Mamed Technology 02 R'Tauber

Catalog entry: שונות no. ⁨45⁩ Yiddish 57 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 57 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

In a talk on technology given by another speaker (R' Tauber, per the catalog title), not by the Rav, the speaker argues that a Jew who must use a device for parnassah is a soldier Hashem sent to a hard front, and may use only what he is commanded, as he is commanded.

This recording is a talk by another speaker (named R' Tauber in the catalog title), not by the Rav. He opens with the privilege of living in a generation led by gedolim, and says the yetzer hara changed tactics: once outside persecution ended, the Jewish strength never to give in turned against the guidance of rabbanim, so that obeying them feels like a prisoner's chains instead of a soldier's duty. An army sends its strongest men to the hardest front, so this generation was trusted with the hardest test. He brings R' Mendel of Rimanov's words that the last battle before Moshiach was pushed off by 150 years, and links it to the 1960s and the rise of personal technology, which, he says, even its own makers keep from their children. He tells stories of children harmed through simple phones, and teaches five rules for one who must use a device: who, when, what, where and how.

Topics: Technology and the Internet · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim · Challenges of Our Generation

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 A generation led by gedolim, facing a test (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  2. 3:27 The yetzer hara's new tactic (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  3. 8:45 A soldier, not a prisoner (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  4. 13:29 The strongest are sent to the hardest front (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  5. 18:00 R' Mendel of Rimanov and Napoleon (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  6. 24:35 How technology crept in (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  7. 31:07 Parnassah and the nuclear department (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  8. 35:13 Stories of 'kosher' phones (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  9. 40:06 When Hashem sends one into the job (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  10. 44:19 Five rules: who, when, what, where, how (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  11. 49:30 What children learn, and the last battle (Another speaker) listed in the guide

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 1:12 7:15 text index
  2. b apparently Bereishis 3:1 24:45 index

Kesuvim

  1. d Tehillim 2:1 55:47 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Bava Basra 57b 0:26 index

Key points

  1. 7:59 The speaker says that after outside persecution ended, the Jewish power never to give in was turned against following the rabbanim, so their guidance is felt as a prison instead of an army.
  2. 13:06 He argues that an army sends its strongest soldiers to the hardest front, so this generation's hard test is a sign that Heaven trusted it.
  3. 24:50 Personal technology, he says, entered quietly like the serpent's bite, and harms people's ability to think, focus and relate to others.
  4. 34:23 One whom Hashem requires to use a device for parnassah is like a soldier assigned to the nuclear department: he must go, but he must guard himself with great care.
  5. 44:19 He gives five rules for such use: who, when, what, where and how, and stresses the 'how' that children see at home.
  6. 49:52 There is no rule that a father may and his child may not; what a parent enjoys on a device, the children will learn to enjoy.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 31:03 If the Torah requires a Jew to earn a living, and today every job needs technology, how can he avoid it?

    Answer: 34:15 Like a soldier ordered into the nuclear department, he must go where Hashem sends him, but use only what he must, guarded and with fear, and nothing beyond it.

  2. Question: 13:02 Why is this generation given such a hard test?

    Answer: 15:55 Because an army sends its strongest soldiers to the hardest front; Heaven makes no mistakes, and sending this generation here shows it was trusted.

Stories

  1. 13:29 The soldier who washed laundry on the front

    The speaker learned with a ba'al teshuvah who had just returned from the Gulf War and would not say what he did there, calling it a military secret. Weeks later he admitted that he had been on a ship of over two thousand soldiers that was entirely the laundry department, and his work on 'the front' was moving washing into the dryer. The speaker uses it to show that an army sends only its strongest to real battle.

  2. 21:54 R' Mendel of Rimanov's sigh before his passing

    According to what R' Shimon of Zhelichov wrote, a few weeks before R' Mendel of Rimanov passed away he sat on his bed on a Friday afternoon after the mikveh and groaned, saying he had done all he could for Napoleon to win, and asking what more to do. Asked about the Ba'al HaTanya's letter, he answered that Moshiach cannot come without the last and hardest battle; if it did not happen then, it would be pushed off by about 150 years.

    In the story: R' Mendel of Rimanov, R' Shimon of Zhelichov, the Ba'al HaTanya, Napoleon

  3. 35:16 The classmate's mother's talk-only phone

    A respected yungerman in Monsey sent his son, about twelve, to a chassidish cheder, where the boy became distracted and withdrawn. A counselor found that the boy had seen terrible things, shown to him by a classmate on the classmate's mother's simple flip phone. The classmate's father insisted he had bought only a talk-only phone, but a friend on the street had taught his son how to open it to the internet, which takes a few minutes.

  4. 37:52 The menahel's 'kosher' phone

    At a gathering of menahalim in Boro Park, a technician asked a respected menahel whether his phone was kosher. The menahel said he had bought it kosher; within two minutes the technician showed him it was fully open to the internet, and the menahel turned pale.

  5. 40:45 The yungerman who would not take an internet job

    A yungerman whose company closed decided he would take no job connected to the internet. Months passed with eight or nine children and growing debts to the grocers. When offered a good job that required internet, he asked a rav, who told him he must take it and guard himself, and then a great Rebbe in Monsey, who blessed him with success in the new job and told him to be careful. Both told him he must take it.

  6. 48:01 The father who would not check the weather

    A Boro Park yungerman whose business requires a smartphone keeps it in his car and carries only a flip phone; when there is a problem he goes out to the car, even at night. Before Chol Hamoed his son asked him to check the weather on his phone, and he answered that he does not touch it except when he is required to.

  7. 50:23 The mother with the pink smartphone

    A couple came to the speaker for an hour about which yeshiva to send their difficult seventeen-year-old son. As they rose, the mother took out a smartphone. She offered to show that it was disconnected and held only pictures and clips, and the speaker asked only whether her children saw her sitting and enjoying it, since they would learn to enjoy it too. He says that ten minutes after they left, the device was broken and in the garbage.

Insights

  1. 7:59 The speaker reads the youth's resistance to rabbanim as the same inborn Jewish stubbornness that kept the nation through persecution, now turned inward by the yetzer hara.
  2. 9:51 A prison and an army look the same from outside, with uniforms, numbers and orders; the whole difference is whether the person inside feels arrested or honored.
  3. 22:51 He links R' Mendel of Rimanov's words that the last battle was pushed off by 150 years to the years around 1965, when the street openly broke down and personal technology began to spread.
  4. 47:25 The danger is not only in what the device can reach but in the attitude: a device used with relish as a 'friendly' family device teaches children to enjoy it, while one used with trembling as a minimal work tool does not.
  5. 45:56 Where Hashem truly requires a device for parnassah, the one who uses it carefully is a hero on the front, not a sinner; the same act done without need is the reverse.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 53:54 The speaker says one who must have a device for parnassah should minimize it to the little he must, filtered, according to the gedolim.
  2. 45:26 He says that one who needs a smartphone for work can usually keep it in the car or in a separate place rather than on his person.
  3. 52:02 He urges parents not to sit and enjoy a device in front of their children, since the children will learn to enjoy it as well.
  4. 38:54 He says parents should come together and ask the mosdos who their child sits next to, since an institution cannot rely on every father's form.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Napoleon, Osama bin Laden, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Rimanov, Rabbi Shimon of Zhelichov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chozeh of Lublin, the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz)

Terms הסתלקות, פרנסה, קליפה

Report an error on this page