פדיון הבן
Pidyan Haben (Bo)
Catalog entry: Simchos בא no. 58 Yiddish 12 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
At a pidyon haben, the Rav contrasts Esav's meal that despised the birthright with the pidyon haben meal that honors the firstborn, Hashem who is First, and the Torah called 'reishis', and explains why eating at it is likened to eighty-four fasts.
The Rav says pidyon haben comes from the Exodus, when Hashem said 'sanctify to Me every firstborn', and that on the night of the plague of the firstborn Jews reached a conduct above intellect and time, tied to 'Bereishis', the first utterance. He relates a sefer's account of a Nittel night and says that at a pidyon haben meal such forces have no hold. From 'My firstborn son is Israel' he turns to Esav's meal, where he despised the birthright, and asks why that is stressed when Esav did worse that day. Using Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen's reading of the Rambam on techiyas hameisim, he answers that despising the birthright revealed denial of 'reishis'. The pidyon haben meal is the reverse: it honors the firstborn and the Torah. He explains the saying that such a meal equals eighty-four fasts, notes how Maseches Pesachim ends, and blesses the family.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Pidyon haben and the night of the Exodus listed in the guide
Asked by the father to speak, the Rav says pidyon haben stems from 'sanctify to Me every firstborn' at the Exodus, when Jews reached a conduct above intellect and time. He relates a sefer's account of a Nittel night and says that at a pidyon haben meal such forces have no hold, as on the night when 'no dog sharpened its tongue'.
-
3:39 Esav's meal and the pidyon haben meal listed in the guide
From 'My firstborn son is Israel' the Rav turns to Esav's meal at which he despised the birthright, and asks why this is stressed when Esav did worse that day. Through Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen's reading of the Rambam on techiyas hameisim he answers that it revealed denial of 'reishis', and calls the pidyon haben meal its reverse, a meal honoring the birthright and the Torah.
-
8:12 A meal equal to eighty-four fasts listed in the guide
The Rav brings from the seforim that eating at a pidyon haben meal is like the eighty-four fasts the Arizal gave for a blemish of the bris, and explains that the root blemish is the first not going to Hashem, so honoring 'reishis' repairs it. He notes that Maseches Pesachim ends with the father's blessing, and blesses the family and all of Israel with redemption.
The shiur, written up
Pidyon haben and the night of the Exodus
The Rav says pidyon haben stems from the Exodus, when Hashem said 'sanctify to Me every firstborn'. On the night of the plague of the firstborn, Jews reached a conduct above intellect and above time. Therefore, he says, at a pidyon haben meal the forces of a night like Nittel have no hold, as on the night when no dog sharpened its tongue. a,c
Esav's meal and the pidyon haben meal
From 'My firstborn son is Israel' the Rav turns to Esav, who ate, drank and despised the birthright. Why stress this, he asks, when Esav did worse that day? Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen explains the Rambam: one who denies techiyas hameisim simply has no connection to it. So too, Esav's scorn showed he denied 'reishis', for, as Rashi on Bereishis brings, the world was created for Israel, called 'reishis'. d,e,g,h
The pidyon haben meal is its reverse: a meal honoring the birthright and the Torah.
A meal equal to eighty-four fasts
The Rav brings from the seforim that eating at a pidyon haben meal is like the eighty-four fasts the Arizal gave for a blemish of the bris. He explains that the root blemish is the first not going to Hashem, so a meal honoring 'reishis' repairs it. He notes that Maseches Pesachim ends with the father's blessing, and blesses the family with nachas and Israel with redemption. k
Sources
Torah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Key points
- 0:52 Pidyon haben comes from the Exodus, when on the night of the plague of the firstborn Jews reached a conduct above intellect and above time.
- 4:14 Relative to the angels, the Rav says, Jews are Hashem's firstborn; the verse does not mean that the nations are ordinary sons.
- 6:43 Esav's despising the birthright was singled out because it revealed that he denied 'reishis', the firstness through which Israel and the Torah are bound to Hashem.
- 7:36 The pidyon haben meal is the reverse of Esav's meal: it honors the birthright and the Torah and gives thanks to Hashem.
- 8:17 Eating at a pidyon haben meal is likened to eighty-four fasts, because honoring 'reishis' repairs the root blemish of the first not being given to Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:23 Why does the Torah stress that Esav despised the birthright, when he committed worse sins that same day?
Answer: 5:44 Like the Rambam's statement on techiyas hameisim as Rabbi Tzadok explains it, scorning the birthright was a sign that Esav had no connection to 'reishis'; his other sins could be ascribed to desire.
-
Question: 8:17 Why is eating at a pidyon haben meal likened to eighty-four fasts?
Answer: 8:44 Because it is the opposite of Esav's meal: it honors 'reishis', and the root blemish that those fasts repair is the first not going to Hashem.
Stories
-
2:45 A Nittel night in a sefer
The Rav relates that an author recounted in his sefer that on a Nittel night someone sat down to learn and was not careful about the custom. A dog then came into the house, and the author saw from this that one must keep Jewish customs.
Insights
- 5:51 The Rav applies Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen's principle, that a person does not believe in what he has no connection to, to Esav: his other sins could stem from desire, but scorning the birthright exposed that he had no connection to 'reishis'.
- 6:56 He ties together Hashem as the First, the sanctity of firstborns, Israel as Hashem's firstborn and the Torah called 'reishis', so that honoring the bechor is honoring all of them.
- 9:37 He explains that the root of a blemish of the bris is that the first does not go to Hashem, which is why a meal honoring 'reishis' is likened to the eighty-four fasts given for that blemish.
- 7:26 He reads the pidyon haben meal as a reversal of Esav's meal: where Esav ate and drank in scorn of the birthright, Jews eat and drink to honor it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Reuven, the Arizal, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu
Terms בכורה, מכת בכורות, ניטל, פגם הברית, פדיון הבן, ראשית, תחיית המתים