Why is it So Difficult to Daven in these Pre-Mashiach Times?
Catalog entry: TEFILA (English) no. 13 Pocket Guide p. 78 English 44 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that in the last days before Moshiach the Satan fights with new weapons against Hashem and Moshiach, and that tefillah, which is always an act of emunah, is what carries Klal Yisroel through.
The Rav opens with the Chofetz Chaim's statement that we live in ikvesa d'Meshicha, and argues with a coin analogy that every day there is a real chance Moshiach comes, despite all the years of waiting. He distinguishes the fixed ketz, known only to Hashem, from earlier moments when Moshiach could come, and recounts dates predicted by tzaddikim that turned into catastrophes, explaining that at such moments the Satan comes as accuser. The Gemara recorded a passed date to teach that disappointment must not shake emunah; Achashverosh and Daniel miscalculated, and even Rabbi Akiva was wrong about Bar Kochba. He then describes the signs of the footsteps of Moshiach: chutzpah, wrongdoing made lawful, inventions that destroy families, all weapons of the Satan fighting for his life. Against this, tefillah, though mocked, is always lishmah, since turning to Hashem is pure emunah, and emunah will bring the geulah.
Topics: Ikvesa DiMeshicha · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · The Power of Tefilah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Moshiach could come any day
The Rav opens with the Chofetz Chaim's words that we live in ikvesa d'Meshicha and the Rambam's principle of belief in Moshiach, and uses a spinning coin to show that every day there is an even chance Moshiach comes. He adds that the fixed time of the geulah is known only to Hashem.
-
4:47 Predicted dates that became catastrophes
The Rav distinguishes the fixed ketz from times when Moshiach could be hastened, as in Mitzrayim, and lists dates tzaddikim gave: the Toldos Yaakov Yosef's Tav Shin, the year Tach, the Malbim's 1914, each of which brought catastrophe. He explains that at such a moment the Satan comes as accuser and brings up Klal Yisroel's sins.
-
11:03 Why the Gemara recorded a date that passed
The Rav asks why Ravina and Rav Ashi wrote a date for Moshiach that had already passed, and answers that it teaches not to let disappointment affect emunah. He then brings the Gemara in Megillah that Achashverosh, and even Daniel, miscalculated the seventy years.
-
18:19 Bar Kochba and the signs of Moshiach
The Rav asks why the Rambam, who writes halachos, tells the story of Ben Koziva whom Rabbi Akiva endorsed, and answers that it is itself a lesson: even Rabbi Akiva can be wrong about Moshiach. He then turns to the Gemara's signs of the footsteps of Moshiach, chutzpah and wrongdoing that has become lawful.
-
24:29 New inventions as the Satan's weapons
The Rav contrasts thousands of years of plow and sword with today's explosion of inventions, and explains that worse than weapons that could destroy the world are weapons against Hashem and Moshiach, as in the passuk about tearing off the bonds. The Satan, fighting for his life, uses them to destroy families and shalom bayis.
-
30:04 The backbone that carries Torah to Moshiach listed in the guide
The Rav brings the promise that Torah will not be forgotten and Rabbi Yaakov Emden's words that Jewish survival in golus is a greater miracle than the splitting of the sea. A small backbone of Jews who keep Torah will carry over to the days of Moshiach, and he says they must thank Hashem and put in extra effort now.
-
34:07 Tefillah is mocked, yet it builds emunah listed in the guide
The Rav says tefillah especially is derided today, citing the Gemara that people scorn things that stand at the height of the world, while even one who does not learn still respects Torah. He explains that tefillah fosters emunah, and contrasts Torah learned shelo lishmah, which is justified only because it leads to lishmah.
-
37:46 A kvitel for a bicycle and a dog listed in the guide
The Rav tells of a kvitel at the Kosel in which a boy asked Hashem for a bicycle and a dog, and explains that the very act of turning to Hashem is lishmah and pure emunah, so every tefillah fortifies emunah. He closes with the Gemara that Chabakuk based everything on emunah, and that just as emunah preceded the song at the sea, emunah will bring the song of the geulah.
The shiur, written up
Moshiach could come any day
The Rav opens with the Chofetz Chaim's frequent remark that we live in ikvesa d'Meshicha, the footsteps of Moshiach, and recalls that the Rambam counts belief in Moshiach's coming among the Thirteen Principles. A spinning coin, he says, has an even chance of tails even after landing on heads ten thousand times; so too, after two thousand years, there is an even chance Moshiach comes today. a
Predicted dates that became catastrophes
Besides the fixed ketz, the Rav explains, Moshiach can come earlier, just as Klal Yisroel left Mitzrayim after 210 years instead of 400. Tzaddikim have named such dates. The Toldos Yaakov Yosef wrote that Moshiach would come in Tav Shin; the Rav recalls waiting for it as a boy, and a few days before that Rosh Hashanah Hitler invaded Poland. Another date, Tach, brought the gezeiros Tach v'Tat, and the Malbim's date of 1914 brought the World War. e
Why do such moments turn into catastrophes? Because then Heaven prepares for Moshiach, and the Satan, for whom Moshiach means his end, comes as accuser and brings up Klal Yisroel's sins.
Why the Gemara recorded a date that passed
The Gemara in the first perek of Avodah Zarah gives a date after which one should not buy anything, since Moshiach will be near. The Rav asks why Ravina and Rav Ashi, who lived after that date, wrote down a disappointment. He answers that it is a message: tzaddikim will predict times of Moshiach, and one should put all one's strength into preparing for them, but if the time passes, the disappointment must not affect one's emunah. Tzaddikim know much, but not the time of the geulah. g
He brings the Gemara in Megillah: Achashverosh made his long feast because he calculated that Yirmiyahu's seventy years had passed, fearing that the Beis HaMikdash would end his kingdom. That is why he offered Esther half the kingdom but nothing that touched the kingdom itself. Even Daniel, the navi whose mission was the geulah, erred about the seventy years. h,i,j
Bar Kochba and the signs of Moshiach
The Rambam in Hilchos Melachim tells how Rabbi Akiva endorsed Ben Koziva as Moshiach, until he was killed. The Rav asks why the Rambam, who writes halachos and not stories, tells this, and answers that the story is a halacha: even Rabbi Akiva, the greatest of the Tannaim, could be wrong about Moshiach. k
Yet the Gemara in Sotah and in Chelek lists signs of Moshiach, and the Rav says they are evident today: chutzpah grows, and wrongdoing is made law, as David HaMelech says in Tehillim. Barriers in arayos that the nations kept since the Mabul are now lawful, and the family is breaking down. l,m,n
New inventions as the Satan's weapons
For thousands of years, the Rav says, people plowed with the plow Noach invented and fought with swords and bows; today new weapons that could destroy the world appear every day. Yet Hashem will not let His world be destroyed.
The backbone that carries Torah to Moshiach
Against this stands the promise in Devarim that Torah will not be forgotten. Rabbi Yaakov Emden writes that Jewish survival in golus is a greater miracle than the splitting of the sea. Though most Jews today do not keep Torah, a backbone will carry it to the days of Moshiach; the Rav says they must thank Hashem and now put in extra effort in Torah and tefillah. r
Tefillah is mocked, yet it builds emunah
Tefillah especially, the Rav says, is derided, as the Gemara in Berachos says people scorn what stands at the height of the world, while even one who does not learn still respects Torah. Yet tefillah fosters emunah. Torah learned shelo lishmah, the Gemara in Pesachim implies, is justified only because it leads to lishmah. s,t
A kvitel for a bicycle and a dog
Tefillah, the Rav says, always has lishmah. He describes the kvitlach at the Kosel and one he picked up, in which a boy asked Hashem for a bicycle and a dog. The request was shelo lishmah, but turning to Hashem is pure emunah. So every tefillah is an exercise in emunah, and the more heart one puts in, the more it fortifies emunah.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- b apparently Sanhedrin 99a index In the write-up: 2:47
- c apparently Sanhedrin 98a 3:04 index
- g apparently Avodah Zarah 9b index In the write-up: 11:15
- h apparently Megillah 11b index In the write-up: 13:51
- i apparently Megillah 15b index In the write-up: 13:51
- j apparently Megillah 12a index In the write-up: 13:51
- l apparently Sotah 49b index In the write-up: 21:13
- m apparently Sanhedrin perek Chelek index In the write-up: 21:13
- p Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:21
- q apparently Bava Basra 16a 29:48 index
- s apparently Berachos 6b index In the write-up: 34:22
- t apparently Pesachim 50b index In the write-up: 34:22
- u apparently Megillah 27a 40:54 index
- v apparently Makkos 24a index In the write-up: 42:45
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:06 Every day there is a real chance that Moshiach will come, no matter how long the wait has been.
- 4:12 Only Hashem knows the fixed time of Moshiach; dates predicted by tzaddikim passed and even turned into catastrophes.
- 11:50 A disappointment over a predicted date must not affect one's emunah; this is why the Gemara recorded a date that had already passed.
- 21:20 The signs of the generation before Moshiach are evident today: chutzpah, wrongdoing made lawful, and the breakdown of the family.
- 28:15 The Satan, fighting for his life before Moshiach, brings new inventions as weapons against Hashem and Moshiach.
- 34:22 Tefillah is mocked more than Torah, yet every tefillah is an exercise in emunah, and emunah is what will bring the geulah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:44 Why is the chance that Moshiach comes today only even, and not certain?
Answer: 2:59 Because Moshiach can linger: there is a fixed time known only to Hashem, and before it his coming depends on other factors.
-
Question: 11:50 Why did Ravina and Rav Ashi write into the Gemara a date for Moshiach that had already passed?
Answer: 12:06 To teach that tzaddikim will predict times of Moshiach, that one should prepare fully for them, and that if they pass, the disappointment must not affect emunah.
-
Question: 20:13 Why does the Rambam, who writes only halachos, tell the story of Ben Koziva?
Answer: 20:26 Because the story is itself a halacha: even a tzaddik's endorsement, even Rabbi Akiva's, can be mistaken when it comes to Moshiach.
-
Question: 40:00 What credit does a boy deserve who davens for a bicycle and a dog?
Answer: 40:12 The request itself is shelo lishmah, but turning to Hashem for it is lishmah and pure emunah.
Stories
-
7:05 Waiting for Tav Shin
The Rav recalls that as a boy he waited eagerly for the year Tav Shin, when the Toldos Yaakov Yosef wrote that Moshiach would come. When Tav Shin came it was a catastrophe: a few days before Rosh Hashanah of that year Hitler invaded Poland.
In the story: Toldos Yaakov Yosef, Hitler
-
38:28 The boy's kvitel at the Kosel
The Rav describes the many kvitlach people put into the cracks of the Kosel, which workers sweep out every few days, and jokes that he once thought of publishing a book of them. He once picked one up: a boy had written in Hebrew asking Hashem for two things, a bicycle and a dog. The Rav says he gives the boy credit, because the very fact that he turned to Hashem shows emunah.
Insights
- 2:09 Like a coin that lands on heads ten thousand times and still has an even chance of tails, the long wait for Moshiach does not lower the chance that he comes today.
- 8:57 Dates when Moshiach was expected turned into catastrophes because the possibility of redemption threatens the Satan, who comes as accuser and brings up Klal Yisroel's sins.
- 11:50 Ravina and Rav Ashi recorded a date for Moshiach that had already passed precisely as a message to later generations that predictions by tzaddikim may fail, and that this must not shake emunah.
- 20:13 The Rambam's account of Ben Koziva is not history but halacha: even an endorsement by Rabbi Akiva cannot settle who Moshiach is.
- 28:15 The explosion of modern inventions is the Satan's arsenal against Hashem and Moshiach, brought out because he is fighting for his life as the end of the yetzer hara approaches.
- 37:46 Unlike Torah, tefillah always contains lishmah: even a request for a bicycle and a dog is lishmah in the very act of turning to Hashem, which is pure emunah.
- 43:08 Just as at the sea emunah came first and then the song, the geulah from this golus will come through emunah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 13:13 The Rav says that when a predicted time of Moshiach passes, one must not let the disappointment affect one's emunah.
- 33:01 The Rav says those who keep Torah should thank Hashem that they are part of the backbone of Klal Yisroel and not among those who stray.
- 34:02 The Rav says that now more than ever an extra effort is needed in Torah and especially in tefillah.
- 42:06 The Rav says the more one davens, and the more heart one puts into davening, the more one fortifies one's emunah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Chavakuk, Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Hitler, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Noach, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), Rav Ashi, Ravina, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Malbim, the Rambam, the Shach, Yaakov Avinu, Yirmiyahu HaNavi
Terms אמונה, ביאת המשיח, בעתה אחישנה, גזירות ת"ח ות"ט, חוצפה יסגא, י"ג עיקרים, כותל המערבי, מלאך המות, עקבתא דמשיחא, פקידה, קוויטל, קטרוג, קץ, רבונו של עולם, שלא לשמה