החילוק בין בגדי אהרן - “לכבוד ולתפארת'” ובגדי אחשורוש - “בהראותו” - לוקסוס

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע תצוה no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 10 תש"מ (1979–80) Yiddish 1 hr 43 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 43 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav contrasts the garments of Aharon, made 'for honor and for beauty' in Hashem's service, with Achashverosh's display of wealth 'to show off', and from there speaks against the luxury and showing off of his own community, the place of malchus and of the feminine side as the end of galus nears, and the great light of Purim.

The Rav opens with the priestly garments, made 'for honor and for beauty' as royal garments, and with the Chasam Sofer's reading of Rashi that the Kohen Gadol never wore them for his own honor. Achashverosh wore those same garments 'to show off the riches of his kingdom', and the Rav asks why he was not punished for this while Belshatzar and he were punished for using the vessels of the Beis Hamikdash. He calls his own community a 'behar'oso' community: houses, rings, weddings and even shuls built to make a name. Bringing a sefer, the Gemara and the Chofetz Chaim, he shows how luxury leads to debt, theft, envy of the nations and a coarse soul, and asks for moderation. He then answers the question through the holiness of malchus, explains that in the sitra achra the feminine side is stronger as Moshiach nears, reads Vashti, Memuchan and Daniel in that light, and closes with the light of Purim and a plea for mercy.

Topics: Middos Tovos · The Mishkan and the Kohanim · Megillas Esther

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Royal garments, not worn for his own honor listed in the guide

    The Rav opens with the priestly garments made 'for honor and for beauty', which the Rambam calls royal garments, and with Rashi's comment that the Kohen Gadol did not wear them for his own honor. He brings the Chasam Sofer's question and answer: the golden garments recalled the sin of the golden calf, so the Kohen Gadol wore them in shame before Hashem.

  2. 4:21 Achashverosh in the Kohen Gadol's garments listed in the guide

    From the Gemara the Rav shows that Achashverosh wore the Kohen Gadol's garments at his feast, and that Belshatzar was killed on the night he used the vessels of the Beis Hamikdash. He asks why Achashverosh was punished at once for the vessels but not for the garments, and explains that the motive of his feast was 'behar'oso', to show off his wealth.

  3. 10:10 A 'behar'oso' community listed in the guide

    The Rav says that 'behar'oso' is the plague of his generation and community: houses, curtains, chandeliers and marble built to outdo the neighbor. He then asks about the Gemara on Achashverosh's beds, whose frames were silver and whose legs were gold, although the legs are the lesser part.

  4. 13:15 The Ruzhiner way and the couch Story listed in the guide

    The Rav tells of his uncle in Yerushalayim, an upholsterer, and of a great Ruzhiner tzaddik there; he recalls the royal conduct of Ruzhin and the Ropshitzer's words about it. The tzaddik had the back of his couch redone in the same costly material, saying he learned from his father that what one lacks inside one does not show outside.

  5. 17:30 Gold where it shows: rings, weddings, shidduchim listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Achashverosh made the legs gold because they show, and the frame silver because it is hidden: pure behar'oso. Following the way of the Ba'al Shem Tov's students he speaks through the verse, then points to engagement rings, flowers, photographers and food at weddings, and even shidduchim, as the same race to outdo, from 'behar'oso' at the start of the feast to 'to show' Vashti at its end.

  6. 22:20 'Let us make a name' and Jewish clothing listed in the guide

    The Rav reads the generation of the Tower, 'let us make ourselves a name', as a shul built to be finer than the next one, unlike building to honor the House of Hashem. He brings the Chasam Sofer that Jews do not boast with clothing: clothes must be clean and neat, but fine dress was for Mordechai before the king, while for the Jews 'light, joy, gladness and honor' means Torah, Yom Tov, milah and tefillin.

  7. 25:38 How luxury leads to theft listed in the guide

    The Rav reads from a sefer (chapter 5) that explains how theft spread: excess spending on clothing and the home, the yetzer hara's push to live above one's real standard until it becomes second nature, then debts and shame. He calls for moderation according to a person and his place, not a rat race, and describes wedding costs in Yerushalayim rising to imitate America, with parents in tears.

  8. 34:58 The Chofetz Chaim's wallpaper and his journey listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Chofetz Chaim's saying that a house with fancy wallpaper is papered with pages of Gemara, since the extra hours of work could have gone to learning, and the story of the rich visitor who found almost no furniture in his house. From Shmuel HaRamasi, who took his vessels with him, he draws that one's home is on high, and he warns that Jewish luxury among the nations, as in Germany and Spain, brought envy.

  9. 38:50 'Three things widen the mind' and sparing Jewish money listed in the guide

    The Rav rejects the use of the Gemara's 'three things widen a person's mind' to justify luxury, bringing the Maharsha that they widen the mind toward worldly pleasure until one becomes like Bilaam. He then brings the rule that the Torah spares Jewish money, and asks why the Kohen Gadol's Yom Kippur garments and vessels were nevertheless so costly, even worth a hundred maneh.

  10. 43:24 The holiness of malchus answers the question listed in the guide

    The Rav answers that the Kohen Gadol is a king and his garments are for the honor of malchus, worn for Hashem and not for himself. Malchus deserves honor even in a non-Jewish king, as Moshe showed Pharaoh, Eliyahu Achav and Esther Achashverosh, because malchus has no counterpart in tumah and comes from holiness. So Achashverosh, a king, did not debase malchus by wearing the priestly garments, but giving the holy vessels to common guests did, and for that he was punished.

  11. 49:06 What not to learn from tzaddikim

    The Rav says that the great leaders of each generation may carry a certain malchus, but simple people cannot imitate it; one must know what to learn from tzaddikim, as the story of the chassid who copied his Rebbe's coffee in tefillin shows. Jews themselves should live as Jews always did, and he brings the Kotzker's saying that the world is the text and the Torah its commentary, which is how the Megillah teaches us to read events.

  12. 53:54 Male and female in holiness and in the sitra achra

    From 'binding his foal to the vine' the Rav explains that in holiness the male is stronger and in the sitra achra the female, as R' Chaim Vital saw in a dream. As Moshiach nears, the feminine side grows stronger; he points to 'ladies first', women's liberation and the call to draft women, which he sees as a danger to the Jewish family, contrary to the first mitzvah of the Torah.

  13. 59:18 The Megillah at the end of a galus

    The Rav says the Megillah is the story of the end of galus Bavel, as ours is the end of galus Edom, and in a side note explains why Daniel, prophet of the redemption, erred in the reckoning. The Megillah opens with the strength of the female side, Queen Vashti; the Samael fleeing to Botzrah means fleeing to his strength, the female side. A Jewish woman is not made a ruler, not because she is second-class, but because she stands for Knesses Yisrael, devoted to Hashem.

  14. 1:05:27 Sun and moon, right above left

    The Rav says that in the future Hashem will raise Knesses Yisrael to be like an equal, as the sun and moon were first created equal, but in this world the right, chesed, must be above the left, din, as 'Hashem's right hand is exalted'. Shimshon could have been Moshiach and fell through a woman, while Moshiach comes through strengthening the right; the right side comes first in halacha and the male is above the female in nature.

  15. 1:10:41 Vashti's banquet, Memuchan and Daniel

    The salvation began with Vashti's removal, on the advice of Memuchan, whom the Gemara calls Haman and a Midrash brought by Tosafos calls Daniel. The Rav reads Vashti's 'women's feast' as a convention for raising women, like those of his day, and explains that Daniel, whose lot was 'the end of days', was moser nefesh to daven three times a day toward Yerushalayim for the rebuilding of the Beis Hamikdash.

  16. 1:17:15 Daniel and Haman, Esther and Mordechai

    The Rav brings the rule that everything has a good side and a bad side, as Kayin was split between the Egyptian Moshe killed and Yisro, and suggests that Haman was Daniel's bad side, so that both readings of Memuchan are true: Daniel's prayer worked through Haman as its instrument to remove Vashti. Esther was lower than Mordechai, and her hiddenness under her husband's greatness is the beauty of the Jewish woman.

  17. 1:23:27 The Megillah is not history; the light of Purim

    Running late, the Rav turns to Purim: one who reads the Megillah 'backwards', as past history, has not fulfilled his obligation, for it draws down the same salvations today. Purim is beyond grasp and will remain when other festivals pass, so the drinking is like an anesthetic; the Megillah is its Hallel and is read at night. Jews drink and sing praises to Hashem, not like the drunkard who becomes a wild animal.

  18. 1:29:12 Rabbah and R' Zeira; moments of favor

    The Rav explains the Gemara of Rabbah and R' Zeira at the Purim meal: 'he slaughtered him' means R' Zeira's soul was drawn out by the sweetness of the Torah revealed then. Purim is full of moments of favor when 'whoever stretches out his hand is given', and even a simple Jew can bring down salvation, at the Megillah, at tzedakah, at mishloach manos and at the meal, if he does not waste them in drunkenness; he tells of a tzaddik in Amsterdam whom the queen came to thank.

  19. 1:35:57 Be a nebach: pleading for mercy on Purim

    The Rav says the light of the Megillah is greater than the light of reading the Torah, and that one must come to Purim knowing he is a nebach and plead for mercy, as R' Yechiel of Gostynin did at the Kotzker's door, and with the Ba'al HaTanya's words on Hashem's great mercy for the Shechinah in galus. He closes with a wish to wipe out Amalek from the world and from our hearts and to merit a joyous Purim.

The shiur, written up

Royal garments, not worn for his own honor

0:27

The Rav opens with the verse that the priestly garments are 'for honor and for beauty', and with the Rambam, who calls them royal garments. Rashi says the Kohen Gadol did not wear them for his own honor, and the Chasam Sofer asks what that adds. He answers that the golden garments recalled the golden calf, so all year the Kohen Gadol wore them in shame before Hashem; even the white garments of Yom Kippur he wore only to do Hashem's will. a,b,c

Achashverosh in the Kohen Gadol's garments

4:26

The Gemara learns from the shared word 'tiferes' that Achashverosh wore the Kohen Gadol's garments at his feast 'to show the riches of his kingdom'. The 'vessels of different kinds' were the vessels of the Beis Hamikdash, which Belshatzar had used on the night he was killed. f,e,g,h

6:34

The Rav asks a strong question: the garments were as holy as the vessels, yet nothing happened when Achashverosh wore them for 180 days, while for the vessels he was punished on the spot. He then reads the motive in the verse: the feast was not to feed or gladden anyone, but 'to show' how rich and mighty he was, with things no one else could match. e

A 'behar'oso' community

10:15

Behar'oso, the Rav says, is the plague of his generation and community: houses with double curtains, chandeliers and marble, each built to outdo the neighbor's. He then asks about Achashverosh's 'beds of gold and silver': the beds were silver and the legs gold, though the legs are the lesser part. i

The Ruzhiner way and the couch

13:27

The Rav tells of his uncle, an upholsterer in Yerushalayim, and a great Ruzhiner tzaddik there. Ruzhin conducted itself with royalty, and the Ropshitzer said the Ruzhiner, riding like a king, held his heart lest it burst from the pain of the galus of the Shechinah. When the uncle delivered a costly couch with a canvas back, the tzaddik said he had learned from his father that what one lacks inside one does not show outside, and had the back redone.

Gold where it shows

18:11

Achashverosh, the Rav explains, had the opposite way: the bed is covered, so silver is enough, but the legs show, so they must be gold. Speaking, like the Ba'al Shem Tov's students, through a verse, he applies it to engagement rings of a carat, to flowers, photographers and thick steaks at weddings, and to shidduchim chosen to impress. The feast began with showing his vessels and ended with Vashti brought to be shown: that is the syndrome.

'Let us make a name' and Jewish clothing

22:41

The Rav reads the Tower generation's 'let us make ourselves a name' as a shul built to outshine others, unlike building for Hashem's honor. He brings the Chasam Sofer that Jews do not boast with clothes: clean and neat, not fancy. Mordechai wore royal dress before the king, but for Jews, as the Gemara explains, 'light and joy' are Torah, Yom Tov, milah and tefillin. j,k,l,m

How luxury leads to theft

25:45

The Rav reads from a sefer, chapter five, that asks how theft became so common, which he says is easy today in business. Its answer is excess spending on clothing and the home, now the norm. The yetzer hara first persuades a person to live above his real standard: the simple man acts like a respected one, the respected one like a noble, a costlier car, then another, until it becomes part of him.

30:22

Then he borrows and cannot repay, fearing people's shame more than sin, and comes to robbery. The Rav asks for moderation according to the person and his place, not a race where the standard keeps rising. He describes wedding costs in Yerushalayim rising to imitate America, with parents in tears.

The Chofetz Chaim's wallpaper

35:04

The Chofetz Chaim said a house with fancy wallpaper is papered with pages of Gemara, since the extra hours worked could have been spent learning; to a rich visitor surprised at his bare house he said he too was on a journey, and his home was there. Shmuel HaRamasi, the Gemara says, took his vessels along, and the Rav reads 'his home was in Ramah' as a home on high. Jewish luxury in Germany and Spain, he adds, stirred the nations' envy. n,o

'Three things widen the mind'

39:21

Some justify luxury with the Gemara that a fine wife, home and vessels widen a person's mind. The Rav brings the Maharsha: they widen it toward this world's pleasures until one becomes like Bilaam with his 'wide soul'. Then he asks: the Torah spares Jewish money, yet the Kohen Gadol washed from a golden pitcher, and R' Yishmael ben Piabi's tunic, worn once, was worth a hundred maneh. p,q,r,s,d

The holiness of malchus answers the question

43:35

The answer is the Rambam's: the Kohen Gadol is a king, and his garments are royal; a Kohen Gadol bows at each blessing, a king even more. Yet he wore them for Hashem, not himself, as Rashi says. Malchus deserves honor even in a gentile king: Moshe spoke of Pharaoh's servants bowing, not Pharaoh, Eliyahu ran before Achav, and Esther took back calling the king a dog. Malchus has no counterpart in tumah; even Achashverosh's kingdom clothes Hashem's, as the Midrash says. t,b,u,v,w,y

47:36

So Achashverosh, a king, did not debase malchus by wearing royal garments, but handing the holy vessels to common guests did, and for that he was punished at once.

What not to learn from tzaddikim

49:25

Great leaders may carry a certain malchus, as the Rav saw at a wedding of their grandchildren, but simple people cannot copy it; one must know what to learn, unlike the chassid who saw his weak Rebbe drink coffee in tefillin and made it his practice. Jews should live as they always did. The Kotzker said the world is the text and the Torah its commentary, and the Megillah teaches to read events that way.

Male and female in holiness and the sitra achra

54:02

From 'binding his foal to the vine', male and female donkey, the Rav explains that in holiness the male is stronger, in the sitra achra the female: R' Chaim Vital dreamt he quickly beat the Samael but not his female counterpart. 'Hashem's right hand' is chesed, the male side, and the Gemara forbids a man to walk behind a woman, unlike 'ladies first'. Near Moshiach the female side grows: women's liberation and talk of drafting women, a grave danger to the Jewish family, against the first mitzvah's 'conquer it', man's way. z,aa,ab,ac

The Megillah at the end of a galus

59:34

The Megillah is the end of galus Bavel, as ours is the end of galus Edom; Achashverosh feasted on his reckoning that the Jews would not be redeemed, in which Daniel too erred, having been punished for advising Nevuchadnezzar to give tzedakah. It opens with the female side's strength: Vashti's word goes out to all women. The Samael will flee to Botzrah, which means strength: the female side. h,ad,af,ae

1:03:49

A woman is not appointed to rule, not because she is second-class, but because Jewish men stand for Hashem and women for Knesses Yisrael, devoted to Him; the Rambam's rule that a husband honor his wife concerns honor, not rule. ag

Sun and moon, right above left

1:06:07

In the future Hashem will raise Knesses Yisrael to be like His equal, as sun and moon began as 'the two great lights'. But in this world the right, chesed, must be above the left, as 'Hashem's right hand is exalted', for the world cannot exist with din. Shimshon could have been Moshiach, as Yaakov hoped, but fell through a woman. Halacha puts the right first, and nature sets the male above the female. ah,aa,ai

Vashti's banquet, Memuchan and Daniel

1:10:57

The salvation began with removing Vashti so 'every man should rule in his house'. The Gemara says Memuchan was Haman; Tosafos brings a Midrash that he was Daniel, whose wife troubled him. The Gemara also says Hasach was Daniel, either cut from his greatness or the one by whom royal matters were decided. aj,ak,al,am

1:13:17

Vashti made a 'women's feast', not one 'for women': a convention to raise women to lead, like the organizations of the Rav's day. Daniel, whose lot was 'the end of days', the right, was moser nefesh to daven three times daily toward Yerushalayim for its rebuilding, knowing he faced the lions. an,ao,ap

Daniel and Haman, Esther and Mordechai

1:17:19

Everything has a good and a bad side: Kayin's bad side was in the Egyptian Moshe killed, his good side in Yisro, who gave Moshe a wife. So, the Rav suggests, Haman was Daniel's bad side and both readings of Memuchan are true: cut from greatness, Daniel still decided royal matters through Haman, his instrument, and his prayer brought Vashti's fall. Esther, who did 'Mordechai's word', was lower than him, as Knesses Yisrael to Hashem; a wife may be great, as R' Akiva said of his wife, yet her hiddenness under her husband is her beauty. am,aq,ar

The Megillah is not history

1:24:12

Running late, the Rav turns to Purim. Reading the Megillah 'backwards', as past history, is no fulfillment, for it draws down today the salvations of Mordechai's day. Purim, which the Rambam brings will remain when other festivals pass, is beyond grasp, so drinking is like an anesthetic. The Megillah is its Hallel, read at night like the Seder's Hallel. The Gemara contrasts the nations' drinking with Jews who drink and sing to Hashem, not like a drunkard turned wild beast. as,at,au,av

Rabbah and R' Zeira; moments of favor

1:29:32

In the Gemara of Rabbah and R' Zeira, 'he slaughtered him' means R' Zeira's soul was drawn out by the sweetness of the Torah revealed then, and the next day Rabbah revived him; one may drink, but stay a mentsch. On Purim 'whoever stretches out his hand is given': at the Megillah, tzedakah, mishloach manos and the meal even a simple Jew can bring salvation. One who drinks all night and comes to the Megillah hungover loses it all; the joy must be joy of a mitzvah. aw

Be a nebach: pleading for mercy

1:36:06

The light that comes with the Megillah, the Rav says, is greater than that of reading the Torah, but one must come as a nebach and plead for mercy. A young man knocked on the Kotzker's door on Purim, saying 'whoever stretches out his hand is given', and came out the great R' Yechiel of Gostynin. The Ba'al HaTanya once ended a teaching with Hashem's great mercy for the Shechinah in galus, and for that one must ask.

1:40:23

Purim's light exceeds even Shabbos and is beyond measure. The Rav closes praying to wipe out Amalek from the world and from our hearts, as read in Parshas Zachor, and to merit a joyous Purim. ax

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 28:2 text index In the write-up: 0:27
  2. j Bereishis 11:4 text index In the write-up: 22:41
  3. u apparently Shemos 11:8 index In the write-up: 43:35
  4. z Bereishis 49:11 text index In the write-up: 54:02
  5. ah Bereishis 1:16 text index In the write-up: 1:06:07
  6. ai apparently Bereishis 49:18 index In the write-up: 1:06:07
  7. ax apparently Shemos 17:14 index In the write-up: 1:40:23

Nevi'im

  1. o Shmuel I 7:17 text index In the write-up: 35:04
  2. v Melachim I 18:46 text index In the write-up: 43:35

Kesuvim

  1. e Esther 1:4 text index In the write-up: 4:26, 6:34
  2. g Esther 1:7 text index In the write-up: 4:26
  3. i Esther 1:6 text index In the write-up: 10:15
  4. l Esther 8:15 text index In the write-up: 22:41
  5. aa Tehillim 118:16 text index In the write-up: 54:02, 1:06:07
  6. af Esther 1:17 text index In the write-up: 59:34
  7. aj Esther 1:22 text index In the write-up: 1:10:57
  8. an Esther 1:9 text index In the write-up: 1:13:17
  9. ao Daniel 12:13 text index In the write-up: 1:13:17
  10. ap apparently Daniel 6:11 index In the write-up: 1:13:17
  11. aq Esther 2:20 text index In the write-up: 1:17:19

Mishnah

  1. r apparently Avos 5:19 index In the write-up: 39:21
  2. s apparently Mishnah Yoma 4:5 index In the write-up: 39:21
  3. as apparently Mishnah Megillah 2:1 index In the write-up: 1:24:12

Talmud Bavli

  1. d apparently Yoma 35b index In the write-up: 39:21
  2. f apparently Megillah 12a index In the write-up: 4:26
  3. h apparently Megillah 11b index In the write-up: 4:26, 59:34
  4. m apparently Megillah 16b on Esther 8:16 index In the write-up: 22:41
  5. n apparently Berachos 10b index In the write-up: 35:04
  6. p Berachos 57b text index In the write-up: 39:21
  7. t apparently Berachos 34b index In the write-up: 43:35
  8. w apparently Megillah 15b index In the write-up: 43:35
  9. ab apparently Berachos 61a index In the write-up: 54:02
  10. ac apparently Yevamos 65b on Bereishis 1:28 index In the write-up: 54:02
  11. ad apparently Bava Basra 4a index In the write-up: 59:34
  12. ae apparently Makkos 12a index In the write-up: 59:34
  13. ak apparently Megillah 12b index In the write-up: 1:10:57
  14. am apparently Megillah 15a index In the write-up: 1:10:57, 1:17:19
  15. ar apparently Kesubos 63a index In the write-up: 1:17:19
  16. au apparently Megillah 14a index In the write-up: 1:24:12
  17. av apparently Megillah 12b on Esther 1:10 index In the write-up: 1:24:12
  18. aw apparently Megillah 7b index In the write-up: 1:29:32

Midrash

  1. y Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 43:35

Rishonim

  1. b Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:27, 43:35
  2. ag Rambam (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:03:49
  3. al Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:10:57
  4. at apparently Rambam Hilchos Megillah 2:18 index In the write-up: 1:24:12

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. c Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:27
  2. k Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:41
  3. q apparently Maharsha on Berachos 57b index In the write-up: 39:21
  4. x Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) 46:23 index

Key points

  1. 0:27 The priestly garments are royal garments 'for honor and for beauty', yet the Kohen Gadol wore them only for the honor of Hashem, never for his own honor.
  2. 9:10 Achashverosh's feast was driven by 'behar'oso', the wish to show off, and the Rav calls the luxury of his own community the same syndrome.
  3. 26:21 Luxury leads a person step by step into debt, theft and shame, so the Rav asks that each person live moderately, according to who he is and where he lives.
  4. 46:00 The trait of malchus comes from holiness, which is why even a non-Jewish king must be given honor.
  5. 54:19 In holiness the masculine side is stronger, in the sitra achra the feminine side is stronger, and as Moshiach nears the feminine side of the sitra achra grows stronger.
  6. 1:11:00 The salvation of Purim began with the removal of Vashti, and Esther, who followed Mordechai's word, stands for Knesses Yisrael and the modesty of the Jewish woman.
  7. 1:26:18 The light of Purim is beyond understanding, and the Rav asks that it be used with sense and joy of a mitzvah, and by pleading for mercy.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:42 What does Rashi add by saying the Kohen Gadol did not wear his garments for his own honor? Wearing plain white garments is no great feat.

    Answer: 2:59 The Chasam Sofer explains that the golden garments recalled the golden calf, so all year the Kohen Gadol wore them with shame before Hashem; Rashi teaches that even in the linen garments of Yom Kippur he did not wear them for his own sake but only to fulfill Hashem's command.

  2. Question: 6:34 Why was Achashverosh not punished for wearing the Kohen Gadol's holy garments for 180 days, yet punished at once when he used the vessels of the Beis Hamikdash?

    Answer: 47:22 The priestly garments are royal garments, and Achashverosh was himself a king, so wearing them did not debase malchus; but giving the vessels to common guests to drink from was a disgrace to malchus.

  3. Question: 12:49 Why were Achashverosh's beds made with silver frames and gold legs, when the legs are the lesser part?

    Answer: 17:50 The frame is covered by upholstery and cannot be seen, while the legs show; Achashverosh spent where it would be seen, which is behar'oso.

  4. Question: 42:11 If the Torah spares the money of Jews, why were the Kohen Gadol's Yom Kippur garments and vessels so costly?

    Answer: 43:24 The Kohen Gadol is a king and his garments are 'for honor and for beauty' as royal garments; he wore them not for himself but for the honor of Hashem.

  5. Question: 1:13:04 Why does the verse say Vashti made a 'women's feast' and not a feast 'for women', and why a separate feast at all?

    Answer: 1:13:41 It was a feast for a cause: Vashti led a campaign to raise women to a leading role, and the feast was a convention for that purpose.

  6. Question: 1:11:43 How can Memuchan be both Haman, as the Gemara says, and Daniel, as the Midrash brought by Tosafos says?

    Answer: 1:19:01 Every soul has a good side and a bad side; Haman was Daniel's bad side, and Daniel's prayer for the rebuilding came about through Haman's advice, so both are true.

Stories

  1. 13:36 The Ruzhiner tzaddik's couch

    The Rav's uncle in Yerushalayim, who had been in the upholstery trade in Vienna, opened an upholstery shop there after the war. A great tzaddik of the Ruzhin line in Yerushalayim ordered an expensive couch from him. When it was delivered, the tzaddik asked why the back was canvas, since he had chosen the best material. The uncle explained that the back stands against the wall and no one puts costly material there. The tzaddik answered that he had not learned so from his father: what one does not have inside one does not show outside, and he had the back made of the same material.

  2. 14:00 The Ropshitzer on the Ruzhiner's carriage

    In Ruzhin the court conducted itself with royal splendor, and the Ruzhiner rode in a gilded carriage drawn by four white horses. The Ropshitzer once saw him riding like a king with his hand held to his heart. He said that the Ruzhiner held his heart so that it would not burst from the pain of the galus of the Shechinah.

    In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh)

  3. 35:47 The Chofetz Chaim and the rich visitor

    A rich man from America visited the Chofetz Chaim and saw that there was almost no furniture in his house; to sit on a bench one had to prop it up with a milk crate. The Chofetz Chaim asked him how he sat on the train, and he answered on a simple bench, because at home he has an upholstered couch. The Chofetz Chaim answered that he too is on a journey in this world, and at home, there, he has.

    In the story: the Chofetz Chaim

  4. 50:44 The chassid who copied the coffee

    A chassid once came to his Rebbe just when the Rebbe felt weak and, before davening, drank a cup of coffee while wearing his tefillin. The chassid went home with a new practice: from then on he drank coffee in tefillin. The Rav tells it to show that one must know what to learn from tzaddikim and what not.

  5. 54:58 R' Chaim Vital's dream

    R' Chaim Vital writes that in a dream at night he was shown that he fought with the Samael and with his female counterpart. He quickly overcame the Samael, but against the female he strengthened himself many times with great effort, until he went down several levels and still could not overcome her. The Rav explains that in the sitra achra the female is stronger than the male.

    In the story: R' Chaim Vital

  6. 1:37:25 R' Yechiel of Gostynin at the Kotzker's door

    A young man came on Purim to the door of the Kotzker Rebbe. The Kotzker asked what he wanted, and he answered that today is Purim, when whoever stretches out his hand is given, so he was knocking and asking. The Kotzker told him to come in, and he stayed a while. When he came out he was an entirely different person, and he became the great R' Yechiel of Gostynin.

    In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe, Rabbi Yechiel Meir of Gostynin

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 4:26 Aharon's garments and Achashverosh's display share the same word, 'tiferes', but the Kohen Gadol wore that beauty for Hashem's honor, while Achashverosh used it 'to show', and that difference separates holy beauty from luxury.
  2. 47:36 Achashverosh was not punished for wearing the priestly garments, which are royal garments worn by a king, but at once for giving the holy vessels to common guests, because that debased malchus itself.
  3. 17:12 Achashverosh made the hidden frames of his beds silver and the visible legs gold, the opposite of the Ruzhiner tzaddik's rule that what one lacks inside one does not show outside.
  4. 36:35 Shmuel HaRamasi took his vessels with him because 'his home was in Ramah': his home was on high, so here, on his journey, he needed nothing, just as the Chofetz Chaim answered his visitor.
  5. 1:02:39 The Samael flees to Botzrah because 'botzrah' means strength: he flees to his strength, the female side, which is why the end of galus brings a rise of the feminine side of the sitra achra.
  6. 1:13:13 The verse says Vashti made a 'women's feast', not a feast 'for women', because it was a feast with a cause: a convention to raise the standing of women, like the movements of the Rav's day.
  7. 1:19:01 Both readings of Memuchan, Haman and Daniel, are true: Haman was Daniel's bad side, and Daniel's prayers for the rebuilding were carried out through Haman's advice to remove Vashti.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 31:21 The Rav says a person should live moderately, according to who he is and where he lives, not in a race to show the other that he is a big man.
  2. 24:06 The Rav says clothing must be clean, neat and dignified, but fancy dress is not for Jews, whose pride is Torah, Yom Tov, milah and tefillin.
  3. 49:28 The Rav says simple people must not imitate the malchus of great tzaddikim; one must know what to learn from them.
  4. 1:29:58 The Rav says Purim must be conducted with sense and with joy of a mitzvah, drinking without becoming wild, so as not to lose the Megillah and the moments of favor.
  5. 1:37:12 The Rav says one should come to Purim knowing he is a nebach and plead for mercy on himself and on the galus of the Shechinah.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Aharon HaKohen, Belshatzar, Bilaam, Daniel, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Hasach, Hevel, Jimmy Carter, Kayin, Memuchan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Pharaoh, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh), Rabbi Yechiel Meir of Gostynin, Rabbi Yishmael ben Piabi, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Zeira, Rashi, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Shimshon, Shmuel HaNavi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Chofetz Chaim, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maharsha, the Rambam, Vashti, Yaakov Avinu

Terms גלות השכינה, כנסת ישראל, מלכות, סטרא אחרא, סמאל, עקבתא דמשיחא, קץ

Report an error on this page