טעם של כפירה הוא rationalization

Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that kefirah is not a conclusion of the mind but a rationalization of the heart: a person who does not want to carry the Torah's demands fools himself with denial and invented reasons.

The Rav opens with the teaching of tzaddikim that fooling oneself is worse than fooling others, since the one who deceives others at least knows the truth. Chazal read 'do not stray after your hearts' as minus, heresy: kefirah comes from the heart, the seat of desires, not from the mind. Psychology, a new science, names two forms of this self-deception. Denial: Chiel of Beis El kept building Yericho while his sons died one by one under Yehoshua's curse; the ostrich hides its head in the sand; the smoker insists cigarettes will not harm him. Rationalization: the ba'al gaavah invents reasons to defend his pride, the bochur blames everything but himself, the wolf calls the grapes sour. This, the Rav says, is the secret of the apikores: Hashem is visible everywhere, but the Torah is too hard for them, so they build ever-changing theories of creation. Every Jew truly believes; old people return to teshuvah once their desires fade, while those driven by gaavah often do not.

Topics: Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Fooling oneself and the heart's desires

    The Rav contrasts the Torah's ban on lying to others with the tzaddikim's warning against fooling oneself, and brings Chazal that 'after your hearts' means heresy, which grows from desires. He notes that psychology, a new science, sheds light on this, adding the Chazon Ish's reply that Chumash and Rashi already teach it.

  2. 4:20 Denial: Chiel, the ostrich and the smoker

    The Rav tells how Chiel of Beis El rebuilt Yericho despite Yehoshua's curse, losing his sons one by one, and asks why he did not stop. The answer is denial, which he illustrates with the bird that buries its head in the sand and the smoker who insists his cigarette will not harm him.

  3. 8:59 Rationalization and the sour grapes listed in the guide

    The Rav defines rationalization as inventing reasons to defend one's pride or desire: the ba'al gaavah who keeps his pride, the bochur who blames his chavrusa, rebbi and the room for not learning, the man who blames the hammer. He tells the fable of the wolf who could not climb the fence and declared the grapes sour.

  4. 13:04 Why apikorsim invent theories of creation listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why apikorsim, who inherited emunah and can see Hashem in nature, history and events, invent ever-changing theories of creation instead of accepting the Chumash. He recalls the evolution taught in his school days, and a frum chief physicist who refuted evolution from science to the yeshiva bochurim, and concludes that they deny because the Torah is too hard for them: the sour grapes again.

  5. 21:27 No true atheist: teshuvah, taivah and gaavah listed in the guide

    The Rav argues that no apikores is truly certain; at most he has a doubt, which no one would gamble on, as with poisoned bottles. Old people do teshuvah once their desires fade, while those driven by gaavah often do not. He concludes that every Jew believes and even a non-Jew can see Hashem through His deeds, citing Reb Elchonon Wasserman that a kofer is liable because kefirah is rationalization.

The shiur, written up

Fooling oneself and the heart's desires

0:08

The Rav notes that the Torah forbids deceiving others, but tzaddikim warned even more against fooling oneself: one who fools another at least knows the truth, while one who fools himself does not even know it.

1:08

Chazal read the verse 'do not stray after your hearts' as referring to heresy. Kefirah, the Rav explains, comes from the heart, the seat of desires, and a person fools himself because he has desires. Psychology sheds light on this, yet the Chazon Ish told a melamed that Chumash and Rashi already teach it. a,b

Denial: Chiel, the ostrich and the smoker

4:38

Yehoshua cursed whoever would rebuild Yericho to lose his firstborn at its foundation and his youngest when he set its gates, and the Navi tells that Chiel of Beis El built it and buried his sons one by one. The Rav asks why he did not stop. d,e

6:38

The answer is denial: refusing to admit what one knows deep in one's heart. The bird hides its head in the sand so as not to see the danger, and the smoker, who knows what cigarettes do, tells himself that this one will not harm him.

Rationalization and the sour grapes

9:05

Rationalization, the Rav explains, is inventing reasons to protect a desire or one's pride. The ba'al gaavah devises arguments to defend his gaavah; the bochur who does not learn blames his chavrusa, his rebbi, the heat or the cold, but never says he does not want to; the man who hits his finger blames the hammer. So the wolf who could not climb the fence declared the grapes sour.

Why apikorsim invent theories of creation

13:21

This, the Rav says, is the secret of the apikores. Every Jew inherited emunah, and Hashem can be seen in nature, in history and in current events. Why then do they invent theories of how the world was created instead of turning to the Chumash? Because accepting it would oblige them to keep the mitzvos, just as the nations refused the Torah when they heard it forbade what their nature craved. f

17:19

Their theories must be revised every few years. The Rav recalls being taught at school, as certain, things about Mars and the moon that were later disproved, and a frum chief physicist of the Atomic Energy Commission who refuted evolution to the yeshiva bochurim from science alone. They deny because the Torah is too hard for them: sour grapes.

No true atheist: teshuvah, taivah and gaavah

21:51

The Rav cites a non-Jewish essayist who wrote that there is no true atheist. At most the apikores has a doubt, yet no one drinks from a hundred bottles when one is poisoned, as when Tylenol was pulled from the shelves. Old people in a nursing home do teshuvah because their desires have faded and the excuse is gone; those driven by gaavah often do not, since admitting a life of error would wound the ego.

26:57

Every Jew believes, the Rav concludes, even one who calls himself an apikores, and even a non-Jew can see Hashem through His deeds. Therefore Reb Elchonon Wasserman says a kofer is held liable: the mind can grasp Hashem, and kefirah is rationalization.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Bamidbar 15:39 text index In the write-up: 1:08
  2. f Bereishis (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:21

Nevi'im

  1. d apparently Yehoshua 6:26 index In the write-up: 4:38
  2. e apparently Melachim I 16:34 index In the write-up: 4:38

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Berachos 12b text index In the write-up: 1:08

Rishonim

  1. c Rashi (place not identified) 2:08 index

Key points

  1. 0:21 Following the tzaddikim, the Rav says one must guard even more against fooling oneself than against fooling others, because self-deception hides the truth even from the deceiver.
  2. 1:08 Chazal read 'after your hearts' as heresy: kefirah comes from the heart, the source of desires, and a person can fool himself because he has desires.
  3. 6:16 Denial means refusing to admit what a person knows deep down, as with Chiel of Beis El, the ostrich and the smoker.
  4. 9:41 Rationalization means inventing reasons to protect one's pride or desire, like the wolf who declared the grapes he could not reach to be sour.
  5. 15:28 The apikores denies creation not because the Torah's account makes no sense, but because the Torah's demands are too hard for him, so he builds his own theories.
  6. 26:57 Every Jew believes in the Ribono shel Olam even when he calls himself an apikores; he only denies it, and even a non-Jew can see Hashem through His deeds.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 6:16 Why did Chiel not stop building Yericho when he saw Yehoshua's curse being fulfilled on his sons one by one?

    Answer: 6:38 Because of denial: a person can refuse to admit what he knows deep in his heart to be true.

  2. Question: 8:33 Why does a smoker keep smoking when he knows it is deadly?

    Answer: 8:41 He denies it, telling himself with each cigarette that this one will not harm him.

  3. Question: 14:20 Why do apikorsim, who can see Hashem everywhere, not accept the Chumash's account of creation?

    Answer: 15:54 Because accepting it would oblige them to keep the mitzvos, which is too hard for them; so they rationalize and make their own theories.

  4. Question: 23:50 Why do people who lived without Torah suddenly do teshuvah in old age?

    Answer: 23:58 Until then they were slaves to their desires; once they can no longer indulge them, the reason for the rationalization is gone, because every Jew truly knows.

  5. Question: 25:26 Why do some never do teshuvah, even at the last moment?

    Answer: 26:26 Because their driving force is gaavah, which does not leave with age, and admitting they lived their whole life in error would wound their pride.

Stories

  1. 3:13 The Chazon Ish and the successful melamed

    A very successful melamed asked the Chazon Ish whether he should study books on educational psychology to become a better melamed. The Chazon Ish answered him: why study psychology books, what is wrong with Chumash and Rashi? Learn Chumash and Rashi and you will know psychology.

    In the story: the Chazon Ish

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 11:21 The wolf and the sour grapes

    In one of the well-known animal fables, a wolf came to a vineyard and saw beautiful, tempting grapes behind a high fence. For three days and three nights he struggled to climb over it. When he saw he could not, he turned around, said the grapes were sour, and walked away, because he did not want to admit he lacked the strength.

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  3. 19:12 The physicist who refuted evolution

    Some twenty years earlier, the Rav recalls, the yeshiva invited one of the chief physicists of the Atomic Energy Commission in Washington, from the time the hydrogen bomb was made, to speak to the bochurim. He was an ehrlicher Jew who gave a shiur every night, and while waiting before his appointment he sat down to learn Gemara. In his lecture, not from the side of Torah but from science alone, he took apart the theories of evolution piece by piece.

Insights

  1. 1:27 Chazal locate heresy in the heart rather than the mind: the verse warns against straying 'after your hearts', and the heart is the seat of desires, so kefirah is born of wanting, not of thinking.
  2. 6:16 Chiel of Beis El, burying son after son as Yehoshua's curse came true and still building, is the Navi's picture of denial: a person can watch the truth happen before his eyes and refuse to admit it.
  3. 17:06 The evolving, constantly revised theories of creation are themselves a sign of rationalization: having rejected the Chumash's account for reasons of the heart, the apikores must keep rewriting his own.
  4. 16:29 The Rav compares rejecting the Torah to the nations who refused it at Sinai: they too rejected it because a particular commandment opposed their nature, not because it made no sense.
  5. 25:35 The two driving forces of the soul, taivah and gaavah, explain who returns at the end of life: when desire fades the excuse is gone and people do teshuvah, but gaavah does not leave with age, and admitting a life lived in error would wound the ego.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 0:21 Citing tzaddikim, the Rav says a person must guard himself even more against fooling himself than against fooling others.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Chiel of Beis El, Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Rashi, Sigmund Freud, the Chazon Ish, Yehoshua bin Nun

Terms אפיקורס, גאוה, כפירה, מינות, מעשה בראשית, ענוה, רבונו של עולם, תאוה, תשובה

Report an error on this page