ברית מילה
Bris (Elul Ki Savoi)
Catalog entry: Simchos כי תבוא no. 2 Yiddish 18 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
At a bris in Elul, the Rav explains that the curses of Parshas Ki Savo hold hidden blessings, just as the bris removes the orlah to reveal the inner holiness of a Jew, and that a father's bris is done purely for the sake of Heaven.
The Rav opens with the question of the Zera Kodesh: Parshas Bechukosai ends its curses with consolation, while Parshas Ki Savo ends with curses alone. He notes that at Har Gerizim and Har Eival only the curses are written, and the Gemara learns the blessings from them by a hekesh. He explains that great good is hidden in the Torah, covered by an orlah, and the bris reveals the inner point. Elul, hinted in 'umal Hashem es levavcha', is the milah of the year, when Tamuz and Av are revealed as good; this is why Ki Savo is read then. The passuk itself answers: 'these are the words of the bris'. He links the bris to the completion of the child's formation and to Avraham Avinu, and contrasts it with Torah and chuppah, where other motives can enter. A bris is purely for Heaven, and he blesses the child accordingly.
Topics: Bris Milah · Chodesh Elul
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Curses without consolation, and the hidden good listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Zera Kodesh's wonder that Ki Savo, unlike Bechukosai, ends without consolation, and notes that only the curses are written while the Gemara learns the blessings from them. He explains that great good lies hidden under an orlah, and that the bris reveals Hashem's covenant with every Jew and the inner point that no place is empty of Him.
-
4:19 Blessings inside the curses; Elul as the bris of the year listed in the guide
Using the hekesh and a rule of Tosafos in Zevachim, the Rav shows that the blessings are contained in the curses. He then explains that Ki Savo is read in Elul because Elul is the milah of the year, hinted in 'umal Hashem', when Tamuz and Av are revealed as good, and compares this to the bris completing a child's formation.
-
9:13 'These are the words of the bris' and Avraham Avinu listed in the guide
The Rav answers the opening question from the passuk 'eleh divrei habris': the curses are words of the bris, which reveals the inner point. He ties this to the end of the year, to the passuk 'umal Hashem' addressed to the generation of Moshiach and to 'levav zarecha', and to Avraham Avinu, whose holiness flares up at every bris and passes from father to child.
-
14:14 A bris purely for Heaven, and the blessing listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara's list of a father's duties to his son and contrasts Torah study and chuppah, where other motives can enter, as with Elisha ben Avuya's father, with the bris, which a father does with no motive but bringing his child into the covenant of Avraham. He closes with the blessing that just as the child entered the bris, so may he enter into Torah, chuppah and good deeds.
The shiur, written up
Curses without consolation, and the hidden good
The Rav brings the Zera Kodesh's wonder: Bechukosai ends its curses with consolation, yet Ki Savo ends with curses alone. He notes that only the curses of Har Eival are written, and the Gemara learns the blessings from them. The answer, he explains, is that great good lies hidden under a covering like an orlah; the bris reveals the inner point, and a Jew must believe that the whole world is full of Hashem's glory, even in bitter times. a,c,e
Blessings inside the curses; Elul as the bris of the year
'These are the words of the bris' and Avraham Avinu
A bris purely for Heaven, and the blessing
The Gemara lists a father's duties: Torah, a wife, and milah. Torah can be taught for honor, as Elisha ben Avuya's father intended at his bris, and a match can be chosen for wealth. A bris, however, gains no honor, since every Jewish child has one; it is done purely to bring the child into Avraham's covenant. The Rav blesses that as he entered the bris, so may he enter Torah, chuppah and good deeds. m,n,o
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
- h Midrash (place not identified) 8:32
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:59 Only the curses of Har Eival are written in Ki Savo; the blessings are learned from them by a hekesh, a sign that the blessings are contained within the curses.
- 2:37 Great good is hidden in the Torah under a covering like an orlah; when the orlah is removed, as at a bris, the inner point is revealed.
- 6:07 Elul, hinted in 'umal Hashem Elokecha es levavcha ve'es levav zarecha', is the bris milah of the year, when the hard months of Tamuz and Av are revealed as good.
- 8:11 The bris completes the formation of the child that began nine months earlier, just as Avraham Avinu with his bris was the completion of creation.
- 14:29 Unlike teaching Torah or arranging a chuppah, where other motives can enter, a father makes a bris purely for the sake of Heaven.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:32 Why does Parshas Ki Savo end its curses with no consolation, unlike Parshas Bechukosai?
Answer: 9:30 The passuk itself says 'these are the words of the bris': the curses are an orlah over hidden good, and the bris reveals that everything was good.
-
Question: 1:59 Why are only the curses written in the parsha and not the blessings?
Answer: 4:33 Because the blessings are contained within the curses; this is why the Gemara learns the blessings from the curses by a hekesh.
-
Question: 6:02 Why is Parshas Ki Savo read specifically in Elul?
Answer: 6:07 Elul is the time of bris milah, hinted in 'umal Hashem', when the inner point is revealed and the orlah removed, so blessings can be drawn out of the curses.
-
Question: 11:00 Why does the passuk tell the generation of Moshiach 'the heart of your children', when they live thousands of years later?
Answer: 11:27 Each generation contains fathers and children, and when the father does teshuvah with the circumcision of the heart, the repair takes effect in the child.
-
Question: 14:15 How is the bris different from the father's other duties, Torah study and marrying off his son?
Answer: 15:52 Torah study and chuppah can be mixed with other motives such as honor or wealth, but a bris has no motive except bringing the child into the covenant of Avraham.
Stories
-
14:38 The father of Elisha ben Avuya at his son's bris
The Rav recounts from Chazal that at the bris of Elisha ben Avuya, his father decided to have him learn Torah. He did so not for its own sake but because he saw the honor given to the Tannaim and wanted his son to have such honor too.
In the story: Elisha ben Avuya, Avuya
Insights
- 4:54 Because the blessings are derived from the curses by a hekesh, and what a teacher lacks the student cannot have, the blessings must already be present inside the curses themselves.
- 2:48 The curses of Ki Savo are like an orlah: a covering over great good, and a bris that removes it reveals the hidden blessing.
- 6:25 Elul is the bris milah of the year: Tamuz and Av are the orlah, and in Elul, with the milah and priah, it is revealed that everything was good all along and judgments turn into merits.
- 9:02 The curses at the end of the year in Ki Savo are themselves a bris at the end of the year, matching the bris that completes a child's formation at its end.
- 11:08 The passuk 'umal Hashem' speaks to the generation of Moshiach yet says 'the heart of your children', because a father's teshuvah through the circumcision of the heart takes effect in his child.
- 15:52 A bris is the one mitzvah a father does for his child that is entirely free of ulterior motives, since every Jewish child is circumcised and there is no honor to gain from it.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Avuyah, Elisha ben Avuyah (Acher), Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Yaakov Avinu