אליעזר's Change from ארור to ברוך The Jewish Instinct of. אמונה

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) חיי שרה no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 55 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 11 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 11 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

From Eliezer's hidden wish that Yitzchak marry his own daughter, the Rav shows how self-interest blinds a person, and explains that a Jew's emunah is an inborn instinct, inherited through the mother, that only sin and rationalization can dull.

The Rav opens with Eliezer's mission to find a wife for Yitzchak and asks, following Rashi, why the word 'ulai' (perhaps) is written without a vav, readable as 'eilai' (to me), only when Eliezer retells the story. He answers that Eliezer, a great tzaddik, hoped Yitzchak would marry his own daughter, but this interest was hidden even from himself; only after Hashem showed him Rivka could he admit it. From here he returns to the question left open last time: if every Jew instinctively believes, why do some not? Besides spiritual sickness, people are blinded by their desires and rationalize, like the wolf and the sour grapes or theorists who invent how the world works rather than read the Creator's book. He distinguishes ta'avah from ga'avah, explains that a Jew's emunah is a feeling inherited from the mother, shown through the Maharal and Hebrew grammar, and closes by warning that philosophy cannot reach G-dliness.

Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Chayei Sarah and Me'aras HaMachpelah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Eliezer's mission and his retelling listed in the guide

    The Rav reviews how Avraham sent Eliezer to Charan for a wife for Yitzchak, how Rivka came out exactly as Eliezer had prayed, and how the Torah repeats the whole story as Eliezer retold it to her family.

  2. 4:54 Ulai without a vav: Eliezer's hidden wish listed in the guide

    Following Rashi and the Sfas Emes, the Rav asks why 'ulai' is written without a vav, readable as 'eilai', only in Eliezer's retelling. He explains that Eliezer, a great tzaddik who hoped his daughter would marry Yitzchak and was rejected as cursed, was blind to his own interest until Hashem showed him Rivka.

  3. 12:50 Why some Jews do not believe listed in the guide

    The Rav returns to last session's question: if every Jew instinctively believes, why are there Jews who do not? Besides a spiritual sickness that dulls the yearning for Hashem, he adds that a person is blinded by his interests, illustrated by the wolf who called the grapes sour.

  4. 16:29 Rationalizing against the Torah listed in the guide

    The Rav shows how a person drawn to forbidden pleasures concludes that the Torah is not good rather than admit his weakness, like the student who blames the lighting or the man who blames the hammer. Although the whole world cries out that there is a Creator, people invent theories to avoid admitting it.

  5. 20:42 The watch, the bugs and the watchmaker's book Story

    The Rav tells the story he once told his fifth-grade class about two newcomers who theorized that bugs chasing cheese drive a watch, until told to read the watchmaker's book. Likewise, instead of theorizing how the world works, one should learn the book written by its Maker, the Chumash, with Rashi, Ramban and the Midrashim.

  6. 25:54 Why they reject the Creator's book listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that people would accept the Chumash if it ended with creation, but it also commands, so like Esav and Yishmael they reject it, a form of denial. This is why people who were not religious all their lives often turn to davening in old age, once their desires are gone.

  7. 30:27 Ta'avah and ga'avah; emunah as instinct listed in the guide

    The Rav distinguishes people driven by ta'avah, who may do teshuvah when old, from those driven by ga'avah, which only grows, and ties this back to ulai and eilai. He then explains that beyond the intellectual proof any gentile can reach, a Jew has an inherited instinct that Hashem is his Father.

  8. 35:43 Three matzos, four cups: emunah from the mother listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Maharal: the three matzos, from grain that brings knowledge, are the three Avos, and the four cups of wine, which stir emotion, are the four Imahos. Since a Jew's emunah is emotion more than intellect, it comes from the mother, which is why Jewishness follows the mother while tribe and inheritance follow the father.

  9. 41:31 Em from emunah: a rule of Hebrew grammar listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Lashon HaKodesh, the language of creation, holds clues to creation: a verb ending in nun drops it as a noun, as shanan gives shen, ganan gives gan and chanan gives chein. So aman, to believe, gives em, mother, while av, father, relates to wanting that comes from knowledge.

  10. 47:33 Believers, children of believers; keeping emunah healthy listed in the guide

    The Rav brings Moshe's worry that the Jews would not believe him and Hashem's answer that they are believers, children of believers, an instinct of the seed. He then explains that keeping the Torah keeps this instinct healthy, while sins sicken it until one is healed through the prescriptions of Torah sages.

  11. 51:49 Torah and mesorah, not philosophy listed in the guide

    The Rav says the inborn emunah must be developed through learning Torah, and that the mesorah from Sinai is absolute proof, to be discussed later. Philosophy was used by great sages of earlier times against the influence of gentile writings in Spain and Arab lands, but it is alien to Torah and dangerous for us, since the mind was formed for this world, not for the abstract.

  12. 57:57 The wrong sense: a sixth sense and insulation listed in the guide

    The Rav compares using the mind to grasp G-d to trying to see a symphony or hear a painting: no sharpening of the wrong sense will help. The sense for G-dliness is ruach hakodesh, which every Jew's neshamah has in potential, but sins insulate the mind from the neshamah like insulation on a wire; a tzaddik feels G-dliness to the degree of his righteousness.

  13. 1:04:21 The masterpiece and the danger of doubt listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Chovos HaLevavos's mashal of a painting and poem that no spilled ink could produce: the world is a masterpiece showing its Maker, though the mind cannot grasp G-dliness itself. He explains why Ein Keloheinu precedes Mi Keloheinu, warns that weighing the possibility of no G-d is a departure from emunah, and closes that we hold to instinct, the evidence of creation and above all the mesorah.

The shiur, written up

Eliezer's mission and his retelling

0:40

The Rav reviews the parsha: Avraham sends Eliezer to his homeland, Charan, to find a wife for Yitzchak, forbidding him to take one from the daughters of Canaan, who descend from Cham. Eliezer asks what to do if the woman will not want to follow him. Rivka then appears exactly as Eliezer had prayed, and the Torah painstakingly repeats the whole story as Eliezer retells it to her family.

Ulai without a vav: Eliezer's hidden wish

5:08

The Rav notes a difference between the two accounts. The first time, 'ulai' (perhaps) is written with a vav (Bereishis 24:5); in the retelling it has none, and Rashi (on Bereishis 24:39) reads it 'eilai', to me: Eliezer had a daughter and hoped to become Avraham's mechutan. Eliezer was no plain person; on 'who ruled over all that was his' (Bereishis 24:2) Chazal say he was master of himself, and he was Avraham's spokesman and teacher. Yet Avraham rejected his daughter, because Eliezer, from Cham, was cursed (Bereishis 9:25-26), and the cursed does not join the blessed. a,b,c,d

8:04

The Sfas Emes asks why this wish appears only in the retelling. The Rav explains that a person's interests can be hidden even from himself and steer him without his admitting it. When Avraham first spoke, Eliezer's 'perhaps she won't follow me' concealed a wish he could not see. Only after he subdued his wishes, prayed for success and saw Hashem send Rivka, with no hope left, could he admit it and say 'eilai'. e

Why some Jews do not believe

13:02

The Rav returns to the question left open last time: if every Jew, as a descendant of Avraham, instinctively believes, why do some not? A partial answer was that emunah can become sick, like a spoiled stomach that loses its appetite. He adds that a person is blinded by his interests, like the wolf who failed for three days to climb into a vineyard and declared the grapes sour rather than admit his weakness.

Rationalizing against the Torah

16:55

The same happens, the Rav says, when the Torah stops a person from forbidden pleasures: rather than admit his weakness, he decides the Torah is no good, just as the failing student blames the lighting and the teacher, and the clumsy builder blames the hammer. Yet the whole universe, its parts all working together, cries out that there is a Creator. So why do people invent theories such as evolution?

The watch, the bugs and the watchmaker's book

20:45

The Rav recalls that some forty years earlier his fifth-grade pupils told him what they had been taught about evolution, and he told them of two intelligent newcomers from Africa who saw a watch for the first time. One theorized that bugs in tubes chase cheese and pull the hands with strings; the other proved it by hearing them stamp. The principal sent them to a watchmaker's book in the library.

24:24

So too, the Rav says, the world's Maker wrote a book, the Chumash, which opens 'Bereishis bara Elokim', and one should learn it with Rashi, Ramban and the Midrashim. n

Why they reject the Creator's book

26:00

People would accept that book, the Rav explains, if it ended with creation, but it goes on to say what to do and not do. Like Esav, who could not accept a Torah forbidding murder, and Yishmael, who could not accept its moral demands, they reject G-d's account and make their own 'bugs and tubes', since accepting it would be like driving with the brakes on. This is denial.

28:31

That is also why people irreligious all their lives start davening in a nursing home: their desires are gone, and with them the negiah, the personal interest, that kept them from believing.

Ta'avah and ga'avah; emunah as instinct

30:37

Not everyone is moved alike, the Rav continues. Ta'avah (lust) and ga'avah (conceit) direct people's lives; those driven by lust may do teshuvah when old, but conceit stays intact and even grows. This is the story of ulai and eilai: under the force of temptation a person cannot see the truth, and once freed he can.

33:39

A Jew's emunah, beyond the intellectual proof for which even gentiles are held accountable, is an inborn feeling inherited from Avraham, the first believer, just as a child knows his father.

Three matzos, four cups: emunah from the mother

35:43

Therefore, the Rav says, emunah comes from the mother. He brings the Maharal on why Pesach night has three matzos and four cups. The Gemara says a child can say 'abba' once he tastes grain (Berachos 40a), so grain gives knowledge, and the three matzos are the three Avos. Wine stirs emotion and subdues intellect, and the four cups are the four Imahos, since women are more emotional. f

38:56

A Jew's emunah is more emotion than intellect, so Jewishness follows the mother, while being a Kohen, the tribe and inheritance follow the father.

Em from emunah: a rule of Hebrew grammar

41:36

The Rav then shows this in Lashon HaKodesh, the language with which, as the Gemara says, Hashem created the world. A verb ending in nun drops it as a noun. Shanan means to learn sharply, as in 'veshinantam' (Devarim 6:7), which the Gemara explains as Torah being sharp in one's mouth (Kiddushin 30a); its noun is shen, a tooth. g,h

44:49

Ganan, to protect, as in Magen Avraham, gives gan, a fenced garden; chanan, to favor, as in the beracha for knowledge, gives chein. So aman, to believe, gives em, mother, while av, father, relates to wanting, the fruit of knowledge. i

Believers, children of believers

47:42

When Moshe feared the Jews would not believe him (Shemos 4:1), Rashi brings the Gemara that they are 'believers, children of believers' (Shabbos 97a), a seed that believes by instinct. This instinct must be kept healthy, the Rav says: as the body needs a proper diet, the soul needs the Torah's ways. One who eats treif or breaks Shabbos sickens his emunah until he takes prescriptions from Torah sages and regains it. j,k

Torah and mesorah, not philosophy

52:02

This inborn emunah, the Rav adds, must be nurtured through learning Torah, and Jews also have a mesorah, received from parents and rabbis back to Sinai, which he will explain another time. Philosophy will not bring us there.

54:02

Great sages of earlier generations could engage in it, writing such books in Spain and Arab lands to offset gentile writings, but it is alien: Tanach, Gemara and Midrash never try to prove G-d by reason. The mind, like every organ, was formed to function in this world; thinking about the end of time or space can drive a person mad.

The wrong sense: a sixth sense and insulation

58:15

Someone who claims to have seen a symphony or listened to a painting is wrong, the Rav says, not because his senses are weak but because he uses the wrong one; using the brain to understand G-d is the same. With five senses we know little of our surroundings, and none of them can perceive G-d.

1:00:59

There is a sixth sense, ruach hakodesh, which every Jew's neshamah has in potential, but sins insulate the mind from the neshamah like insulation on a live wire. Some current still penetrates, so to the degree a person is a tzaddik he feels G-dliness; with more sins the feeling is lost altogether.

The masterpiece and the danger of doubt

1:04:22

The world still shows its Maker. The Rav brings the Chovos HaLevavos's mashal: a masterpiece painting with a masterly poem beneath it cannot come from wind spilling ink onto paper, and whoever says so is rationalizing. The mind sees the products of G-dliness, not G-dliness itself. l

1:06:51

He explains that Ein Keloheinu precedes Mi Keloheinu because the answer must come first. A philosopher who weighs the possibility that there is no G-d departs from emunah at that moment, a risk only the great sages of old could take. He concludes that we rely on instinct, on the masterpiece of creation and above all on the mesorah. m

Sources

Torah

  1. a Bereishis 24:5 text index In the write-up: 5:08
  2. c apparently Bereishis 24:2 index In the write-up: 5:08
  3. d apparently Bereishis 9:25-26 index In the write-up: 5:08
  4. g Devarim 6:7 text index In the write-up: 41:36
  5. j Shemos 4:1 text index In the write-up: 47:42
  6. n Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 24:24

Talmud Bavli

  1. f Berachos 40a text index In the write-up: 35:43
  2. h Kiddushin 30a text index In the write-up: 41:36
  3. k apparently Shabbos 97a index In the write-up: 47:42

Rishonim

  1. b Rashi on Bereishis 24:39 text index In the write-up: 5:08
  2. l Chovos HaLevavos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:04:22

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Sfas Emes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:04

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. i apparently Shemoneh Esrei, berachos Magen Avraham and Atah Chonen index In the write-up: 44:49
  2. m Siddur (Ein Keloheinu) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:06:51

Key points

  1. 9:22 A personal interest can be hidden even from the person himself; Eliezer could only recognize his wish for Yitzchak as a son-in-law after it could no longer come true.
  2. 13:10 Every Jew instinctively believes in Hashem as a descendant of Avraham Avinu; when a Jew does not believe, it is because his emunah is sick or because he is blinded by his own interests.
  3. 26:03 People reject the Torah's account of creation because the Torah also tells them what to do and not do, and accepting it would stand in the way of their pleasures.
  4. 30:00 Those driven by ta'avah often return when age takes their desires away, but those driven by ga'avah do not, since conceit grows with age.
  5. 38:34 A Jew's emunah is more emotion and instinct than intellect, and therefore it comes from the mother, which is why Jewishness follows the mother while tribe and inheritance follow the father.
  6. 49:32 Keeping the Torah keeps one's spiritual organism healthy and the instinctive emunah strong; one who strayed can be healed through the guidance of Torah sages.
  7. 54:37 Philosophy is not the way for us to reach G-dliness: the human mind was not made for it, and weighing both sides of the question of G-d's existence is itself dangerous.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 8:43 Why is 'ulai' written without a vav, readable as 'eilai', only when Eliezer retells the story?

    Answer: 9:22 At first Eliezer's wish for Yitzchak as a son-in-law was hidden even from himself; only once Rivka was found and his hope was gone could he see it.

  2. Question: 13:02 If every Jew instinctively believes in Hashem, why are there Jews who do not believe?

    Answer: 13:42 Their emunah can become sick through wrong spiritual nourishment, and they are blinded by their interests and rationalize.

  3. Question: 28:56 Why do people who were never religious often start davening and learning in old age?

    Answer: 29:10 When they can no longer pursue their desires, the negiah that kept them from accepting G-d is gone, so they start believing.

  4. Question: 35:46 Why are there three matzos but four cups of wine on Pesach night?

    Answer: 36:47 The Maharal explains that matzah, from grain that brings knowledge, stands for the three Avos and intellect, while wine stirs emotion and stands for the four Imahos.

  5. Question: 39:24 Why does Jewishness follow the mother when tribe and inheritance follow the father?

    Answer: 40:51 Because a Jew's emunah is an emotion and instinct rather than intellect, and emotion comes from the mother.

  6. Question: 1:06:43 Why do we say Ein Keloheinu before Mi Keloheinu?

    Answer: 1:06:51 The answer must come before the question, since entertaining the question even for a moment without the answer is apikorsus.

Stories

  1. 15:06 The wolf and the sour grapes

    A wolf saw delicious grapes in a vineyard and tried for three days and three nights to climb the fence, but it was too high. In the end he turned around, declared the grapes sour, and left. The Rav explains that the wolf would not admit his own inability, so he blamed the grapes.

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 20:42 The two newcomers and the watch

    The Rav recounts that about forty years earlier, when he taught fifth grade, pupils told him what they had been taught about evolution, and he told them a story. Two intelligent men newly arrived from Africa saw a watch for the first time and theorized that inside it bugs in tubes chase cheese on splinters and pull the hands with strings; the second proved it by hearing the bugs stamping. The principal told them to verify it in a book written by a watchmaker in the library.

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 8:27 The missing vav in Eliezer's retelling marks the moment his hidden interest surfaced: only once Rivka was certain to marry Yitzchak could he see that 'perhaps' had meant 'to me'.
  2. 24:02 Theories about how the world works are like guessing at a watch's mechanism while the watchmaker's own book lies in the library: the Creator wrote the Chumash.
  3. 42:14 In Lashon HaKodesh a verb ending in nun loses it as a noun, so aman, to believe, becomes em, mother, showing that emunah comes from the mother.
  4. 58:56 Trying to grasp G-d with the mind is like trying to hear a painting: the failure is not weakness of the organ but using the wrong sense altogether.
  5. 1:01:53 Sins act like insulation on a live wire, cutting the mind off from the neshamah's contact with G-d; a tzaddik still feels some of the current, to the degree of his righteousness.
  6. 1:06:51 Ein Keloheinu is said before Mi Keloheinu so that the answer comes before the question, since even a moment of entertaining the question without the answer is a departure from emunah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 24:55 The Rav says that instead of pondering how the world was made, one should learn the Chumash with Rashi, Ramban and the Midrashim.
  2. 49:32 The Rav says a Jew keeps his emunah healthy by keeping the ways of the Torah and not poisoning himself with aveiros.
  3. 50:40 According to the Rav, one whose emunah has been weakened should take 'prescriptions' from Torah sages, who know how to heal the soul.
  4. 52:02 The Rav says emunah should be nurtured through learning Torah, and that those who are not tzaddikim and gedolim should keep away from philosophy.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Cham, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Esav, Leah Imeinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, Sarah Imeinu, Shem, the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, the Sfas Emes, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אמונה, אפיקורס, גאוה, חציצה, לשון הקודש, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מסורה, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, תאוה, תשובה

Report an error on this page