אל תבטחו בנדיבים

Catalog entry: תפילה no. ⁨20⁩ Pocket Guide p. 49 Yiddish 45 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 45 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Going through the chapter of Tehillim 'Al tivtechu vindivim', the Rav explains that a Jew's hope rests only on Hashem, who measures every person's share of help and suffering, and that even when people help him they are only Hashem's messengers.

The Rav opens with 'Al tivtechu vindivim': the great donors cannot be relied on, since a man can change his mind or leave the world. Yaakov Avinu is the model of bitachon; the Midrash contrasts his empty-handed journey to Charan with Eliezer's camels, and he said 'my help is from Hashem, Maker of heaven and earth'. Even when donors help, they are only messengers. Reading 'sivro' as 'shivro', the Rav explains that every person's measure of suffering is fixed, so one who pours his toil into Torah and avodas Hashem is spared suffering elsewhere. He goes on through the chapter: helpers and enemies are Hashem's instruments; Hashem keeps faith across generations and gilgulim, frees trapped sparks of holiness in their time, and watches over the orphan and widow. Bitachon is drawn from Torah, tzaddikim, and the 'Tziyon' of every generation, such as Shabbos. He closes on 'Ki tov zamrah Elokeinu': Dovid HaMelech sings even under midas hadin.

Topics: Bitachon · Pesukei DeZimra · Hester Panim and Suffering

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Do not rely on the donors listed in the guide

    The Rav observes that the largest tzedakah comes from ordinary Jews of the batei midrash, not from the rich, and reads 'al tivtechu vindivim': a man can promise, then change his mind or leave the world, and his plans are lost with him.

  2. 3:55 Yaakov, the pillar of bitachon listed in the guide

    On 'ashrei she'Kel Yaakov b'ezro', the Rav brings the Midrash that Yaakov went to Charan with nothing, unlike Eliezer's camels, and said 'my help is from Hashem, Maker of heaven and earth'. One whose hope is on Hashem sees even helping donors as mere messengers.

  3. 7:27 Every person's measure of suffering listed in the guide

    Bringing a reading of 'sivro' as 'shivro', the Rav explains that each person must go through a fixed measure of suffering and nachas. He tells of a man who lost a gold watch after having nachas from new curtains, and explains the custom of saying 'kaparah' over a broken glass.

  4. 12:06 Breaking oneself for Hashem listed in the guide

    Every person comes into the world to be broken, so the Rav says one should put his toil into Torah and avodas Hashem and be spared suffering in health and children. He asks why not everyone does so and answers that they lack bitachon; one whose breaking is 'al Hashem Elokav' shows true hope.

  5. 16:46 Helpers, enemies and Hashem's true reckoning listed in the guide

    On 'Hashem li b'ozrai', the Rav says one must thank those who help yet see Hashem behind them, and see an enemy too as Hashem's instrument, as Dovid did with Shimi ben Gera. On 'shomer emes l'olam' he explains, with Rashi, that Hashem's reckoning spans generations and gilgulim, illustrated by a din Torah before Reb Yitzchak Hamburger.

  6. 22:54 Hashem frees what is bound, in its time listed in the guide

    On 'Hashem matir asurim', the Rav explains that Hashem arranges ways, such as bitul b'rov, for a trapped spark of holiness to become permitted. A person may not force such a release himself, just as Klal Yisrael was sworn to wait for the geulah and not take it by force.

  7. 26:39 The blind, the bent, the orphan and the widow listed in the guide

    The Rav goes through 'pokeach ivrim', 'zokef kefufim', 'ohev tzaddikim' and 'yasom v'almanah ye'oded': those without worldly wisdom, those bent under burdens and the forsaken are not lost, for Hashem watches over them. He brings a letter of Reb Yonasan to his widowed sister that most orphans grow up successful, while the planned paths of the wicked are overturned.

  8. 32:25 Where bitachon is drawn from: Tziyon listed in the guide

    The Rav sums up the chapter's theme as bitachon and asks where it is acquired: from the Torah, from tzaddikim and their stories, and from 'Tziyon', which today exists in soul and in time, such as Shabbos. He tells the Gemara's story of Nakdimon ben Gurion to show that Hashem's kingship of 'yimloch Hashem l'olam' is present in every generation.

  9. 38:12 Singing to Hashem even in midas hadin

    Moving to 'Ki tov zamrah Elokeinu', the Rav explains that after Ashrei Dovid HaMelech could not stop praising. He contrasts mockers of long, loud davening with their own shouting at ball games, and explains that Dovid sings even under midas hadin, as in 'tzarah v'yagon emtza uvshem Hashem ekra'.

The shiur, written up

Do not rely on the donors

1:30

The Rav observes that the largest tzedakah does not come from the wealthy but from ordinary Jews of the batei midrash, kollel yungeleit and melamdim. This is why the passuk warns 'al tivtechu vindivim': even fine, generous people cannot be relied on. a

3:04

A man may promise, the Rav explains, but 'teitzei rucho': either he leaves the world, or the inspiration he received from Above departs and he returns to his earthiness and does not keep his word. On that day all the plans of those who relied on him are lost. b

Yaakov, the pillar of bitachon

3:55

Fortunate is he whose help is the G-d of Yaakov, for Yaakov is the pillar of bitachon. The Rav brings the Midrash: Eliezer came for Yitzchak's match with camels and gifts, while Yaakov came to Charan with nothing. Yet Yaakov did not lose his trust; looking to his 'horim', his parents' wealth, he said 'my help is from Hashem, Maker of heaven and earth'. c,d,e

6:30

Even when donors do help, such a person sees that they are only Hashem's instrument and messenger; if they refuse, Hashem will find another.

Every person's measure of suffering

7:27

The Rav brings a pshat in the name of Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz on 'sivro': every person must go through suffering in this world, and it is written in Heaven how much. Everything is with a reckoning.

8:54

He tells of a Jew in Yerushalayim who came to a tzaddik lamenting the loss of his gold watch. The tzaddik learned that he had just enjoyed new curtains, a great nachas there, and explained that the measure of nachas had been used up. Nachas in one area means less in another, and the Rav explains in this way the custom of saying 'kaparah' when a glass breaks: a loss decreed was paid with a glass.

Breaking oneself for Hashem

12:11

Every person comes into the world to be broken; his whole life is a process leading to 'yashuv l'admaso'. Since the suffering is fixed anyway, the Rav says one should pour it into avodas Hashem: toil over a Tosafos and a blatt Gemara, and be spared suffering in health and in nachas from children. b

14:01

Why, then, doesn't everyone do so? Because they lack bitachon. Anyone can claim to have trust; the sign is 'shivro al Hashem Elokav', that he breaks himself for Hashem. c

Helpers, enemies and Hashem's true reckoning

17:13

On 'Hashem li b'ozrai', the Rav says one must be grateful to whoever helps him, yet see through him, as with an X-ray, that Hashem is the One helping. The same holds for an enemy: Dovid HaMelech bore Shimi ben Gera no grudge, since Hashem had sent him. f,g

18:34

'Oseh shamayim va'aretz': the One who made so great a world can provide what one needs. 'Shomer emes l'olam', Rashi explains, means Hashem keeps faith even after many generations, so a lack comes from His decree, not from a competitor. h,i

20:34

The Rav tells of a din Torah before Reb Yitzchak Hamburger in which he ruled, 'lo bashamayim hi', against what seemed true, because an account from an earlier gilgul was being settled. So too, 'oseh mishpat la'ashukim': a ruling that seems wrong may balance an old account. j,k

Hashem frees what is bound, in its time

22:54

'Hashem matir asurim': a spark of holiness may be trapped in something forbidden. When there is a merit, Hashem arranges means such as bitul b'rov or a chazakah to release it. No computer could keep such a reckoning. j

25:42

A person, however, may not force this himself, just as Klal Yisrael was sworn not to go up as a wall but to wait for the geulah. It must come from Hashem alone. l

The blind, the bent, the orphan and the widow

26:47

'Pokeach ivrim': some people do not understand business or politics, yet Hashem will not let them lose what is due to them. 'Zokef kefufim': those bent under a heavy load are lifted when the time of mercy comes, and 'ohev tzaddikim', He sends His tzaddikim their salvation at its appointed time. m

29:27

'Yasom v'almanah ye'oded': the orphan and widow, who seem forsaken, are not; Hashem encourages them. The Rav cites a letter of Reb Yonasan to his widowed sister, printed in the new Ya'aros Devash, that most orphans grow up wealthy and successful, since Hashem watches them better than a father. The wicked, by contrast, map out their careers and Hashem overturns them. n,o

Where bitachon is drawn from: Tziyon

32:26

The theme of the chapter, the Rav says, is bitachon, and he asks where it is acquired. Once people drew it in Yerushalayim; today Yerushalayim is the tzaddik and talmid chacham, and the Torah, Hashem's 'four cubits of halachah'. One draws bitachon from Tehillim, from upright Jews and from stories of tzaddikim. p

34:30

Tziyon exists in place, in soul and in time: Shabbos and other holy times. These are not old tales; as with Nakdimon ben Gurion, whose tefillah brought rain and then made the sun shine past nightfall, Hashem's kingship is forever. 'Elokayich Tziyon l'dor vador': every generation has its Tziyon. q,r

Singing to Hashem even in midas hadin

38:40

The Rav turns to 'ki tov zamrah Elokeinu'. Dovid HaMelech concluded Tehillim with Ashrei, the greatest praise, yet could not stop, and began again 'Hallelukah, hal'li nafshi', because singing to Hashem is good and pleasant. s,t,u

40:22

Some mock those who daven long and loudly, though the Gemara counts tefillah among things 'standing at the height of the world' that people treat lightly. Those mockers shout at a ball game over an inflated piece of pigskin; they have pleasure in that, but not in davening. v

43:11

The sefarim explain 'Elokeinu' as midas hadin: Dovid sings even under judgment. For him 'kos yeshuos esa' and 'tzarah v'yagon emtza' end alike, 'uvshem Hashem ekra', since all Hashem does is for his good. The Rav closes on 'boneh Yerushalayim Hashem'. w,x

Sources

Torah

  1. k Devarim 30:12 text index In the write-up: 20:34

Nevi'im

  1. g apparently Shmuel II 16:10 index In the write-up: 17:13

Kesuvim

  1. a Tehillim 146:3 text index In the write-up: 1:30
  2. b Tehillim 146:4 text index In the write-up: 3:04, 12:11
  3. c Tehillim 146:5 text index In the write-up: 3:55, 14:01
  4. e Tehillim 121:1-2 text index In the write-up: 3:55
  5. f Tehillim 118:7 text index In the write-up: 17:13
  6. h Tehillim 146:6 text index In the write-up: 18:34
  7. j Tehillim 146:7 text index In the write-up: 20:34, 22:54
  8. m Tehillim 146:8 text index In the write-up: 26:47
  9. n Tehillim 146:9 text index In the write-up: 29:27
  10. r Tehillim 146:10 text index In the write-up: 34:30
  11. s Tehillim 145 text index In the write-up: 38:40
  12. t Tehillim 146:1 text index In the write-up: 38:40
  13. u Tehillim 147:1 text index In the write-up: 38:40
  14. w apparently Tehillim 116:3-4, 13 index In the write-up: 43:11
  15. x Tehillim 147:2 text index In the write-up: 43:11

Talmud Bavli

  1. l apparently Kesubos 111a index In the write-up: 25:42
  2. p Berachos 8a text index In the write-up: 32:26
  3. q apparently Taanis 19b-20a index In the write-up: 34:30
  4. v Berachos 6b text index In the write-up: 40:22

Midrash

  1. d Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 3:55

Rishonim

  1. i apparently Rashi on Tehillim 146:6 index In the write-up: 18:34

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. o Ya'aros Devash (place not identified) index In the write-up: 29:27

Key points

  1. 2:42 The Rav explains that one cannot rely on the donors, because a man may change his mind or leave the world, and with him his plans are lost.
  2. 6:30 Even when people do help, the one whose hope is on Hashem sees them only as a messenger; if they refuse, Hashem has another messenger.
  3. 7:42 Every person must go through suffering in this world, and how much is decreed in Heaven; nachas in one area means less in another, and suffering in one area spares another.
  4. 13:06 The Rav says one should put his exertion into avodas Hashem, toiling over a Tosafos or a blatt Gemara, and thereby be spared suffering in health and in nachas from children.
  5. 19:31 Hashem's reckoning is true over many generations: a loss or an unexpected ruling may settle an account from an earlier gilgul.
  6. 32:41 Bitachon is acquired by going to the Torah and to tzaddikim and by drawing from the 'Tziyon' of each generation, in place, in soul or in time, such as Shabbos.
  7. 43:11 'Ki tov zamrah Elokeinu' teaches that Dovid HaMelech sings to Hashem even when He acts with midas hadin, since everything Hashem does is for his good.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 14:01 If each person's suffering is measured, why does not every Jew put all his toil into learning and avodas Hashem?

    Answer: 14:24 Because he lacks bitachon; the one whose hope is truly on Hashem breaks himself for Hashem and is spared elsewhere.

  2. Question: 15:26 How can one tell that a person's hope is truly on Hashem, when anyone can say he has bitachon?

    Answer: 15:46 When he breaks himself for Hashem, knowing that by doing so he spares himself other suffering.

  3. Question: 32:41 From where does one acquire bitachon?

    Answer: 32:44 From going to the Torah and the tzaddik, from stories of tzaddikim, and from the 'Tziyon' of place, soul and time, such as Shabbos.

  4. Question: 39:27 Why did Dovid HaMelech continue with another chapter of praise after concluding with Ashrei?

    Answer: 39:48 Because praising Hashem is so pleasant that he could not stop; 'ki tov zamrah Elokeinu, ki na'im'.

Stories

  1. 8:32 The lost gold watch and the new curtains

    A Jew in Yerushalayim, in hard times, came to a tzaddik lamenting that he had lost his gold watch. The tzaddik asked whether he had recently had some special nachas, and the man said he had just bought new curtains for his home, a great nachas in Yerushalayim then. The tzaddik explained that a person's measure of nachas is set, and the extra nachas of the curtains was balanced by the loss of the watch.

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 20:34 A din Torah before Reb Yitzchak Hamburger

    A lender died, and his heirs came to Reb Yitzchak Hamburger claiming a debt; the borrower said he had already paid. It became apparent that the deceased had come and cried out that he had indeed been repaid. Reb Yitzchak ruled that 'lo bashamayim hi' and the case had to be decided by the law, and the reckoning, the Rav explains, was that in an earlier gilgul the borrower was the one who owed.

    In the story: Reb Yitzchak Hamburger

  3. 35:54 Nakdimon ben Gurion and the water

    Nakdimon ben Gurion needed water for the olei regalim and borrowed it from a non-Jew, promising to return it by a certain day. The day was ending and there was still no water. Nakdimon went into the Beis HaMikdash and davened, and it began to rain until the cisterns filled; when the non-Jew claimed the day was already over, a miracle was made, the clouds dispersed and the sun shone.

    In the story: Nakdimon ben Gurion

Insights

  1. 7:21 The Rav reads 'sivro' (his hope) as 'shivro' (his breaking): since a person must be broken in any case, the sign of true hope in Hashem is that he breaks himself for Hashem, in toil over Torah and avodas Hashem.
  2. 12:11 A person's lifetime is described as a process of being broken, 'teitzei rucho yashuv l'admaso', so his suffering is not wasted if he directs it into his avodah.
  3. 17:23 The Rav compares seeing Hashem behind a helper to looking through an X-ray: among all who come to help, one sees Hashem Himself coming to help.
  4. 33:34 'Tziyon' is not only a place: when there is no Beis HaMikdash, the source of bitachon is found in Tziyon of the soul, the tzaddik and talmid chacham, and in Tziyon of time, Shabbos and other holy times; this is 'Elokayich Tziyon l'dor vador'.
  5. 23:39 Bringing a hidden spark of holiness out before its time is like taking the geulah by force: Hashem brings it out through means such as bitul b'rov, but a person may not do it himself.
  6. 38:46 The Rav explains that Dovid HaMelech, having finished Tehillim with Ashrei, could not hold back his appetite for praise and added 'Hallelukah, hal'li nafshi', for praising Hashem is 'na'im', pleasant.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 13:06 The Rav says one should put his toil into avodas Hashem, laboring over a Tosafos or a blatt Gemara until he understands.
  2. 17:11 The Rav says one must show gratitude to whoever helps him, yet know that Hashem sent the help.
  3. 33:49 The Rav says one should acquire bitachon by learning Torah, attaching oneself to upright Jews and hearing from them stories of tzaddikim.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Nakdimon ben Gurion, Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz, Rashi, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Reb Yitzchak Hamburger, Shimi ben Gera, Yaakov Avinu

Terms בטחון, גלגול, הכרת הטוב, יסורים, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, ניצוצות, עליה לרגל, רבונו של עולם, שליחות

Report an error on this page