חכמה ובינה מולידים מדותע"י דעת.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ג no. 9 Pocket Guide p. 73 English 48 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 3, the Rav explains how Chochmah and Binah give birth to love and fear of Hashem, and how Da'as, deep and lasting concentration, makes those middos genuine and lasting.
The Rav opens with the weeks of Sefirah, when the middos are refined, since good middos are the prerequisite for Torah. He then reads Tanya chapter 3: the soul has intellect (Chochmah, Binah, Da'as) and middos, and the intellect is the father and mother of the middos, with Da'as as the bridge that controls them; a bowl of cookies and a gifted child who is not yet responsible illustrate this. Chochmah is the flash of insight, Binah builds it up like bricks. Contemplating Hashem's greatness first produces yirah, a sense of shame before His greatness, and only afterwards true ahavah, the soul's thirst to cling to Hashem. A digression on Shechem and Dina explains the fiery words of love. Finally, Da'as means intense and lengthy concentration; without it love and fear are only empty imaginings. He ends with refining the middos through Sefirah.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Sefiros · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Yiras Shamayim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sefirah, middos and the text of chapter 3
The Rav explains that middos are refined during Sefirah because they are the prerequisite for Torah, and links each chapter of Pirkei Avos to that week's middah. He then reads Tanya chapter 3: the soul is divided into intellect, Chochmah, Binah and Da'as, and middos, which are born of the intellect.
-
4:08 Da'as as the bridge: cookies and a katan listed in the guide
Chochmah and Binah give birth to the middos, and Da'as is the bridge that unites them. With a jar of cookies the Rav shows how understanding produces desire and how Da'as, responsibility, holds it in check; a child may be a genius but is not yet a bar da'as.
-
8:30 Chochmah as a flash, Binah as building listed in the guide
Applied to avodas Hashem, seeing and contemplating Hashem's greatness gives birth to love or fear. The Rav defines the intellect as the power in the mind that produces thought: Chochmah, koach mah, is a sudden flash of insight from Hashem, and Binah, from binyan, builds it brick by brick into a complete understanding.
-
13:52 Birchas Yotzer: fear, then love listed in the guide
The Rav shows the birth of the middos in davening: in Birchas Yotzer one contemplates the greatness of creation and produces yirah, then in Ahavah Rabbah the great love of Hashem for Klal Yisroel arouses love in return, leading to the self-sacrifice of Krias Shema. This requires thinking deeply, not running through the words.
-
18:06 Why yirah must come before ahavah listed in the guide
Though ahavah is the higher middah, genuine love can only come after fear. Fear is within a person's choice, love is not, as the spinach example shows; once a person has yirah, Hashem grants ahavah, the 'avodas matanah'. The Rav brings the Maggid's words on the way of the 'ish' and a Gemara that yirah first is a good sign.
-
23:40 Higher fear is shame before greatness listed in the guide
The Tanya begins with the higher fear of Hashem's greatness, not the lower fear of punishment. The Rav compares it to everyone rising when a president enters, and brings the Gemara that yirah is busha, shame, and the reading of Bereishis as 'yarei boshes'. After the fear the heart flames with love.
-
27:28 The words of love by Shechem and Dina
The four expressions of love in the Tanya appear in the parsha of Shechem and Dina. The Rav explains that Shechem carried sparks of kedushah: he and Dina were reincarnated as Zimri and Kozbi and later as Rabbi Akiva and his wife, and their daughter became Osnas, Yosef's wife. The fierce words of love reflect those sparks struggling to break free of the klipah.
-
36:10 Love as the soul's thirst listed in the guide
Returning to the Tanya, the Rav says every Jew who unites his Chochmah and Binah can come to a burning love for Hashem, klos hanefesh, like a thirsty man in the desert who sees water. The fire in the heart thirsts for the water of Chochmah, the point of G-dliness in the soul; the other middos are branches of love and fear.
-
40:43 Da'as: intense and lasting focus listed in the guide
Da'as, from 'yada', means connecting: to give birth one must fix the mind with strength and for a long time on Hashem's greatness, or the love and fear will be only empty imaginings. Da'as sustains the middos. The Rav closes on purifying the middos during Sefirah, comparing the last weeks to refining silver to sterling.
The shiur, written up
Sefirah, middos and the text of chapter 3
The Rav recalls that the seven middos are refined during the weeks of Sefirah. Rabbi Chaim Vital asks why the Torah stresses mitzvos and not middos, and answers that middos are the prerequisite: whoever enters the school of Torah has already graduated from the school of middos. That is why Pirkei Avos is learned in Sefirah, each chapter tied to that week's middah. a,b
Da'as as the bridge
Chochmah and Binah, the father and mother, give birth to Chesed and Gevurah, love and fear of Hashem, and Da'as is the bridge that unites intellect with middos. A man sees a jar of cookies: knowing and grasping what they mean to him gives birth to a desire to eat, a middah even animals have. Da'as is responsibility, which stops him after a few cookies instead of thirty.
That is why a katan, even a genius, is not a bar da'as: nothing yet lets his understanding govern his middos.
Chochmah as a flash, Binah as building
In avodas Hashem, a person who beholds Hashem's greatness, which is Chochmah, and thinks into it, which is Binah, gives birth to love or to fear. The intellect, the Rav explains, is not the thinking itself but the power in the mind that produces thought.
Chochmah is 'koach mah', something not yet tangible: while puzzling over a sugya, a bolt of lightning brings a new insight from Hashem, almost like prophecy. Binah, from binyan, takes that first brick and adds brick to brick until a complete explanation answers every question.
Birchas Yotzer: fear, then love
Davening shows this birth. In Birchas Yotzer a person contemplates Hashem's sublime creation and produces yirah; then, considering Hashem's great love for Klal Yisroel, his love is aroused in return, 'as water reflects a face'. With yirah and ahavah he can say Krias Shema with mesiras nefesh. But this needs deep thought, not running through the words, about how Hashem fills and surrounds all worlds. d
Why yirah must come first
In rank ahavah is greater, yet in attaining them genuine love comes only after fear. Nobody can decide to love Hashem, just as one cannot decide to love spinach; but fear is within one's choice, as when a man unsure of the brachah refrains from eating. Once he has yirah, Hashem responds with ahavah.
Higher fear is shame
The Tanya does not begin with fear of punishment, a mere stepping stone, but with awe of Hashem's greatness, as everyone stands when a president enters though he will not strike them. The Gemara says such yirah is busha, shame, and Bereishis is read as 'yarei boshes': a tiny creature is ashamed to defy so great a King. After this fear, the Tanya says, the heart flames with love like tongues of fire. g,h
The words of love by Shechem and Dina
The Tanya's four words of longing appear in the parsha of Shechem and Dina, and a Midrash says they must be used for avodas Hashem. The Rav touches on why, 'like one skipping over flames': Shechem was reincarnated as Zimri and Dina as Kozbi, and later as Rabbi Akiva and the wife of Turnus Rufus whom he married. The Zohar says Shechem held a spark of Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon. i,j,k,l
Such attraction reflects a match made in Heaven; as the passuk hints, 'together' they were one before birth, and marriage is a reunion. Shechem also held a spark of Moshiach ben Yosef: Dina bore him a daughter whom Yaakov hid in a thornbush with a necklace; angels brought her to Potifera, and she became Osnas, Yosef's wife. Shechem itself was Yosef's portion. m,n,o,p,q
The words are so fierce because Shechem was a klipah holding sparks of kedushah that strained to break free, like a bird tearing itself from a trap.
Love as the soul's thirst
Every Jew, however physical, who unites his Chochmah and Binah will burn with love for Hashem, klos hanefesh, the soul ready to leave, like a man in the desert who sees water. Citing the Etz Chaim, the Rav explains that thirst comes from the element of fire in the heart, while Chochmah is the water; the love yearns to return to the point of G-dliness in the soul. The other middos are branches of love and fear. r,s,t
Da'as: intense and lasting focus
Da'as, from 'yada', means union. A little Chochmah and Binah will not give birth; one must fix his thought on Hashem's greatness like a nail, both intensely and at length. A clever man who grasps the greatness has not done enough. u,v
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a Sha'arei Kedushah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:29
- c apparently Tanya ch. 3 index In the write-up: 3:06
- e Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:44
- g apparently Tanya ch. 3 index In the write-up: 24:14
- v apparently Tanya ch. 3 index In the write-up: 40:49, 42:55
- w apparently Tanya ch. 6 index In the write-up: 45:23
Other
Key points
- 4:08 Chochmah and Binah are the father and mother of the middos, and Da'as is the bridge that unites intellect with emotion and controls it.
- 11:29 Chochmah is a sudden flash of new insight whose origin a person does not know; Binah builds on it thought by thought until a complete structure stands.
- 18:46 Although ahavah ranks higher than yirah, in attaining them yirah must come first; genuine ahavah follows as a gift from Hashem.
- 26:06 True yirah is not fear of punishment but shame before Hashem's greatness, that so small a creature should go against His will.
- 37:23 Ahavah is the soul's yearning to cling to Hashem, like the fire in the heart that thirsts for the water of Chochmah.
- 41:00 Da'as is strong and lengthy concentration on Hashem's greatness; without it, love and fear are only imaginings.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:29 Why does the Torah put so little emphasis on middos, only on mitzvos?
Answer: 0:47 Because middos are the prerequisite; anyone who comes to Torah is assumed to already have them.
-
Question: 18:17 If ahavah is greater than yirah, why does davening, and the Tanya, put yirah first?
Answer: 18:46 In rank ahavah is higher, but in attaining them genuine ahavah can only come after yirah.
-
Question: 34:04 Why does the parsha of Shechem use such powerful words of love, found nowhere else?
Answer: 34:34 Shechem was a klipah holding sparks of kedushah, and those sparks needed great force to break free and return to their root.
-
Question: 43:42 Why does the Tanya call love without Da'as 'dimyonos shav' and not 'sheker'?
Answer: 44:01 Shav means there is something there, though it is useless; later chapters say it has some worth.
Stories
-
32:08 Dina's daughter becomes Osnas
The Rav relates, citing Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, Targum Yonasan and Da'as Zekeinim, that Dina gave birth to a daughter from Shechem. The brothers were unhappy with the child and wanted to kill her, so Yaakov carried her away, placed her in a small thornbush and hung a necklace on her neck saying that its bearer was a child of Yaakov. Angels carried her to Mitzrayim, where she was adopted by Potifera; she is Osnas, named for the bush, and Yosef married her.
In the story: Dina, Shechem ben Chamor, Yaakov Avinu, Potiphera, Osnas, Yosef HaTzaddik
Insights
- 0:37 The Torah does not stress middos because good middos are the entrance requirement: whoever enters the school of Torah is assumed to have graduated from the school of middos.
- 6:54 Da'as is responsibility: a child may out-learn adults, yet he is not a bar da'as because there is no bridge yet by which his understanding governs his middos.
- 20:34 Love cannot be commanded into being, just as a man cannot decide to love spinach, but fear is within one's choice; therefore yirah is the 'avodas avodah' a person works on and ahavah the 'avodas matanah' Hashem grants in return.
- 34:34 The intensity of the words of love by Shechem shows a spark of kedushah struggling to tear itself free of the klipah, like a bird pulling with all its strength out of a trap.
- 38:53 The love born of Binah is the fire in the heart thirsting for water, and that water is Chochmah, the point of G-dliness in the soul: the love yearns to return to its own source.
- 43:39 The Tanya calls love without Da'as 'dimyonos shav', not 'sheker': shav means there is something there, only it is useless, and later chapters say it has some worth.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 16:50 The Rav says Birchas Yotzer should not be run through in a moment; one must think into what one is saying about Hashem's greatness.
- 21:05 According to the Rav, a person should work on yirah, which is within his choice, by refraining from what the Torah forbids, and Hashem then grants ahavah.
- 45:17 The Rav says the weeks of Sefirah are for purifying the middos in preparation for Shavuos.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dinah, Kozbi bas Tzur, Osnas, Potiphera, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon, Shechem ben Chamor, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Maggid of Mezritch, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik, Zimri ben Salu
Terms אהבת השם, בושה, בינה, דעת, חכמה, יראת שמים, מדות, ניצוצות, ספירת העומר, עבודת מתנה, קליפה, רבונו של עולם