish soul is rooted in a passage of the Torah, so answering a kashya in that passage helps the Jew rooted there to do teshuvah.
  6. 31:47 Eliyahu HaNavi will answer all the kashyos because he will bring all Jews to teshuvah, even the Erev Rav.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:35 Why does the parsha of tumos open with the mitzvah of mila?

    Answer: 14:10 Mila removes the four klipos, and tzaraas, which includes all four, is the harshest tumah; mila even overrides tzaraas, and Eliyahu, the malach habris, equals tzaraas in gematria and comes to remove it.

  2. Question: 14:28 Why does Eliyahu come to every bris?

    Answer: 14:47 Every bris is a miniature geulah that cuts away the four klipos, and the geulah will be ushered in by Eliyahu.

  3. Question: 31:49 Why is Eliyahu the one who will answer the kashyos (Teiku)?

    Answer: 31:53 Because he brings Jews to teshuvah, and a kashya in Torah corresponds to a soul; when all do teshuvah there will be no more kashyos.

  4. Question: 36:29 If Rabbi Evyasar met Eliyahu, why should that prove he is a great man?

    Answer: 36:37 Meeting Eliyahu alone would not prove it; what proves it is that Eliyahu confirmed he said the halacha correctly, since clarifying a halacha is a greater merit than gilui Eliyahu.

  5. Question: 38:12 How can halachos be learned from Eliyahu when the Torah is no longer in heaven?

    Answer: 40:00 When Eliyahu comes clothed in a body he is a student in the chain from Moshe Rabbeinu and one may learn from him; when he comes only as a soul, one may not.

  6. Question: 2:39 Why did Rabbi Yochanan say Eliyahu will expound the verse, when he surely knew Ravina's simple answer?

    Answer: 44:54 He saw a deeper meaning: neveilah and treifah are kosher animals gone bad, the Erev Rav, and only Eliyahu will bring them to teshuvah.

Stories

  1. 41:16 Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver's son looks for Eliyahu

    Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver once told his son that Eliyahu HaNavi was in the street. The son went out and did not find him, but he saw animals tied to posts: some were wild and tried to tear themselves loose because they were hungry, while another stood quietly. He thought that when the grain is given out they will all get it at the same time, so the jumping gains nothing. When he told his father he had not seen Eliyahu, his father said that one who gets a real good thought has had gilui Eliyahu; the lesson was that those who exert themselves for parnassah get the same parnassah as the others.

    In the story: Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver

    told in 2 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 2:54 The Rav reads Rabbi Yochanan's 'Eliyahu will expound this passage' not as a lack of an answer, since he surely knew Ravina's answer, but as a hint that neveilah and treifah allude to the Erev Rav, whom only Eliyahu will bring to teshuvah.
  2. 14:47 A bris mila is a small-scale geulah: cutting away the four layers of the orlah parallels subduing the four kingdoms, which is why Eliyahu, the herald of the geulah, is present.
  3. 29:39 A kashya on a passage of Torah is at the same time a kashya on the Jew whose soul is rooted in that passage, so explaining a difficult text is a way of bringing that Jew to teshuvah.
  4. 31:49 Eliyahu's role of answering the unresolved questions (Teiku) and his role of bringing Jews to teshuvah are one role, because answering a kashya and repairing a soul are the same act.
  5. 42:55 Behind every midrash peliah stands a neshama peliah, a concealed soul; one who explains such a midrash reaches a level of gilui Eliyahu, since every good Torah thought is Eliyahu working through one's own body.
  6. 48:24 The advice to grieve over Yerushalayim when stuck on a kashya is explained by the fact that all Jews together are called Yerushalayim: their teshuvah is its rebuilding, and then the Torah opens.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 10:18 The Rav says the weeks of Sefirah are meant for breaking the four root middos and working on good middos before Shavuos.
  2. 21:35 The Rav says one should learn Torah lishmah and in depth, so as to break the klipah of a kashya and reach the truth.
  3. 48:24 The Rav brings that one who meets a kashya in learning should stop and grieve over the churban Yerushalayim, and then the Torah opens for him.
  4. 51:12 The Rav urges using Chodesh Iyar, a month of Torah and tikkun, to build Yerushalayim through teshuvah, learning and answering kashyos.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achiya HaShiloni, Aharon HaKohen, Avihu, Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nadav, Rabbi Evyasar, Rabbi Yitzchak of Skver, Rabbi Yochanan, Rashi, Ravina, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ramban, the Yismach Moshe, Yechezkel HaNavi

Terms אליהו הנביא, ארבע מלכיות, מצורע, ספירת העומר, ערב רב, פדיון שבויים, פריעה, קושיא, קליפה

Report an error on this page