bachurim emor
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current אמור no. 15 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 31 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Learning the end of Tanya chapter one, the Rav explains how the four bad middos of the animal soul come from the four elements, and why a Jew's animal soul, which comes from kelipas nogah, can be turned to holiness.
The Rav recalls that the animal soul lives in the blood, which is why a Jew may not eat blood, and that the sitra achra imitates holiness the way a monkey imitates a man. Everything is made of four elements, fire, air, water and earth, which he explains with everyday examples such as a balloon, water that cannot hold a shape, and gravity. From the four elements come four bad middos: anger and pride from fire, which rises; pursuit of pleasure from water; wildness, mockery and idle talk from air, which has no substance; and laziness and sadness from earth, which always falls. He then explains that a Jew's good middos and his animal soul come from kelipas nogah, the 'shining' kelipah of Yechezkel's vision, which can be raised to holiness, like orlah fruit in the fourth year and the fourth layer at a bris milah. A Jew eats with brachos and washing; even a simple Jew's good deeds are inwardly for Hashem, while a gentile's are for himself.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Middos Tovos · Kedushah and Kelipah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The soul in the blood and the four elements listed in the guide
The Rav recalls that the animal soul is in the blood and that a Jew therefore may not eat blood, and that the sitra achra imitates holiness. He introduces the four elements that everything is made of and explains air as something real that has no substance, like the air in a balloon.
-
3:41 Water, earth and fire listed in the guide
The Rav explains water as having substance but no stability, earth as solid, and fire as the energy in everything, including the warmth in a person. He notes that the nations call the four elements gas, liquid, solid and energy.
-
7:07 Anger and pride from fire, pleasures from water listed in the guide
The Rav reads Tanya's words that four bad middos come from the four elements in the blood. Anger comes from fire, as an angry face turns red; pride also comes from fire, because everything falls to the earth by gravity while fire alone rises. The craving for pleasures comes from water.
-
11:40 Wildness from air, sadness from earth listed in the guide
The Rav explains that wildness, mockery, boasting and idle talk come from air, which has no substance, and illustrates with wild music that has no taste, contrasting it with real Chassidish song. Laziness and sadness come from earth, which falls fastest; a depressed person lies in bed and does not want to get up, while a joyful person rises fresh.
-
16:28 Kelipas nogah and the fourth year of orlah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that even the natural good middos of Jews, mercy and kindness, come from kelipas nogah, the weakest kelipah, which can go either to holiness or to impurity. He brings Yechezkel's vision of four barriers, the last being nogah, like a window shade the sun shines through, and the mitzvah of orlah: three years forbidden, the fourth year holy.
-
20:37 How a Jew eats listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts a rich gentile who eats breakfast in bed out of desire with an honest Jew, who first washes, says Modeh Ani, puts on tefillin and davens, then washes for bread and makes hamotzi. Through this the Jew turns his eating into holiness, which is possible because his animal soul comes from kelipas nogah.
-
23:52 Bris milah and doing good for Hashem listed in the guide
The Rav compares the bris milah, where three layers are cut off and the fourth is raised through priah, to the four kelipos. He concludes that a gentile's good middos, even mercy, are for himself, while a Jew, even a simple one, inwardly does everything for Hashem, and a finer Jew eats in order to serve Hashem.
The shiur, written up
The soul in the blood and the four elements
Concluding Tanya chapter one, the Rav recalls that the animal soul is in the blood. A Jew may not eat blood, because what one eats becomes part of him, and the life of an animal contradicts the life of a Jew. The sitra achra imitates holiness as a monkey imitates a man. a
He explains that everything is made of four elements, fire, air, water and earth. Air is real but has no substance: it fills a balloon, yet when the balloon bursts it takes up no space.
Water, earth and fire
The Rav explains that water has substance, but a child cannot build a house of water blocks; it stands only by a miracle, as at the Yam Suf. Earth is solid. Fire is the energy in everything, the warmth in a person and the strength of a flame. The four elements correspond to the four letters of Hashem's Name.
Anger and pride from fire, pleasures from water
He reads the Tanya's words that from these elements in the blood come four bad middos. Anger comes from fire: an angry person's face turns red and burns, as the passuk speaks of fire kindled in anger. a,c
Pride, he explains, also comes from fire. The earth pulls everything down like a magnet, an apple, water, even air, but a flame rises from its wick. So pride lifts itself up. The desire for pleasures comes from water.
Wildness from air, sadness from earth
According to the Rav, wildness, mockery, boasting and idle talk come from air, which has no substance. Wild music has no taste and no spirit, unlike a pure Chassidish niggun; it makes a person hefker, bound to nothing, like the slave the Gemara says prefers hefker. d
Laziness and sadness come from earth, which falls fastest. A depressed person lies in bed and does not want to get up, while a joyful person rises fresh and goes to the Rebbe's tisch with vitality.
Kelipas nogah and the fourth year of orlah
The Rav explains that even the natural good middos of Jews, mercy and kindness, come from kelipas nogah, the weakest kelipah, which can enter holiness or impurity; a person has the choice. Yechezkel saw four barriers before Hashem, the last called nogah. Nogah is like a window shade: Hashem's light still shines through. a,e
How a Jew eats
The Rav describes a rich gentile who rings for breakfast in bed and eats from desire. An honest Jew does not run to eat: he rises, says Modeh Ani, washes, puts on tefillin and davens, then washes and makes hamotzi. His eating is different, and it brings holiness into him, because his animal soul comes from kelipas nogah.
Bris milah and doing good for Hashem
He explains that at a bris milah, the orlah's three layers belong to the three impure kelipos and are cut off, while the fourth is raised through priah and becomes part of the holy covenant. So too the blood of a Jew comes from kelipas nogah, which lets Hashem's light through.
Therefore, he says, a Jew can turn eating and pleasures into holiness when he acts for the sake of Heaven; otherwise they fall into impurity.
He concludes that a gentile's good middos are for himself: even his mercy lets him enjoy his ice cream undisturbed. A Jew, even a simple one, inwardly acts for Hashem without knowing it, and a finer Jew eats to have strength to learn, daven and serve Hashem.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:24 The animal soul is in the blood, so a Jew may not eat blood, since what one eats becomes part of him.
- 2:10 All of creation is a combination of four elements: fire, air, water and earth, corresponding to the four letters of Hashem's Name.
- 7:56 Four bad middos come from the four elements: anger and pride from fire, pursuit of pleasure from water, wildness and idle talk from air, laziness and sadness from earth.
- 23:33 A Jew's animal soul comes from kelipas nogah, which can be turned to holiness, while that of a gentile comes from the three impure kelipos, which cannot.
- 27:07 A gentile's good middos are ultimately for himself, while a Jew, even a simple one, inwardly does good for Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:31 Why does pride come from the element of fire?
Answer: 10:17 Because every element falls to the earth by its pull, while fire alone rises; pride likewise lifts itself up.
-
Question: 15:11 Why may a person sleep until late in the day?
Answer: 15:14 Because he is sad and does not want to be active; this comes from earth, which always falls and lies down.
-
Question: 27:48 Why does a gentile act with mercy?
Answer: 27:50 For his own sake: knowing someone is hungry would disturb him, so he gives in order to enjoy his own food.
Insights
- 10:31 Each bad middah behaves like its element: pride rises like fire against the pull that brings everything else down, while sadness lies down like earth, which falls fastest.
- 13:19 Wild music belongs to the element of air: it has no substance and makes a person ownerless, bound to nothing, like the Gemara's slave who prefers hefker.
- 18:45 Kelipas nogah is like a window shade: a barrier between man and Hashem through which the sun still shines.
- 20:02 Orlah and bris milah share one pattern: three parts that cannot be redeemed and a fourth that is raised to holiness, matching the three impure kelipos and kelipas nogah.
- 27:43 Even a gentile's mercy can be selfish: he gives to the hungry so that he himself can enjoy his ice cream in peace.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Yechezkel HaNavi
Terms ארבע יסודות, נפש הבהמית, סטרא אחרא, עצבות, ערלה, פריעה, קליפת נוגה, שלש קליפות הטמאות, שם הוי"ה