נסתמו עיניהם ולבם של ישראל מצרות השעיבוד- ובכל זאת -ויחי יעקב
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע ויחי no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 8 תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1 hr 14 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains why Parshas Vayechi is 'closed', why the end of the galus is hidden, and teaches that in the very closed space stand the words 'Vayechi Yaakov': the emunah of Yaakov lives on in Klal Yisrael even in the darkest night of the galus.
The Rav opens with Rashi's two reasons why Parshas Vayechi is 'closed': the hearts and eyes of Yisrael were closed by the bondage, and Yaakov wished to reveal the end and it was hidden from him. Since the Jews are the Torah, their state shows in the Torah. Yaakov found no ches or tes in the names of the tribes, so knowing the end was no part of their mission. The Rav gives reasons why the end is hidden: it must stay open to 'achishenah', not knowing is part of the galus, and every great good is hidden from the Satan. A long digression on covering drinks, the Gemara of the pilegesh of Givah and the traits of a ger leads to the almanah, a picture of Knesses Yisrael in galus, exposed to the 'snake'. He ends that in the closed space stand the words 'Vayechi Yaakov': Yaakov lives, emunah survives, and those who waited for the redemption will be the most precious.
Topics: Vayechi and the Shevatim · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · Awaiting Moshiach · Simple Emunah, Above Reason
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why Parshas Vayechi is closed listed in the guide
The Rav brings a Midrash through Rabbeinu Bachya that Yaakov's seventeen years in Egypt repaid the seventeen years he raised Yosef, then Rashi's reason that the parsha is closed because the hearts and eyes of Yisrael were closed. Since the Jews are the Torah, their state shows in it; he adds the closed mem of 'lemarbeh hamisrah' and that the parsha speaks of the redemption.
-
4:02 No ches and tes in the names of the tribes listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Yaakov wanted to reveal the end but saw no ches or tes in the names of the tribes. A person's name hints at his mission, so he understood that knowing the end is not the mission of a Jew; one must daven to Hashem like a child to a parent, without calculating the end.
-
8:02 Why the end is hidden listed in the guide
The Rav gives reasons why the end is hidden: a revealed end would be fixed and could not come early, the Maharal says not knowing is part of the galus, and every great good is hidden so that the Satan should not accuse. He shows this in Moshiach's hidden lineage, the covered shofar, matzah and challos, and in kosher wine that a goy's touch spoils.
-
16:12 Covering drinks from the snake
The Rav explains why the Gemara requires covering drinks because of the snake: a Jew is refined and sensitive, and the holier a thing is, the more easily it is spoiled, while a goy is not harmed. He brings the Shelah that the snake is a spiritual force, so a ba'al nefesh is careful even today.
-
20:07 The fly and the hair of the pilegesh
As a digression, the Rav takes up the difficult Gemara about the pilegesh of Givah, where Rabbi Evyasar says a fly was found and Rabbi Yonasan a hair, and both are true, and asks what happened if the husband did not mind the fly. He brings Tosafos that she was a bas yefas toar, and explains that a ger keeps every mitzvah like a Jew but the inherited traits of the seed of the avos, like mercy and modesty, come from yichus.
-
25:35 Is a ger a child of Avraham?
The Rav asks whether a ger receives the traits of the Jewish soul. The Mishnah in Bikkurim says a ger cannot say 'our fathers', while the Yerushalmi says he can, since Avraham is 'father of a multitude of nations', and the Rambam and Shulchan Aruch follow it. He then brings the Gemara that Shmuel would not drink water from a widow's house, who is not careful about uncovered water, but did drink from a goy.
-
31:55 Cleanliness, and the answer about the pilegesh
The Rav notes that goyim are more careful about outward cleanliness, like Esav who shows his 'kosher hooves', though cleanliness is a real path to kedushah. Returning to the Gemara, he answers that the husband did not mind the fly, but the hair showed she lacked the traits of the daughters of Yisrael, so the fly was revealed in hindsight as negligence: both opinions are true.
-
38:15 Why the punishment for Michah's idol waited
The Rav stresses that nothing happens by chance, and brings the Maharal that from the punishment one learns the sin, as with Kamtza and bar Kamtza. The Gemara in Chelek says the tens of thousands fell at Givah because no one protested Michah's idol; the punishment waited until the Jews showed at Givah that they could fight for a person's honor, revealing in hindsight that they could have fought for Hashem's.
-
45:48 Knesses Yisrael as an almanah listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the widow is not careful about uncovered water, since gilui is a real prohibition. He explains that Knesses Yisrael in galus is called an almanah, 'for the man is not at home': in galus the eyes and heart are closed, the yetzer hara grows strong, and the fear of Heaven that came from Yerushalayim is missing.
-
53:28 The longest night of the galus listed in the guide
The Rav describes the end of the galus as the longest night, falling around Parshas Vayechi, darker than even the Chanukah lights can reach. The Jews are exposed to the snake and the end is hidden; he brings the Midrash of Yaakov's ladder, where the present galus seemed to have no end.
-
58:53 In the closed space: 'Vayechi Yaakov' listed in the guide
The Rav teaches that in the space of nine letters that is missing stand the words 'Vayechi Yaakov': Yaakov lives, and so does the emunah he planted. He ties Yaakov to Shabbos and the third Beis HaMikdash, explains why Melaveh Malkah mentions Yaakov, who 'did not die', and tells of the Kotzker and Reb Meir of Apta to show that believing is greater than seeing.
-
1:07:42 The reward of those who waited listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that precisely holding on to emunah in the darkest times can bring Moshiach, and that those who waited will be the most precious when they see Moshiach crowned. For them Hashem has kept the wine no eye has seen; the one thing that saves in these long nights is to hold on to emunah and bitachon.
The shiur, written up
Why Parshas Vayechi is closed
The Rav opens with a Midrash brought by Rabbeinu Bachya: Yaakov lived seventeen years in Egypt to match the seventeen years he sustained Yosef as a child. Yosef was the provider, but every provider was once a receiver, and those years had to be repaid. a
He then brings Rashi's question why the parsha is closed: the eyes and hearts of Yisrael were closed by the bondage. Since the Jews are the Torah itself, whatever happens to them shows in the Torah. Rabbeinu Bachya adds the closed mem of 'lemarbeh hamisrah' in Yeshayahu, said of Moshiach, and the Rav notes that Vayechi too speaks of the redemption, as in 'ad ki yavo Shiloh'. a,b,c,d
No ches and tes in the names of the tribes
Why the end is hidden
The Rav asks why the end is hidden at all. Had Yaakov revealed it in the Torah, it would be fixed, but the end can come early: 'zachu, achishenah'. The Maharal says not knowing the end is itself part of the decree of galus, for an exile whose end is known is no longer galus. h
A further reason: the world is run like a court, 'melech bamishpat ya'amid aretz', where accusers come forward. What is not noticed draws no accuser, which is why tzaddikim hid their ways and why one must not cause an ayin hara; the Zera Kodesh says that speaking against others raises an accuser in Heaven. i,j
So every great good is hidden. Moshiach comes from Lot's daughters and from Rus, so that the Satan should not suspect; the shofar, the matzah and the challos are covered; Daniel says the words are 'closed and sealed until the time of the end'. Kosher wine, used for every kiddush, is so lofty that even a goy's touch spoils it. k
Covering drinks from the snake
The fly and the hair of the pilegesh
As an aside, the Rav takes up a hard Gemara in Gittin. Of the pilegesh of Givah, Rabbi Evyasar says her husband found a fly, Rabbi Yonasan a hair, and Hashem says both are true: the fly he did not mind, the hair he did. But if he did not mind the fly, the Rav asks, what happened at all? o
He brings Tosafos, who asks how she had hair, since the Gemara in Sanhedrin says Jewish daughters had none, and answers that she was a bas yefas toar. A ger has all the laws of a Jew, 'kager ka'ezrach', but traits like mercy pass down from the avos, and the Shulchan Aruch warns against marrying into a cruel family. p,q,r,s
Is a ger a child of Avraham?
Does a ger receive these traits? The Mishnah in Bikkurim says a ger cannot say 'our fathers', since the avos are not his parents. The Yerushalmi says he can, since Avraham is 'father of a multitude of nations'. Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen explains that the avos are truly fathers of every Jew. t,u,v
The Rambam follows the Yerushalmi, and the Shulchan Aruch discusses on this basis whether a ger may be a shliach tzibbur. The Rav then brings the Gemara that Shmuel would not drink water at a widow's house, since she is not careful about uncovered water, yet he drank from a goy, who is careful about cleanliness. w,x,y
Cleanliness, and the answer about the pilegesh
The Rav finds it striking that goyim are more careful about outward cleanliness, like Esav, whom the Midrash compares to a pig showing its kosher hooves. Cleanliness is truly a path to kedushah: a Jewish table must be clean, and outer cleanliness awakens inner purity. Among goyim, though, it is the outside alone. z
Returning to the Gemara: as Tosafos says, the pilegesh was a giyores. A fly in a drink can happen in the best home, and her husband did not mind it. But the hair showed that she lacked the traits of the daughters of Yisrael, so the fly was revealed in hindsight as negligence, and both opinions are true. p
Why the punishment for Michah's idol waited
Nothing happens by itself; all is hashgachah pratis, even the tens of thousands who fell in the war over the pilegesh. The Maharal in Netzach Yisrael teaches that from the punishment one knows the sin: Yerushalayim was destroyed through Kamtza and bar Kamtza because the sin was baseless hatred and lashon hara. The Gemara in Gittin blames the husband's excessive fear. aa,o
The Gemara in Chelek says the real cause was Michah's idol, whose smoke mixed with the mizbe'ach's, and no one protested: for Hashem's honor they did not protest, for a person's honor they did. Why did the punishment wait? Not everyone is a fighter, and quiet people could be judged favorably. Only when they fought at Givah was it revealed that they could have fought for Hashem, like a wife loyal only halfway. ab
Knesses Yisrael as an almanah
Back to Shmuel and the widow: gilui is a real prohibition, and the Rambam says one who is not careful receives lashes. Why then is the widow not careful? According to simple pshat, a widow and orphan are sensitive, but the Rav brings a remez. y,ac
Knesses Yisrael in galus is called an almanah, as in Eichah, 'hayesah k'almanah' and 'imoseinu k'almanos', because 'ki ein ha'ish beveiso'. In galus, as when the Jews went down to Egypt, the eyes and heart are closed, and the yetzer hara grows strong; Rashi at the end of Shelach says the eyes and heart lead to sin. ad,ae,af,ag
The fear of Heaven a Jew should have came from Yerushalayim and the Beis HaMikdash. In galus that fear of 'the husband' is missing. The widow hopes and prepares with mitzvos for his return, but the end is closed.
The longest night of the galus
Near the end of days the trials grow and the galus becomes a long night, 'shomer mah milaylah', getting longer like the nights before Parshas Vayechi, the longest of the year. The Chanukah lights were lit to brighten that darkness, but now it has sunk lower than they reach. This is 'ki ein ha'ish beveiso': the Jews are exposed to the snake and the end is hidden. ah,af
In the closed space: 'Vayechi Yaakov'
Yaakov saw that the tribes' mission was 'tzaddik be'emunaso yichyeh': to hold fast to emunah in these trials. What stands in the missing space of nine letters? Two words: 'Vayechi Yaakov', Yaakov lives. Where the parsha is closed, there one sees that the emunah Yaakov planted lives on. aj
Yaakov stands for Moshiach and Shabbos, 'nachalas Yaakov', and the third Beis HaMikdash is the house of the G-d of Yaakov. As Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen says, one who believes in something is connected to it. On Motzaei Shabbos, when its light is gone, Jews escort it with emunah at Melaveh Malkah, recalling Dovid, Eliyahu and Yaakov, who 'did not die', as Chazal derive from 'v'atah al tira avdi Yaakov': as his seed lives, he lives. ak,al,am
Reb Meir of Apta sent to the Kotzker: you dispute with one who sees the ushpizin in his sukkah? The Kotzker replied that he believes they come, and believing is greater than seeing.
The reward of those who waited
This is what Hashem wants in such a time, and precisely this can bring Moshiach, when it is darkest. Tzaddikim gave dates that passed, yet 'if it tarries, wait for it'. The Midrash says those who waited for Hashem's kingship will be the most precious, as 'v'kivisi lo' though He hid His face, and Daniel's 'ashrei hamechakeh'. an,ao,ap
When Moshiach is crowned, they will say 'this is our G-d, we hoped for Him'. For them Hashem has kept the wine of which 'no eye has seen', untouched by the snake. 'Ki lishuascha kivinu kol hayom' is among the first questions asked at judgment, and in these long nights the one thing that saves is to hold on to emunah and bitachon. aq,l,ar
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
- c Yeshayahu 9:6 text index In the write-up: 1:27
- l Yeshayahu 64:3 text index In the write-up: 1:09:38
- ah Yeshayahu 21:11 text index In the write-up: 53:33
- aj Chavakuk 2:4 text index In the write-up: 59:10
- ak Yeshayahu 58:14 text index In the write-up: 1:00:49
- am Yirmeyahu 30:10 text index In the write-up: 1:00:49
- an Chavakuk 2:3 text index In the write-up: 1:07:42
- ao Yeshayahu 8:17 text index In the write-up: 1:07:42
- aq Yeshayahu 25:9 text index In the write-up: 1:09:38
Kesuvim
- i Mishlei 29:4 text index In the write-up: 10:02
- k Daniel 12:9 text index In the write-up: 12:33
- ad Eichah 5:3 text index In the write-up: 48:40
- ae Eichah 1:1 text index In the write-up: 48:40
- af Mishlei 7:19-20 text index In the write-up: 48:40, 53:33
- ap Daniel 12:12 text index In the write-up: 1:07:42
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- h Sanhedrin 98a text index In the write-up: 8:02
- m Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:31
- o Gittin 6b text index In the write-up: 20:21, 38:18
- q Sanhedrin 21a text index In the write-up: 22:20
- y Gemara Avodah Zarah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 28:29, 45:48
- ab Sanhedrin 103b text index In the write-up: 40:58
- al Taanis 5b text index In the write-up: 1:00:49
- ar apparently Shabbos 31a index In the write-up: 1:09:38
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Rishonim
- a apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Bereishis 47:28 index In the write-up: 0:07, 1:27
- b Rashi on Bereishis 47:28 text index In the write-up: 1:27
- e Rashi on Bereishis 32:30 text index In the write-up: 4:21
- f Rashi on Devarim 18:13 text index In the write-up: 6:36
- g apparently Rambam, Hilchos Melachim 12:2 index In the write-up: 6:36
- p apparently Tosafos on Gittin 6b index In the write-up: 22:20, 35:06
- w apparently Rambam, Hilchos Bikkurim 4:3 index In the write-up: 28:29
- ac apparently Rambam, Hilchos Rotzeach 11:5 index In the write-up: 45:48
- ag apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 15:39 index In the write-up: 48:40
Acharonim and Chassidus
- j Zera Kodesh (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:02
- n Shelah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:44
- s apparently Shulchan Aruch, Even HaEzer 2:2 index In the write-up: 22:20
- x apparently Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 53:19 index In the write-up: 28:29
- aa Netzach Yisrael (place not identified) index In the write-up: 38:18
Key points
- 1:27 Parshas Vayechi is 'closed' because the eyes and hearts of Yisrael were closed by the bondage, and since the Jews are the Torah, their state is mirrored in it.
- 4:24 Yaakov saw no ches or tes in the names of the tribes; knowing the end is not the mission of a Jew, who must daven for the redemption without making calculations.
- 8:17 The end is hidden so that it is not fixed and can come early, because not knowing is part of the galus, and because every great good must be hidden from the Satan.
- 48:40 Knesses Yisrael in galus is called an almanah; like a widow who is not careful about uncovered drinks, in galus the yiras shamayim is weakened and the Jews are exposed to the 'snake'.
- 1:00:05 In the space where the parsha should be open stand the words 'Vayechi Yaakov': the emunah Yaakov planted lives on in Klal Yisrael even when nothing can be seen.
- 1:08:27 The Jews who waited for the redemption through the darkest times will be the most precious, and for them Hashem has prepared the wine kept since creation.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:27 Why is Parshas Vayechi 'closed', without the usual space before it?
Answer: 1:36 Because the eyes and hearts of Yisrael were closed by the bondage, and because Yaakov wished to reveal the end and it was closed to him; yet in that space stand the words 'Vayechi Yaakov'.
-
Question: 8:02 Why is the time of the end hidden?
Answer: 8:17 So that it is not fixed and can come earlier through 'achishenah', because not knowing is part of the galus, and because every great good is hidden from the Satan.
-
Question: 21:30 In the Gemara of the pilegesh, if the husband did not mind the fly, what happened in that case?
Answer: 36:59 The hair revealed that she lacked the traits of Jewish daughters, so the fly was revealed in hindsight as negligence, and both opinions are true.
-
Question: 42:25 If the sin was failing to protest Michah's idol, why did the punishment wait until the pilegesh of Givah?
Answer: 42:49 Not everyone is a fighter, and quiet people could be judged favorably; only when they fought at Givah for a person's honor was it revealed that they could have fought for Hashem's honor.
-
Question: 46:50 Why is a widow not careful about uncovered water, when gilui is a real prohibition?
Answer: 48:40 She is a hint to Knesses Yisrael in galus, called an almanah because 'the man is not at home', and she takes on the traits of that state, lacking the fear of a husband.
-
Question: 1:03:35 Why is Yaakov mentioned in the zemiros of Melaveh Malkah?
Answer: 1:03:47 Yaakov 'did not die': as his descendants live, he lives, and on Motzaei Shabbos, when the light of Shabbos is gone, the Jew escorts it with emunah in Yaakov, who stands for Shabbos and the third Beis HaMikdash.
Stories
-
1:05:04 The Kotzker and Reb Meir of Apta on the ushpizin
The Kotzker had a great dispute with other tzaddikim over his new path. One of them, Reb Meir of Apta, sent a messenger asking whether he dared dispute with someone who sees the seven ushpizin come into his sukkah. The Kotzker answered that he dared, because he believes the ushpizin come into his sukkah, and believing is greater than seeing.
In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe, Reb Meir of Apta
Insights
- 1:53 Because the Jews are the Torah itself, their spiritual state is mirrored in the very layout of the Torah: the closing of their hearts in Egypt shows up as a closed parsha.
- 5:00 Yaakov read in the absence of ches and tes from the tribes' names that knowing the end is not part of a Jew's mission, since each name hints at its bearer's mission.
- 12:42 Covering the shofar until it is blown, the matzah at the Seder and the challos, and the hidden lineage of Moshiach, all follow one rule: the greatest good is hidden so the Satan should not accuse.
- 36:59 The two opinions on the pilegesh of Givah are both true: the husband did not mind the fly, but the hair revealed that she lacked the traits of Jewish daughters, turning the fly in hindsight into negligence.
- 42:25 The punishment for not protesting Michah's idol waited until Givah, because only when the Jews fought for a person's honor did it become clear that they could have fought for Hashem's.
- 48:57 The widow's laxness about uncovered water is a hint to Knesses Yisrael in galus: without 'the fear of the husband' she is exposed to the snake's poison.
- 59:44 The missing space of nine letters before Vayechi is filled by the words 'Vayechi Yaakov': where the closing is, there one finds that Yaakov lives.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 6:41 The Rav says a Jew should daven to Hashem for the redemption like a child relying on his parents, and not make calculations of the end or of his own merits.
- 12:01 The Rav says a Jew should take care not to cause an ayin hara or speak badly of others, since this creates an accuser in Heaven.
- 59:18 The Rav says that in the darkest times of the galus one must hold on to emunah and bitachon and believe Hashem will help, even when no light is felt in learning or davening.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Micha (of the idol), Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Evyasar, Rabbi Meir of Apta (the Ohr LaShamayim), Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), Rabbi Yonasan, Rashi, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אושפיזין, בעתה אחישנה, טבת, יין המשומר, יין נסך, מלוה מלכה, עקבתא דמשיחא, פרשה סתומה, קטרוג, קץ, רחמנים ביישנים וגומלי חסדים