ביאור השבח לה' כשאנו אומרים - אלקי אברהם
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וירא no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 4 תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 58 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that saying 'Elokei Avraham' in Shemoneh Esrei is a praise of Hashem because Hashem's chesed was revealed through Avraham, whose mesirus nefesh for chesed, and finally against his own nature at the Akeidah, fills Parshas Vayera.
The Rav opens with Rabbeinu Bachya: the people of Sedom were reincarnations of the generation of the Tower of Bavel, and those of Tzoar, spared by Lot's prayer, came back again as Korach's congregation. From here he speaks of hidden accounts from earlier lives behind terrible decrees, and brings the Chasam Sofer on Yirmiyahu and Chanamel's field: Yirmiyahu was a reincarnation of Shlomo HaMelech, yet Hashem, 'G-d of all flesh', does not punish the new body. The Rav asks how tikkun then works, and distinguishes the soul's repair from the body's suffering. He then turns to his main theme: the first bracha of Shemoneh Esrei praises Hashem as 'Elokei Avraham' because Avraham revealed Hashem's chesed, with mesirus nefesh, even toward idolaters and the cruel people of Sedom. He brings the Lubliner Rav, Onkelos, the Bnei Yissaschar and the Ran on Yishmael's expulsion and the Akeidah, and ends that every Jew carries a piece of Avraham and Yitzchak.
Topics: Avraham Avinu · Tzedakah, Chesed and Hachnasas Orchim · Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos · Shemoneh Esrei
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sedom, the Tower generation and Korach
The Rav continues with Rabbeinu Bachya on the sedra and brings his teaching that the people of Sedom were reincarnations of the generation of the Tower of Bavel, who came again as Korach's congregation. Using the Targum on the kings in Lech Lecha, he explains that Tzoar, spared by Lot's prayer, still needed its punishment later.
-
6:32 Hidden accounts behind terrible decrees
Applying this, the Rav addresses those who ask why righteous Jews and their children perished in the Holocaust and in earlier decrees, saying Hashem has accounts we do not know that will become clear when Moshiach comes. He cites sefarim that the victims of the gezeiros of Tach were the zealots of the Second Temple who opposed Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai.
-
9:41 Yirmiyahu buys Chanamel's field
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer on the haftarah of Yirmiyahu chapter 32: just before the churban Hashem had Yirmiyahu buy his cousin Chanamel's field as a sign that fields would again be bought in Eretz Yisroel. He explains Chanamel's own plan: by selling to a tzaddik in a sale of the land now and the produce later, he hoped to keep a share that the conquerors could not take.
-
15:59 Yirmiyahu as Shlomo's reincarnation
Continuing the Chasam Sofer, the Rav explains that Yirmiyahu was a reincarnation of Shlomo HaMelech, whose marriage to Pharaoh's daughter on the night of the Temple's dedication brought the decree of churban, so Yirmiyahu feared Chanamel's security was false. Hashem's reply, 'I am Hashem, G-d of all flesh', means the new body did not sin and is not punished.
-
20:59 Tikkun of the soul and the luz bone
The Rav asks: if the new body is innocent, what is the point of returning for tikkun? He answers that an old blemish must still be repaired, but a tzaddik's body does not suffer for it, and after teshuvah one is a new person. He adds that the luz bone did not benefit from Adam's sin, and connects it to melave malka and to the tzaddikim mentioned on motzaei Shabbos.
-
26:20 Why 'Elokei Avraham' is a praise listed in the guide
The Rav says the parshiyos of the Avos must be toiled over like a Tosafos, because the first bracha of Shemoneh Esrei, 'Elokei Avraham', is a praise and even serves as its malchus. Hashem is a Rav Chesed, and this was revealed through Avraham, who hated idolatry with a depth beyond our five chapters of Avodah Zarah, yet served idol-worshipping Arabs three days after his milah.
-
32:02 The cruelty of Sedom and Avraham's prayer listed in the guide
The Rav tells Chazal's account of the girl in Sedom who secretly fed a poor man and was smeared with honey and killed by bees, and explains Sedom's outlook that the poor are parasites to be wiped out. Avraham nevertheless prayed for them, even speaking sharply toward Heaven, and this mesirus nefesh for chesed shows how great is Hashem's chesed, the praise in 'Elokei Avraham'.
-
38:15 Lot's descendants, the angels and Onkelos listed in the guide
The Rav notes that Ammon and Moav, though from Lot of Avraham's family, kept Sedom's point of no chesed, and brings the Ramban that Sedom was judged because it was in Eretz Yisroel. He brings that the three angels came from milah, priah and metzitzah, then the Lubliner Rav on 'when Elokim made me wander from my father's house': Avraham spoke to Sarah of Hashem's chesed in saving him from idolatry, which Onkelos, himself a convert, understood.
-
45:31 Chesed beyond nature and Sarah's laughter listed in the guide
On 'this is your kindness', the Rav explains that to receive chesed beyond nature one must do chesed with mesirus nefesh, citing the Bnei Yissaschar, and this is how Avraham explained to Avimelech why he asked Sarah to say she was his sister. Sarah was then remembered, and the Rav brings the Midrash that many barren women and prayers were answered with her, though not everyone recognized it was in her merit.
-
50:09 Yishmael's expulsion and the Akeidah: against his nature listed in the guide
The Rav notes that both Rosh Hashanah readings come from this parsha, which speaks of answered prayers. He then explains that sending Yishmael away early in the morning was, like the Akeidah, a test against Avraham's nature of chesed, and brings the Bnei Yissaschar that at the Akeidah Yitzchak took on love while Avraham took on Yitzchak's gevurah.
-
54:27 The Ran on the Akeidah and a piece of Avraham listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Derashos HaRan that the Akeidah was only a request, as Rashi reads 'na', so the test was to act against chesed when it was only a measure of piety. He closes that every Jew carries a piece of Avraham and Yitzchak, can awaken mesirus nefesh in small struggles, and must toil in this sedra to say 'Elokei Avraham' properly.
The shiur, written up
Sedom, the Tower generation and Korach
The Rav continues learning Rabbeinu Bachya on the sedra, noting that the Chasam Sofer learned it every Shabbos and always found new things in it. Rabbeinu Bachya teaches that the souls of the generation of the Tower, who said 'let us make ourselves a name', were reincarnated in the people of Sedom to repair that sin. They failed, and came down again as Korach's congregation, the 'men of name', who were swallowed by the earth together with their children. a,b,c,e
Hidden accounts behind terrible decrees
From here the Rav turns to those who ask why such precious Jews, and their innocent children, perished in the Holocaust in Europe. He answers that Hashem has accounts we do not know, all of them mercy and kindness, and when Moshiach comes everything will become clear. He cites sefarim that those killed in the gezeiros of Tach were the zealots of the Second Temple who fought Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai's view of surrendering to Rome.
Yirmiyahu buys Chanamel's field
To clarify this further, the Rav brings the Chasam Sofer on the haftarah from Yirmiyahu. Just before the churban, while Yirmiyahu was prophesying exile, Hashem told him that his cousin Chanamel ben Shalum would come to sell him his field, and he should buy it as a sign that fields would again be bought in Eretz Yisroel. h,i,j
Chanamel, the Rav explains, had his own plan. He believed Yirmiyahu's prophecy that all Jewish fields would be seized, so he sold the land now and its produce after his death to Yirmiyahu, a tzaddik whose portion would not be taken, hoping thereby to keep a share for himself.
Yirmiyahu as Shlomo's reincarnation
The Chasam Sofer continues: Yirmiyahu was a reincarnation of Shlomo HaMelech, who married Pharaoh's daughter on the night of the Temple's dedication, and from that day the churban was decreed. Yirmiyahu therefore wondered how Chanamel could secure himself through him, the very cause of the churban; this is the meaning of his prayer about the sins of fathers paid out to their children. h,n,k
Tikkun of the soul and the luz bone
The Rav finds this wonderful but asks: if the new body is innocent, why must it suffer, and what is the point of a soul returning for tikkun? He answers that an old blemish must still be repaired, but a tzaddik's body does not suffer for it. After teshuvah, as the Rambam says, one is a new person, and the earlier account has no bearing on now. p
Why 'Elokei Avraham' is a praise
The Rav now comes to the main point. The parshiyos of the Avos must be toiled over like a Tosafos, because all year we say 'Elokei Avraham' in Shemoneh Esrei. Simply translating 'the G-d of Avraham' is not the intent: the first brachos are praise of Hashem, and 'Elokei Avraham' even serves as the malchus of the bracha.
The cruelty of Sedom and Avraham's prayer
Next Avraham risks himself praying for Sedom, people opposed to chesed who would have lynched him. The Rav tells Chazal's account behind 'the outcry that has come to Me': a girl who secretly brought bread to a starving poor man was smeared with honey and stung to death by bees. Sedom held that the poor are parasites to be wiped out, and whoever feeds them is himself fed to the bees. t,u
Hearing of Sedom's overthrow, the Rav says, we would have rejoiced; Avraham prayed for them, even speaking sharply, 'far be it from You', something only tzaddikim may do, as the Gemara relates of Levi. This mesirus nefesh for chesed shows how great is the chesed of Hashem who created Avraham, the praise in 'Elokei Avraham'. v,w
Lot's descendants, the angels and Onkelos
Lot came from Avraham's family of chesed, but his daughters' descendants, Ammon and Moav, though holding sparks of Moshiach, kept Sedom's point and did not greet Israel with bread and water. The Ramban says Sedom was judged so severely because it was in Eretz Yisroel. The Rav also brings that the three angels came from milah, priah and metzitzah: to overturn Sedom, to announce Sarah's child, and to heal Avraham. y,z
On 'when Elokim made me wander from my father's house', the Lubliner Rav says Avraham would encourage Sarah by recalling Hashem's kindness: in Nimrod's time Hashem saved him from becoming an idolater like his father Terach. Onkelos, himself a convert, understood this, and his translation reflects his own experience. aa,ac
Chesed beyond nature and Sarah's laughter
Avraham continued, 'this is your kindness': to merit chesed beyond nature one must do chesed with mesirus nefesh. The Bnei Yissaschar writes that one who needs a salvation beyond nature should do a mitzvah beyond nature, and so Avraham told Avimelech he had asked Sarah to do such a chesed so they would merit a child. aa,ad
Yishmael's expulsion and the Akeidah
The Ran on the Akeidah and a piece of Avraham
The Derashos HaRan says Avraham was not obligated: Rashi reads 'na' as a request. So the test was acting against his chesed when it was only piety. al,am,an
Every Jew carries a piece of Avraham and Yitzchak. In each small struggle he can awaken their mesirus nefesh, after toiling in this sedra to say 'Elokei Avraham'.
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 11:4 text index In the write-up: 1:08
- c apparently Bamidbar 16:2 index In the write-up: 1:08
- d apparently Bamidbar 16:14 4:13 index
- e apparently Bamidbar 16:27 index In the write-up: 1:08
- f Bereishis 14:2 text index In the write-up: 5:20
- r apparently Bereishis 28:19 index In the write-up: 24:36
- u apparently Bereishis 18:21 index In the write-up: 32:16
- v Bereishis 18:25 text index In the write-up: 35:48
- x apparently Bereishis 18:30 37:31 index
- y apparently Devarim 23:5 index In the write-up: 38:32
- aa apparently Bereishis 20:13 index In the write-up: 42:11, 45:35
- ae Bereishis 21:1 text index In the write-up: 48:49
- af Bereishis 21:6 text index In the write-up: 48:49
- ah Bereishis 21:12 text index In the write-up: 50:10
- ai Bereishis 21:14 text index In the write-up: 50:10
- ak Bereishis 22:7 text index In the write-up: 53:15
- am apparently Bereishis 22:1-2 index In the write-up: 54:27
Nevi'im
- i Yirmiyahu 32:7 text index In the write-up: 9:47
- j apparently Yirmiyahu 32:14-15 index In the write-up: 9:47
- k apparently Yirmiyahu 32:17-19 index In the write-up: 16:02
- l Yirmiyahu 32:25 12:47 text index
- m Yirmiyahu 32:27 text index In the write-up: 20:29
- n apparently Yirmiyahu 32:31 index In the write-up: 16:02
- o apparently Yechezkel 18:22 23:00 index
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- ag Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 48:49
Rishonim
- a Rabbeinu Bachya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:08
- p Rambam, Hilchos Teshuvah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:07
- q Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:36
- z Ramban (place not identified) index In the write-up: 38:32
- ab apparently Rashi on Bereishis 20:13 42:33 index
- al Derashos HaRan (place not identified) index In the write-up: 54:27
- an apparently Rashi on Bereishis 22:2 index In the write-up: 54:27
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:49 According to Rabbeinu Bachya, the people of Sedom were the generation of the Tower of Bavel reincarnated, and the people of Tzoar, who escaped through Lot's prayer, returned as Korach's congregation to complete their tikkun.
- 16:48 The Chasam Sofer explains that Yirmiyahu was a reincarnation of Shlomo HaMelech, and Hashem's answer 'I am Hashem, G-d of all flesh' teaches that the new body, which did not sin, is not punished for the soul's earlier sin.
- 27:51 The praise in 'Elokei Avraham' is that Hashem's attribute of chesed was revealed in the world through Avraham, so a person can only say it properly after toiling in the parshiyos of the Avos.
- 31:28 Avraham's chesed was mesirus nefesh: he served idol-worshipping Arabs three days after his milah and prayed for Sedom, people who despised chesed and opposed him.
- 45:38 To merit chesed beyond nature one must do chesed with mesirus nefesh beyond nature, which is how Avraham explained his request of Sarah, and soon afterward Sarah was remembered.
- 52:36 Sending away Yishmael and the Akeidah were tests that required Avraham, the man of chesed, to act against his own nature, and according to the Ran the Akeidah was only a request, not a command.
- 56:07 Every Jew has a piece of Avraham and of Yitzchak, and in each small struggle with his will he can awaken that point of mesirus nefesh.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:46 If Tzoar too was under the decree with the other cities of Sedom, why was it spared then?
Answer: 6:02 Tzoar was spared through Lot's prayer, so its people did not receive their punishment then and needed a greater one later, when they returned as Korach's congregation and were swallowed by the earth.
-
Question: 13:03 Why did Chanamel want to sell his field to Yirmiyahu just as Yerushalayim was being handed over to the Kasdim?
Answer: 14:14 Knowing exile was coming and Jewish fields would be lost, he hoped that selling to a tzaddik, whose lot would not be taken, would keep him a share in the field.
-
Question: 17:15 How could Chanamel rely on Yirmiyahu, when Yirmiyahu, as Shlomo HaMelech's reincarnation, was himself the cause of the churban?
Answer: 20:29 Hashem answers 'I am Hashem, G-d of all flesh': He is G-d of the body as well, and Yirmiyahu's new body did not sin, so it is not punished for the soul's earlier sin.
-
Question: 21:07 If the new body is innocent, why should Yirmiyahu suffer at all, and what is the purpose of a soul returning for tikkun?
Answer: 21:48 The old blemish of the soul must still be repaired, but the body of a tzaddik who did not sin does not suffer for it; losing the field is not a punishment for Shlomo's sin.
-
Question: 27:29 What praise of Hashem is there in calling Him 'Elokei Avraham'?
Answer: 29:31 Hashem is a Rav Chesed, and this was revealed through Avraham, who drew the attribute of chesed into the world with mesirus nefesh; how great then is the chesed of the One who created Avraham.
-
Question: 54:27 If, as the Ran says, Hashem did not command the Akeidah but only requested it, what was the test?
Answer: 55:16 The test was whether Avraham, the man of chesed, would be ready to do an act of cruelty against his own nature when it was not an obligation but only a measure of piety.
Stories
-
33:13 The girl of Sedom who fed a poor man
The Rav relates from Chazal that a girl in Sedom secretly gave food to a poor man whom the townspeople had decreed should starve. Each day when she went to draw water she took along a piece of bread for him. She was caught, taken up to a roof, smeared with honey and bound, and the bees came and stung her to death. The Rav explains that this was Sedom's outlook: whoever wants to feed the 'parasites' will himself be fed to the bees.
Insights
- 1:55 The Rav links three generations as one group of souls: the builders of the Tower who wanted 'a name' became Sedom, and the survivors of Tzoar became Korach's 'anshei shem', each return carrying the unpaid account of the last.
- 20:29 Through the Chasam Sofer, 'G-d of all flesh' is read as G-d of the body and not only of the soul: a reincarnated soul's sin is not a reason to make the new, innocent body suffer.
- 21:48 The Rav distinguishes repairing a blemish from being punished for it: a tzaddik or baal teshuvah may still need to mend an old pegam, yet he is a new person before Hashem and his body does not suffer for the old sin.
- 28:12 'Elokei Avraham' is itself the malchus of the first bracha of Shemoneh Esrei, which does not say 'Melech ha'olam', because Hashem's kingship is shown by His having a tzaddik like Avraham in the world.
- 31:21 Avraham's chesed was mesirus nefesh precisely because it went to those he had most reason to reject: he, who understood better than anyone how to despise idolatry, served idolaters, and he prayed for Sedom, who would have lynched him.
- 44:34 Following the Lubliner Rav, Onkelos's rendering of Avraham's words to Sarah came from his own life: as a convert he felt, as Avraham did, the chesed of being taken out of idolatry.
- 52:36 The Akeidah and Yishmael's expulsion are one test: Avraham, the embodiment of chesed, had to act with gevurah against his own nature, and according to the Ran he did so when it was only a request, not a command.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 26:29 The Rav says one must toil in the parshiyos of the Avos as one toils over a Tosafos, so as to know whom one means when saying 'Elokei Avraham' all year.
- 56:39 The Rav says that in each small struggle to give up a desire for Hashem's sake, a Jew should remind himself that he is a piece of Avraham and Yitzchak and awaken in himself a little mesirus nefesh.
- 46:27 Citing the Bnei Yissaschar, the Rav says one who needs a salvation beyond nature should do a mitzvah beyond nature.
- 7:13 The Rav says we cannot demand accounts from Hashem for terrible decrees; His reckonings are hidden from us and will become clear when Moshiach comes.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avimelech, Avraham Avinu, Chanamel ben Shalum, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Korach, Lot, Nimrod, Onkelos, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Meir Shapiro (the Lubliner Rav), Sarah Imeinu, Shlomo HaMelech, Terach, the Chasam Sofer, the Ramban, the Ran, Yaakov Avinu, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms גלגול, דור הפלגה, הכנסת אורחים, לוז, מדת חסידות, מלוה מלכה, מסירות נפש, עקידה, פגם, תיקון