The Differences Between the מסירת נפש of אברהם אבינו by the עקידה and להבדיל Today's Suicide Bomber

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) וירא no. ⁨4⁩ Pocket Guide p. 54 תשס"ה (2004–05) English 44 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 44 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Avraham's mesiras nefesh at the Akeidah differs from the self-sacrifice of nations and of today's suicide bombers, because a Jew's love for Hashem is inborn and intrinsic, shown by the simcha and calm with which Avraham and Yitzchak went.

The Rav opens by explaining that each Shabbos is woven from its sedra and never repeats, and that the events of the parsha recur spiritually: as Hashem visited Avraham after his milah, He visits our sick generation of ikvesa d'Meshicha. He tells how the Belzer Rav had a cheder learn the current sedra so a frozen river would thaw. Shabbos Vayera holds both Rosh Hashanah readings and is a miniature Rosh Hashanah. He then asks what is special about the Akeidah when nations and suicide bombers also give their lives, and answers that Avraham and Yitzchak went with simcha and calm. Through the dispute of Yitzchak and Yishmael over milah, the Rambam on coerced consent, and milah versus tefillin, he shows that a Jew is a Jew from birth. A Jew's love for Hashem is intrinsic, like a parent's love for a child, unlike the indoctrinated devotion of terrorists.

Topics: Mesiras Nefesh · Akeidas Yitzchak · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Every Shabbos is woven from its sedra

    The Rav explains that each Shabbos is made of the fabric of its sedra and never repeats. He counts 600,000 Shabbosos in the world's history, matching the 600,000 souls of Israel and the 600,000 letters of the Torah, and shows how letters are made of smaller letters.

  2. 5:01 Hashem visits our sick generation

    The Rav says the oneg of Shabbos should be joy with Hashem, and that what the sedra tells repeats itself spiritually: as Hashem visited Avraham on the third day after his milah, He visits us this Shabbos. He describes our generation as very sick, with intermarriage, the internet and cell phones, because the Satan fights the approach of Moshiach in ikvesa d'Meshicha.

  3. 9:16 The Belzer Rav and the frozen river Story

    The Rav names the Akeidah as the pinnacle of the parsha and says the tzaddikim taught to live with the parsha. He tells how lumber merchants came to the Belzer Rav when the river stayed frozen, and he traced it to the cheder learning Mikeitz instead of the current sedra; once they switched, the ice melted.

  4. 14:45 Shabbos Vayera as a miniature Rosh Hashanah

    The Rav shows that both Rosh Hashanah readings, the remembering of Sarah and the Akeidah, are in this sedra, so this Shabbos is a small Rosh Hashanah in which one can complete what was lacking. He adds that the shofar comes from the ram of the Akeidah and that the Akeidah is mentioned in Rosh Hashanah prayers and said every morning.

  5. 18:19 What made the Akeidah special: simcha listed in the guide

    The Rav asks what is special about Avraham's readiness to sacrifice Yitzchak, when nations also did such things and soldiers give their lives for a cause. He answers that Avraham went with simcha, walked at Yitzchak's pace, and came home as if nothing special had happened, while suicide bombers are visibly nervous and often give up; he contrasts the toll in Iraq with Hashem's protection in Eretz Yisrael.

  6. 24:52 Yitzchak, Yishmael and the age of milah listed in the guide

    The Rav asks what pride there is in the Akeidah if Yishmael's descendants also give their lives. He brings Rashi on the dispute in which Yishmael boasted of consenting to milah at thirteen and Yitzchak answered he would give all his limbs, and asks why Hashem gave a Jewish boy the greatest mitzvah at eight days, denying him the chance to show devotion.

  7. 29:30 A Jew is born a Jew: milah and tefillin listed in the guide

    The Rav answers that a Jew's milah shows that he is a Jew from birth. He brings the Rambam on how forced consent counts, since every Jew truly wants to do Hashem's will and only the body resists, and the Gemara that calls both milah and tefillin a sign: milah at eight days shows Jewishness without daas, tefillin at bar mitzvah reflects choice, and Yishmael has only that kind of devotion.

  8. 35:57 Intrinsic love versus indoctrination listed in the guide

    The Rav distinguishes love based on reasons from intrinsic love, like a mother's love for her child or a person's love for himself. A Jew's love for Hashem is intrinsic, since every Jew is a part of Hashem and His child, which is why whole communities gave their lives in the Crusades without exception; the Arabs, by contrast, are trained and indoctrinated in camps, like soldiers in an army. The recording ends mid-thought.

The shiur, written up

Every Shabbos is woven from its sedra

0:21

The Rav opens with the principle that each Shabbos is woven from the threads of its sedra and never repeats. Hashem gave 600,000 Shabbosos, some 300,000 in the six thousand years and as many in the seventh millennium, matching the 600,000 souls of Israel and the 600,000 letters of the Torah. Like the Yismach Moshe, he says every Shabbos, like every soul, is unique, with a task no other Shabbos can accomplish. a

Hashem visits our sick generation

5:31

Citing Yeshayahu's call to make Shabbos a delight, the Rav says oneg Shabbos is joy with Hashem, not self-indulgence. What the sedra tells repeats itself spiritually: as Hashem visited Avraham on the third day after his milah, as Rashi explains, He visits us this Shabbos. And we are very sick, with intermarriage and with the internet and cell phones breaking homes, because in ikvesa d'Meshicha the Satan fights to delay Moshiach. b,c

The Belzer Rav and the frozen river

10:03

Calling the Akeidah the pinnacle of the parsha, the Rav recalls that the tzaddikim taught to live with the parsha. Lumber merchants once came to the Belzer Rav in spring: the river was still frozen, and if their logs missed the mills' deadline they would lose everything. He asked what the cheder was learning; it was Mikeitz, a winter sedra read around Chanukah. Once the melamed taught the sedra of the week, a heat wave melted the ice and the logs arrived in time. The sedra, the Rav concludes, conducts the affairs of the week.

Shabbos Vayera as a miniature Rosh Hashanah

15:00

Both Rosh Hashanah readings, Hashem remembering Sarah and the Akeidah, are in this sedra, so this Shabbos is a miniature Rosh Hashanah, and one whose Rosh Hashanah was lacking can complete it now. The shofar itself comes from the ram of the Akeidah, which is recalled on Rosh Hashanah and every morning in davening. d

What made the Akeidah special: simcha

18:22

The Rav then asks what is special about the Akeidah. Nations also offered their children, as the Torah warns in Devarim, and history is full of soldiers who gave their lives for a cause. But do they go with simcha? Suicide bombers are nervous; many are caught or turn themselves in. e

21:12

Avraham, who knew, walked at the pace of Yitzchak, who did not, as the Midrash makes clear; once told, Yitzchak too went with simcha. Afterwards Avraham returned to Be'er Sheva 'together' with the others, as if he had done nothing special. The Rav adds that while bombings kill many daily in Iraq, in Eretz Yisrael Hashem helps and most attempts are intercepted. f,g

Yitzchak, Yishmael and the age of milah

25:01

Yet Yishmael's descendants also give their lives, so what is our pride? The Rav brings Rashi: Yishmael boasted that he consented to milah at thirteen, when he could have protested, while Yitzchak was circumcised at eight days; Yitzchak answered he would give all his limbs. This raises a question. Milah is the greatest mitzvah, as the Shulchan Aruch writes, so why deny a Jewish boy the chance to show devotion? h,i

A Jew is born a Jew

30:04

The answer: a Jew's milah shows that he is born a Jew. The Rambam asks how flogging a man until he says he wants to bring his korban, as the Gemara rules, counts as consent, and answers that every Jew wants Hashem's will; the yetzer hara comes from the body, so the body is flogged until the neshama's true will emerges. j

32:56

The Gemara in Megillah calls both milah and tefillin a sign. Milah at eight days, without daas, shows a Jew remains a Jew even if he converts away; tefillin near bar mitzvah reflects daas and choice, the only devotion Yishmael has. So the sedra opens with Avraham's milah and Hashem's visit, and ends with the Akeidah. k,l

Intrinsic love versus indoctrination

36:08

People have always given their lives for king, nation and ideals. The Rav distinguishes love based on reasons, such as someone's kindness, intelligence or beauty, from intrinsic love, like a mother fighting for her child or a person loving himself. A child is an extension of the parent, so a Harvard professor and a mother in the jungle care for a child alike.

41:11

A Jew loves Hashem this way: every Jew is a part of G-d above, and the Torah calls us Hashem's children. Sin can deaden this love, but inwardly it remains even in the worst sinner. So in the Crusades whole communities gave their lives without exception, while the Arabs must be trained and indoctrinated in camps, like soldiers; the recording ends there. m

Sources

Torah

  1. d Bereishis 21:1 text index In the write-up: 15:00
  2. e apparently Devarim 12:31 index In the write-up: 18:22
  3. g Bereishis 22:19 text index In the write-up: 21:12
  4. l Bereishis 18:1 text index In the write-up: 32:56
  5. m Devarim 14:1 text index In the write-up: 41:11

Nevi'im

  1. b Yeshayahu 58:13 text index In the write-up: 5:31

Talmud Bavli

  1. j Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 30:04
  2. k Megillah 16b text index In the write-up: 32:56

Midrash

  1. f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 21:12

Rishonim

  1. c apparently Rashi on Bereishis 18:1 index In the write-up: 5:31
  2. h apparently Rashi on Bereishis 22:1 index In the write-up: 25:01

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Yismach Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:21
  2. i apparently Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah, beginning of Hilchos Milah index In the write-up: 25:01

Key points

  1. 0:02 Every Shabbos is woven from its sedra, has its own unique task, and never repeats itself.
  2. 14:54 Shabbos Vayera contains the Torah readings of both days of Rosh Hashanah and is therefore a miniature Rosh Hashanah.
  3. 18:22 The uniqueness of the Akeidah was not the readiness to give a son, which nations have also shown, but that Avraham and Yitzchak went with simcha and without any nervousness.
  4. 30:04 A Jew is a Jew from birth, independent of his understanding and choice, which is why milah is done at eight days while tefillin waits for bar mitzvah.
  5. 40:00 A Jew's love for Hashem is an intrinsic love, like a parent's love for a child, because Jews are a part of Hashem and His children.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 18:19 What is special about Avraham's readiness to sacrifice Yitzchak, when nations also did such things and soldiers give their lives for a cause?

    Answer: 19:29 Avraham and Yitzchak went with simcha and calm, walking together at one pace and returning as if nothing special had happened, unlike nervous suicide bombers.

  2. Question: 28:00 Why does Hashem give a Jewish boy the greatest mitzvah, milah, at eight days, depriving him of the chance Yishmael had to show devotion at thirteen?

    Answer: 29:46 Milah shows that a Jew is a Jew from birth, without daas or choice; Yishmael, who is not inwardly a Jew, can only show devotion of the mind, so his milah waits until he has understanding.

  3. Question: 31:02 If a korban requires the owner's will, how can flogging him until he says he wants it count, when that is under duress?

    Answer: 31:20 The Rambam answers that every Jew truly wants to do Hashem's will; the yetzer hara comes from the body, so the body is flogged, and then the neshama's real will comes out.

  4. Question: 33:06 Milah and tefillin are both a sign; why is milah at eight days and tefillin only at bar mitzvah?

    Answer: 33:52 Milah shows that a Jew is a Jew without daas, from birth; tefillin requires daas and expresses a person's own choice.

  5. Question: 37:55 Why does a mother love her child and even give her life for it?

    Answer: 38:51 It is intrinsic love: the child is an extension of the parent, and just as a person loves himself without a reason, a parent loves a child.

Stories

  1. 12:00 The Belzer Rav and the frozen river

    Lumber merchants who floated logs down the river to the mills came to the Belzer Rav in the spring: the river was still frozen and they would lose their fortune if the logs missed the contract's deadline. The Rebbe asked what the children in their town's cheder were learning, and they said Parshas Mikeitz. He told them that is why it is cold, since Mikeitz is a winter sedra read around Chanukah; they should learn the sedra of the week. They had the melamed teach the current sedra, a heat wave came, the ice melted, and the logs arrived in time.

    In the story: the Belzer Rav

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 0:33 The Rav links the 600,000 Shabbosos of the world's history to the 600,000 souls of Israel and the 600,000 letters of the Torah: just as every soul is unique, no Shabbos ever repeats.
  2. 5:57 What the sedra describes happens again spiritually that week: on Shabbos Vayera Hashem visits a sick generation as He visited Avraham on the third day after his milah.
  3. 15:14 Because both Rosh Hashanah readings are in Vayera, this Shabbos carries something of Rosh Hashanah, and one who feels his Rosh Hashanah was lacking can complete it then.
  4. 21:12 The proof of Avraham's simcha is that he walked at the same pace as Yitzchak, who did not know, and that he returned 'together' as if he had done nothing special.
  5. 30:00 Yitzchak's milah at eight days was not a loss of a chance for devotion: it shows that a Jew is a Jew by birth, beyond choice, while Yishmael's devotion is only a matter of the mind, like tefillin.
  6. 31:20 The Rambam's explanation of coerced consent shows that a Jew's true will is always to do Hashem's will; the flogging only subdues the body from which the yetzer hara comes.
  7. 41:28 Mesiras nefesh of whole communities without exception is explained by intrinsic love, which needs no reason, as opposed to devotion that must be trained and indoctrinated.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 5:21 The Rav says the oneg of Shabbos should be joy with Hashem, and the Shabbos itself should 'enjoy' the way it is kept.
  2. 15:39 The Rav says one who feels his Rosh Hashanah was lacking can complete it on Shabbos Vayera.
  3. 10:28 The Rav cites the tzaddikim that one should live with the parsha of the week.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, the Belzer Rav (unspecified), the Rambam, the Yismach Moshe, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אות, בחירה, דעת, חלק אלוק ממעל, מסירות נפש, עונג שבת, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, רבונו של עולם, רוצה אני, רמ"ח אברים

Report an error on this page