פדיון הבן
Pidyon Haben
Catalog entry: Simchos no. 61 Yiddish 27 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the seudah of a pidyon haben, unlike Esav's feast over despising the bechorah, honors the Jewish people's status as Hashem's firstborn, His 'reishis', and that even the last generations share in that status.
The Rav opens with the custom of performing the pidyon haben in the middle of the seudah for publicity, and asks why this mitzvah needs more publicity than others. He turns to the parsha of the festivals, where the Torah interrupts the omer and Shavuos with the mitzvos of leket and peah. He then explains that Esav's sin in despising the bechorah was a flaw in his outlook, since the bechorah stands for the chosenness of Israel, the 'reishis' for whose sake the world was created. Esav even made a feast over it; the seudah of pidyon haben does the opposite and shows honor for the bechorah, which is greater than the mitzvah itself. The theme of reishis runs from Pesach to Shavuos. The forgotten sheaves and the corner of the field stand for the last generations, which are as precious as the first fruits, and the seudah is a chizuk in these times.
Topics: Bris Milah and Simchos · Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · The Greatness of Every Jew
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the pidyon haben is done mid-seudah listed in the guide
The Rav notes that, unlike other mitzvos, the pidyon haben is performed in the middle of the seudah for publicity, and asks why. He turns to the parsha of the festivals, the omer and the count to Shavuos, and to Rashi's question why leket and peah interrupt the festivals.
-
4:18 Esav despised the bechorah
The Rav asks why the Torah stresses that Esav despised the bechorah while not mentioning the five grave sins he did that day. He explains that the bechorah is the chosenness of Israel, the 'reishis' for which the world was created, and that the bechorah belongs to whoever wants to serve Hashem.
-
8:58 A sin of outlook, and Esav's feast listed in the guide
Through Rav Tzadok's reading of the Chazal on techiyas hameisim, the Rav explains that despising the bechorah is a symptom of having no share in it, a sin only an Esav commits. Esav even made a feast over it, and the seudah of pidyon haben expresses the opposite: a Jew's joy in his share in Israel's 'reishis'.
-
13:08 Honor of the bechorah, and Esav's false reishis listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Gemara in Megillah that honor of the Torah outweighs its study, and says the seudah, honoring the bechorah, is greater than the mitzvah itself. He shows that reishis runs through many mitzvos, and that Esav's and Amalek's 'reishis' is false, as shown by its lack of a good end.
-
17:54 From Pesach to Shavuos: the festival of reishis
The Rav describes the time from Pesach to Shavuos as one long festival of reishis, in which a Jew identifies with Hashem's first 'produce' through the omer and the bikkurim. He then turns to the last generations, in a time of great hester panim, when it is hard to see that Jews are Hashem's reishis.
-
21:19 The last sheaves are also reishis listed in the guide
The Rav explains that leket, shikchah and peah, the last grain of the field, stand for the last generations, which are as precious as the first fruits; this answers why they appear among the festivals. He concludes that a seudah of pidyon haben in these last generations is a great chizuk, and closes with a brachah for the true redemption.
The shiur, written up
Why the pidyon haben is done mid-seudah
The Rav notes that at other mitzvos, such as a bris, the seudah follows the mitzvah, yet the custom at a pidyon haben is to begin the seudah and perform the redemption in its middle, for publicity. He asks why this mitzvah needs more publicity than others.
Esav despised the bechorah
The Rav recalls that Esav sold the bechorah and the verse ends 'and Esav despised the bechorah'. Chazal say he committed five grave sins that day, yet the Torah mentions none of them, only that he despised the bechorah. e
He explains that the bechorah is the chosenness of Israel, Hashem's firstborn, called 'reishis': the world was created so there would be a Jewish people serving Hashem. Whatever has a beginning has an end, so every Jew will have a good acharis. The bechorah, as Yaakov told Esav, belongs to whoever wants to serve Hashem; Esav wanted only this world. f
A sin of outlook, and Esav's feast
Rav Tzadok explains that one who denies techiyas hameisim loses it not as a punishment: denial is a symptom of having no connection to it. So too, Esav's other sins a Jew could stumble in, but despising the bechorah was a flaw in his outlook that only an Esav falls into, and the Torah records it as a sign for all generations.
Honor of the bechorah
The Rav says the seudah is even more important than the mitzvah. The Gemara in Megillah sets aside Torah study for reading the Megillah, yet sets aside the Megillah for the honor of the Torah, since honor of the Torah is greater than its study. So too, Jews make a seudah to honor the bechorah, the reverse of Esav's feast, and that honor shows their emunah in their root. k
From Pesach to Shavuos
The Rav describes Pesach as the renewal of reishis, beginning a long chol hamoed through the omer until Shavuos, when a Jew identifies with the first grain he cuts from his field. He then turns to the last generations, a time of great hester panim and persecution, when it is hard to see that Jews are Hashem's reishis.
The last sheaves are also reishis
The first grain is reishis, but what of the last stalks, left long after the harvest? The Rav explains that leket, shikchah and peah are the last generations, and they too are reishis, as precious as the omer and the bikkurim. This is why Rashi says one who gives them is as if he built the Beis Hamikdash and offered korbanos. c,d
He concludes that a seudah of pidyon haben in these last generations, begun before the mitzvah because honor of the bechorah counts like the mitzvah itself, is a great chizuk. He closes with a brachah for the true redemption.
Sources
Torah
- a apparently Vayikra 23:10 index In the write-up: 1:50
- c apparently Vayikra 23:22 index In the write-up: 1:50, 21:32
- e Bereishis 25:34 text index In the write-up: 4:21
- f apparently Shemos 4:22 index In the write-up: 5:26
- m apparently Shemos 13:2 15:44 index
- n apparently Shemos 12:2 15:45 index
- o apparently Bamidbar 24:20 index In the write-up: 15:36
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:42 The custom is to perform the pidyon haben in the middle of the seudah, as a matter of publicizing the mitzvah.
- 5:26 The bechorah stands for the chosenness of Israel, called 'reishis', for whose sake the whole world was created.
- 10:00 Esav's despising of the bechorah was a sin of outlook, not of desire or anger, and only an Esav can stumble in it.
- 14:11 The seudah of pidyon haben is the reverse of Esav's feast: Jews make a seudah to honor the bechorah.
- 13:15 Honoring the bechorah is greater than the mitzvah of the bechorah itself, as honor of the Torah is greater than its study.
- 22:54 The last generations, like the forgotten sheaves and the corner of the field, are as precious to Hashem as the first fruits.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:22 Why does pidyon haben need more publicity than other mitzvos?
Answer: 11:27 Because its seudah honors the bechorah, the reverse of Esav's feast over despising it, and this honor is even greater than the mitzvah.
-
Question: 5:00 Why does the Torah stress Esav's despising of the bechorah and not the five grave sins he did that day?
Answer: 9:46 Those sins a Jew too could stumble in, but despising the bechorah is a flaw in outlook that only an Esav falls into.
-
Question: 13:22 The Gemara in Megillah seems to contradict itself about whether Torah study or Megillah reading comes first.
Answer: 13:45 Torah study is set aside, but honor of the Torah is greater than its study and sets aside Megillah reading.
-
Question: 3:20 Why are leket and peah written in the middle of the festivals?
Answer: 22:54 The last grain of the field stands for the last generations, which are reishis too and as precious as the bikkurim.
Insights
- 5:06 The Torah singles out Esav's despising of the bechorah over his five grave sins because it was a flaw in outlook that reveals who he is, a sign for all generations.
- 9:12 Following Rav Tzadok, not believing in something is a symptom that one has no connection to it, since a person by instinct believes in what he belongs to.
- 6:27 Using a rule of geometry, the Rav argues that whatever has a beginning has an end; Israel, the true reishis, will have a good acharis, while Amalek's lack of a good end shows its reishis is false.
- 14:14 Doing the pidyon haben inside the seudah reverses Esav's feast: he celebrated despising the bechorah, while Jews feast to honor it, and that honor outweighs the mitzvah itself.
- 22:40 Leket, shikchah and peah, the last grain left at the end of the harvest, appear among the festivals of reishis because the last generations are as precious to Hashem as the first fruits.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 24:50 The Rav says that a seudah of pidyon haben in the last generations is a great chizuk, showing that Jews today still uphold the reishis.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Amalek, Esav, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, Rav Avdimi bar Rav Yosef, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אחרית הימים, ביכורים, בכורה, הסתר פנים, ספירת העומר, פדיון הבן, ראשית, שתי הלחם, תחיית המתים