The Depth of the Perfection of the משפטי התורה
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) משפטים no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 58 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 22 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains, through the Zohar's teaching that Parshas Mishpatim holds the secret of gilgul, that every judgment of Hashem and of a Torah court is perfectly just, even when we cannot see the whole picture.
The Rav opens with the laws of the Jewish servant and the Zohar's statement that the parsha holds the secret of gilgul: souls return to complete the mitzvos they left undone. A Baal Shem Tov story of a debtor reborn as a horse illustrates it. He explains why the Torah begins with the eved ivri: theft, which the Chiddushei HaRim sees in every sin, drops a Jew back to before the Exodus, yet Hashem never rejects him; the seventh year, like Shabbos, the inner point that cannot be extinguished, frees him for nothing. The amah ivriah shows Hashem searching for ways to redeem. A second Baal Shem Tov story shows that a seemingly unjust event settles an old wrong judgment. The world is conducted by the psak of Torah courts, as Reb Chaim Ozer's advice shows. Like those who blamed Mordechai or Yaakov, we do not see the whole picture; until Moshiach we hold on to emunah.
Topics: Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos · Mishpatim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The laws of the Jewish servant listed in the guide
Tying the parsha to the end of Shovavim, the Rav goes through the opening pesukim on the Jewish servant: sold for theft, freed after six years, the gentile maidservant, and the ear piercing. He notes that the Rashbam reads 'forever' literally, unlike the Gemara, which says until Yovel.
-
6:44 The Zohar: the secret of gilgul
The Rav brings the Zohar that the parsha holds the secret of gilgul, and explains that souls come down again to complete the 613 mitzvos in thought, speech and deed. One who could not do a mitzvah need not return if he learned about it; only his own negligence brings him back.
-
13:14 The Baal Shem Tov and the special horse Story
The Rav tells the Baal Shem Tov's story, brought by the Chofetz Chaim in Ahavas Chesed, of a horse that was the gilgul of a dead debtor; when the Baal Shem Tov received and tore up the IOU, the horse dropped dead and the soul went up to Gan Eden.
-
19:09 Why the Torah opens with the eved ivri listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the first laws after Matan Torah concern something as rare as a Jewish servant, and answers that the whole parsha is about the repair of souls. He explains that eating with a brachah repairs souls in food, brings the Chasam Sofer on the ox that killed a man, and shows how low the servant has fallen, since he may marry a gentile maidservant.
-
27:30 Theft: the root of every sin
The Rav brings the Chiddushei HaRim that the Torah places the parsha of teshuvah and vidui by theft because every sin steals the faculties Hashem gave for His service. The thief sold as a servant falls back to the state of the Jews before the Exodus.
-
32:11 Shabbos, the point that cannot be extinguished listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem never rejects anyone and gave the Jews Shabbos: the dimensionless point inside the six sides, the spark in every Jew that brings him back. The seventh year frees the servant 'for nothing', a pardon like the torn IOU in the Baal Shem Tov story.
-
40:36 The amah ivriah and Hashem's ways of redemption listed in the guide
The Rav turns to the Jewish maidservant, who can be redeemed in many ways and goes out at twelve even before the seventh year, as a symbol of Hashem searching for ways to redeem every soul. All suffering serves a tikkun, and when the time of the geulah comes Jews will go out free even if their tikkun is incomplete.
-
46:12 The talmid on the mountain Story
The Rav tells how the Baal Shem Tov sent a talmid who asked about the Zohar to watch silently from a mountain: a rider loses his wallet, a second man takes it, and the rider beats an innocent pauper. The Baal Shem Tov explains that this settled a wrong verdict given by a careless dayan some sixty years earlier.
-
53:08 Never say the dayan was wrong listed in the guide
From the story the Rav concludes that what seems unfair has a hidden reason, and brings the Chofetz Chaim's warning not to claim a dayan judged wrongly, since Hashem stands with honest dayanim. He adds what he heard from a great tzaddik: before Moshiach, old accounts were settled in the generation of the Holocaust.
-
59:14 Six million and the courts that run the world listed in the guide
The Rav suggests that the six million correspond to the 600,000 letters of the Sefer Torah multiplied by ten, the completeness of Klal Yisrael. He brings 'mishpetei Hashem emes', explaining that the judgments look unjust only when seen separately, and that the world is conducted by what Jewish dayanim pasken.
-
1:03:55 Reb Chaim Ozer and the lung illness Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells of a man with a hopeless lung illness who came to Reb Chaim Ozer Grodzinski in Vilna. Since that condition in an animal is disputed between the Beis Yosef and the Rema, Reb Chaim Ozer told him to move to Eretz Yisrael, where the Beis Yosef is followed, and he lived.
-
1:08:56 Jewish courts and the courts above listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi that disputes belong before Jewish dayanim, not gentile courts, and the Chasam Sofer that each Jewish court has a court of holy malachim above it while a gentile court corresponds to the seventy heavenly princes. One who goes to a gentile court without permission is judged by those malachim.
-
1:14:11 We do not see the whole picture listed in the guide
Approaching Adar, the Rav notes that Jews blamed Mordechai, and some blamed Yaakov for sending Yosef, because they did not see the whole story; so too those who blame the gedolim who told Jews not to go to America. Only when Moshiach comes will all be understood; until then one must hold on to emunah.
The shiur, written up
The laws of the Jewish servant
The Rav notes that this parsha closes the six weeks of Shovavim, when one should find the corrections Hashem wants of a person; since the whole parsha cannot be covered, he dwells on its opening. A thief who cannot repay is sold as a servant, serves six years and goes out free for nothing, whether or not the debt is paid. If he is married, his master supports his family, and his master may give him a gentile maidservant, whose children remain slaves.
The Zohar: the secret of gilgul
The Rav brings the Zohar that the opening words of the parsha hold the secret of gilgul. A person's history is longer than his years: what he does not complete in one lifetime, he comes down again to finish. Each of the 248 limbs and 365 sinews corresponds to a mitzvah, and at techiyas hameisim a person will have only the limbs with which he did mitzvos. d
Each mitzvah must be fulfilled in thought, speech and deed. One who cannot do a mitzvah, such as pidyon haben when his firstborn is a daughter, need not return if he learned about it; only his own negligence brings him back. Since Shovavim is a time of teshuvah, its last week reads the parsha of the repair of souls.
The Baal Shem Tov and the special horse
The Rav tells a story of the Baal Shem Tov that the Chofetz Chaim brings in Ahavas Chesed. A wealthy host refused to give him a horse that worked like ten, but did give him the IOU of a debtor who had died. The Baal Shem Tov tore it up, and moments later the horse dropped dead. e
He explained that the debtor could not enter Gan Eden while he owed money, and had come back as the horse to work off his debt. Pitying him, the Baal Shem Tov had asked for the horse; once he forgave the debt, the soul flew up to where it belongs.
Why the Torah opens with the eved ivri
The Rav asks why the first laws after Matan Torah deal with the Jewish servant, when far more common matters exist. Following the Zohar, he answers that the whole parsha speaks of the repair of souls, each given a chance to come down and complete what it left undone. d
Even food may contain souls, and eating meat with a brachah said with kavanah repairs the soul in the animal. So the ox that kills a person is stoned and its flesh may not be eaten: the Chasam Sofer explains that it held a soul sent down to repair a past gilgul that wasted its chance, and losing a Jew's brachah over it is the second part of its punishment. f
The servant, the Rav adds, has fallen so low that he may marry a gentile maidservant, something terrible for any other Jew.
Theft: the root of every sin
The Rav sees theft as the root of it all. The Torah places the parsha of teshuvah and vidui by one who stole, and the Chiddushei HaRim explains that every sin is theft, since one uses the life and strengths Hashem gave for His service for oneself. The thief who cannot repay and is sold falls back to the state of the Jews before the Exodus, as if they had never become a nation. g,h
Shabbos, the point that cannot be extinguished
Hashem, the Rav says, never rejects anyone, and creates ways to rehabilitate even this Jew. For this He gave Shabbos, in whatever form it comes, including the seventh year. In every Jew there is a point that cannot be extinguished; a point has no dimension, like the yud of a Yid. Every object has six sides, and the seventh is the point within them that occupies no space: that is Shabbos, meaning return.
However a person damaged himself in six days, the seventh brings him back to the point. The spark may be covered with dirt, but like a pilot light it remains, and uncovering it will be his salvation. Since the pasuk ties Shabbos to the Exodus, the servant who fell back to before the Exodus is released by the seventh year. i
He goes out 'chinam' though he has not repaid: an amnesty, like the IOU the Baal Shem Tov tore.
The amah ivriah and Hashem's ways of redemption
Next comes the Jewish maidservant. The Torah wants her master to marry her and so redeem her, and gives other ways of redemption, discussed at length in the Gemara in Kiddushin; she even goes free on reaching twelve, before the seventh year. The Rav sees here how Hashem searches for new ways to bring every soul to its redemption. j,k
All suffering, of individuals or nations, serves a tikkun, and when everything reaches completion the geulah comes. If Hashem wishes to redeem before the tikkun is complete, the Jews will go out free by a gift of pardon.
The talmid on the mountain
A talmid asked the Baal Shem Tov about the Zohar on Mishpatim, and was told to hide on a mountain, watch and not react. A rider napped under a tree and rode off without his wallet; a second man found it and took it; then a pauper sat down to eat dry bread. The rider returned and beat the pauper unconscious, finding nothing, while the talmid kept silent.
The Baal Shem Tov explained that some sixty or seventy years earlier a careless dayan had wrongly awarded disputed money. The rider was the one who received it, the finder the one it was taken from, and the pauper was the dayan, receiving his punishment.
Never say the dayan was wrong
The Baal Shem Tov concluded that what seems unfair has reasons in a past we do not know. The Chofetz Chaim warns not to leave a din Torah saying the dayan erred, for Hashem stands with honest dayanim. A lender without witnesses who loses his case may be settling an old account from a previous gilgul or between his forebears.
The Rav adds what he heard from a great tzaddik: being just before Moshiach, many old accounts were gathered into the generation of the Holocaust, and those souls, cleansed, will merit to see Moshiach.
Six million and the courts that run the world
The Rav offers a thought: Klal Yisrael is complete at 600,000, like the letters of the Sefer Torah, and in kedushah everything is multiplied by ten, giving six million, so those who perished represented the whole nation. 'Mishpetei Hashem emes' teaches that judgments look faulty only when seen separately. The world stands on din, and what Jewish dayanim pasken is how Hashem conducts it. l
Reb Chaim Ozer and the lung illness
A man whose doctor gave him no hope over a lung condition came to Reb Chaim Ozer Grodzinski in Vilna. An animal with such a defect is treif and cannot live twelve months. Reb Chaim Ozer asked for the exact diagnosis and told him to move to Eretz Yisrael: this condition is disputed between the Beis Yosef and the Rema, and there the Beis Yosef, who holds it kosher, is followed. He moved and lived, showing that the world follows the Torah's psak.
Jewish courts and the courts above
Rashi explains 'before them' as excluding gentile courts, and going to them is a chillul Hashem. The Chasam Sofer explains that above every Jewish court sits a court of holy malachim judging alike, while gentile courts correspond to the seventy heavenly princes who channel bounty to the nations. One who goes to a gentile court without the dayanim's permission puts himself in the hands of the Satan's malachim, who will judge him on Rosh Hashanah and after death. m
We do not see the whole picture
As Adar approaches, the Rav recalls the Gemara that the Jews blamed Mordechai for refusing to bow to Haman; they did not see what the end of the Megillah reveals. Some blamed Yaakov Avinu for sending Yosef to his brothers, not knowing the descent to Mitzrayim was needed; without Yosef, the Gemara says, Yaakov would have been dragged there in iron chains. n,o
So too people blame the gedolim who warned against going to America. The Rav says being killed as a Jew is the greatest tikkun for a soul, but declines to explain more, since we do not see the whole picture, and a qualified gadol's advice is as if from heaven. When Moshiach comes all will say 'mishpetei Hashem emes'; until then one holds on to emunah. l
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 6:56 Following the Zohar, the Rav teaches that Parshas Mishpatim contains the secret of gilgul, and that the whole parsha speaks about the repair of souls.
- 9:14 Every person must complete all 613 mitzvos, corresponding to his limbs and sinews, in thought, speech and deed; what he leaves undone through his own fault brings him back in another gilgul.
- 32:18 Hashem never rejects a Jew: the eved ivri goes out in the seventh year and the amah ivriah even earlier, showing that Hashem creates ways for every soul to be redeemed.
- 52:27 Events that look unjust, even a verdict of an honest dayan, may be settling accounts from earlier gilgulim that we do not know.
- 1:02:31 The world is conducted according to the Torah and the psak of the Jewish dayanim, which is mirrored by the courts above.
- 1:15:29 People who blamed Mordechai, Yaakov Avinu or the gedolim did not see the whole picture; only when Moshiach comes will everyone understand, and until then one holds on to emunah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 20:00 Why does the Torah begin the laws given right after Matan Torah with the Jewish servant, something rare in everyday life?
Answer: 20:55 Because, as the Zohar says, the parsha holds the secret of gilgul: it speaks of the repair of souls who come down again to complete what they left undone.
-
Question: 11:16 Must a person who could not do a mitzvah, such as pidyon haben when his firstborn is a daughter, come back in a gilgul for it?
Answer: 11:27 No. If he learned the mitzvah with thought and speech he need not return; only if he failed to do it through his own negligence.
-
Question: 23:16 Why may the flesh of an ox that killed a person not be eaten?
Answer: 23:50 The Chasam Sofer explains that it is part of its punishment: the soul in it wasted its gilgul and is denied the tikkun of a Jew's brachah over it.
-
Question: 39:00 Why does the servant go free in the seventh year if he has not yet repaid his theft?
Answer: 38:55 The seventh year is a form of Shabbos, which brings a Jew back; he goes out 'chinam', with a pardon, like a debtor whose IOU is torn.
-
Question: 1:14:23 Why did the Jews blame Mordechai, and others blame Yaakov for sending Yosef?
Answer: 1:15:29 Because they saw only part of the story; at the end of the Megillah, and with the whole Torah, it is clear that it was for the good of the Jews.
Stories
-
14:12 The Baal Shem Tov and the horse
The Baal Shem Tov visited a wealthy man who showed him a horse that worked as much as ten horses, and asked for it as a gift; the man refused. He then asked to see the man's loan documents and asked for one IOU whose debtor had died; the man gave it, and the Baal Shem Tov tore it up. Moments later the horse dropped dead. The Baal Shem Tov explained that the debtor could not enter Gan Eden owing money and came back as the horse to work off his debt; once the debt was forgiven, his soul went up to Gan Eden.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
47:05 The talmid who watched from the mountain
A talmid asked the Baal Shem Tov about the Zohar on Mishpatim, and was told to hide on a mountain and watch without reacting. He saw a rider nap under a tree and lose his wallet, a second man find it and take it, and a pauper sit down to eat his dry bread; the rider returned and beat the pauper until he fell unconscious, but found nothing. The Baal Shem Tov explained that some sixty or seventy years earlier a careless dayan had awarded money wrongly: the rider had received it wrongly, the finder was the one it had been taken from, and the pauper was the dayan receiving his punishment.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
1:04:19 Reb Chaim Ozer's advice to the sick man
A man whose doctor found a lung condition and gave him no hope came to Reb Chaim Ozer in Vilna for a brachah. Reb Chaim Ozer asked for the exact details of the condition, and then told him to move to Eretz Yisrael. He explained that in an animal this condition is disputed between the Beis Yosef and the Rema; in Europe the Rema is followed and it is treif, while in Eretz Yisrael the Beis Yosef is followed and it is kosher. The man moved, and he lived.
In the story: Reb Chaim Ozer Grodzinski
Insights
- 23:50 According to the Chasam Sofer, the ox that killed is a soul that came down to be repaired and failed; the ban on eating its flesh is the second part of its punishment, for it loses the tikkun of a Jew making a brachah over it.
- 28:52 The Chiddushei HaRim explains that every sin is also theft from Hashem, since one uses the life and strengths given to serve Him for himself; this is why the Torah places teshuvah and vidui by the thief.
- 31:50 The Rav explains that the thief sold as a servant returns to the state of Klal Yisrael before the Exodus, so his release in the seventh year matches the pasuk that Shabbos is a remembrance of leaving Mitzrayim.
- 34:09 Shabbos is the dimensionless point, like the yud of a Yid, that sits inside the six sides of every object; it can be covered but never extinguished, like a pilot light, and it brings a Jew back.
- 39:12 The word 'chinam' means amnesty: the servant who has not repaid his theft is pardoned like a debtor whose IOU is torn, just as the Baal Shem Tov tore the document.
- 59:55 The Rav suggests that the six million correspond to the 600,000 letters of the Torah multiplied by ten, the number of completeness in kedushah, so that they represented the whole of Klal Yisrael.
- 1:07:58 The psak of the Torah governs nature itself: Reb Chaim Ozer told a man whose lung condition is treif according to the Rema but kosher according to the Beis Yosef to move to Eretz Yisrael, where the Beis Yosef is followed, and he lived.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 11:30 The Rav says that one who cannot do a mitzvah in deed should at least learn about it, using his mind and mouth for it.
- 54:02 Following the Chofetz Chaim, the Rav says one should not leave a din Torah saying the dayan judged wrongly, since one does not know the whole story.
- 1:20:07 The Rav says a believer must regard the advice of a qualified gadol as coming from heaven, even when it does not seem to turn out well.
- 1:21:18 When events seem unjust, the Rav says one must hold on to emunah until the time comes when everything will be understood.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Chaim Ozer Grodzinski, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rashi, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Chofetz Chaim, the Rashbam, the Rema, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms גלגול, יובל, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, נקודה, עבד עברי, רבונו של עולם, שובבים, תיקון