הבינוני יכול להיות כצדיק בעיתות רצון' עיבור נשמת צדיק בתוכו' כשעושה עצמו שמח בטוב ומואס ברע זוכה שזה נעשה טבעו.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ט"ו no. ⁨32⁩ Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 45 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 45 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains how a beinoni, who cannot choose to be a true tzaddik, can still fulfill the oath 'be a tzaddik': through moments of real joy in Hashem, through habit that becomes second nature, and through the soul of a tzaddik that comes into him (ibbur).

The Rav reviews the Tanya's distinction: a beinoni wages a constant war with the yetzer hara and every Jew can reach that, but being a tzaddik needs a special soul. This explains the double oath, 'be a tzaddik and do not be a rasha': not being a rasha is in everyone's hands, while 'be a tzaddik' means to strive for it. Still, the Tanya says, a person should set times to contemplate that worldly pleasures are worthless and to rejoice in Hashem; even if passing, at his level it counts. Habit also becomes second nature, as with a brachah said with thought. With the parable of Dovid's harp and a tuned piano string he shows that joy below arouses joy above. Perhaps a spark of a tzaddik's soul will come into him, as in the story of Rav Chaim Vital. A Jew's small mitzvah is multiplied above, which he illustrates with Haman and the omer.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Serving Hashem with Simcha

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why the oath is doubled listed in the guide

    The Rav reviews the difference between a tzaddik, who needs a special soul, and a beinoni, whose constant war with the yetzer hara is in every Jew's hands. He uses it to explain the double oath 'be a tzaddik and do not be a rasha', and notes that a Jew can taste joy in Hashem on Shabbos, Yom Tov or during learning, though it does not last.

  2. 6:33 Contemplation and habit as second nature listed in the guide

    The Rav reads the Tanya's 'nevertheless': a person should set times to contemplate that worldly pleasures are worthless and to rejoice in Hashem. Even if this is not absolute truth for a beinoni, at his level he fulfills 'be a tzaddik'; and since habit becomes second nature, the feeling can become truly his.

  3. 12:02 A brachah and learning said with thought listed in the guide

    The Rav gives examples of building the habit: pausing a few seconds before a brachah to think for Whom and why one makes it, and before learning to think that Torah is the wisdom of Hashem. Done regularly, this becomes nature, and an awakening below brings an awakening above.

  4. 15:40 Dovid's harp and the tuned string listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara that a harp hung over Dovid's bed and played at midnight, and explains it with a piano tuner's fork: a string tuned to the same note vibrates by itself. Dovid was tuned to Gan Eden; likewise a Jew who rejoices in Hashem arouses Hashem's joy in him, as in 'yismach Yisrael' and 'yismach Hashem'.

  5. 21:40 Gilgul, ibbur and Rav Chaim Vital's story listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that a soul which failed through negligence to fulfill mitzvos returns in a full gilgul, while one that missed a mitzvah not by its fault, or a lofty soul that longs for mitzvos, comes into a living Jew for a while as an ibbur and helps him do the mitzvah. He describes unexplained times of great love and closeness as such an ibbur, and tells how Rav Chaim Vital sat on the grave of Benayahu ben Yehoyada and the Arizal stood up for him.

  6. 29:37 A tzaddik's soul enters him; the sundial listed in the guide

    The Rav returns to the Tanya: one who accustoms himself to rejoice in Hashem will play the music of joy on his soul, and perhaps a spirit from above, a spark of a tzaddik's soul, will come into him so that he serves with true joy. This is a third way to fulfill 'be a tzaddik', and the joy he causes above is far greater than what he feels, like a sundial's shadow moving an inch while the sun moves millions of miles.

  7. 34:21 Haman's ten thousand talents and the omer

    The Rav repeats a thought he said at the Pesach seudah: the Gemara tells that Haman found Mordechai teaching the laws of the omer's handful and said it outweighed his ten thousand talents. He explains that a Jew's mitzvah rises and is multiplied through the worlds while a non-Jew's deed stays below, and he distinguishes 'aseres' (a collective, a multiplication) from 'isaron' (a division, as in 'ishon', a small person in the eye).

  8. 40:11 The barley omer is lifted up listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the omer, brought of barley, animal food, like the minchas sotah, is the cheapest offering, yet it is called the omer of waving because it is lifted up and turns from animal into man, raising the Jews day by day until Shavuos. He concludes that the beinoni's small joy below arouses great joy above, and with the help of the soul that comes into him he fulfills 'be a tzaddik' in truth.

The shiur, written up

Why the oath is doubled

0:53

The Rav reviews what the Tanya has said so far. A tzaddik has already defeated the yetzer hara, which no longer sits in the left chamber of his heart; for that one must be born with a special soul. A beinoni never sins but still wages a constant war with the yetzer hara, and every Jew can do that. Being a tzaddik, then, is not a matter of choice; being a beinoni is.

1:59

With this, the Tanya in chapter 14 explains the double language of the oath before birth in Niddah 30b, 'be a tzaddik and do not be a rasha'. Not being a rasha is in everyone's hands; 'be a tzaddik' means to strive for it. The Rav adds that a Jew who guards himself all week can taste real delight in Hashem on Shabbos or Yom Tov, even over a page of Gemara, but it does not stay. a,b

Contemplation and habit as second nature

6:35

Even so, the Tanya says, a person must set times to contemplate why he was created and that the pleasures of this world have no substance, and to rejoice in Hashem. The Rav explains that this is not absolute truth for the beinoni, yet at his level it is his truth, since he can renew it tomorrow at davening or next Shabbos, and so he fulfills 'be a tzaddik'. d

11:15

The Tanya adds that habit rules a person and becomes second nature, so repeated contemplation can make loathing evil truly his. f

A brachah said with thought

12:51

The Rav gives examples. Before a brachah, a person can take a few seconds to think for Whom and why he makes it, for Hashem who has provided all his needs since birth. Done regularly, thanks and love grow until he cannot make a brachah without thinking. The same applies before learning, remembering that Torah is the wisdom of Hashem.

Dovid's harp and the tuned string

15:40

The Rav brings the Gemara in Berachos 3b that a harp hung over Dovid's bed and played at midnight. He explains it with a piano tuner's fork: when a piano is in tune, the fork vibrates by itself, and two strings tuned alike sound together. Dovid was tuned to Gan Eden, where at midnight the tzaddikim sing, so his heart awoke by itself, with no alarm clock. g

19:50

It works the other way too: a Jew who serves Hashem with joy is the string that arouses a matching joy above. As Yisrael rejoices in its Maker (Tehillim 149:2), Hashem rejoices in His works (Tehillim 104:31). i,j

Gilgul, ibbur and Rav Chaim Vital

21:51

The Rav explains that no one can fulfill every mitzvah. A soul that neglected mitzvos through its own fault must return in a full gilgul. A soul that missed one through no fault, or a lofty soul that longs for mitzvos, comes into a living Jew for a while, an ibbur, and helps him do the mitzvah; one who visits the sick wholeheartedly may merit the soul of Avraham Avinu.

25:46

Sometimes a person feels, for an hour or a whole Shabbos, a love and closeness to Hashem far above his level. The Rav says this is such an ibbur, which benefits both souls.

27:29

Rav Chaim Vital records in his Sefer HaGilgulim that the Arizal once stood up for him: unknowingly he had sat on the grave of Benayahu ben Yehoyada, and the Arizal told him that soul was now with him. The Rav adds that the Ben Ish Chai merited this too, so his sefarim are named after that passuk (Shmuel II 23:20). k,l

A tzaddik's soul enters him; the sundial

29:58

Returning to the Tanya, the Rav reads that one who accustoms himself to rejoice in Hashem will play joy on his soul's harp, and perhaps a spirit from above, a spark of a tzaddik's soul, will come into him, so that his joy is true, as in 'rejoice, tzaddikim, in Hashem' (Tehillim 97:12). This is a third way to fulfill 'be a tzaddik'. m,n

33:10

Moreover, the joy his mitzvah causes above is far greater than what he feels, like a sundial's shadow moving an inch while the sun moves millions of miles.

Haman's ten thousand talents

34:21

The Rav repeats what he said at the Pesach seudah. The Gemara in Megillah 16a tells that Haman found Mordechai teaching the laws of the omer's handful, and said it outweighed his ten thousand talents of silver. o

36:37

Even a small mitzvah, like tzitzis, rises and grows through the worlds. A non-Jew's good deed improves him but does not go up. The Rav adds that 'aseres' means a collective, a multiplication, while 'isaron' means a division, as 'ishon' is the small person reflected in the eye.

The barley omer is lifted up

40:11

The omer is the cheapest offering, of barley, animal food, like the minchas sotah. Haman thought his ten thousand talents would surely outweigh it, but he did not know that a non-Jew's offering stays below. The Jews' omer is called the omer of waving: it is lifted up, turns from animal to man, and raises them until Shavuos.

44:03

So too, the Rav concludes, the beinoni's small joy below arouses great joy above, and with the help of the soul that comes into him he fulfills 'be a tzaddik' in truth.

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. l apparently Shmuel II 23:20 index In the write-up: 27:29

Kesuvim

  1. h apparently Tehillim 31:20 18:41 index
  2. i Tehillim 149:2 text index In the write-up: 19:50
  3. j Tehillim 104:31 text index In the write-up: 19:50
  4. n Tehillim 97:12 text index In the write-up: 29:58
  5. r apparently Tehillim 17:8 39:41 index

Mishnah

  1. p Mishnah (place not identified) 35:50 index

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Niddah 30b text index In the write-up: 1:59
  2. g Berachos 3b text index In the write-up: 15:40
  3. o Megillah 16a text index In the write-up: 34:21

Rishonim

  1. q Rashi (place not identified) 39:09 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 1:59
  2. c apparently Tanya ch. 1 2:02 index
  3. d apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 6:35
  4. e apparently Tanya ch. 13 9:46 index
  5. f apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 11:15
  6. m apparently Tanya ch. 14 index In the write-up: 29:58

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. s Siddur (place not identified) 43:27 index

Other

  1. k Sefer HaGilgulim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:29

Key points

  1. 1:00 Being a beinoni, who never sins though the yetzer hara still fights him, is within every Jew's choice; being a tzaddik is not, since it needs a special soul.
  2. 5:09 This explains why the oath is doubled: 'do not be a rasha' is an absolute obligation, while 'be a tzaddik' means to strive toward it.
  3. 8:51 Moments of joy in Hashem that a beinoni reaches through contemplation are not absolute truth, yet relative to his level he fulfills 'be a tzaddik' through them.
  4. 11:15 Habit rules a person and becomes second nature, so repeated contemplation can make loathing evil and rejoicing in Hashem his nature.
  5. 19:50 A Jew's joy in serving Hashem below arouses a matching joy above, like two strings tuned to the same note.
  6. 30:48 Through his own effort the beinoni may merit that the soul of a tzaddik enters him (ibbur), and with its help he serves Hashem with true joy.
  7. 33:10 A Jew's small mitzvah is multiplied as it rises through the worlds, unlike the deeds of a non-Jew, which stay below.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:59 Why is the oath given before birth doubled, 'be a tzaddik' and also 'do not be a rasha'?

    Answer: 5:04 Because being a tzaddik is not in a person's choice, so 'be a tzaddik' means to strive for it, while not being a rasha is in everyone's choice.

  2. Question: 4:38 If a beinoni has no choice to truly loathe evil and rejoice in Hashem, how does he fulfill 'be a tzaddik' at all?

    Answer: 10:14 Through contemplation he reaches moments that are true at his level; through habit it becomes second nature; and he may merit a tzaddik's soul entering him, with whose help his joy is true.

  3. Question: 35:12 Why did Haman say the omer's handful outweighed his ten thousand talents of silver?

    Answer: 41:27 Because a non-Jew's deed stays below, while a Jew's mitzvah, even the cheapest offering, is lifted up and multiplied in the upper worlds.

  4. Question: 40:11 Why was the omer brought of barley rather than fine wheat flour?

    Answer: 40:41 Barley is animal food, making it the lowliest offering, like the minchas sotah; yet it is lifted up and turns from animal into man, raising the Jews until on Shavuos they bring the two loaves of wheat, food of man.

Stories

  1. 27:29 Rav Chaim Vital at the grave of Benayahu ben Yehoyada

    Rav Chaim Vital records in his Sefer HaGilgulim that he once came to his Rebbe, the Arizal, and the Arizal stood up for him. Without knowing it, Rav Chaim Vital had sat on the grave of Benayahu ben Yehoyada, one of the forgotten graves of tzaddikim the Arizal had revealed around Tzfas, and had concentrated on certain kavanos there. The Arizal told him that the soul of Benayahu ben Yehoyada was now with him as an ibbur. The Rav adds that the sefarim say the Ben Ish Chai also merited this, which is why his sefarim are named after that passuk.

    In the story: Rav Chaim Vital, the Arizal, Benayahu ben Yehoyada, the Ben Ish Chai

    told in 5 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 1:50 The oath's two halves are not of equal weight: 'do not be a rasha' is fully in a person's hands, while 'be a tzaddik' is a charge to strive, since being a tzaddik is not given to free choice.
  2. 10:02 Truth is measured by the person's level: a passing feeling of loathing for worldly pleasure is not truth for a complete tzaddik, but for the beinoni it is his truth, since he can renew it tomorrow at davening or next Shabbos.
  3. 17:06 Dovid's harp played at midnight like a piano string vibrating in response to a tuning fork: Dovid's heart was tuned to the song of the tzaddikim in Gan Eden, so it awoke by itself, with no alarm clock.
  4. 26:41 An ibbur benefits both souls: the Jew can serve with a love and joy beyond his own level, and the departed tzaddik gets to do once more the mitzvah he longed for or was missing.
  5. 41:18 Haman's ten thousand talents of charity lost to the barley omer because a non-Jew's deed stays below, while a Jew's cheapest offering is lifted (tenufah) and multiplied in the upper worlds.
  6. 39:01 'Aseres' denotes a collective and multiplication while 'isaron' denotes division, as 'ishon' (the pupil) means a small person reflected in the eye.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 6:52 The Rav says a person should set times for a cheshbon hanefesh, contemplating why man was created and that worldly pleasures have no substance.
  2. 12:51 The Rav says that before a brachah one should take a few seconds to think for Whom and why he makes it, until it becomes his nature.
  3. 14:38 The Rav says that before learning one should pause and think why and before Whom he learns, that the Torah is the wisdom of Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Benayahu ben Yehoyada, Dovid HaMelech, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rashi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ben Ish Chai, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), Yaakov Avinu

Terms בינוני, גלגול, חלל השמאלי, עיבור

Report an error on this page