“חסד לאומים חטאת.” נפש אלקות דישראל - חלק אלקי ממש.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH א-ב no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 73 English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav contrasts the self-serving kindness of the nations, whose animal soul comes from the impure klipos, with a Jew's ability to act purely for Hashem, and then opens Tanya chapter two: the Jew's second soul is 'truly a part of G-d above'.
The Rav reviews that a Jew's animal soul comes from klipas nogah, which can be elevated, while that of the nations comes from the three impure klipos; therefore, as the Gemara says, the kindness of the nations is a sin, done for themselves. He shows the opposite with Yaakov's seven years for Rachel, which seemed like a few days because his love was spiritual, like a tzaddik's longing for a mitzvah. Love for a thing one consumes is really self-love, and even tzedakah or martyrdom can be for oneself; a Jew can lift his compassion and even his eating to be for Hashem. Answering a question, he digresses to the Zohar: Rachel is the aspect of Yovel, of return and redemption, explaining theft, the Hebrew servant, Shabbos, Chanukah, Yaakov's grief at Rachel's death and Migdal Eder. Finally he opens Tanya chapter two: the Jewish soul is G-dliness 'mamash', breathed from Hashem's inwardness.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Kedushah and Kelipah · Yisroel and the Nations
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Klipas nogah and the kindness of the nations listed in the guide
The Rav reviews that a Jew's animal soul is from klipas nogah, which can be raised to good, while that of the nations is from the three impure klipos, as in the Eitz Chaim. He brings the Gemara in Bava Basra that the kindness of the nations is a sin, since they cannot act purely for Hashem.
-
3:53 Yaakov's seven years for Rachel
The Rav asks why seven years of waiting seemed to Yaakov like a few days, and explains that his love for Rachel was spiritual, like Rav Nachum of Chernobyl longing for the esrog or a person building a sukkah. Yaakov's kiss was like kissing tefillin.
-
9:55 Loving oneself versus loving Hashem listed in the guide
With the man who 'loves chicken', the Rav shows that most love is self-love. He contrasts tzedakah given out of love of Hashem with giving to calm one's own feelings or to win honor, explains 'chesed le'umim chatas' this way, and says a Jew can lift his compassion to be purely for Hashem.
-
16:32 Exceptions, and elevating a steak listed in the guide
Answering a question, the Rav says exceptional individuals among the nations carry sparks of Jewish souls, as with converts. He explains that a Jew's eating, from klipas nogah, can be elevated when done for Hashem or used for learning, while forbidden food cannot be raised until the days of Moshiach.
-
19:41 Rachel and Yovel: everything returns to its root
Bringing the Zohar on Yaakov's seven years, the Rav explains Yovel as return to the root: every person's portion holds sparks only he can elevate. A thief takes another's portion, and a Hebrew servant, who lost the forty days of Torah, falls to a shifchah; Shabbos returns him, and Yovel frees even one who wishes to stay.
-
27:48 Chanukah as Yovel; Rachel and Moshiach
Going off on a tangent before Chanukah, the Rav explains with the Me'or Einayim that wicks and oils not lit on Shabbos are lit on Chanukah: souls Shabbos cannot lift, Chanukah, the eighth like Yovel, can. Rachel, who unites Klal Yisrael, is the shofar of Moshiach and the ingathering, buried near Beis Lechem, and Yaakov worked seven years to reach Yovel through her.
-
35:39 Rachel's death and Migdal Eder
The Rav notes that Yaakov himself offered the seven years, and brings the Zohar that Rachel's death was his greatest suffering: he felt the geulah taken away. He then brings the Targum Yonasan and the passuk in Michah that Migdal Eder is where Moshiach will be revealed, Hashem's consolation to Yaakov, and takes a question about Leah.
-
40:57 The second soul: G-dliness 'mamash' listed in the guide
The Rav opens Tanya chapter two and stresses that every word is exact, so 'mamash' means actually. Unlike the animal soul shared with all creatures, the second soul is G-dliness itself; he brings the Zohar that Hashem, the Torah and Yisrael are one, the passuk 'vayipach b'apav', the bracha Elokai neshamah, and that one who blows, blows from within himself.
-
47:40 Neshamah and breath; 'alu b'machshavah' listed in the guide
The Rav explains that neshamah also means breath, a person's inwardness, as seen in Rus's kiss of Naomi against Orpah's. He then reads that Yisrael 'arose in thought' first, the reason for creation, and notes the Tanya writes 'by way of a parable' here, since Hashem's thought is unlike ours.
The shiur, written up
Klipas nogah and the kindness of the nations
The Rav reviews the previous session: a Jew's animal soul comes from klipas nogah, a husk that can be transformed to good, while that of the nations comes from the three impure klipos, which can never be raised, as written in the Eitz Chaim that Rabbi Chaim Vital recorded from the Arizal. Therefore, he explains, the Gemara in Bava Basra calls the kindness of the nations a sin: even their chesed is for themselves, since they cannot act purely to give Hashem pleasure. a,b
Yaakov's seven years for Rachel
As the opposite, the Rav brings Yaakov, whose seven years of work for Rachel were in his eyes like a few days. Superficially this makes no sense, he says: for one who longs for something, each day of waiting is like a year. But Yaakov's love was not physical; it was spiritual, the love a tzaddik has for a mitzvah, like Rav Nachum of Chernobyl standing with the esrog before dawn on Sukkos, thirsting to fulfill the mitzvah. c
Loving oneself versus loving Hashem
A man who says he loves chicken, the Rav observes, eats it up; he does not love the chicken, he loves himself. So it is with most human love. A tzaddik gives tzedakah for Hashem, and even his compassion for the poor is driven by the mitzvah of the Torah to open one's hand to the poor. e
One who has not refined himself may give only to calm his own feelings, so the poor man's hunger will not spoil his supper, or for honor and a plaque; even martyrdom can be for the sake of going down in history. This is the meaning of the kindness of the nations being a sin. A Jew's compassion also comes from the animal soul, but from klipas nogah, so he can work himself up to giving purely for Heaven, a level the nations cannot reach. b
Exceptions, and elevating a steak
Answering a question, the Rav says the commentators acknowledge exceptional individuals among the nations: they carry scattered sparks of Jewish souls, as converts do, but they are the rare exception. A Jew can eat steak for pleasure or truly for the sake of Heaven, and then klipas nogah has its ascent; even if he ate for pleasure, the food is elevated when he learns with its strength, though the impression of the desire must be cleansed. Forbidden food, from the impure klipos, cannot rise until the days of Moshiach.
Rachel and Yovel: everything returns to its root
Since the question touched on Yaakov's work, the Rav brings the Zohar on why it had to be seven years: there is the aspect of Shemitah, seven years, and after it Yovel, and Rachel is the soul of Yovel, which gathers and returns everything to its root. f
Everything Hashem sends a person holds sparks of holiness that only he can elevate: half an apple a guest eats is his, the other half belongs to another soul, and anything out of its place must return, as a stone thrown up comes down. A thief takes what is another's, and is himself removed from what is his.
The closest possession is one's spouse, a match from Heaven. A Hebrew servant, sold for theft, loses the 'mem' of mishpachah, the forty days of the Torah, leaving shifchah. After six years he goes free, a return like Shabbos; one who wants to stay goes free at Yovel, which is geulah, proclaimed with the shofar, like teshuvah. g
Chanukah as Yovel; Rachel and Moshiach
Since Chanukah is approaching, the Rav brings the Me'or Einayim of Chernobyl on the wicks and oils not lit on Shabbos but lit on Chanukah. The soul is a candle of Hashem, as the passuk says; some souls even Shabbos cannot pull out of their impurity, but Chanukah can, for it is the eighth, like Yovel after seven times seven, with a power beyond Shabbos. h,i,j
Rachel is the soul of Yovel, which is Moshiach. The Rav cites the Rambam that Moshiach will gather the scattered of Yisrael; at the shofar people will leave their offices open and run. Rachel, the uniting mother, is promised that the children will return to their border, and she is buried near Beis Lechem, the place of Moshiach, which the klipah imitates with its false messiah. So Yaakov worked seven years to reach Yovel through her. k,l
Rachel's death and Migdal Eder
The second soul: G-dliness 'mamash'
The Rav opens Tanya chapter two: the second soul of a Jew is 'truly a part of G-d above'. Every word of the Tanya is exact; the preface tells that he weighed for weeks whether to add a vav, so 'mamash' is no exaggeration. The animal soul is shared with all creatures; the second soul, only the Jew's, is G-dliness itself, as the Zohar says that Hashem, the Torah and Yisrael are one. q,r,s
Hashem breathed into Adam a soul of life, and the bracha Elokai neshamah shows every Jew has this too. A man shapes clay with his hands, as Hashem made all creation, but breath comes from within; as the Zohar says, one who blows, blows from within himself, so the soul is from Hashem's inwardness. t,u,v
Neshamah and breath; 'alu b'machshavah'
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:00 A Jew's animal soul is from klipas nogah and can be elevated; that of the nations is from the three impure klipos and cannot, so their kindness is done for themselves.
- 4:49 Yaakov's seven years seemed like a few days because his love for Rachel was spiritual, like a tzaddik's longing to do a mitzvah.
- 10:08 Most human love is self-love; even giving tzedakah or giving one's life can be for one's own satisfaction or fame.
- 14:41 A Jew's compassion also comes from the animal soul, but he can work on himself to act purely for Hashem, and even his eating can be elevated.
- 20:03 Following the Zohar, Rachel is the aspect of Yovel, return to the root and redemption, which is why Yaakov worked seven years for her.
- 41:34 The Tanya's word 'mamash' is exact: the second soul of a Jew is actual G-dliness, breathed from Hashem's inwardness.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:12 Why did seven years of waiting seem to Yaakov like a few days, when longing makes each day like a year?
Answer: 5:18 His love was spiritual, like longing for a mitzvah, so the time flew as it does for one eagerly building a sukkah.
-
Question: 10:00 If a man loves chicken, why does he eat it?
Answer: 10:05 He does not love the chicken; he loves himself and wants to gratify himself.
-
Question: 20:06 Why did Yaakov's work for Rachel have to be seven years?
Answer: 20:10 Following the Zohar: seven is Shemitah and then comes Yovel; Rachel is the aspect of Yovel, so he worked seven years to reach it.
-
Question: 36:17 Why was Rachel's death the greatest suffering Yaakov experienced, worse even than losing Yosef?
Answer: 36:44 Rachel was the geulah, so at her death he felt the redemption being taken from him and from Klal Yisrael.
-
Question: 41:34 What does the Tanya mean by 'mamash' when it calls the soul part of G-d?
Answer: 42:55 It is not an exaggeration: the soul is actual G-dliness, breathed from Hashem's inwardness, unlike 'alu b'machshavah', where he writes only 'by way of a parable'.
Stories
-
5:43 Rav Nachum of Chernobyl waiting for the esrog
Someone described seeing Rav Nachum of Chernobyl before dawn on Sukkos, standing with the esrog in his hand and waiting for daybreak so he could do the mitzvah. The expression on his face showed he was thirsting to fulfill it.
In the story: Rabbi Nachum of Chernobyl
Insights
- 4:28 The Rav reads Yaakov's seven years 'like a few days' as proof of spiritual love: physical longing makes each day a year, while love for holiness, like building a sukkah, makes years fly.
- 7:07 Yaakov's kiss of Rachel is compared to a tzaddik kissing his tefillin and tzitzis, since she was for him the epitome of holiness.
- 25:26 A Hebrew servant loses the 'mem', the forty days in which the Torah was given, from 'mishpachah', and what remains is 'shifchah'.
- 28:58 Chanukah, the eighth after seven like Yovel after the Shemitos, can lift souls that even Shabbos cannot.
- 36:47 Yaakov's grief over Rachel was the loss of the geulah she embodied, and Migdal Eder, where Moshiach will appear, was Hashem's consolation.
- 51:00 The Tanya says 'mamash' of the soul being part of G-d, but 'by way of a parable' of Yisrael arising in Hashem's thought, because His thought is unlike ours.
- 47:47 Neshamah and neshimah share one word: breath is a person's inwardness, so Hashem blowing into Adam means His own life entered him.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Lavan, Leah Imeinu, Naomi, Orpah, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rachel Imeinu, Rus, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu
Terms דביקות, חלק אלוק ממעל, יובל, לשם שמים, ניצוצות, נפש הבהמית, נפש השנית, פנימיות, קיבוץ גליות, קליפת נוגה, שלש קליפות הטמאות, שמיטה