צורך המיוחד להדגיש אמיתיות התורה לדורנו
Catalog entry: אמונה ב' no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 40 Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
In a time of hester panim, when open miracles are not seen, the Rav shows why the truth of the Torah rests on events an entire people witnessed: Matan Torah before millions, and a sefer Torah that described what that whole generation had seen with its own eyes.
The Rav opens by describing the present as a time of hester panim, when the open miracles of earlier tzaddikim are no longer seen. After a long stretch of unusable audio, he brings the passuk in Devarim that asks whether any nation ever heard the voice of G-d speaking as the Jews did, and stresses that at Matan Torah the whole people, millions of men, women and children, became prophets at once; an event witnessed by so many cannot be denied. He then turns to the last mitzvah of the Torah, that every Jew write a sefer Torah. All the sifrei Torah were identical, and the generation that received them, who had been children under twenty in the wilderness, found in it the events of the forty years they had lived through, and agreed that it was true. In the last part, he cites the principle that the Torah will never be exchanged, and argues that a Torah of hard obligations would not have been accepted had it not been true.
Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai · Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A time of hester panim listed in the guide
The Rav opens by calling the present a time of hester panim, when the miracles that tzaddikim once showed in the world are no longer seen. Much of the stretch is badly garbled.
-
7:30 Unusable audio (Unclear audio)
-
22:30 A revelation before a whole nation listed in the guide
The Rav brings the passuk in Devarim asking whether any people ever heard the voice of G-d as the Jews did, and stresses that millions became prophets at once. Such an event, witnessed by so many and handed down through the generations, cannot be denied.
-
28:04 Every Jew's sefer Torah as testimony listed in the guide
The Rav explains the last mitzvah of the Torah, that every Jew write a sefer Torah, all of them identical. The generation that received it had been children in the wilderness, recognized in it the forty years they had lived through, and agreed that it was true.
-
32:01 A Torah that will not be exchanged listed in the guide
The Rav cites the principle that the Torah will never be exchanged, and argues that people would accept a teaching that lets them eat what they want, but a Torah of hard obligations was accepted only because it was true. The end of the recording is badly garbled.
The shiur, written up
A time of hester panim
The Rav opens by describing the present as a time of hester panim, when Hashem's face is hidden, and refers to the Gemara on this. He contrasts it with earlier generations, when tzaddikim showed miracles in the world; today, he says, such miracles are not seen. Much of this opening is too garbled in the recording to follow further.
A revelation before a whole nation
The Rav brings the passuk in Devarim 4:32-33, which tells the Jews to ask of all the generations and all the lands whether anything like this ever happened, whether a people ever heard the voice of G-d speaking as they did. He stresses that the whole people heard it: every Jew became a prophet, thousands upon thousands, millions of people. a
From here he draws his point. An event that happened before so many people, and was handed down from generation to generation, cannot be denied.
Every Jew's sefer Torah as testimony
The Rav then turns to the last mitzvah of the Torah, in Devarim 31:19, that every Jew have his own sefer Torah. Every sefer Torah was exactly the same, and there could not be a different version of the Torah. b
Those who received it, he explains, had been children under twenty in the wilderness and were now grown men who remembered everything that had happened. They found in the Torah the events of the forty years they had lived through, and all agreed that this was the sefer Torah and that it was true.
A Torah that will not be exchanged
The Rav cites the principle of faith in the Ani Maamin, principle 9, that this Torah will not be exchanged and there will be no other Torah. c
He then argues from how people behave. When told there is a G-d, they accepted it, and a teaching that freed them from hard obligations and let them eat whatever they want would be accepted easily. Yet the Jews accepted a Torah full of demands, which shows that it is true. The rest of the recording is too garbled to follow.
Sources
Torah
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:10 The Rav describes the present as a time of hester panim, when the open miracles of earlier generations are not seen.
- 23:54 At Matan Torah an entire people of millions heard Hashem speak and became prophets, something no other nation ever claimed.
- 24:55 An event that happened before so many people and was handed down through the generations cannot be denied.
- 28:04 Every Jew was commanded to write his own sefer Torah, and all the sifrei Torah were exactly the same.
- 29:38 The generation that received the sefer Torah had lived through the forty years it described and confirmed that it was true.
- 32:03 The Rav cites the principle of faith that the Torah will never be exchanged for another.
Insights
- 24:41 The Rav rests the truth of the Torah not on miracles a person must take on trust but on a public event: millions heard Hashem speak at once, and an event seen by so many cannot be denied.
- 28:41 He reads the mitzvah that every Jew write a sefer Torah as a test of truth: the identical Torah given to everyone described events the whole generation had seen itself, so it could be checked by all.
- 29:38 He points out that those who received the sefer Torah had been children under twenty in the wilderness and were now grown men who remembered everything that had happened.
- 33:34 He argues that a teaching that lets people eat whatever they want would be easily accepted, so the acceptance of a Torah full of hard obligations itself shows its truth.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu