Shelach
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current שלח no. 13 תשע"א (2010–11) Yiddish 40 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav teaches bachurim that good middos are the precondition for Torah, that a person's middos reach even into his property and his friends, and that from bnei Torah, like a silk shirt, far more is demanded than the letter of the law.
The Rav opens with Rabbi Chaim Vital's question in Shaarei Kedushah: why does the Torah hardly speak of middos? The answer is that derech eretz precedes Torah: the Torah was given to people who already have middos. He urges the bachurim going to camp to stress middos and be role models. Middos are hidden in the laws of damages: a person's property is an extension of his nefesh, as the story of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair's donkey shows, so an honest owner's ox does not damage, and a tzaddik's belongings and even friends absorb his soul. Through Rabbah bar bar Chana's porters and the Zohar's stringency on netilas yadayim, he explains that the Torah has levels matching levels of the soul, and more is demanded of a ben Torah. A spot ruins a silk shirt but not a potato sack. He closes with Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, who refused to sign the cherem and merited a chain of generations.
Topics: Middos Tovos · Bein Adam LaChaveiro
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Torah is silent about middos
The Rav brings Rabbi Chaim Vital's question why the Torah hardly speaks of middos, and answers that derech eretz precedes Torah: middos are a precondition. He then tells the bachurim going to camp to stress middos and be role models for others.
-
4:18 Damages and the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
The Rav shows that the laws of damages in Bava Kamma teach respect for another's property, and explains the Mishnah's 'I made its damage possible' to mean that a person's property is part of his nefesh. He proves it from the Gemara's story of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair's donkey, which would not eat untithed grain.
-
10:00 An honest owner's ox does not damage
The Rav explains that an honest Jew's ox will not damage, and reads the kinds of damage (goring, eating, trampling) as reflections of the owner's own middos. From the same idea he explains why a tzaddik's belongings are precious and why a baal middos makes his friends into baalei middos.
-
13:29 Rabbah bar bar Chana and the porters Story
The Rav tells the Gemara's story of Rabbah bar bar Chana, whose porters broke his wine barrels: Rav ruled that he must forgo the damage and even pay their wages, citing 'that you may walk in the way of the good'. He then raises a parallel question: why does the Zohar forbid walking four amos before washing in the morning when the Shulchan Aruch does not?
-
17:27 Levels of Torah, levels of the soul
The Rav explains that the Torah has four levels, pshat, remez, drush and sod, matching the levels of the soul, nefesh, ruach and neshamah, and brings the Arizal on receiving the extra souls of Shabbos. A simple Jew fulfils the pshat; a ben Torah must do more, and a higher Jew must keep the sod of the Zohar. This is what Rav told Rabbah bar bar Chana.
-
22:17 The potato sack and the silk shirt
The Rav gives a parable: a paint spot on a potato sack does not matter, but a small spot ruins a silk shirt for a wedding. Bnei Torah are silk; poor middos in them, like not greeting people or not standing up for an elderly man on the bus, are a chillul Hashem. For them, going beyond the letter of the law is the law.
-
29:54 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin and the cherem Story
The Rav tells how the Vilna Gaon, fearing another false messiah like Shabbsai Tzvi, opposed the Ba'al Shem Tov and had his students sign a cherem against the chassidim, and only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused. He explained this from the Akeidah: Hashem Himself commanded Avraham to slaughter Yitzchak, but an angel was enough to stop him, so a command to harm a Jew is not accepted even from a great angel.
-
35:20 A chain of generations as the reward
The Rav lists chassidic dynasties where son after son were great tzaddikim, and notes that among the Litvish this is not found, except for the descendants of Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, the Brisker family. He brings that this was his reward for refusing to harm a Jew, and closes that one must work on middos between man and his fellow even more than on other halachos.
The shiur, written up
Why the Torah is silent about middos
The Rav brings Rabbi Chaim Vital's question in Shaarei Kedushah: middos are so important, so why does the Torah say so little about them? The answer is that derech eretz precedes Torah. The Torah was given to people who already have middos; this is a precondition, like the entrance test a bachur takes before a yeshivah gedolah. a,b
Turning to the bachurim leaving for camp, where they will eat, learn and sleep together with friends, he says middos matter even more there, and one should be a role model for a friend who lacks them.
Damages and the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
The Torah does command 'do what is right and good', and gives the details in the laws of Bava Kamma: respecting another's property and not being a damager. The Mishnah lists the categories of damage and holds the owner liable because he made the damage possible. The Rav explains that a person's property is part of him, an extension of his nefesh. c,d,e
An honest owner's ox does not damage
So an honest Jew's ox will not damage; had the owner been more upright, his ox would not have harmed. For the same reason a tzaddik's belongings are precious, because his soul entered them. And one who becomes a true baal middos makes his friends into baalei middos too, since a friend is part of one's nefesh.
Rabbah bar bar Chana and the porters
The Rav tells the Gemara's story: Rabbah bar bar Chana's porters broke his wine barrels, and Rav ruled that, being poor, they need not pay, and then that he must even pay their wages. Each time he asked 'is this the law?', Rav answered with the verse of walking in the way of the good and keeping the paths of the righteous. g,h
Levels of Torah, levels of the soul
He answers that the Torah has four parts, pshat, remez, drush and sod, as the soul has levels: nefesh, ruach and neshamah. The Arizal describes receiving these extra souls at points in the Shabbos davening.
The potato sack and the silk shirt
The Rav gives a parable. A farmer complains of a paint spot inside a potato sack and is told it is foolishness. Later, as a clothing merchant, he sells a silk shirt for a wedding and the customer returns it over a tiny spot; now the spot ruins the whole shirt.
Bachurim, bnei Torah, are the silk shirt; more is demanded of them. A bachur who learns diligently and goes to the mikveh but does not answer 'good morning', or keeps his seat on a packed bus when an elderly man comes in, causes a chillul Hashem.
Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin and the cherem
The Rav relates that shortly before the Ba'al Shem Tov, Shabbsai Tzvi claimed to be the messiah and told people the mitzvos need not be kept, and many followed him. The Vilna Gaon feared the Ba'al Shem Tov was another such case and, for the sake of Heaven, had his students sign a cherem against the chassidim. He erred, the Rav says, but meant well.
A chain of generations as the reward
Among chassidic tzaddikim, the Rav notes, many left a chain of generations, son after son great tzaddikim: from the Maggid through Rabbi Avraham HaMalach and Rabbi Shalom of Prohobisht to the Ruzhiner and his descendants, the Gerrer line from the Sfas Emes, and the Chabad line from the Ba'al HaTanya.
Among the Litvish this is not found, except for Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, whose descendants are the Brisker family. He merited it because he guarded himself from harming a Jew and did not sign the cherem. The Rav concludes that one must work on middos between man and his fellow even more than on other halachos.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:22 The Torah hardly speaks of middos explicitly because derech eretz precedes Torah: middos are a precondition for receiving it.
- 6:45 The laws of damages carry a lesson in middos: a person's property is part of his nefesh, so the way his animal behaves reflects his own middos.
- 17:43 The Torah has levels, pshat, remez, drush and sod, matching the levels of the soul, and the higher a person stands the more is demanded of him.
- 25:01 Bnei Torah are like a silk shirt: a small flaw in middos that would not matter elsewhere ruins them and causes a chillul Hashem.
- 29:15 For bnei Torah, going beyond the letter of the law is itself the law.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:30 Since middos are so important, why does the Torah hardly speak of them?
Answer: 1:41 Because derech eretz precedes Torah: the Torah was given to people who already have middos, as a precondition, like an entrance test for a yeshivah.
-
Question: 8:49 Why would Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair's donkey refuse untithed grain, when an animal has no free choice?
Answer: 9:09 Because a person's property is part of his nefesh; the soul of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair had spread into his animal.
-
Question: 16:32 Why does the Zohar forbid walking four amos in the morning before washing, when the Shulchan Aruch does not?
Answer: 17:29 The Torah has four levels matching the levels of the soul: a simple Jew is bound by the pshat of the Shulchan Aruch, while a higher Jew must keep the sod of the Zohar.
-
Question: 16:05 How could Rav require Rabbah bar bar Chana to forgo the damage and pay the workers, against the strict law?
Answer: 21:53 By the Shulchan Aruch the workers would have to pay, but Rabbah bar bar Chana stood higher, and for him the halachah is different.
-
Question: 34:17 Why did Hashem Himself command Avraham to bring Yitzchak, but send an angel to stop him?
Answer: 34:36 To command slaughtering a Jew one does not believe even an angel, so Hashem Himself had to say it; to save, an angel suffices.
-
Question: 38:43 Why did Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, alone among the Litvish, merit a chain of great generations?
Answer: 39:31 Because he guarded himself from harming any Jew and did not sign the cherem.
Stories
-
7:16 Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair's donkey
Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair came to a place, and the innkeeper gave his donkey barley, but the donkey would not eat. When the innkeeper asked why, Rabbi Pinchas suggested that perhaps the grain was demai, produce bought from an unlearned person from which the tithe had not been separated. The Rav explains that a person with free choice knows what he may eat, but here the soul of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair had spread even into his animal.
In the story: Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
-
13:40 Rabbah bar bar Chana's wine barrels
Rabbah bar bar Chana hired workers to carry his barrels of wine, and on the way they dropped them and the wine spilled out. He called them to a din Torah before Rav, who ruled that since they were poor they need not pay. When the workers then said they had not been paid for their day's work, Rav ruled that he must pay them. Each time Rabbah bar bar Chana asked whether this was the law, Rav answered with the verse about walking in the way of the good and keeping the paths of the righteous.
In the story: Rabbah bar bar Chana, Rav
-
30:59 Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refuses to sign
The Rav relates that shortly before the Ba'al Shem Tov there was the false messiah Shabbsai Tzvi, who told people the mitzvos no longer had to be kept, and many Jews were drawn after him. The Vilna Gaon feared the Ba'al Shem Tov might be another such case and, for the sake of Heaven, made a cherem against the chassidim and told his students to sign it. Only Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin refused. When his rebbe asked him why, he answered from the Akeidah that his rebbe was a great angel, but a command from an angel to harm a Jew is not obeyed.
In the story: the Vilna Gaon, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, the Ba'al Shem Tov, Shabbsai Tzvi
Insights
- 6:34 The Rav reads the Mishnah's 'I made its damage possible' as saying that a person's property is an extension of his nefesh, so the owner of a damaging ox is himself the source of the damage.
- 10:30 He reads the categories of damage as the owner's middos showing through his animal: goring reflects a will to harm, eating another's grain reflects desire, and trampling reflects carelessness about others.
- 12:55 Because a friend is part of one's nefesh, a person who becomes a true baal middos will make his friends into baalei middos too.
- 18:14 The four levels of Torah correspond to the levels of the soul, so the Zohar's stringencies and Rav's ruling for Rabbah bar bar Chana are the halachah for a person on a higher level, not a departure from it.
- 34:25 From the Akeidah, where Hashem Himself commanded the slaughter but an angel sufficed to stop it, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin learned that a command to harm a Jew is not accepted even from a great angel.
- 38:45 The Rav connects Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin's refusal to harm a Jew with the unbroken chain of great descendants he merited, unusual among the Litvish.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 2:53 The Rav tells the bachurim that in camp, living together with friends, they must put even more emphasis on middos and be a role model for a friend who lacks them.
- 26:14 He says a bachur should answer when greeted, and should give up his seat on a crowded bus to an elderly man; failing to is a chillul Hashem.
- 28:08 He warns against the wild new way of pushing and grabbing that has entered among yeshivah bachurim, and says bnei Torah must go beyond the letter of the law.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rabbah bar bar Chanah, Rabbi Avraham HaMalach, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, Rabbi Chaim Soloveitchik (Reb Chaim Brisker), Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, Rabbi Shalom of Prohobisht, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rav (the Amora), Shabsai Tzvi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Beis HaLevi (Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik of Brisk), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Noda BiYehudah, the Sfas Emes, the Tzemach Tzedek, the Vilna Gaon
Terms דמאי, דרך ארץ קדמה לתורה, חילול השם, לפנים משורת הדין, מדות, נשמה יתירה, עקידה, פרד"ס