The Kotzker eases out a scoffer

About: the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk) Rebbe Reb Bunim of Peshischa

The tellings differ on whom this happened with.

The story

Retold here from 4 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

Rebbe Reb Bunim's chevra was made of great minds, and a brilliant newcomer arrived. The Kotzker saw that he was not the same inside as outside: he had a streak of scoffing, lacked emunas tzaddikim and mocked the Ba'er Heitev's words on walking without washing the hands. The Kotzker drew close to him and talked with him until he decided on his own to leave. In the end he proved rotten, and the Kotzker was always glad he had saved the chevra. The tellings differ on how he was eased out: in one it is Rebbe Reb Bunim himself who was glad to have drawn the young man away from his chassidim; in others the Kotzker told him that Rebbe Reb Bunim was not as great as he seemed, and he left.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
הקב"ה מדקדק על האדם לפי מדריגתו; סוף זמן תיקון שובבי”ם 3 משפטים תשל"ט (1978–79) Yiddish 1:37
שיר המעלות הבטחים בה' 33 תפילה not known Yiddish 12:47
יהודי היקר בעבודת התפילה 20 שיעורים לבחורים not known Yiddish 1:19
Spiritual Coins are Created by our Desire to Give שקלים 2 שקלים not known English 50:53