נצחיות של עם ישראל§ ביאור שנאת הגיום§ קשר מיוחד בין ארץ ישראל ועם ישראל
Catalog entry: אמונה ב' no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 40 Yiddish 39 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav shows three wonders of the Jewish people: their eternity, the nations' jealous hatred of the chosen people who light up the world, and their unique bond with Eretz Yisroel, which blooms only for them.
Continuing from the previous week, the Rav recalls that the mighty empires that destroyed the Beis Hamikdash have vanished while the small Jewish people lives on, as the pesukim in Malachi, the tochachah, Nitzavim and Yeshayahu promise. He then asks why the nations are so bothered that Jews call themselves the chosen people, and answers that they know it is true; their jealousy turns into hatred, as the Zohar shows from Yosef and his brothers. He reads Mark Twain and Tolstoy on the Jew's immortality and a letter of President Adams on the Jews as the teachers of belief in one G-d, and adds the Abarbanel and Spain's decline after the expulsion. The third wonder is the bond with Eretz Yisroel: Jews still mourn it after two thousand years, and the land, desolate under every other people, now blooms as the Jews return, which the Gemara calls the clearest sign of the end of exile.
Topics: Netzach Yisroel · Yisroel and the Nations · Traveling to and Living in Eretz Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The eternal people outlives the empires listed in the guide
The Rav recalls last week's theme, that the empires who destroyed the Beis Hamikdash vanished while Israel lives on, and brings the promises of Malachi, the tochachah, Nitzavim and Yeshayahu that the Jews will remain a small but enduring people and return to their land.
-
4:35 Why the nations hate the chosen people listed in the guide
The Rav asks why it bothers the nations that Jews call themselves chosen, when other peoples' boasts are only laughed at. He answers that they know it is true and cannot become Jews themselves, so they are jealous, and jealousy breeds hatred, as the Zohar learns from Yosef and his brothers; this is the root of the persecutions throughout the exile.
-
8:02 Mark Twain and Tolstoy on the eternal Jew listed in the guide
The Rav reads, in English, Mark Twain's description of the Jew who is barely one percent of mankind yet outlived Egypt, Babylon, Persia, Greece and Rome, and Tolstoy's words that the Jew is the emblem of eternity whom no persecution could destroy. He concludes with Moshe Rabbeinu's words that the nations will call Israel a wise and understanding people.
-
13:47 Surviving every catastrophe; the Abarbanel and Spain listed in the guide
The Rav lists the catastrophes since those writers, the pogroms, the Holocaust and the wars, which the Jews survived as the eternal people and a light to the nations. Every king had Jewish advisors; the Abarbanel, minister of the king of Spain, refused to stay when the Jews were expelled, and Spain sank into insignificance without its Jews.
-
18:40 A light to the nations: President Adams's letter listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Christianity and Islam both come from the Jews, who brought emunah to the world, as Yeshayahu said that nations will walk by Israel's light. He reads a letter of President John Adams answering a call to make Jews second-class citizens, that the Hebrews did more to civilize mankind than any nation by teaching belief in one supreme G-d, and notes that Jews still fill the highest offices, fulfilling the blessing to Avraham.
-
24:10 The third wonder: longing for Eretz Yisroel listed in the guide
The Rav moves to the third wonder, the bond of the Jews with Eretz Yisroel: no other people longs for a homeland it lost, yet Jews mention and mourn it three times a day. He tells of Napoleon finding Jews mourning on Tisha B'Av and saying such a people will surely return to its land, and adds that whole communities gave their lives for Hashem, which no other nation can claim.
-
29:10 A land that blooms only for the Jews listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Torah's praise of the good land the Jews were brought to, and the tochachah's warning that in exile it would become desolate, so that a stranger would see it burnt and unsown. He concludes that with the Jews the land is the most fruitful, and without them a wasteland, as he himself saw on his first visit some thirty years earlier.
-
32:40 The blooming land as the revealed end listed in the guide
The Rav describes how the land, which for two thousand years no nation could settle, is now covered with fields and forests as the Jews return, and brings the Gemara in Sanhedrin that there is no clearer sign of the end than Eretz Yisroel giving its fruit. He recalls the tiny fruits once brought from there and its poverty, contrasts them with today's prosperity, and calls it a wonder before one's eyes.
The shiur, written up
The eternal people outlives the empires
The Rav returns to last week's theme: Egypt, Babylon, Greece, Persia and Rome, the mighty powers that destroyed the Beis Hamikdash, have vanished, while Israel remains, as Malachi says, "you, children of Yaakov, have not been consumed" (Malachi 3:6). Moshe Rabbeinu promised that Hashem would never reject them to destroy them (Vayikra 26:44), and that He would gather them back even from the ends of the heavens (Devarim 30:3-4). a,b,c
The Torah foretold that they would remain few in number, and so they are: fifteen million Jews against over three hundred million descendants of Yishmael. Yet Yeshayahu promised that mountains may move but Hashem's covenant will not (Yeshayahu 54:10), and Hashem will bring them back and do them more good than their fathers (Devarim 30:5). d,e
Why the nations hate the chosen people
The Rav asks why it bothers the nations that Jews call themselves the chosen people, when tribes that boast of being the best are merely laughed at. He answers that they know it is true, yet cannot become Jews themselves, so they are jealous; and jealousy breeds hatred, as the Zohar learns from Yosef, whose brothers first envied him and then hated him (Bereishis 37:4, 37:11). From this jealousy come the decrees, killings and expulsions that fill Jewish history in exile. f,g
Mark Twain and Tolstoy on the eternal Jew
The Rav notes that the nations' own wise men admit the Jews' superiority, and reads, in English, from Mark Twain's essay (Concerning the Jews): the Jews are barely one percent of mankind, yet their contributions are out of all proportion to their numbers; Egypt, Babylon, Persia, Greece and Rome rose and passed away, while the Jew saw them all, beat them all, and remains, and Twain asks what the secret of his immortality is. h
Surviving every catastrophe; the Abarbanel and Spain
Since those writers, the Rav says, came the pogroms in Russia, the Holocaust, two wars and the war in Eretz Yisroel, and the Jews outlived it all as the eternal people and, in Yeshayahu's words, a light to the nations. Every king in exile kept Jewish advisors because they were the best. j
One was the Abarbanel, minister to the king of Spain, a descendant of Dovid Hamelech and, as the Sanzer Rav said, one of three who knew the time of Moshiach. When Spain expelled its Jews, the king wanted him to stay, but he went with his people. Spain, then the mightiest power, became insignificant without its Jews.
A light to the nations: President Adams's letter
The Jews gave emunah to the world: Christianity and Islam both come from them, as Yeshayahu said, "nations shall walk by your light" (Yeshayahu 60:3). The Rav reads President John Adams's letter, written when someone wanted Jews treated like second-class citizens: the Hebrews did more to civilize men than any other nation, by teaching mankind of one supreme, wise, almighty sovereign of the universe. k
The third wonder: longing for Eretz Yisroel
The third wonder is the bond of the Jews with Eretz Yisroel. A Roman or a Greek does not long for his ancient homeland, yet Jews, two thousand years in exile, mention it and lament it three times a day. Napoleon, hearing weeping in a shul on Tisha B'Av and learning the reason, said that a people still longing for its land after seventeen hundred years will surely return to it.
The Rav adds that no other nation can claim what Jews did in the Crusades and the decrees of 1648: whole communities, not individuals, let themselves be killed rather than abandon Hashem.
A land that blooms only for the Jews
Hashem promised a land of brooks and springs, wheat and vines (Devarim 8:7-9), but warned that in exile it would be desolate (Vayikra 26:32-33), so that a stranger would see it burnt and unsown (Devarim 29:21-22). Hence, the Rav explains, with the Jews it is the most fruitful land, and without them a wasteland; on his first visit some thirty years earlier he found it stony and desolate. m,n,o
The blooming land as the revealed end
Now, the Rav says, the land is covered with fields and forests because Jews are returning. For two thousand years no nation could settle it; only wandering Bedouin passed through, nothing grew, and every power that tried to settle it failed, as the Torah warned that the enemies would be desolate there (Vayikra 26:32-33). n
The Gemara in Sanhedrin (98a) says there is no clearer sign of the end than Eretz Yisroel giving its fruit again, and the Rav joins it to Yirmeyahu's promise that joy will again be heard in Yehudah and Yerushalayim (Yirmeyahu 33:10). He recalls the tiny apples and walnuts once brought from there, and the poverty of its people, and contrasts them with today's millions of Jews and its prosperity: a wonder before one's eyes. p,q
Sources
Torah
- b apparently Vayikra 26:44 index In the write-up: 0:30
- c apparently Devarim 30:3-4 index In the write-up: 0:30
- e apparently Devarim 30:5 index In the write-up: 2:34
- g apparently Bereishis 37:4, 37:11 index In the write-up: 5:02
- i Devarim 4:6 text index In the write-up: 12:26
- l Bereishis (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:55
- m Devarim 8:7-9 text index In the write-up: 29:51
- n apparently Vayikra 26:32-33 index In the write-up: 29:51, 32:49
- o apparently Devarim 29:21-22 index In the write-up: 29:51
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Other
Key points
- 0:44 The great empires that oppressed Israel have vanished, while the small Jewish people has outlived them all, as Hashem promised through the Torah and the Neviim.
- 5:21 The nations hate the Jews because they are jealous of them, and they are jealous because they know the Jews really are the chosen people.
- 13:06 Honest non-Jewish thinkers such as Mark Twain, Tolstoy and President Adams admitted the Jew's eternity and his role in bringing belief in G-d to the world.
- 14:38 The Jews are a light to the nations, bringing wisdom and emunah to the whole world, as Yeshayahu foretold.
- 26:03 No other people longs for a land it left so long ago; the Jews still mourn Eretz Yisroel after two thousand years of exile.
- 31:35 Eretz Yisroel is fruitful only when the Jews are there; under others it stayed desolate, and its blooming today is the Gemara's clearest sign of the end of exile.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:44 How can the Jews, some fifteen million against hundreds of millions of Yishmaelim, be sure they will survive?
Answer: 3:20 Because Hashem promised through Yeshayahu that mountains may move but His covenant with Israel will not, and He made a covenant that they will always remain a people.
-
Question: 5:02 Why does it bother the nations that the Jews call themselves the chosen people, when many peoples boast and no one cares?
Answer: 5:21 Because they know it is true and cannot become Jews themselves, so they are jealous, and jealousy leads to hatred.
Stories
-
15:16 The Abarbanel refuses to stay in Spain
The Abarbanel, a great tzaddik and sage, was a minister of the king of Spain when the Jews were given the choice to convert or leave with nothing. The king told him that all the Jews must go but he should stay, because the king needed him. The Abarbanel refused, said he goes with his people, and left. After the Jews were gone, Spain, then the mightiest power, became a poor and insignificant country.
In the story: the Abarbanel
-
26:28 Napoleon and the mourners of Tisha B'Av
Napoleon, the ruler of France, passed a shul and heard crying inside. Curious, he went in and saw Jews sitting on the floor, and asked what day it was. They told him it was Tisha B'Av, when they weep because the Beis Hamikdash was destroyed and they were driven from Eretz Yisroel. He said that a people still longing for its land after seventeen hundred years will surely return to it.
In the story: Napoleon
-
31:53 The Rav's first visit and the small fruits
The Rav recalls that when he first traveled to Eretz Yisroel some thirty years earlier, he had imagined it beautiful, but found it desolate, with stony ground. He also remembers that Jews coming from Eretz Yisroel to America would bring its fruits along, tiny apples and small walnuts. Today, he says, the land is covered with growth and its fruits are large.
Insights
- 5:36 Other peoples' claims to be the best are simply laughed at; only the Jews' claim to be chosen provokes the nations, because they know in their hearts that it is true.
- 6:06 Since the nations cannot themselves become Jews and accept the Torah, their recognition turns into jealousy, and jealousy into hatred, as with Yosef's brothers; this is the root of the persecutions of the exile.
- 13:27 The admissions of Mark Twain, Tolstoy and President Adams are themselves a fulfillment of the pesukim that the nations will call Israel wise and will walk by its light; those gentiles with a point of truth concede it.
- 17:40 Spain, once the mightiest nation, sank into insignificance after it expelled its Jews, showing that the nations' greatness came from Jewish minds.
- 31:43 The Torah's warning that the land would be desolate is also a guarantee: for two thousand years no other people could settle it, and it flourishes only when the Jews return.
- 34:54 The Rav sees the change in Eretz Yisroel within a few decades, from desolation to fruitfulness and wealth, as the Gemara's revealed sign of the end, a wonder seen with one's own eyes.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, John Adams, Leo Tolstoy, Malachi, Mark Twain, Moshe Rabbeinu, Napoleon, the Abarbanel, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), Yaakov Avinu, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms גלות, השגחה פרטית, מסירות נפש, עם הנבחר, עם הנצח, קנאה, תשעה באב