הדרכה לקיץ לבחורים הנוסעים להרים
להיות חלק מבריאה לעשות רצונו דרוש בפרק ר' אליעזר דמילה' נחיצות העבודה במחנה קיץ' חיזוק הרמת הקול בתפילה.
Catalog entry: שונות no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 34 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 1 hr 12 min
Listen
About this shiur
Speaking to bachurim about to leave for a summer camp, the Rav explains that each of them is sent there as a shaliach of Hashem, like all of creation, and tells them to fulfill that mission by learning, avoiding machlokes, and davening warmly and aloud.
The Rav opens with the summer months, when the meraglim went out, and says that every bachur going to camp is a shaliach meant to repair that sin. In the country one sees how trees, birds and water all do exactly what Hashem commanded at creation; a person should join this 'family' of creation, but by his own choice. He warns against machlokes, citing Korach, and contrasts it with machlokes for the sake of Heaven. He then introduces the perek of Rabbi Eliezer d'Milah: through the Eglei Tal and Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer he shows that milah and Shabbos are one matter, which is why hilchos milah are taught inside Maseches Shabbos. He stresses the danger that comes with a great mission, and closes with a long call, from the Ramban, the Ba'al haTanya and others, to daven together, with warmth and a raised voice.
Topics: A Person's Mission in the World · Davening with the Tzibbur and the Beis HaKnesses · Summer and Bein HaZmanim · Bris Milah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Going to camp as a shaliach listed in the guide
The Rav ties the summer to the time the meraglim set out, and says each bachur leaving home for camp is a shaliach meant to repair their sin. The rebbeim, chaverim, learning and davening are the tools of the mission, and at every step one chooses whether to be a faithful shaliach or like the meraglim.
-
4:22 All of creation does its shlichus listed in the guide
In the country one sees the sky, grass, birds and water without buildings hiding them, each doing what Hashem commanded at creation. The Rav asks why a person should be different, and says the bachurim should join this 'family of nature' as shluchim, but by choice, and work together as a team.
-
9:44 Korach and machlokes for Heaven's sake listed in the guide
From Parshas Korach the Rav teaches that one may not make machlokes like Korach and his company. He explains that their dispute was split inside as well, each wanting something else, because each sought himself; a machlokes of Torah for Heaven's sake instead brings friendship and team-work.
-
13:46 The Eglei Tal: Shabbos, milah and the Shach listed in the guide
Introducing the perek of Rabbi Eliezer d'Milah, the Rav brings the Eglei Tal's introduction: he wrote on hilchos Shabbos as a tikkun for pegam habris, since Shabbos contains the whole Torah. He then relates the Eglei Tal's defense of the Shach, who allows a transgression to save a limb, against the kal vachomer from milah in Yoma: milah overrides Shabbos only because it too contains everything.
-
22:05 Why hilchos milah are in Maseches Shabbos listed in the guide
The Rav shows that Shabbos and milah are both called bris and strengthen each other, and that all the laws of milah are taught through how milah falls on Shabbos. He asks why the perek opens with 'if he did not bring the tool' rather than with a new halacha, and answers that it continues the previous perek to show that hilchos milah are hilchos Shabbos.
-
29:50 Avraham's milah on Yom Kippur listed in the guide
The Rav asks why Avraham, who kept the whole Torah, waited for his milah until commanded, and answers from Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer that he was circumcised on Yom Kippur, the Shabbos of Shabbosos and root of Shabbos. He adds that milah is called the greatest mitzvah and pegam habris the greatest aveirah, and both are tied to Yom Kippur.
-
34:58 The worth of learning in camp listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every bit of Torah and every mitzvah of the smallest Jew raises the whole creation, and learning about milah is like fulfilling it. He urges the bachurim to use the precious time in camp with toil and chiddushim, and says that being sent to learn such Torah shows they are considered important in Heaven, like a president who sends only his best men on vital missions.
-
39:22 A great mission needs chizuk listed in the guide
Like Moshe telling the meraglim to strengthen themselves, the Rav says a precious mission is a dangerous one: a truck of diamonds needs armor and two drivers. The yetzer hara will lie in wait with lashon hara, leitzanus and machlokes, and just as the Gemara has a soul sworn and strengthened before birth, one must ask Hashem for chizuk and take only the good.
-
42:31 Avodas hatefillah and the Ramban listed in the guide
Turning to tefillah, the Rav says this generation must measure its davening against earlier ones and be ashamed of the weakness. Tefillah is avodah of the heart, and he brings the Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo: every mitzvah, even buying a mezuzah, rests on emunah, and the purpose of raising the voice in tefillah and of shuls is to proclaim publicly that we are Hashem's creations.
-
50:48 The Ba'al haTanya: daven together aloud listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Ba'al haTanya, whose Shulchan Aruch is accepted everywhere, pleading that the tzibbur daven together word by word in a raised voice, not some loudly and others silently, as the Sefardim do. He adds that one asked by the gabbai to daven should not refuse, and that one with a fine voice must use it for Hashem, recalling Navos who withheld his voice.
-
56:07 The Pri Megadim and why we raise our voice listed in the guide
The Rav goes through the poskim on a loud voice: the Beis Yosef on answering with all one's strength, the Kaf HaChaim citing the Eliyahu Rabbah, and the Pri Megadim, brought by the Mishnah Berurah, that one need not shout since Hashem hears. He answers that the voice is not for Hashem to hear but to arouse kavanah and wake the sleeping neshamah; only one who needs no such arousal may daven quietly.
-
1:00:24 Levels of hidden avodah; the Chafetz Chaim listed in the guide
From the Shunamis, who needed signs to know Elisha was holy, the Rav explains that the higher a person stands, the less his avodah shows outside: yesharim sing and shout, tzaddikim less, chassidim and kedoshim hide it. He then brings the Chafetz Chaim, who writes that one should cry out to Hashem in tefillah, and the Stoliner Rebbe who davened aloud so chassidim would learn from him.
-
1:04:42 Every tefillah a Ne'ilah; closing charge listed in the guide
The Rav asks the bachurim to test for themselves whether they daven better with warmth, and notes that even a cold shul shouts at Ne'ilah, though every tefillah is a diamond. With the Gemara on Iyov, punished for keeping silent, he explains that one who feels the pain cries out. He closes with Shabbos Parshas Korach, the sweetness of Hodu on Erev Shabbos, and a brachah to be good shluchim.
The shiur, written up
Going to camp as a shaliach
The Rav notes that the summer, when everyone leaves home for the country and camps, is the season in which the meraglim set out. Each bachur going to camp, he says, is a shaliach sent to repair their failed mission.
He was sent there by Hashem and did not choose it; his only choice is whether to fulfill the mission. The tools of that mission are his rebbeim, chaverim, the masechta he learns and the tefillos he davens, and at every step he decides whether to be a faithful shaliach or like the meraglim.
All of creation does its shlichus
In the country, the Rav says, one sees the sky, the grass, birds and flowers, with no tall buildings hiding Hashem's works. A tree grows and water flows because Hashem commanded it at creation; the same Torah that commands us to learn commands the rain and the sun, so the whole world carries out its shlichus.
Why, he asks, should a person be different? The bachurim should join this family of nature as shluchim, with one difference: a bird has no choice, while a person has free will. That is the purpose of their stay, and in camp they should learn team-work, since together one can succeed far more than alone.
Korach and machlokes for Heaven's sake
From Parshas Korach the Rav brings the prohibition not to be like Korach and his company, and contrasts it with a machlokes for the sake of Heaven. He notes the wording 'Korach and his company': when all seek Hashem's honor they are bound together, but each of Korach's camp sought himself, so they disagreed among themselves as well. a,b
A dispute in learning, by contrast, brings friendship and a feeling that everyone serves Hashem together.
The Eglei Tal: Shabbos, milah and the Shach
Turning to the perek of Rabbi Eliezer d'Milah, the Rav brings the introduction of the Eglei Tal, who chose to write on hilchos Shabbos as a tikkun for pegam habris: Shabbos contains the whole Torah, and pegam habris contains all aveiros. d
There the Eglei Tal discusses the Shach, who rules that one may transgress rather than lose a limb. One could ask: the Gemara in Yoma learns that saving life overrides Shabbos from milah, which concerns one of the 248 limbs, so a limb should override Shabbos too. The Eglei Tal answers that milah contains all the limbs, just as Shabbos contains all the mitzvos, so only milah can override Shabbos. An ordinary limb against one ordinary aveirah is one against one, and there the Shach is right. e,f
Why hilchos milah are in Maseches Shabbos
From this the Rav concludes that Shabbos and milah are one matter: both contain the whole Torah and both are called bris. That is why the perek of milah belongs to Maseches Shabbos, and a milah on Shabbos is especially great, since each strengthens the other. g
All the laws of milah, he shows, are taught through what is done when milah falls on Shabbos, so that one learns hilchos milah from Shabbos.
This explains how the Mishnah opens: 'Rabbi Eliezer says, if he did not bring the tool'. Rashi explains this refers back to the end of the previous perek, 'all needs of milah are done on Shabbos'. The Rav asks why the new perek does not simply begin with that line. He answers that the Mishnah ties them together on purpose, so no one would think milah was placed there incidentally: hilchos milah are hilchos Shabbos. h,j,i
Avraham's milah on Yom Kippur
The commentators ask why Avraham, who kept the whole Torah, waited for milah until commanded at ninety-nine. The Rav offers another answer from Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer, that Avraham was circumcised on Yom Kippur. Yom Kippur is the Shabbos of Shabbosos, the root of Shabbos, and milah must be bound up with Shabbos, so Avraham waited for a Shabbos-like day. k
The worth of learning in camp
Every bit of Torah, the Rav says, brings wondrous tikkunim to all the worlds; no place in Hashem's creation is not raised by the smallest mitzvah of the smallest Jew. Learning about milah, the greatest mitzvah, counts, like the Gemara's teaching on learning the korbanos, as if one fulfills it. m
So the bachurim must use these precious moments with toil and chiddushim. A president sends his most important people on vital missions; being sent to learn such Torah shows they are valued in Heaven.
A great mission needs chizuk
Moshe told the meraglim to strengthen themselves because the mission was great. A truck of stones can take a side road, but diamonds need an armored truck and two drivers. The bachurim must expect the yetzer hara to lie in wait with lashon hara, leitzanus and machlokes. As the Gemara has a soul sworn before birth to be a tzaddik, they need chizuk from Hashem. n,o
Avodas hatefillah and the Ramban
Turning to avodas hatefillah, the Rav says this generation must measure itself against earlier ones and be ashamed of its weakness. Tefillah is a hard avodah, the avodah of the heart, and shouting without kavanah is worthless. p
The Ba'al haTanya: daven together aloud
Next the Rav brings the Ba'al haTanya, whose Shulchan Aruch is accepted everywhere, who pleads that people daven together, word by word, not one aloud and another silently. The Sefardim do so, the whole congregation saying each word with the chazzan. r
One whom the gabbai asks to daven should not refuse, and one with a good voice must use it for Hashem. The Gemara says Navos, who had a beautiful voice, came to his end for not using it for the tzibbur.
The Pri Megadim and why we raise our voice
The Rav goes through the poskim: the Beis Yosef on answering with all one's strength, and the Kaf HaChaim citing the Eliyahu Rabbah, who wondered at loud singing until he saw the Ramban. The Pri Megadim, cited by the Mishnah Berurah, says one need not shout since Hashem hears. s,t,u,q,v,w
The Rav answers that the voice is not for Hashem but because the voice arouses kavanah. One who needs no arousal may be quiet; most must daven warmly, so the voice rises and wakes the sleeping neshamah.
Levels of hidden avodah; the Chafetz Chaim
The Shunamis needed signs to know Elisha was holy, the Rav explains, because the higher a person stands, the less his avodah shows. Yesharim shout and sing, tzaddikim show less, chassidim and kedoshim even less. x
He then brings the Chafetz Chaim in his siddur: a person should not be silent in tefillah but cry out to Hashem. With the Ramban, the Ba'al haTanya and Jewish custom, the Rav prefers this to the lone Pri Megadim. The Stoliner Rebbe always davened aloud so his chassidim would learn to daven warmly. y,q,r,v
Every tefillah a Ne'ilah; closing charge
The Rav asks each bachur to test for himself whether he davens better warmly. Even a cold shul shouts at Ne'ilah, because then it means something; but every tefillah is a diamond, three a day, and none should be let go.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- c Chasam Sofer (place not identified) 12:43 index
- d apparently Eglei Tal, introduction index In the write-up: 13:46
- e Shach (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:06
- l apparently Even HaEzer 23 index In the write-up: 33:07
- r Shulchan Aruch HaRav (place not identified) index In the write-up: 50:54, 1:02:46
- s Beis Yosef (place not identified) index In the write-up: 56:26
- w Mishnah Berurah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 56:26
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:52 Each bachur going to camp is a shaliach sent by Hashem, and the place, the rebbeim, the chaverim and the learning are the tools of that mission.
- 5:43 All of nature carries out the command Hashem gave it at creation; a person is asked to do the same, but through his own free choice.
- 22:13 Milah and Shabbos are one matter, each containing the whole Torah, so the laws of milah are taught within Maseches Shabbos.
- 40:20 The greater the mission, the greater the danger along the way, so one must strengthen oneself and guard against lashon hara, leitzanus and machlokes.
- 49:37 Davening aloud is a proclamation that we are Hashem's creations, and the voice arouses the heart, so the Rav urges davening warmly and together, word by word.
- 1:06:49 Every tefillah is a diamond, as precious as Ne'ilah of Yom Kippur, and one who feels the pain cries out.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 16:18 Since milah, one of a person's 248 limbs, overrides Shabbos, why may one not desecrate Shabbos to save a limb, while the Shach allows a transgression to save one?
Answer: 19:30 Milah contains all the limbs and Shabbos contains the whole Torah, so only milah can override Shabbos; an ordinary limb against one ordinary aveirah is one against one, so the Shach is right.
-
Question: 27:24 Why does the perek of Rabbi Eliezer d'Milah open with 'if he did not bring the tool' instead of beginning a new subject?
Answer: 28:52 To continue the previous perek and teach that hilchos milah are hilchos Shabbos, not a separate subject placed there by chance.
-
Question: 29:58 Why did Avraham, who kept the whole Torah before it was given, wait for his milah until he was commanded?
Answer: 30:28 So that it would fall on Yom Kippur, the Shabbos of Shabbosos, since milah must be bound up with Shabbos.
-
Question: 58:30 If Hashem hears even a quiet tefillah, as the Pri Megadim says, why raise the voice?
Answer: 59:25 The voice arouses kavanah and wakes the sleeping neshamah; one who needs no such arousal may indeed daven quietly.
-
Question: 1:08:27 Why was Iyov punished for keeping silent at Pharaoh's counsel, if crying out would not have helped?
Answer: 1:09:03 Because when he later suffered he did cry out, showing that one who truly feels the pain shouts even when it will not help.
Stories
-
1:04:09 The Stoliner Rebbe as ba'al tefillah
The Rav tells that the Stoliner Rebbe had a powerful voice and would always serve as the ba'al tefillah himself. His davening carried far, and he did it so that his chassidim would learn from him to daven with warmth.
In the story: the Stoliner Rebbe
Insights
- 1:34 The summer camp season, which falls in the days the meraglim went out, is a chance to repair their failed mission by being faithful shluchim.
- 10:44 Korach's dispute was split within itself because each side sought itself; only when all seek Hashem's honor are they bound together, even in disagreement.
- 28:04 The Mishnah ends one perek with 'all needs of milah are done on Shabbos' and opens the next by continuing it, to teach that hilchos milah are themselves hilchos Shabbos.
- 30:59 Avraham delayed his milah so it could fall on Yom Kippur, the root of Shabbos, because milah must be bound up with Shabbos.
- 59:19 A loud voice in tefillah is not for Hashem to hear but to awaken the one davening; this answers the Pri Megadim's question.
- 1:08:27 Iyov was punished for his silence even though shouting would not have helped, because one who truly feels the pain cries out regardless.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 4:28 The Rav tells the bachurim to work together as a team in camp and avoid machlokes, lashon hara and leitzanus.
- 36:47 He urges them to use the time in camp to learn with toil and with heart, and to try for chiddushim.
- 52:12 He asks that the tzibbur daven together, word by word, with a warm and raised voice, and that each test for himself whether warmth improves his davening.
- 53:00 One whom the gabbai asks to daven before the amud should not refuse, and one with a good voice should use it for Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Elisha HaNavi, Iyov, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Navos HaYizre'eli, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chofetz Chaim, the Pri Megadim, the Ramban, the Shach, the Stoliner Rebbe, Yisro
Terms יגיעה, מחלוקת, מרגלים, נשמה יתירה, עבודה שבלב, פגם הברית, פיקוח נפש, רבונו של עולם, רמ"ח אברים, שבת שבתון, שליחות