לימוד משידוך הראשון - שנעשה בלי השתתפות של מעשי אדם
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע בראשית no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 3 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 47 min
Listen
About this shiur
From the first shidduch in the Torah, which came to Adam only when he stopped searching and slept, the Rav teaches bitachon, and then explains Rashi's question why the Torah opens with Bereishis through three 'Torahs': of creation, of man and of Yisrael.
The Rav opens with the principle that the first appearance of a thing in the Torah, the blueprint of the world, defines it. The first 'ezer' is the woman: Adam went through all the animals and found no partner, and only when Hashem cast sleep on him did he receive her. Help comes from Hashem, not from running around. He develops this with Chizkiyahu, who slept while Sancheriv's camp fell, with Yaakov, the father of bitachon, with the sukkah, whose essence is sleeping, and with the levels in gathering the manna. He then turns to Rashi's question why the Torah begins with Bereishis. The Torah holds three Torahs: of creation, which nature keeps without choice; of man, the seven mitzvos of Noach; and of Yisrael. Mankind failed three times, control passed to Avraham, and Eretz Yisrael, the center of creation, is claimed by all. All of Bereishis is the introduction to 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem'.
Topics: Bitachon · Adam HaRishon and Gan Eden · Miracles and Nature
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The first ezer: Adam's search for a partner listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that the first samech in the Torah is at the creation of the woman, and explains that the Torah is the blueprint of the world, so the first 'ezer' in it teaches what help is. Adam went through all the animals and found no partner; only when Hashem cast sleep on him and took his rib did he open his eyes and recognize his ezer.
-
3:57 Help comes from Hashem: sleep, Yaakov and the sukkah listed in the guide
The Rav draws the lesson that a person cannot get his ezer by running around; it comes from Hashem. He brings the Midrash on the kings, where Chizkiyahu said he would sleep and Hashem would fight, as happened with Sancheriv's camp, and the Midrash on Yaakov, the father of bitachon, who had nothing yet did not lose his trust. The sukkah, a flimsy hut open to rain, is the shelter of bitachon, and the Gemara speaks of sleeping in it because only one who feels secure can sleep.
-
10:26 Levels of bitachon: the manna and the lesson of bitul listed in the guide
The Rav cites the Chovos Halevavos in Shaar HaBitachon against the belief that one must chase extra jobs all day, and brings the levels at which the Jews gathered the manna: some ran out early, others went farther, and the tzaddikim who davened and learned found it at their door. He concludes that the first ezer in the Torah came after all Adam's efforts failed, and teaches bitul.
-
13:56 Rashi's question and the three Torahs
The Rav brings Rashi's question why the Torah did not begin with the first mitzvah given to Yisrael, and the answer that the nations should not call the Jews robbers, and asks why the nations still cry 'robbers' today. He sets out the order of the Torah: it contains three Torahs, of creation, of man and of Yisrael, and the Torah of creation runs from the first passuk of Bereishis.
-
18:51 Nature is a Torah, and a miracle changes it
The Rav brings the Gemara in Shabbos about the man for whom a miracle happened to nurse his child, and its criticism that the order of creation was changed for him. He explains that all of nature is written in the pesukim of Bereishis, as whole masechtos rest on a few words, so a bird flying or a tree giving fruit fulfills the Torah like a Jew putting on tefillin, only without choice. A miracle therefore changes the Torah, and tzaddikim held back from making miracles.
-
26:32 The Torah of man: creation in man's hands
The Rav explains the Torah of man: Hashem put all of nature under man, and the Gemara in Sanhedrin derives the seven mitzvos of Noach from one passuk. When man keeps his Torah, creation keeps its Torah; in the generation of the flood even the animals stopped keeping theirs, while in the generation of the desert all of nature flourished, and after the churban it declined. Because mankind sinned, Hashem took the control from them and after the generation of the dispersion gave it to Avraham Avinu.
-
33:12 Three strikes, and the last chance at Sinai
The Rav lays out the order of Bereishis as three strikes: Adam's sin with the Tree of Knowledge, the flood and the generation of the dispersion, after which the keys of creation passed to Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov and the shevatim. At the giving of the Torah Hashem gave the nations a last chance, going to Esav and Yishmael, who refused. All these stories are an introduction to 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', the Torah of Yisrael given only to the Jews.
-
36:33 Why the nations claim Eretz Yisrael
The Rav asks how the nations can claim the land from the Jews, when every land in history, America included, was taken by conquest, and conquest is a kinyan, as the Rambam explains about the kedushah of the land. He answers that Eretz Yisrael is different: it is the center of creation, where the world was founded and the Beis Hamikdash is hinted in the word Bereishis, so everyone wants a share. From Hevel through the Crusades to the daily newspapers, the wars center on it, and the seven nations include all seventy.
-
43:09 All of Bereishis as an introduction to Hachodesh
The Rav asks why the Torah did not open with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', since the most important comes first, and answers that the nations would ask why only the Jews received the Torah of Yisrael. Bereishis is a chapter of history: the nations had their chances, failed at the flood and the dispersion, and Hashem chose Avraham, swore the land to the Avos, and only then gave the Torah of Yisrael. The nations do not admit it now, but when Moshiach comes they will see the reason.
The shiur, written up
The first ezer: Adam's search for a partner
The Rav opens with the Midrash about the first samech in the Torah, at the creation of the woman. Since the Torah is the blueprint of the world, the first 'ezer' (helper) it mentions defines what help is, and that ezer is the woman. a
Adam went around to all the animals looking for a partner and found none. Only when Hashem cast sleep on him and took his rib did he open his eyes and recognize his ezer.
Help comes from Hashem
From this the Rav learns that a person cannot get his ezer by running around; it comes from Hashem, as the passuk in Tehillim 121 says. He brings the Midrash on the kings: Chizkiyahu said he would sleep and Hashem would fight his war, and in the middle of the Pesach night Sancheriv's camp was destroyed. g,h
Yaakov is the father of bitachon. According to the Midrash he fled with nothing, while Eliezer had come with ten camels, yet he did not lose his trust. The sukkah, a flimsy hut that the rain and wind enter, is the shelter of bitachon, and the Mishnah on sukkah speaks of sleeping, because only one who feels secure can sleep. o,p
Levels of bitachon and the lesson of bitul
The Rav cites the Chovos Halevavos in Shaar HaBitachon against thinking one must chase a second and third job. With the manna, as the Gemara in Yoma describes, some ran out early and others went farther, while the tzaddikim who davened and learned found it at their door. The first ezer came after all of Adam's efforts failed: a lesson in bitul. q,r
Rashi's question and the three Torahs
The Rav brings Rashi's question on the first passuk: why does the Torah not begin with the first mitzvah given to Yisrael? Rashi answers with the passuk in Tehillim 111: if the nations call the Jews robbers, they can reply that Hashem created the world and gave the land to whom He wished. The Rav asks why the nations still cry 'robbers' today. t,u
He explains that the Torah contains three Torahs: of creation, of man, which belongs to the nations as well, and of Yisrael. The Torah of creation begins with the first passuk of Bereishis.
Nature is a Torah, and a miracle changes it
The Gemara in Shabbos 53b tells of a poor man who could not hire a nursemaid, and a miracle let him nurse his infant himself. Yet the Gemara remarks how lowly he was that the order of creation was changed for him. x
The Torah of man
Next comes the Torah of man: Hashem put all of nature under man, as Dovid HaMelech says in Tehillim 8:7, and the Gemara in Sanhedrin 56b derives the seven mitzvos of Noach from the passuk in Bereishis 2:16. ab,ad,ae
If man keeps the Torah of man, creation keeps the Torah of creation, and if not, not. In the generation of the flood even the animals stopped keeping theirs. In the generation of the desert, which learned Torah from Moshe Rabbeinu for forty years, nature flourished so that one cluster of grapes needed eight men; after the churban it declined. Because mankind sinned, Hashem took the control away from them and gave it to Avraham Avinu.
Three strikes and a last chance
The Rav reads Bereishis as three strikes: Adam's sin, the flood and the dispersion, after which the keys of creation passed to Avraham and his children. At the giving of the Torah the nations got a last chance: Hashem went to Esav and to Yishmael, and they refused. All these stories lead up to 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem' in Shemos 12:2. v
Why the nations claim Eretz Yisrael
The Rav asks how the nations can claim the land at all. Every land in history was taken by conquest, as America was taken from the Indians, and conquest is a kinyan; the Rambam explains that this is why the kedushah of the land lapsed.
He answers that Eretz Yisrael is different. It is the center of creation, the place from which the world was founded, as in Yoma 54b, and the word Bereishis already hints at the Beis Hamikdash. Therefore everyone feels he must have a share in it: Hevel was killed over it, the Crusades were fought over it, and so tiny a country is on the front page every day. ai
All of Bereishis as an introduction
Since the Gemara says the most important comes first, the Rav asks why the Torah did not open with Hachodesh, Shemos 12:2. Bereishis is a chapter of history, which the passuk in Devarim 32:8 describes: the nations had their chances and failed, so Hashem chose Avraham and swore the land to the Avos, as in Tehillim 105:9-11. All of it explains why the Torah of Yisrael was given only to the Jews; the nations do not admit it now, but when Moshiach comes they will see the reason. v,aj,ak,al
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 2:21 0:31 text index
- c Bereishis 2:18 1:08 text index
- d Bereishis 2:23 1:52 text index
- f apparently Bereishis 2:20 2:51 index
- k apparently Bereishis 33:17 6:38 index
- s apparently Bamidbar 11:8 12:08 index
- v Shemos 12:2 text index In the write-up: 33:41, 43:19
- y apparently Devarim 24:1 index In the write-up: 20:54
- z Bereishis 1:20 text index In the write-up: 24:19
- aa Bereishis 1:11 text index In the write-up: 24:19
- ac apparently Bereishis 1:28 26:53 index
- ae apparently Bereishis 2:16 index In the write-up: 26:39
- af Bereishis (place not identified) 29:43 index
- ag apparently Bereishis 11:8 32:51 index
- ak Devarim 32:8 text index In the write-up: 43:19
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- g apparently Tehillim 121:1-2 index In the write-up: 3:57
- i Tehillim 18:38 5:29 text index
- m apparently Tehillim 46:8 6:47 index
- n apparently Tehillim 84:13 6:56 index
- u Tehillim 111:6 text index In the write-up: 14:03
- ab apparently Tehillim 8:7 index In the write-up: 26:39
- al apparently Tehillim 105:9-11 index In the write-up: 43:19
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Yevamos 63a 2:00 index
- l Gemara (place not identified) 6:47 index
- r apparently Yoma 75a index In the write-up: 10:51
- x Shabbos 53b text index In the write-up: 19:02
- ad Sanhedrin 56b text index In the write-up: 26:39
- ah Gemara (place not identified) 37:29 index
- ai apparently Yoma 54b index In the write-up: 38:41
- aj Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 43:19
Midrash
Rishonim
Key points
- 3:06 Adam found his ezer only after his own search through all the animals failed and Hashem cast sleep on him: real help comes from Hashem, not from one's own running.
- 6:33 The sukkah is the shelter of bitachon, the mark of Yaakov Avinu, the father of bitachon, and from Sukkos one takes bitachon for the whole year.
- 14:03 The Rav raises Rashi's question why the Torah does not begin with the first mitzvah, and Rashi's answer that the nations should not be able to call the Jews robbers.
- 16:45 The Torah contains three Torahs: the Torah of creation, the Torah of man given to the nations, and the Torah of Yisrael.
- 28:06 Creation was put under the control of man; when man keeps his Torah, nature keeps its Torah, and after three failures Hashem gave the keys to Avraham and his children.
- 38:41 Eretz Yisrael is the center and foundation of creation, which is why all the nations want a share in it.
- 36:23 All of Bereishis is an introduction to 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', explaining why the Torah of Yisrael was given only to the Jews.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:39 How did Adam, the first man, obtain his ezer?
Answer: 3:06 He went around to all the animals and could not find one; only when he went to sleep did Hashem take his rib and give him the woman.
-
Question: 10:01 Why does the Gemara on the mitzvah of sukkah speak mainly about sleeping rather than eating or drinking?
Answer: 10:18 Because sleeping is the essence of the sukkah, the shelter of bitachon, and a person who does not feel secure cannot sleep.
-
Question: 19:37 Why does the Gemara criticize a man for whom a miracle was made?
Answer: 20:54 Nature is written in the Torah and the creation fulfills it; a miracle changes nature and so changes the Torah, which is why tzaddikim avoided miracles.
-
Question: 14:03 Why does the Torah begin with Bereishis and not with the first mitzvah given to Yisrael?
Answer: 14:24 So that when the nations call the Jews robbers, the Jews can answer that Hashem created the world and gave the land to whom He wished.
-
Question: 38:24 How can the nations claim Eretz Yisrael from the Jews, when every nation took its land by conquest?
Answer: 38:41 Eretz Yisrael is different from all other lands: it is the center and foundation of creation, so everyone feels he should have a share in it.
-
Question: 43:19 If the most important comes first, why did the Torah not begin with 'Hachodesh hazeh lachem', the start of the Torah of Yisrael?
Answer: 46:19 All of Bereishis is the introduction that explains why the Torah of Yisrael was given only to the Jews and not to the nations.
Stories
-
5:38 Chizkiyahu sleeps while Sancheriv's camp falls
The Rav brings the Midrash that King Chizkiyahu said he would go to sleep and Hashem would fight his wars. When Sancheriv besieged Yerushalayim on the night of Pesach, the Jews made the Korban Pesach and told of the Exodus, and in the middle of the night Sancheriv's whole camp was destroyed by an angel.
In the story: Chizkiyahu HaMelech, Sancheiriv
-
19:02 The man who nursed his infant
The Rav retells the Gemara in Shabbos about a poor man who could not afford a nursemaid for his infant. A miracle happened and he was able to nurse the child himself. The Gemara comments how lowly this man was that the order of creation was changed for him.
Insights
- 0:40 Since the Torah is the blueprint of the world, the first time a thing appears in it defines it; the first 'ezer', Chava, was given to Adam only after all his efforts failed and he slept, so help by its nature comes without human action, an exercise in bitul.
- 8:35 The Gemara's laws of sukkah focus on sleeping rather than eating, because sleep is the essence of the sukkah: only one who feels secure can sleep, and the sukkah is a flimsy hut under Hashem's protection.
- 24:10 Nature is itself a Torah: a bird flying fulfills a command of the Torah just as a Jew putting on tefillin does, the only difference being that man has free choice.
- 19:47 Because nature is written in the Torah, a miracle that changes nature changes the Torah, which is why the Gemara criticizes the man for whom nature was changed and why tzaddikim avoided making miracles.
- 28:13 Creation keeps its Torah only when man keeps his: in the generation of the flood even the animals strayed from their kinds, while in the generation of the desert nature flourished so that one cluster of grapes needed eight men.
- 33:47 Bereishis is a history of three strikes against mankind, Adam, the flood and the dispersion, after which the keys of creation passed to Avraham, and even then the nations were given a last chance at Sinai.
- 38:41 The nations' claim to Eretz Yisrael, unlike any other land taken by conquest, comes from its being the center and root of creation, which even its name, the Mediterranean, 'middle of the land', reflects.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 3:57 The Rav says a person cannot obtain his ezer by running around and scheming; the help comes from Hashem.
- 9:08 The Rav says that as one takes freedom from Pesach and Torah from Shavuos for the whole year, from Sukkos one takes bitachon for the whole year, and its sign is simchah.
- 10:51 Citing the Chovos Halevavos, the Rav says a person should not think he must chase a second and third job and run all day after parnassah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Chizkiyahu HaMelech, Dovid HaMelech, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Esav, Hevel, Lavan, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yitzchak, Rashi, Sancheiriv, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms בחירה, בטחון, ביטול, דור הפלגה, החודש הזה לכם, טבע, ליסטים אתם, מבול, מן, מעשה בראשית, סוכה, רבונו של עולם, שבע מצוות בני נח, תרדמה