עבודה תמה זהו שבירת היצר. שלא לחפוש מנוחה - זהו עבודת אברהם אוהבי. שייכות ענין זה למילה.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ט"ז no. ⁨33⁩ Pocket Guide p. 76 English 1 hr

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains the Tanya's distinction between the 'oved Elokim', the beinoni who keeps fighting his yetzer hara, and the one who 'has not served Him' because his good conduct costs him no struggle, and stresses that for the beinoni this lifelong struggle is a complete avodah.

The Rav opens Tanya chapter 15 with the verse in Malachi that contrasts tzaddik with rasha and 'oved Elokim' with 'one who has not served Him'. 'Oved' is present tense: the beinoni who is still at war with the yetzer hara over the 'small city' of the body, while 'eved', a noun, is the tzaddik who has already won. He digresses on how much weaker today's generation is, comparing it to a small child whose slips are forgiven, and supports this with the yetzer hara cited before and after the Flood and with Bilaam's blessing that Hashem does not look at wrongdoing in Yaakov. He then defines the beinoni 'who has not served Him': a natural or habituated masmid who does no aveiros but makes no effort beyond his routine, explained through the Gemara of learning a hundred versus a hundred and one times. The beinoni's lifelong struggle is a complete avodah, illustrated by two stories.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Oved Elokim versus eved

    The Rav opens the chapter with the verse contrasting tzaddik and rasha, oved Elokim and one who has not served Him, and explains that 'oved' is the beinoni still at war with the yetzer hara while 'eved' is the tzaddik who has already won. He then notes that the beinoni himself has two levels.

  2. 11:03 A weaker generation, treated gently

    The Rav digresses on how far the world has fallen since earlier generations, recalling the decent world of his youth, and says that today one must be gentler with talmidim and friends. Like a two-year-old who slips, today's Jews are not held to the old standard; what matters is that they want to do Hashem's will.

  3. 17:50 The yetzer hara before and after the Flood

    The Rav asks how the yetzer hara could be the reason both for bringing the Flood and for never bringing another, and answers that the mighty generations before it were held responsible while the weakened world after it is treated like a sick child. He adds Bilaam's blessing that Hashem does not look at wrongdoing in Yaakov, with Rashi, and distinguishes one who slips while wanting to be good from one who sins in rebellion.

  4. 26:07 The beinoni who has not served Him

    The Rav defines the beinoni 'who has not served Him': he keeps all the mitzvos and learns constantly but by routine, without using Hashem's help to grow. He explains why such a person needs no struggle: he is a natural masmid of cold temperament, or he trained himself until it became second nature, so the hidden love of Hashem suffices.

    1. 26:07 Routine avodah and the third judge : The Rav describes the routine day of the one who has not served Him, and recalls from the earlier chapter that Hashem is the third judge who tips the scale for whoever wants to be good.
    2. 29:52 The natural masmid : The Rav asks how one can avoid all aveiros without fighting the yetzer hara, and answers with the natural masmid whose black gall cools him so that worldly pleasures do not draw him.
    3. 34:56 Hidden love and second nature : Unlike one who must arouse fear of Hashem by contemplating His greatness, this person needs only the hidden love every Jew inherits. The same holds for one who trained himself until learning became natural: once the struggle ends, he is no longer an oved Elokim unless he goes beyond his routine.
  5. 40:35 A hundred and one times listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the Gemara that one who reviews a hundred times has not served Him, while one who reviews a hundred and one times has: like the donkey drivers who charge double past the usual distance, the extra time goes beyond the routine. He links a hundred to the gematria of the yetzer hara's name and a hundred and one to the angel Michael, and concludes that the beinoni must always seek to grow, which is his complete avodah.

  6. 47:06 The struggle until the last breath listed in the guide

    Few people kill the yetzer hara; most struggle until their last moment. The Rav tells of a chassid who on his deathbed made a gesture of victory over the yetzer hara, and the Chiddushei HaRim's comment that at that moment he lost the battle. This lifelong struggle is the beinoni's complete avodah.

  7. 50:32 The masmid of Koretz and his judgment Story

    The Rav tells of a young masmid in Koretz who agreed to divorce rather than stop learning, was brought back by his father-in-law, and after his death reported that he was sentenced to Gehinnom for one fleeting proud thought, a sentence reduced because he accepted it without question. He concludes that if people today were judged this way it would be grim, but the main thing is to truly want to be an oved, and Hashem does not scrutinize those who slip.

The shiur, written up

Oved Elokim versus eved

0:04

Opening chapter 15 of the Tanya, the Rav recalls that a beinoni can never become a complete tzaddik; his mission in this world is a constant war with the yetzer hara. The verse in Malachi says that in the future one will see the difference between tzaddik and rasha, and between an 'oved Elokim' and 'one who has not served Him'. These are two separate pairs: the one who has not served Him is not a rasha. As the Gemara explains, he learns each piece of Gemara a hundred times, while the oved Elokim learns it a hundred and one times. a,b,c

4:05

What, then, separates the tzaddik from the oved Elokim? The Rav answers from the grammar. 'Oved' is present tense: a man in the middle of his avodah, still waging war over the 'small city' of his body and refusing to let the yetzer hara use his limbs as its tools, though he never fully evicts it. 'Eved' is a noun, like 'chacham' or 'melech': a title already earned, just as a 'ganav' is one who has actually stolen, not one able to. The tzaddik is the eved: he has driven the yetzer hara out and his heart is left empty of it.

9:05

Within the oved, the Rav adds, there are two levels: the oved Elokim and the one who keeps every mitzvah he can yet is called 'one who has not served Him'. He notes that in the Tanya's day such Jews, who never sinned, were common.

A weaker generation, treated gently

11:05

Today, the Rav says, even fine Jews stumble constantly in speech and in thought; the world has declined greatly in two hundred years. He recalls the decent world of his youth, when one could leave the door open and sit in the park at night, and contrasts it with today.

13:58

The old sefarim are very harsh, he says, but a slipping two-year-old is not punished like a careless adult. We are small children compared to earlier generations, so one must be gentler with talmidim and friends; the main thing is to want to do Hashem's will.

The yetzer hara before and after the Flood

18:17

The Rav raises a question: before the Flood Hashem cites man's yetzer hara as the reason to bring it, and afterwards He cites the same yetzer hara as the reason never to bring another. His answer is that the generations before the Flood were mighty people who lived almost a thousand years, with a strain of malachim in them; the Arizal says they returned as the generations of the Exodus and the desert. After the Flood came a weakened, sick world without strength to fight the yetzer hara, and like a sick child it is left alone. d,e

22:02

He brings Bilaam's blessing that Hashem does not look at wrongdoing in Yaakov, and Rashi there that Hashem is not exacting with them. The key, the Chiddushei HaRim shows, is the clause that follows, 'Hashem his G-d is with him': one who wants to live a righteous life and keeps falling, then does teshuvah, is not scrutinized. But one who sins in rebellion and does not care belongs to Masechta Gehinnom in the Reishis Chochmah. f,g,h

The beinoni who has not served Him

26:28

Returning to the Tanya, the Rav defines the beinoni 'who has not served Him'. He makes no special effort: he rises, davens, is honest in business and keeps his sedarim, all by routine, without striving to be better. He never sins and learns whenever he can, yet wages no war with the yetzer hara. As the earlier chapter explained, Hashem is the third judge who tips the scale for anyone who wants to be good, and the beinoni could use this light to improve each day; this one does not. i

30:49

Why is it routine for him? Because his yetzer hara does not oppose him. How can that be? He is a natural masmid, a cold, unexcitable person whose black gall quiets him, so the pleasures others pursue do not draw him; he likes to be closed in his room and learn.

35:06

One who must fight mobilizes strength by contemplating Hashem's greatness and his own smallness, which brings him to fear of Hashem. This person needs only the hidden love every Jew inherits from the Avos, which surfaces in times of stress. The same holds for one who trained himself until learning became second nature: while he struggled he was an oved Hashem, but no longer, unless he learns beyond his routine.

A hundred and one times

40:54

This explains the Gemara: one who reviews a hundred times has not served Him, while one who reviews a hundred and one times is an oved. Reviewing a hundred times was the custom, and like donkey drivers who charge double for a mile past the usual distance, the extra time breaks a routine and demands effort. c

43:39

The Rav adds that the yetzer hara's name equals a hundred, so up to a hundred one is still in his domain and can forget; the hundred and first reaches the domain of Michael, equal to a hundred and one. Even a natural masmid can grow in quality without limit, and this is the beinoni's complete avodah.

The struggle until the last breath

47:06

Few kill the yetzer hara; most struggle until their last moment. A chassid on his deathbed made a gesture of victory over the yetzer hara, and the Chiddushei HaRim said that at that moment he lost the battle. Constant struggle is the beinoni's complete avodah; Hashem does not demand that he become a tzaddik.

The masmid of Koretz

50:48

The Rav tells of a young masmid in Koretz. While his father-in-law was away, his mother-in-law pressed him to earn a living; he answered that he had never caused anyone pain and would rather give a get than stop learning. Riding back to the yeshiva immersed in learning, he met his returning father-in-law, who brought him home, rebuked his wife and daughter, and stopped the get.

55:12

He became a great tzaddik and promised to return after his death to tell his judgment. Led toward Gan Eden, he was sentenced to twelve months of Gehinnom for one fleeting thought that people would give him a higher title if they knew how much he could learn; because he accepted it without asking why, the sentence shrank to nothing. If we were judged this way, the Rav concludes, it would be grim, but today the main thing is to truly want to be an oved, and Hashem helps one who slips do teshuvah.

Sources

Torah

  1. d apparently Bereishis 6:5 index In the write-up: 18:17
  2. e apparently Bereishis 8:21 index In the write-up: 18:17
  3. f Bamidbar 23:21 text index In the write-up: 22:02

Nevi'im

  1. b Malachi 3:18 text index In the write-up: 0:04

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Chagigah 9b text index In the write-up: 0:04, 40:54

Rishonim

  1. g Rashi on Bamidbar 23:21 text index In the write-up: 22:02

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 15 index In the write-up: 0:04
  2. h Reishis Chochmah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:02
  3. i apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 26:28

Key points

  1. 1:32 Tzaddik and rasha form one pair and 'oved Elokim' and 'one who has not served Him' a second pair, both within the level of the beinoni and the tzaddik who is not a rasha.
  2. 4:05 'Oved' in the present tense describes the beinoni who is in the middle of the war with the yetzer hara, while 'eved', a noun like 'chacham' or 'melech', describes the tzaddik who has already driven it out.
  3. 26:28 The beinoni 'who has not served Him' does no aveiros and learns constantly, but does it by routine, without fighting his yetzer hara or striving to grow.
  4. 31:47 Such a person may be a natural masmid, cooled by the black gall, or one who trained himself until learning became second nature; either way he needs only the hidden love of Hashem every Jew has.
  5. 40:54 Learning a hundred and one times, one more than the accustomed hundred, is what makes one an 'oved Elokim', because it breaks a routine.
  6. 46:44 For the beinoni, the constant struggle against the yetzer hara until his last breath is a complete avodah; Hashem does not demand that he become a tzaddik.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 3:14 What is the difference between a tzaddik and an oved Elokim, since both are special people?

    Answer: 4:05 The oved is in the middle of the war with the yetzer hara; the tzaddik is an eved who has already driven it out.

  2. Question: 19:05 How can the yetzer hara be the reason both for bringing the Flood and for not bringing another?

    Answer: 19:31 Before the Flood people were mighty and responsible; after it the world became weak and sick, and like a sick child is left alone.

  3. Question: 23:04 How does Bilaam say Hashem does not see wrongdoing in Yaakov, when Jews do sin?

    Answer: 23:32 Because 'Hashem his G-d is with him': one who wants to do Hashem's will and slips is not scrutinized, unlike one who sins in rebellion.

  4. Question: 31:22 How can a person keep all the mitzvos and never sin without fighting the yetzer hara?

    Answer: 31:47 He is a natural masmid whose black gall cools him, or he has trained himself until it became second nature.

  5. Question: 40:38 Why is one who reviews a hundred and one times an oved Elokim and one who reviews a hundred times not?

    Answer: 42:02 A hundred was the accustomed routine; going one beyond it, like the donkey drivers' fare past the usual distance, takes extra effort.

Stories

  1. 48:05 The chassid's gesture on his deathbed

    A chassid who all his life was careful not to do wrong lay on his deathbed. At his last moment he made the European gesture of a thumb between two fingers, as if to tell the yetzer hara that he had won. When the Chiddushei HaRim was told of it, he said that at that very last moment he lost the battle, since the struggle lasts until the last breath.

    In the story: Chiddushei HaRim

  2. 50:48 The young masmid of Koretz

    A young married man in Koretz sat and learned all day. While his father-in-law was away, his mother-in-law and wife pressed him to earn a living; he answered that he had never caused anyone pain and would rather give a get than stop learning, and they went to the Rav for the divorce. As he rode back to the yeshiva immersed in learning, his returning father-in-law met him, brought him home and rebuked his wife and daughter, and the get was stopped. The young man became a great tzaddik and talmid in Koretz; before his death he promised to return and tell his judgment. He reported that he was being led to Gan Eden when he was sentenced to twelve months of Gehinnom for one fleeting thought that people would give him a higher title if they knew how much he could learn, and that the sentence shrank to nothing because he accepted it without asking why.

    In the story: Reb Pinchas of Koretz

Insights

  1. 4:05 The Rav reads the difference between 'oved' and 'eved' grammatically: 'oved' is a present participle, a man still in the act of serving, while 'eved' is a title earned, as 'ganav' names one who has actually stolen and not one able to steal.
  2. 19:31 The same yetzer hara that caused the Flood became the reason not to bring another, because the generations before it were giants held fully responsible, while the world after it is like a sick child who is left alone.
  3. 39:20 A good routine can itself mean one is not serving Hashem: one who reached the level of masmid through struggle stops being an 'oved Elokim' once it becomes second nature, unless he pushes beyond it.
  4. 43:19 A hundred reviews stay within the domain of the yetzer hara, whose name has the gematria of a hundred, while the hundred and first moves into the domain of the angel Michael, whose name equals a hundred and one, where forgetting no longer rules.
  5. 46:02 Even a natural masmid with no struggle in quantity can become an 'oved Elokim' through quality, learning better, where there is no limit to growth.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 14:05 The Rav says that today one must be gentler with talmidim and friends and not demand as much as earlier generations did.
  2. 15:56 The Rav says the main thing is to want to be a tzaddik: to rise each morning hoping to find favor in Hashem's eyes and do nothing displeasing to Him, and when one slips, to do a little teshuvah.
  3. 46:10 The Rav says even one who learns naturally should look for a way to improve, if not in quantity then in the quality of his learning.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Bilaam, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rashi, the angel Michael, the Arizal, the Chiddushei HaRim

Terms אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, התמדה, יצר הרע, מבול, מרה שחורה, נפש האלקית, סמאל, עיר קטנה, צדיק גמור

Report an error on this page