“משה אב לנביאים” - the Root of the Yiddishe Mesorah
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 11 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains, from the Rambam, that our emunah in the Torah rests not on Moshe Rabbeinu's miracles but on the whole nation hearing Hashem appoint him at Har Sinai, so that every mitzvah and every other navi is believed only through Moshe Rabbeinu.
Continuing from last week, the Rav reads the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8: Klal Yisroel did not believe in Moshe Rabbeinu because of his signs, since a sign can always leave a doubt that it was a trick; the signs in the midbar were done because they were needed. They believed because at Har Sinai every Jew was a navi and heard Hashem speak to Moshe and appoint him. Therefore a navi who performs wonders to contradict Moshe is not heard, like witnesses who claim it is night when the beis din sees it is day. Listening to any other navi is a mitzvah, like listening to two witnesses, and not proof. The Rav reads a letter in the Igros Moshe on why a tradition seen by a multitude cannot be false. He closes by answering Rashi's question on the first mitzvah, and explains the Ani Maamin that Moshe is the father of all the nevi'im.
Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Moshe Rabbeinu · Matan Torah at Har Sinai
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Not belief through signs listed in the guide
The Rav recalls that our emunah rests on a mesorah the whole nation saw, and reads the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8 that Klal Yisroel did not believe in Moshe Rabbeinu because of his signs. He compares a sign to a magician's trick that still leaves a doubt, and explains that the signs in the midbar were done because they were needed.
-
4:20 All Yidden were nevi'im at Sinai listed in the guide
The Rav explains that at Matan Torah every Jew was a navi and heard Hashem speak to Moshe and appoint him, as the pesukim in Shemos promise. Therefore a navi who performs wonders to refute Moshe Rabbeinu is not heard, like witnesses who say it is night while the beis din sees it is day.
-
10:25 Listening to a navi is like listening to witnesses listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a navi may command a temporary deviation, as Eliyahu offered korbanos on Har Hakarmel, but never avodah zarah. Listening to such a navi is a mitzvah like accepting two witnesses, which is not foolproof, as the case of Navos shows; only Moshe Rabbeinu's nevuah, which the whole nation saw and heard, is certain.
-
15:36 A letter on proving the Torah true listed in the guide
The Rav sums up the Rambam and reads a letter from the Igros Moshe to someone troubled by doubts about the truth of the Torah. The answer is not philosophy but the mesorah of a multitude: a father cannot tell his son he saw something together with 600,000 people if nobody else saw it, and even the nations accept the miracles of Mitzrayim and the midbar.
-
21:49 The first mitzvah and Moshe av lanevi'im listed in the guide
The Rav returns to Rashi's question why the Torah did not begin with HaChodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah, though milah and gid hanasheh came earlier. He answers that those mitzvos are known only because Moshe told us about them, so HaChodesh hazeh is the first mitzvah heard from Moshe, and explains the Ani Maamin that Moshe is the father of all nevi'im before and after him.
The shiur, written up
Not belief through signs
Continuing from last week, the Rav recalls that our emunah rests on a mesorah the whole of Klal Yisroel saw, not on one man's claimed revelations. Beyond instinct and philosophy, he says, there is a mitzvah of emunah, and he turns to the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8: the Jews did not believe fully in Moshe Rabbeinu because of the signs he showed them. a
A sign, the Rav explains, is like a circus trick where a squirrel jumps out of an empty hat; something the eye does not see can leave a small question mark in the heart. Moshe's signs in the midbar were done because they were needed, not as proof.
All Yidden were nevi'im at Sinai
At Matan Torah, the Rav explains, every one of the millions of Jews was a navi. Nobody relayed it to us; the entire nation saw and heard. This is what Hashem told Moshe in Shemos 19:9, that He would come in the cloud so the people would hear Him speak with Moshe and believe in him forever. Already at the burning bush, Hashem promised that they would receive the Torah on that very mountain and see that Moshe was appointed. b,c
Listening to a navi is like listening to witnesses
A navi may command something temporarily, the Rav explains, as Eliyahu offered korbanos on Har Hakarmel when sacrifice outside Yerushalayim was forbidden, but never avodah zarah, as Parashas Re'eh teaches. We obey him because the Torah says to listen to the navi, just as it says to accept two witnesses. d,e,f,h
Witnesses are not foolproof: in the case of Navos under Achav, false witnesses had him put to death. Beis din questions them as the Gemara in Sanhedrin describes, yet it remains a mitzvah, not certainty. So too a navi of proven righteousness. Moshe's nevuah alone is foolproof, since our own eyes saw and ears heard, as Devarim 4:32 asks whether any nation ever heard Hashem's voice. g,i,j
A letter on proving the Torah true
The Rav then reads a letter in the Igros Moshe to someone whose yetzer hara kept asking how he knows the Torah is true. The answer avoids philosophy: a mesorah given to a multitude who saw with their eyes cannot be false. k
A father cannot tell his son he saw something with 600,000 people; the son would ask others and find nobody knew. Millions saw Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah, received the same Torah, and nobody objected. Even the nations accept the miracles of Mitzrayim, Yam Suf and the Jordan, so everything written is verified.
The first mitzvah and Moshe av lanevi'im
Sources
Torah
- b Shemos 19:9 text index In the write-up: 4:30
- c Shemos 3:12 text index In the write-up: 4:30
- e apparently Devarim ch. 13 (Parashas Re'eh) index In the write-up: 10:44
- f Devarim 18:15 text index In the write-up: 10:44
- h Devarim 19:15 text index In the write-up: 10:44
- j Devarim 4:32-33 text index In the write-up: 12:10
- m Shemos 12:2 text index In the write-up: 22:04
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 2:05 According to the Rambam, Klal Yisroel's belief in Moshe Rabbeinu was not based on his signs, because a sign always leaves a small doubt that it was a trick.
- 4:30 At Har Sinai every Jew was a navi and heard Hashem speak to Moshe and appoint him to give the rest of the Torah; this is the basis of believing in him.
- 7:47 A navi who shows wonders in order to contradict Moshe Rabbeinu's nevuah is not listened to, just as two witnesses who say it is night are not believed when the beis din sees it is day.
- 11:48 Listening to any other navi is a mitzvah under the Torah's conditions, like listening to witnesses, not a certainty; only Moshe Rabbeinu's nevuah is beyond doubt.
- 18:04 A tradition that a multitude saw with their own eyes cannot be false, since a lie about something that hundreds of thousands witnessed would be exposed at once.
- 23:18 Every mitzvah, even milah, and every navi before or after Moshe is accepted only because Moshe Rabbeinu transmitted it, which is why he is called the father of all the nevi'im.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:05 If Klal Yisroel saw Moshe Rabbeinu's signs, why is that not the basis of their emunah in him?
Answer: 2:59 A sign always leaves a doubt that it was a trick; the emunah rests on the whole nation hearing Hashem speak to Moshe at Har Sinai.
-
Question: 7:39 If a navi performs great wonders and says Hashem told him something against Moshe Rabbeinu, why is he not listened to?
Answer: 9:10 Because Moshe's nevuah is as clear to us as daylight, having heard it ourselves, just as witnesses saying it is night are not believed when the beis din sees it is day.
-
Question: 22:04 Rashi asks why the Torah did not begin with HaChodesh hazeh lachem, the first mitzvah; but milah and gid hanasheh were given earlier.
Answer: 23:09 Those earlier mitzvos are known only because Moshe Rabbeinu told us of them, so HaChodesh hazeh is the first mitzvah heard from Moshe himself.
Insights
- 3:10 The Rav explains that Moshe Rabbeinu's miracles in the midbar were not done to prove anything; each was done because it was needed, such as drowning the Mitzrim or the earth swallowing the rebels.
- 8:26 Since every Jew heard Hashem appoint Moshe, the nevuah of Moshe is for us as clear as daylight, so no wonder can compete with it; the question is never who shows bigger miracles.
- 11:48 Obeying any later navi is itself a mitzvah from Moshe Rabbeinu's Torah, like obeying witnesses, and not a matter of being convinced by his miracles.
- 22:52 The Rav answers Rashi's question by explaining that milah and gid hanasheh are known only because Moshe told us of them, so HaChodesh hazeh lachem is the first mitzvah heard from Moshe Rabbeinu.
- 24:41 He reads 'Moshe av lanevi'im' as meaning that even the nevi'im before Moshe, like Avraham and Yaakov, are known through him, and those after him are believed because he commanded us to listen to them.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achav, Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Navos HaYizre'eli, Rashi, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms גיד הנשה, החודש הזה לכם, יציאת מצרים, מסורה, מתן תורה, נבואה, רבונו של עולם