The Uniqueness of the שידוך of יצחק and רבקה שידוכים: Seeing Open השגחה פרטיות, Sublime Origin, Guidance - Meet בקדושה, We Need תפילה
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) חיי שרה no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 55 תש"ס (1999–2000) English 1 hr 3 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that shidduchim are the one place where Hashem lets us glimpse His hidden hashgacha pratis, why an ordinary shidduch needs a 'lie' thrown to the Satan while the holy shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka did not, and why a bochur must guard himself and daven much for his zivug.
The Rav opens with the first Ani Maamin and the Ba'al Shem Tov's falling leaf: every detail is guided by Hashem, but hidden. Shidduchim are the one area where He lets us see it, as the Midrash of Cleopatra shows. He asks why Rabbi Yaakov Emden wrote a jest about the shadchan and falsehood, and answers with the Tzemach Tzedek: a shidduch is so lofty that bringing it down needs some coarseness, a lie, and the shadchan is paid for the lie. That lie is the bone thrown to the Satan, like the se'ir la'azazel and the goat hairs on tefillin. The shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka was so holy it needed no lie, so Eliezer is not named. He urges the bochurim to guard themselves, to daven much, citing Moshe's 515 tefillos, and to say Lulei Hashem. He ends with Besuel, Lavan and Kislev.
Topics: Shidduchim and Chasunah · Hashgacha Pratis · Chayei Sarah and Me'aras HaMachpelah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Hashgacha pratis is everywhere but hidden listed in the guide
The Rav opens with the first Ani Maamin and the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching that how every falling leaf lands is decreed from Above. All this is hidden and looks natural; the one area where Hashem lets us glimpse it is shidduchim.
-
4:10 Cleopatra's challenge: Hashem makes matches listed in the guide
The Rav tells the Midrash of Cleopatra, who asked Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya what Hashem does since creation and failed when she paired a thousand slaves. He explains she thought the world runs by itself like a finished tape recorder, and that in shidduchim Hashem's hand is seen, as every couple has a story of wonders.
-
9:12 Rabbi Yaakov Emden's jest; a shidduch is hidden listed in the guide
The Rav asks why Rabbi Yaakov Emden, who surely shunned leitzanus, wrote a jest about shidduchim into a sefer. He brings Reb Velvel of Brisk that all the efforts are only for the nerves, and the Tzemach Tzedek that a shidduch is a hidden matter which even the malach announcing it does not know, like Shmuel who did not know which son of Yishai to anoint.
-
14:14 Why a shidduch needs a lie; paying the shadchan listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Tzemach Tzedek that bringing so holy a thing down into this world needs some coarseness, so nearly every shidduch involves a lie of the shadchan. He tells of couples without shalom bayis whom a tzaddik told to pay the shadchan, and explains that one pays the shadchan for the lie, since Hashem does everything but will not lie.
-
18:47 Lulei Hashem ezrasa li; the parsha of shidduchim listed in the guide
The Rav returns to Rabbi Yaakov Emden: the shadchan takes money for the lie. A shadchan may cause harm, but Hashem is the true help, as in the passuk 'Lulei Hashem ezrasa li', which Yaakov Avinu said going to Charan and which a sefer says to recite. He notes the minhag to read this parsha of Yitzchak and Rivka's shidduch from a second Sefer Torah for a chassan.
-
22:33 Guidance for bochurim; how shidduchim were made listed in the guide
The Rav tells the bochurim to guard themselves from aveiros in their youth, which make the shidduch harder, and says meeting many times is unnecessary, since the Gemara only requires seeing her. He brings a German Rav on the parsha and Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky's account of his own brief meeting, and contrasts the old way, with fewer divorces, with American culture.
-
27:19 Eliezer's name; throwing a bone to the Satan listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Eliezer's name shows his mission was shidduchim, 'ezri me'im Hashem', and asks why his name is not mentioned in the whole parsha. He begins the answer: a shidduch needs a lie because the Satan must be thrown something, as with the se'ir la'azazel on Yom Kippur and the goat hairs that stick out of the tefillin.
-
33:38 The holy shidduch that needed no lie listed in the guide
The Rav adds the many mitzvos of a meal as another place something is given to the Satan, and says that in a shidduch he is given the sheker, his food. The shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka was Kodesh Kodashim, so no lie was needed; Eliezer told only the truth, acted only as Avraham's messenger, not as a shadchan, and therefore is not named.
-
37:33 A parsha of hashgacha; many tefillos needed listed in the guide
The Rav calls the parsha a parsha of hashgacha pratis, touching in Eliezer's tefillah and thanks, and says one may need many tefillos for a shidduch. He brings Chazal that Moshe Rabbeinu davened 515 tefillos and one more would have brought him into Eretz Yisrael, urges the bochurim to start now saying the kapitel after Shemoneh Esrei as the Bnei Yissaschar says, and to stay pure in thought.
-
43:33 Besuel's poison and Lavan's fear listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi that Besuel poisoned Eliezer's food and a malach switched the dishes, and asks why Eliezer gave gifts to Rivka, her brother and mother but not to Besuel. He answers that Eliezer knew by ruach hakodesh what would happen and avoided any suspicion. He brings Targum Yonasan that Lavan is Bilam, and explains how Eliezer warned Lavan with 'vaHashem hitzliach darki'.
-
51:01 Shabbos Mevarchim Kislev
The Rav closes noting that this Shabbos is Shabbos Mevarchim Kislev, a month of light whose whole span is like a Yom Tov, when the Torah came out strong over the Lavans and Besuels in the days of the Chashmona'im. He calls for adding Torah and mitzvos and ends with a wish for the full light of Moshiach.
The shiur, written up
Hashgacha pratis is everywhere but hidden
The Rav opens with the first Ani Maamin: Hashem made the world and controls every tiny detail, for the many and for the individual. He brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that when a leaf falls, whether it lands face up or down, which way its stem points, who steps on it and when it is swept away, is all decreed from Above. a
Yet all this is hidden; everything looks natural. There is one area, he says, where Hashem lets us take a glimpse: shidduchim.
Cleopatra's challenge
The Rav tells the Midrash of Cleopatra, who asked Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya what Hashem does since He created the world. He answered that Hashem makes matches. She said she could do that too, paired a thousand men slaves with a thousand women, and the next morning they came out with black eyes and bloody noses, until she admitted that only Hashem makes shidduchim. b
He explains her question: as a gentile she believed Hashem made the world and left it, like a tape recorder that runs after its maker is gone. The answer pointed her to the one area where His guidance is seen. Every couple, the Rav tells the bochurim, has a story of how wondrously their shidduch came about, and from there one may infer that Hashem controls everything else.
Rabbi Yaakov Emden's jest; a shidduch is hidden
The Rav raises a difficulty. Leitzanus is among the worst traits, the opposite of simple emunah and temimus, and the Navi warns against it; yet Rabbi Yaakov Emden, who surely shunned it, wrote into a sefer of Torah a line that sounds like a jest about shidduchim. Why? s
Before answering he brings Reb Velvel of Brisk, that the shadchan, the inquiries and the meetings are only for the nerves, since Hashem does it all. He then brings the Tzemach Tzedek that a shidduch is a hidden matter. The Gemara says a heavenly voice announces the match before a child is formed, yet even the malach does not know and keeps trying. So too Shmuel, sent to anoint a son of Yishai, tried each son until Hashem chose David. c,d
Why a shidduch needs a lie
Out of billions of people, Hashem sends each one his match, though one may lose it through aveiros. The Tzemach Tzedek says that bringing so holy a thing down into this world needs some coarseness, so almost every shidduch involves a lie of the shadchan, without which one side would not have agreed. The Rav notes how strictly the Torah tells us to distance ourselves from falsehood, and that no one finds the marriage exactly as he imagined. e
He tells of couples without shalom bayis who came to a tzaddik; he asked whether they had paid the shadchan, and once they paid, peace returned. Why pay at all? Hashem does everything, but He will not say a lie for you; the fee is for the lie.
Lulei Hashem ezrasa li
This answers Rabbi Yaakov Emden: his words were no jest, for the shadchan takes his money for the falsehood. Some shadchanim even threaten to make trouble, but Hashem guards a person, as the passuk says, 'Lulei Hashem ezrasa li', had Hashem not been my help I would have been lost. f
The Midrash says Yaakov Avinu said this kapitel going to Charan for his shidduch, and a sefer advises reciting it after Shemoneh Esrei. The Rav adds the minhag of reading this parsha, the shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka, from a second Sefer Torah for a chassan, since the Torah teaches through it how to make a shidduch. g
Guidance for bochurim
Speaking to young bochurim now, since he cannot know who will tell them later, the Rav warns them to guard themselves from aveiros in their youth, which make it harder for the shidduch to come. Meeting ten or forty times is unnecessary; the Gemara requires seeing her, and one learns little from seeing anyway. i
He mentions a German Rav who writes that this parsha shows how a shidduch is made: the father sends a messenger. Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky told how his own shidduch was made: his mother saw the girl, and when they met in a Rav's house she brought in coffee and cake, he said 'a dank', she answered 'bitte', and that was all. That, the Rav says, is how the Litvaks did it, with far fewer divorces and more shalom bayis than today.
Eliezer's name; a bone for the Satan
Eliezer was the first shadchan. A person's name holds his purpose, as Rabbi Meir knew a person by his name, and Eliezer's greatest accomplishment was Yitzchak's shidduch. His name means 'my help is from Hashem': he came into the world for shidduchim. Why, then, is his name not mentioned once in the whole parsha? j,k
The Rav starts the answer. A shidduch needs a lie because the Satan, the mekatreg, must be thrown something, like a dog at a feast. One may not do so on one's own, only where the Torah says, as with the two goats on Yom Kippur, one for Hashem and one for Azazel. So too with tefillin, the mitzvah of emunah: a few goat hairs stick out of the bayis, his share, like the se'ir la'azazel. l
The holy shidduch that needed no lie
A meal too is full of mitzvos, so something is given to the Satan there. In a shidduch he is given the falsehood, his food. But the shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka was Kodesh Kodashim; the Satan could do nothing there, and no lie was needed to bring it down.
Eliezer told Besuel and Lavan the complete truth. He acted only as Avraham's messenger, not as a shadchan; Hashem made this shidduch alone, and so his name is not mentioned.
A parsha of hashgacha; many tefillos
The whole parsha is one of hashgacha pratis, the Rav says, and so touching, in Eliezer's pleading and thanks, that it sometimes brings him to tears. A shidduch may need tefillah over and over. Tefillah always helps, and the Midrash teaches, 'kavei el Hashem': if it is not answered, strengthen yourself and daven again. m
Chazal say Moshe Rabbeinu davened 515 tefillos, the gematria of 'Va'eschanan'; one more would have brought him into Eretz Yisrael, and Hashem told him to stop, for his burial in the midbar was for the good of that generation. Even such a tzaddik needed 516. So the Rav urges the bochurim to begin now saying the kapitel after Shemoneh Esrei, as the Bnei Yissaschar advises, and to stay pure in thought, for a good shidduch can make or break a person. n,h
Besuel's poison and Lavan's fear
Lavan could not stop the shidduch. Besuel wanted to kill Eliezer and take his money, and put poison in his food; a malach switched the dishes and Besuel died overnight, as Rashi brings. Then the Rav asks: Eliezer gave gifts to Rivka, her brother and her mother, so why nothing to Besuel? o,p
Eliezer, a great man with ruach hakodesh, knew what would happen. Had Besuel eaten anything from him and died, they would have blamed Eliezer, imprisoned him and taken his money. So he gave him nothing.
The next morning they asked him to stay. Lavan, the Rav says, was Bilam, as Targum Yonasan says in Balak and Matos. Seeing the miracles done for this tzaddik, he could not bear Rivka entering such a house. Eliezer warned him, 'vaHashem hitzliach darki': he knew why Besuel died, and Lavan would meet the same end. Lavan took fright, and later sought revenge on Yitzchak's son Yaakov. q,r
Shabbos Mevarchim Kislev
The Rav closes noting that this is Shabbos Mevarchim Kislev, a month of light, the month of Chanukah, which differs from other months with a Yom Tov in that the whole month is festive. Then the Lavans and Besuels fell and the Torah, with the Chashmona'im, came out with a great yeshuah. He calls for adding Torah and mitzvos, and ends with the hope that the light of the Chanukah candles brings the full light of Moshiach.
Sources
Torah
- e apparently Shemos 23:7 index In the write-up: 14:28
- l Vayikra 16:8 text index In the write-up: 29:32
- n apparently Devarim 3:23 index In the write-up: 39:37
- p apparently Bereishis 24:53 index In the write-up: 43:57
- r Bereishis 24:56 text index In the write-up: 48:10
- s apparently Devarim 18:13 index In the write-up: 9:17
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:00 Everything in the world, down to how a falling leaf lands, is guided by Hashem's individual hashgacha, but it is hidden from our eyes.
- 3:49 Shidduchim are the one area where Hashem shows His hand openly, and from there one can infer His control over everything else.
- 15:22 Following the Tzemach Tzedek, a shidduch is so lofty that bringing it into this world requires a lie, and the shadchan is paid for saying it.
- 29:35 The lie is what is thrown to the Satan so he does not spoil a great mitzvah, as with the se'ir la'azazel and the hairs on the tefillin.
- 36:12 The shidduch of Yitzchak and Rivka was so holy that no lie was needed; Eliezer told only the truth.
- 38:56 One may need very many tefillos for a shidduch, as Moshe Rabbeinu needed one more than his 515, so one should keep davening and start early.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:26 What did Cleopatra mean by asking what Hashem does since creation, and why was the answer 'He makes matches'?
Answer: 6:52 She believed He made the world and left it to run by itself, like a finished tape recorder; Rabbi Yehoshua pointed her to shidduchim, where His guidance is plainly seen.
-
Question: 18:23 Why must one pay the shadchan, if Hashem makes the shidduch?
Answer: 18:34 One does not pay him for making the shidduch but for saying the lie, which Hashem does everything except.
-
Question: 10:53 Why would Rabbi Yaakov Emden, who shunned leitzanus, write a jest about the shadchan into a sefer?
Answer: 18:47 It was no jest: the shadchan's fee is truly for the falsehood a shidduch requires.
-
Question: 29:22 Why can an ordinary shidduch not be made without a lie?
Answer: 29:32 Because the Satan, a mekatreg, must be thrown something with every great mitzvah, and falsehood is his food.
-
Question: 28:27 Why is Eliezer's name not mentioned in the whole parsha of the shidduch?
Answer: 36:18 That shidduch was Kodesh Kodashim and needed no lie, so Eliezer acted only as a messenger, not as a shadchan, and Hashem made it.
-
Question: 45:15 Why did Eliezer give gifts to Rivka's brother and mother but not to Besuel?
Answer: 46:33 He knew by ruach hakodesh that Besuel would die from his own poison, and if he had eaten anything from Eliezer he would have been blamed.
Stories
-
4:10 Cleopatra pairs a thousand slaves
Cleopatra used to call Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya to discuss matters, and once asked what Hashem does since He created the world. He answered that He makes matches, and she said she could do that too. She lined up a thousand men and a thousand women slaves facing each other and had each marry the one opposite. The next morning one had a black eye, another a bloody nose, another needed first aid, and she admitted that only Hashem can make shidduchim.
In the story: Cleopatra, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya
-
17:43 Paying the shadchan restores shalom bayis
The Rav says he knows of many cases, some personally, where a couple had no shalom bayis and came to a tzaddik. The tzaddik asked whether they had paid the shadchan; they had not, thinking they could have managed without him. They paid the shadchan and the shalom bayis returned.
-
24:37 Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky's shidduch meeting
Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky told how his shidduch was made: the girl was the daughter of a great Rav, and his mother went to see her and came back with a good report. They arranged to meet in the house of a Rav in a town between the two towns. He sat learning with the Rav, she came in with a tray of coffee and cake, he glanced and said 'a dank', she answered 'bitte' and walked out, and that was all he saw of her.
In the story: Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky
-
43:57 Besuel's poison
Besuel wanted to kill Eliezer and take his money, and put poison into his food. A malach exchanged the dishes and Besuel died overnight from his own poison, as Rashi brings. Eliezer had given gifts to Rivka, her brother and her mother but not to Besuel, so that no one could accuse him of the death.
In the story: Besuel, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Rivka Imeinu, Lavan
Insights
- 8:46 Shidduchim are where Hashem briefly shows Himself as the One who runs the world, and from that open case one may make a hekesh, an inference, to all the hidden ones.
- 6:52 Cleopatra's question 'what does Hashem do since creation' reflects the view that He made the world like a tape recorder that runs without its maker; the answer 'He makes matches' points to the area where that view visibly fails.
- 18:34 Since Hashem makes the shidduch but will not say a lie, the shadchan's fee is payment for the lie he tells, which explains Rabbi Yaakov Emden's seemingly jesting words.
- 31:22 The lie in a shidduch is the Satan's portion, like the se'ir la'azazel and the goat hairs left sticking out of the tefillin: with the greatest mitzvos he is given something so he will not spoil them.
- 28:27 Eliezer's name is absent from the whole parsha of the shidduch because that shidduch needed no lie and no shadchan; Hashem made it, and Eliezer was only Avraham's messenger.
- 46:33 Eliezer withheld gifts from Besuel because he knew by ruach hakodesh that Besuel would die that night, and did not want to be blamed for poisoning him.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 22:53 The Rav tells the bochurim to guard themselves from aveiros in their youth, since these make it harder for the shidduch to come.
- 23:14 The Rav says there is no need to meet many times, since one does not find out much from seeing anyway.
- 39:10 The Rav says one should keep davening when a tefillah is not answered, and not be discouraged.
- 41:44 The Rav urges the bochurim to start already now saying the kapitel 'Lulei Hashem' after Shemoneh Esrei, to accumulate tefillos for the shidduch.
- 42:59 The Rav says to keep clean and pure in thought, and that one who guards this has more help from Hashem in the shidduch.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Besuel, Bilaam, Cleopatra, Dovid HaMelech, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Lavan, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pinchas, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rashi, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky, Rivka Imeinu, the Baal Shem Tov, the Brisker Rav (Rabbi Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik), the Tzemach Tzedek, Yaakov Avinu, Yishai, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה פשוטה, הסתר פנים, השגחה פרטית, זיווג, ליצנות, קודש הקדשים, קטרוג, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, שבת מברכים, שטן, שידוך, שלום בית, שעיר לעזאזל, תמימות