Sh
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. 10 Yiddish 1 hr 19 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Mordechai, while busy saving lives, saw the inner Torah within the events of the Megillah, so that only those Sanhedrin members whose portion was the plain level of Torah saw his work as a loss of Torah study.
The Rav starts from the Gemara that Mordechai was first counted fourth among the leaders who went up to Eretz Yisroel and later fifth, from which Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives, and asks how this fits with Mordechai's greatness. He brings the Gemara that Rabbi Meir wrote a Megillah from memory and explains, with the Midrash that Rabbi Meir's Torah read 'garments of light', that Rabbi Meir saw through the outer skin of creation to the Torah inside it, so he copied the Megillah from creation itself. He then brings the eight kings of Edom, where Divrei Hayamim, written by Ezra, says the eighth king died while the Torah does not, and distinguishes, through the Gemara about Moshe and Rabbi Akiva, between seeing with prophecy and understanding with wisdom. From his level of prophecy Ezra did not see Mordechai's inner Torah. So too some of the Sanhedrin, whose portion was the plain meaning, as in the stories of the Beis Yosef and of a student of the Lechovitcher. The majority saw Mordechai's greatness.
Topics: Megillas Esther · Shushan Purim · Pshat, Remez, Drush and Sod · The Power and Greatness of Torah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
8:00 Mordechai fourth, then fifth; Rabbi Meir's Megillah
The Rav brings the Gemara that Mordechai dropped from fourth to fifth because he was busy saving lives, from which Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater, and asks how that fits with Mordechai. He then brings the Gemara that Rabbi Meir wrote a whole Megillah from memory and asks how this was allowed.
-
12:25 Seeing the Torah inside creation
The Rav explains that the world was created through the Torah and a higher person sees its inner Torah, and tells of a tzaddik who saw in a ceiling only letters and holy names. With the Midrash that Rabbi Meir's Torah read 'garments of light', he explains that Rabbi Meir saw through the 'skin' of creation, so he wrote the Megillah from what he saw in creation.
-
15:44 The eighth king of Edom; prophet and sage
The Rav brings the Zohar on the eight kings of Edom, where the Torah does not say 'and he died' by the eighth king while Divrei Hayamim, written by Ezra, does, and the early sages' remark that Ezra did not grasp that world. To explain, he brings the Gemara about Moshe and Rabbi Akiva and distinguishes between a prophet who sees and a sage who understands.
-
20:10 Ezra's prophecy and Mordechai's inner sight
The Rav explains that Ezra wrote according to his level of prophecy, even though in wisdom he grasped more. He describes the Megillah as a wondrous thing that will remain forever, and says that Mordechai, while saving lives, saw the inner Torah of the Megillah, while from Ezra's level it looked like a loss of Torah study.
-
24:09 Each one's portion in Torah; the Sanhedrin's view
The Rav tells how the Arizal told the Beis Yosef that his portion is in halacha, and how the Lechovitcher told a great student not to learn kabbalah because his portion is the plain meaning. So too the minority of the Sanhedrin saw Mordechai's work as a loss of Torah, while the majority saw his greatness; he ends with Mordechai's greatness.
-
33:33 Another speaker's Purim song and blessings (Another speaker)
-
42:28 Another speaker's parable and closing blessings (Another speaker)
-
48:49 Singing and closing announcements (Singing)
The shiur, written up
Mordechai fourth, then fifth; Rabbi Meir's Megillah
The Rav brings the Gemara in Megillah 16b: when the first group went up to Eretz Yisroel, Mordechai was counted fourth among its leaders, yet some twenty years later he is counted fifth, because he had come down in level. From this Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives. The Rav asks how this can be said of Mordechai, when we are Mordechai's chassidim. a
Seeing the Torah inside creation
The Rav explains that the world was created through the Torah, so every part of it is a part of the Torah, and a higher person sees the inner Torah, not the outer shell. He tells of a tzaddik who said before his passing that in a ceiling he saw only letters and holy names.
The eighth king of Edom; prophet and sage
The Rav brings the Zohar, which wonders how the verses of the eight kings of Edom (Bereishis 36:31-39) can hold the whole order of creation. By each king it says 'and he died', but not by the eighth, Hadar, which belongs to a higher world. In Divrei Hayamim (1:43-51), written by Ezra, it does say 'and he died', and the early sages say that Ezra did not grasp that world. e,f,g
Ezra's prophecy and Mordechai's inner sight
So Ezra, the Rav explains, wrote according to his prophecy, which did not reach the world of Hadar, though in wisdom he did grasp it; there is no contradiction. The Megillah, he says, is a wondrous thing that will remain even when other books are nullified.
Mordechai, while going to the gentiles to save Jews, did not stay at the plain story of the Megillah; he saw its inner Torah, so he had no loss of Torah study. From Ezra's level, which saw the outside, it looked like a loss of Torah, and Mordechai fell from his level.
Each one's portion in Torah
Some great members of the Sanhedrin, the Rav says, had their portion in the plain meaning of Torah. He tells that the Beis Yosef would fall asleep at the Arizal's kabbalah lectures, and the Arizal told him his portion is in halacha. The Lechovitcher likewise told a student, a great gaon, not to learn kabbalah: this is no lack, he is greater than others, it is simply his portion.
This, he explains, is why some of the Sanhedrin separated from Mordechai, as the Gemara says, and from them Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater. The majority saw that while saving lives Mordechai was engaged in the inner Torah. The rule is true, yet Mordechai did not fall; the Rav ends with the greatness of Mordechai. b,j
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Key points
- 8:40 From Mordechai being counted fourth and later fifth, Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives.
- 12:25 The world was created through the Torah, so every part of creation is a part of the Torah, and a higher person sees that inner Torah rather than the outer shell.
- 14:42 Rabbi Meir could look through the 'skin' covering creation and see the Torah in it, which is how he could write a Megillah without a written copy.
- 18:52 A prophet sees with his eyes, while a sage understands with wisdom; one can grasp a matter with wisdom without having reached it in prophecy.
- 23:17 While Mordechai worked to save lives he saw the inner Torah of the Megillah's events, so for him it was no loss of Torah study.
- 24:19 Some of the Sanhedrin, whose portion in Torah was its plain meaning, saw it as a loss of Torah study and separated from him, while the majority saw his greatness.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 9:20 If Mordechai dropped in rank because of his work saving lives, how can that fit with Mordechai's greatness?
Answer: 23:21 While saving lives Mordechai saw the inner Torah of the events, so he had no loss of Torah; only the minority of the Sanhedrin, whose portion was the plain meaning, saw it as a loss.
-
Question: 10:43 How could Rabbi Meir write a Megillah without looking at a written copy?
Answer: 15:13 He saw the Megillah in creation itself, so he wrote from what he saw.
-
Question: 18:26 How can Rabbi Akiva understand more than Moshe Rabbeinu?
Answer: 19:50 Moshe knew it too; Rabbi Akiva's grasp is spoken of as wisdom, Moshe's as prophetic sight.
-
Question: 17:26 How can the early sages say that Ezra did not grasp the world of the eighth king?
Answer: 20:33 In wisdom he grasped it, but he wrote according to his prophecy, which did not reach it.
Stories
-
13:10 The tzaddik who saw letters in the ceiling
The Rav relates that a tzaddik said before his passing that when he looks at a ceiling he does not see the ceiling. He sees only the letters, the holy names and the inner part, the words through which Hashem created the world.
-
24:23 The Beis Yosef and the Arizal
The Rav relates that the Beis Yosef wanted to learn kabbalah from the Arizal, but at the Arizal's lectures he would fall asleep. The Arizal told him that this is not his portion in the Torah; his place is to be great in halacha.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), the Arizal
-
24:45 The Lechovitcher's student
The Rav relates that the Lechovitcher had a student who was a great gaon and served as rav of a town. The Lechovitcher told him not to learn kabbalah, because his portion in Torah is its plain meaning; this is no lack, and he is greater than others, it is simply his portion. The student listened to him.
In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch
Insights
- 15:13 Rabbi Meir did not write the Megillah from memory in the ordinary sense: he saw the Megillah written in creation itself, so he was copying from what he saw.
- 14:42 The 'skin' (or) covering creation is what hides its inner Torah; Rabbi Meir saw through it, and that is why his Torah read 'or' with an aleph, light.
- 19:50 Ezra's writing 'and he died' by the eighth king reflects his level of prophecy, not his wisdom; in wisdom he could grasp more than he saw in prophecy, as Rabbi Akiva could expound what Moshe saw.
- 27:01 Rav Yosef's rule that Torah study is greater than saving lives is true, yet Mordechai did not fall: those who separated from him judged by their own level, whose portion was the plain meaning of Torah.
- 25:08 Having one's portion only in the plain meaning of Torah is no lack: the Lechovitcher told such a student he was greater than others, it was simply his portion.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Ezra HaSofer, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rav Yosef, the Arizal
Terms ביטול תורה, השגה, כתנות אור, פנימיות