The Depth of the כיבוד אב of יוסף and our Connection to the אבות
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) ויחי no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשל"ז (1976–77) English 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Yosef asked for his own bones to be carried to Eretz Yisrael as a hiddur in honoring his father, since a son's bones are an extension of his father, and from there that Yaakov Avinu never died because every Jew carries a part of him.
On Shabbos Chazak of Vayechi the Rav asks a series of questions on Yosef's answer to Yaakov. Instead of simply promising to bury his father in Eretz Yisrael, Yosef seems to speak of himself, then makes his brothers rather than his sons swear to carry his bones, imposes this on them as well, and speaks of his 'bones' although a tzaddik's body does not decay, as the Rav illustrates with accounts of tzaddikim found intact. He answers with the Gemara that a person's bones come from his father: Yosef's bones are Yaakov's extension, so carrying them completes Yaakov's burial, a task for Yaakov's sons. He then brings the Gemara that Yaakov Avinu did not die: in the drush of Torah he lives in every Jewish heart. This ties to Melave Malka, where Yaakov's past and David HaMelech's future meet, and to teshuvah: since Yaakov lives on, no Jew is ever too late.
Topics: Kibud Av VaEm · Vayechi and the Shevatim · The Passing of a Tzaddik
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shabbos Chazak and Yaakov's last request listed in the guide
The Rav opens with the strength to be drawn from Shabbos Chazak and from Yaakov Avinu. He then reads Yaakov's request not to be buried in Mitzrayim, and Yosef's reply 'I will do as you say', which the Daas Zekeinim reads as Yosef promising that he too will be carried to Eretz Yisrael.
-
4:18 Questions on Yosef's reply and his bones listed in the guide
The Rav asks why Yosef, at his father's last will, seems to turn to himself; why he made his brothers rather than his sons swear to carry his bones, imposing on them what is only a chumrah; and why he was punished with being called 'bones' in his lifetime and what insult there is in speaking of one's own bones.
-
10:00 A tzaddik's body does not decay
The Rav brings the Gemara in Bava Metzia and accounts of tzaddikim, the Rebbe Reb Elimelech of Lizhensk and others, whose bodies were found intact, and the grain Yosef stored that did not rot, and a Stoliner signature that stayed black. He concludes with the question: Yosef knew his whole body would remain, so why did he speak only of his bones?
-
16:07 Bones from the father: Yosef's hiddur listed in the guide
The Rav answers all the questions with the Gemara that a person's bones come from his father. Yosef's bones are Yaakov's extension, so by having them carried to Eretz Yisrael Yosef was not thinking of himself but adding a hiddur to his father's burial, and he said 'my bones' to make clear he meant the mitzvah.
-
20:01 Why the brothers, and all of them listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a father's burial is the sons' obligation more than the grandsons', so Yosef gave the completion of Yaakov's burial to Yaakov's sons, his brothers. Since all the brothers' bones also belong to Yaakov, Rashi's 'with you' shows they too were carried up, so that nothing of Yaakov would remain in Mitzrayim.
-
23:29 Yaakov Avinu did not die listed in the guide
The Rav explains the trace of life, kusta d'chayusa, that remains in a body after death, which is why one davens at a tzaddik's kever, and tells of the Yismach Moshe at the kever of the Rebbe Reb Elimelech. He then brings the Gemara that Yaakov Avinu did not die, and explains that beyond his kever Yaakov left a trace of himself in every living Jew.
-
28:20 Pshat, drush and the Avos in every Jew listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Torah has pshat and drush, the Torah she'b'al peh that comes from the Jewish heart; in pshat Yaakov was buried, in drush he lives in every Jewish heart. Avraham gave love, Yitzchak fear, and Yaakov the Jewish neshama itself, so every child of Yaakov is a Jew, and while Jewish children live, Yaakov lives.
-
32:47 Melave Malka: Yaakov the past, David the future listed in the guide
The Rav explains that at Melave Malka, the meal for the luz bone, Jews sing 'Al tira avdi Yaakov' and speak of those who never died. Yaakov is the past from which Jews draw and David HaMelech the future they are heading toward; this is why the parsha of Yaakov's passing is called Vayechi.
-
38:07 Shabbos does not die either listed in the guide
The Rav brings a proof from the Melave Malka meal, held after Shabbos for Shabbos: just as Yaakov did not die, Shabbos does not go away. Every Jew should be proud that Yaakov is in him as a father, and he explains why the seforim say Melave Malka reaches higher than the other meals of Shabbos.
-
41:31 Into the week and golus with Yaakov; never too late
The Rav says the Jews carry Yaakov's fresh brachos into the weekdays and into the golus of Shemos without fear. Since a Jew never dies, no Jew can say it is too late; the weeks of teshuvah that begin after Chazak are a time to return to the source of the neshama.
The shiur, written up
Shabbos Chazak and Yaakov's last request
On Shabbos Chazak, the Rav says, one must draw strength from the parsha and from Yaakov Avinu. He reads Yaakov's request in Bereishis 47:29 not to stay in Mitzrayim even temporarily, and Yosef's reply in 47:30, 'I will do as you say'. The Daas Zekeinim explains that Yosef meant he too would see to it that he is carried to Eretz Yisrael. a,c,d
Questions on Yosef's reply and his bones
At first sight, the Rav says, this is a lack of plain manners: at his father's last will Yosef forgets his father and thinks of himself. More questions follow. Yosef made his brothers swear to bring up his bones (Bereishis 50:25), and Rashi on Shemos 13:19 says all the brothers were brought up with him. Why the brothers and not his own sons, and why impose on them what is only a chumrah? e,f,g
A tzaddik's body does not decay
The Rav brings the Gemara in Bava Metzia about a body that stayed intact for years, and says the body of a tzaddik who guarded kedushah does not decay. He knew a Jew from Skver, one of ten Jews the Nazis forced to open the kever of the Rebbe Reb Elimelech, who was found in perfect condition close to two hundred years after his passing. Even the grain Yosef stored did not rot, and a signature of Rabbi Yisroel of Stolin stayed black on a letter that turned brown. So Yosef knew his whole body would remain; why speak only of bones? i
Bones from the father
All these questions, the Rav says, are answered by the Gemara in Niddah: the bones come from the father, the flesh from the mother, and the neshama from Hashem. A son's bones are one step removed from his father's body. Yosef meant: not only you, but your extension in me will be carried up. He said 'my bones' to show that he meant the mitzvah, a hiddur in his father's burial. j
Why the brothers, and all of them
The Gemara says a person is obligated more in his father's burial than his grandfather's, so Yosef gave the completion of Yaakov's burial to Yaakov's sons, his brothers. And since their bones also belong to Yaakov, they too were brought up, as Rashi explains, so that nothing of Yaakov would remain in Mitzrayim. g,k
Yaakov Avinu did not die
After death, the Rav explains, a trace of life, the kusta d'chayusa, stays in the body; that is why one davens at a tzaddik's kever, and from it the body will revive at techiyas hameisim. He tells how the Yismach Moshe, at the kever of the Rebbe Reb Elimelech, offered a perutah to tzedakah for any neshama that would call the Rebbe. Then he brings the Gemara in Taanis that Yaakov Avinu did not die: beyond his kever, Yaakov left a trace of himself in every living Jew. l
Pshat, drush and the Avos in every Jew
To explain, the Rav says Torah has pshat and drush, the Torah she'b'al peh that comes out of the Jewish heart. In pshat Yaakov was buried; in the drush, read in Jewish hearts, he lives. Avraham gave the Jews love and Yitzchak fear, but Yaakov gave the neshama itself, the source from which all Jewish souls are hewn. A child of Avraham can be a goy, like Yishmael, and of Yitzchak, like Esav, but every child of Yaakov is a Jew.
Melave Malka: Yaakov the past, David the future
At Melave Malka, the Rav says, Jews sing 'Al tira avdi Yaakov' (Yirmiyahu 30:10) and speak of those who never died, like David HaMelech and Eliyahu HaNavi. Yaakov is the past the Jews draw from; David, Melech HaMashiach, is the future they head toward, and Chazal say the two share one neshama. Shalosh seudos is Yaakov's meal, taken into the week, and in the dark days of golus hope comes from David. That is why the parsha of Yaakov's passing is called Vayechi. m
Shabbos does not die either
The Rav's proof is the Melave Malka meal itself, eaten for Shabbos after Shabbos has ended: just as Yaakov did not die, Shabbos does not go away. Every Jew should be proud that Yaakov is his father, not a distant ancestor. The seforim say this meal reaches higher, he explains, because after Shabbos Jews lift themselves toward the Shabbos of the days of Moshiach.
Into the week and golus with Yaakov
The Jews carry Yaakov's brachos, read that very morning (Bereishis 49:2), into the weekdays and into golus without fear. Since a Jew never dies, the Rav says, no Jew may say it is too late: that is said only of the dead. The weeks of teshuvah after Chazak are a time to return, better through learning than fasting. p
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- h Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 7:53
Rishonim
Key points
- 16:23 According to the Gemara a person's bones come from his father, so a son's bones are an extension of the father's body.
- 18:06 Yosef's request that his own bones be carried to Eretz Yisrael was not about himself but a hiddur in his father's burial, completing it.
- 20:41 Yosef gave the task to his brothers because burying a father is the sons' obligation more than the grandsons', and all the brothers had to be carried up so that nothing of Yaakov would remain in Mitzrayim.
- 27:32 Yaakov Avinu did not die: besides the trace of life left in his body, he left a part of himself in every living Jew.
- 34:29 At Melave Malka the Jews take Yaakov, their past, into the weekdays, and draw hope from David HaMelech, their future, both of whom never died.
- 43:19 Because Yaakov lives on in every Jew, no Jew can say it is too late for him to return to Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:31 Why does Yosef, when his father gives his last will, seem to turn to himself and speak of being carried to Eretz Yisrael too?
Answer: 18:06 A son's bones come from his father, so carrying Yosef's bones up completes Yaakov's burial; Yosef was adding a hiddur to his father's request.
-
Question: 5:32 Why did Yosef make his brothers, and not his own sons, swear to carry his bones?
Answer: 20:41 The burial of a father is more the sons' obligation than the grandsons'; since Yosef's bones are Yaakov's extension, Yaakov's sons should carry them.
-
Question: 7:10 Why did Yosef impose on his brothers that their bones too be carried up, when that is only a chumrah?
Answer: 21:54 It was not their personal matter: their bones also belong to Yaakov, so to complete the hiddur nothing of Yaakov could stay in Mitzrayim.
-
Question: 15:53 Yosef knew his whole body would remain intact, so why did he speak only of his bones?
Answer: 19:28 By 'my bones' he meant the part of his father in him, to show that he intended the mitzvah of his father's burial.
-
Question: 26:09 How can the Gemara say Yaakov Avinu did not die, when the passuk says he was eulogized and buried?
Answer: 28:00 In pshat he died and was buried, but in the drush of Torah, read in Jewish hearts, Yaakov left himself in every living Jew and lives on.
-
Question: 40:14 Why do the seforim say the Melave Malka meal reaches higher than the Shabbos meals?
Answer: 40:51 On Shabbos, Shabbos comes to the Jew; after Shabbos he lifts himself toward the Shabbos of the days of Moshiach, higher than the Shabbos just past.
Stories
-
10:53 The Rebbe Reb Elimelech found intact
The Rav says he personally knew a Jew who lived in Skver and who saw the Rebbe Reb Elimelech. The Nazis ordered the graves of Lizhensk removed, but whenever they came to the Rebbe's grave something happened and they could not move it, so they had ten Jews do it, and this Jew was one of them. When they opened the grave of the Rebbe Reb Elimelech, who had passed away close to two hundred years earlier, they found his body in perfect condition.
In the story: Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech)
-
14:24 The Stoliner signature that stayed black
The Rav says he has at home a letter written some sixty years earlier by the gabbai of Rabbi Yisroel of Stolin, the Yenuka, and signed by the Rebbe himself. Writing ink turns brown after about thirty years, and indeed the whole letter has turned brown, but the tzaddik's signature is black and fresh as if written today.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Stolin
-
24:45 The Yismach Moshe at the Rebbe Reb Elimelech's kever
The Yismach Moshe once came to daven at the kever of the Rebbe Reb Elimelech. He announced at the cemetery that he would give a perutah to tzedakah for the merit of any neshama that would go tell the Rebbe Reb Elimelech that he had come, in case the Rebbe was not at his kever. The Rav adds that whether or not the neshama was there, a trace of life always remains at the kever.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech)
Insights
- 18:06 Yosef's 'I too will be carried up' was not selfishness at his father's deathbed: since a son's bones come from his father, carrying Yosef's bones was a hiddur in Yaakov's own burial.
- 19:28 Yosef said 'my bones' rather than 'me' precisely to show that he meant his father's part in him and the mitzvah, not his own person.
- 20:41 Yosef commanded his brothers and not his sons because the completion of Yaakov's burial belongs to Yaakov's sons before his grandsons.
- 30:02 'Yaakov Avinu did not die' belongs to the drush of Torah, which is read not in the Sefer Torah but in Jewish hearts, where Yaakov lives on.
- 36:23 The parsha in which Yaakov passes away is called Vayechi, 'and he lived', because Yaakov still lives in every Jew.
- 40:56 Melave Malka reaches higher than the Shabbos meals because after Shabbos the Jew lifts himself toward the Shabbos of the days of Moshiach, the future of David HaMelech.
- 44:36 'Too late' is said only of someone who died; since Yaakov did not die and no part of a Jew dies, no Jew is ever too late for teshuvah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 39:06 The Rav says every Jew should be thrilled and proud to know that he has Yaakov Avinu within himself, as a father and not a distant ancestor.
- 41:59 The Rav says the Jews can go into the weekdays and into golus without fear, knowing that Yaakov Avinu is with them.
- 43:34 The Rav says no Jew may tell himself that he has ruined himself and it is too late; he can always return to Hashem.
- 43:56 For the weeks of teshuvah after Chazak, the Rav says he does not advocate fasting; it is better to sit and learn and do teshuvah through learning.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Rabbi Yisrael of Stolin, Rashi, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Vilna Gaon, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms כיבוד אב, לוז, מהדרין, מלוה מלכה, מערת המכפלה, עצמות, רבונו של עולם, תורה שבעל פה, תחיית המתים, תשובה