ברית מילה

Bris Milah - Shushan Purim

Catalog entry: Simchos שושן פורים no. ⁨29⁩ Yiddish 21 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 21 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

At a bris seudah on Shushan Purim, the Rav explains that Megillas Esther and Purim hold only a glimmer of the light of Moshiach, since the wiping out of Amalek is not yet complete, and that a bris milah, like Purim, removes the orlah and reveals that light.

The Rav opens with the Gemara: Esther asked the Chachamim to write her book for all generations, and they answered that Amalek may be written only three times, not four. He asks why, and adds Shmuel's view that Esther is not one of the holy writings, though the twenty-four books are the ornaments of the Shechinah. He explains that every book existed in heaven before its navi wrote it; Megillas Esther holds a spark of the light of Moshiach, given to accustom the eyes, and Purim is not yet complete because Amalek is not yet wiped out. Bringing the Bnei Yissaschar and the Chasam Sofer, he links Purim to bris milah: both remove the orlah and reveal a glimpse of Moshiach. He applies this to the bris seudah on Shushan Purim, blesses the child and family, and closes by answering his opening question.

Topics: Bris Milah · Megillas Esther · Shushan Purim · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why Amalek may be written only three times listed in the guide

    The Rav opens with Esther's request to be written for all generations and the Chachamim's answer that Amalek may be written only three times, and asks why. He adds Shmuel's view that Esther is not one of the holy writings, and asks how that fits with the twenty-four books corresponding to the twenty-four combinations of the Name Adnus.

  2. 4:10 The Megillah holds the light of Moshiach listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that every navi's book existed in heaven before he wrote it, and that Megillas Esther holds a spark of the light of Moshiach, given to accustom Jews to that light. Since Purim's essence is the wiping out of Amalek, which is not yet complete, the Megillah's place among the holy writings is still hidden in heaven until Moshiach comes.

  3. 9:24 Purim, bris milah and the removal of the orlah listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar that the Megillah has the laws of the holy writings only on Purim, and explains that on Purim Jews receive a glimpse of the days of Moshiach. He shows that a bris milah gives the same glimpse, brings the Chasam Sofer that 'Megillah' stands for removing idolatry from the land, and concludes that a Shushan Purim seudah is a seudah of bris milah.

  4. 13:32 A bris seudah on Shushan Purim listed in the guide

    The Rav says this bris seudah differs from others: on Shushan Purim every Jew who keeps Purim properly receives a measure of bris milah, is freed from his evil part, and can make a new covenant with Hashem. He praises the child's family of Torah, Chassidus and yiras Shamayim and blesses the child and the family to see the light of Moshiach.

  5. 17:24 Why the Chachamim finally wrote the Megillah listed in the guide

    After finishing his blessings, the Rav returns to his opening question: Yehoshua, Shaul, and Mordechai and Esther each only weakened Amalek, and the Megillah, written in concealment without Hashem's name, shows the wiping out is not yet complete. The Chachamim wrote it once they understood that Hashem wanted Haman's descendants to learn Torah in Bnei Brak, and they were content with the glimpse of Moshiach.

The shiur, written up

Why Amalek may be written only three times

0:08

The Rav opens with the Gemara: Esther asked the Chachamim to write her book for all generations, and they answered that Amalek may be written only three times, not a fourth. He asks why. He adds Shmuel's view that Esther is not among the holy writings, and asks how that fits with the twenty-four books, which correspond to the twenty-four combinations of the Name Adnus. a,f

The Megillah holds the light of Moshiach

4:14

The twenty-four books, the Rav explains, are the ornaments of the Shechinah, and each existed in heaven before its navi wrote it. Megillas Esther holds a spark of Moshiach's light, given so Jews can grow used to it. Purim will remain when other yomim tovim are nullified, as the Rambam writes, because it is not yet finished: its essence is wiping out Amalek, which is still incomplete. k

8:06

So even for Shmuel the Megillah is one of the twenty-four, but its place is still hidden in heaven. When Moshiach comes, it will appear in a new garment.

Purim, bris milah and the removal of the orlah

9:24

The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar that the Megillah has the laws of the holy writings only on Purim, since on Purim Jews receive a glimpse of the days of Moshiach. A bris milah gives the same glimpse: Eliyahu HaNavi comes and the orlah is removed. Citing the Chasam Sofer, that 'Megillah' stands for removing idolatry from the land, he concludes that a Shushan Purim seudah is a seudah of bris milah. m

A bris seudah on Shushan Purim

13:36

This seudah, the Rav says, differs from every other bris seudah. On Shushan Purim every Jew who keeps Purim properly receives a measure of bris milah, is freed from his evil part, and can make a new covenant with Hashem. He praises the child's family of Torah, Chassidus and yiras Shamayim, and blesses them to see the light of Moshiach.

Why the Chachamim finally wrote the Megillah

18:51

Returning to his question, the Rav explains that Yehoshua, Shaul, and Mordechai and Esther only weakened Amalek. The Megillah, written without Hashem's name, shows the wiping out is incomplete, while a fourth writing requires completion. The Chachamim wrote it once they saw that Hashem wanted Haman's descendants to learn Torah in Bnei Brak. q

Sources

Torah

  1. c apparently Shemos 17:8-16 0:38 index
  2. d apparently Devarim 25:17-19 0:42 index

Nevi'im

  1. e apparently Shmuel I 15 0:48 index
  2. h apparently Yeshayahu 3:18-24 3:02 index
  3. j Malachi 1:1 4:51 text index

Kesuvim

  1. b apparently Mishlei 22:20 0:22 index
  2. o Esther 8:16 12:45 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 0:08
  2. f Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 0:08
  3. l apparently Sanhedrin 20b 6:45 index
  4. p Megillah 16b 12:45 text index
  5. q Gittin 57b text index In the write-up: 18:51

Midrash

  1. i Midrash (place not identified) 4:51

Rishonim

  1. g apparently Rashi on Shemos 31:18 2:46 index
  2. k apparently Hilchos Megillah 2:18 index In the write-up: 4:14
  3. n Tosafos (place not identified) 9:32 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. m Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:24

Key points

  1. 0:22 The Chachamim hesitated to write Megillas Esther because the Torah allows Amalek's war to be written three times, and a fourth time would require a complete wiping out of Amalek.
  2. 4:14 The twenty-four books of Tanach are the ornaments of the Shechinah, and each book existed in heaven before its navi drew it down into writing.
  3. 5:27 Megillas Esther and Purim hold a spark of the light of Moshiach, given so that Jews can grow used to that light before it comes in full.
  4. 6:17 Purim is not yet a finished yom tov, since its essence is the wiping out of Amalek, which is not yet complete.
  5. 11:04 A bris milah, like Purim, removes the orlah and reveals a glimpse of the days of Moshiach, so the Shushan Purim seudah is a seudah of bris milah.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:20 Why may Amalek be written only three times, so that the Chachamim at first refused to write Megillas Esther?

    Answer: 18:51 Each earlier victory only weakened Amalek; a fourth writing must already be a complete wiping out, and the hidden Megillah shows it is not yet complete. They wrote it once they saw Hashem wanted Haman's descendants to learn Torah in Bnei Brak.

  2. Question: 3:43 According to Shmuel, Esther is not one of the holy writings; what then of the twenty-four books that correspond to the twenty-four combinations of the Name?

    Answer: 8:11 It is one of the twenty-four, but its place is still in heaven and not fully revealed, because the wiping out of Amalek is not yet complete; it will shine fully when Moshiach comes.

Insights

  1. 19:38 The Rav reads the Chachamim's hesitation as more than a counting rule: a fourth writing of Amalek belongs to the final, complete wiping out of Amalek, and the Megillah's concealment shows that time had not come.
  2. 5:35 Megillas Esther was given as a spark of Moshiach's light so that Jews can get used to it, since the full light, if it came at once, would be too strong to bear.
  3. 6:12 Purim will remain when other yomim tovim are nullified precisely because it is not yet finished: its full expression waits for the complete wiping out of Amalek.
  4. 8:00 Shmuel's view that Esther is not among the holy writings is reconciled: it is one of the twenty-four, but its place is still hidden in heaven until Moshiach comes and the Megillah appears in a new garment.
  5. 11:57 The Shushan Purim seudah is itself a seudah of bris milah, since the Megillah means removing idolatry from the land, just as the bris removes the orlah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 14:27 The Rav says that on Shushan Purim, a Jew who keeps Purim properly is freed from his evil part and can turn to Hashem and make a new covenant with Him, to be good from now on.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Agag, Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Malachi, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, Shmuel (the Amora), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yehoshua bin Nun, Yeshayahu HaNavi

Terms ימות המשיח, מחיית עמלק, מילה, ערלה, שכינה

Report an error on this page