The Kotzker Rebbe and the ushpizin

About: the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk) Rabbi Meir of Apta (the Ohr LaShamayim) the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)

The tellings differ on whom this happened with.

The story

Retold here from 6 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

The Kotzker Rebbe had a new path in serving Hashem that another great tzaddik disagreed with. That tzaddik sent a messenger asking why the Kotzker quarreled with him, since on Sukkos he sees with his own eyes the seven ushpizin coming into his sukkah. One telling names that tzaddik Reb Meir of Apta and another the Apta Rav; the rest leave him unnamed or say only that he was one of the Galician tzaddikim. The Kotzker sent back that on Sukkos he believes with complete faith that the seven ushpizin come into his sukkah, for believing is greater than seeing.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
נסתמו עיניהם ולבם של ישראל מצרות השעיבוד- ובכל זאת -ויחי יעקב 3 ויחי תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1:05:04
טעם על מה שמדליקין במנורה יחידה ולא בנרות נפרדות 5 סעודת זאת חנוכה תשנ"ב (1991–92) Yiddish 57:13
רשב"י מתקן פגם תלמידי ר' עקיבא של "אני אמלוך" 7 סעודת ל"ג בעומר תשנ"ט (1998–99) Yiddish 31:28
מצה - A Food of אמונה and גאולה 1 פסח תשס"א (2000–01) English 20:47
התבוננות בנפלאות הבריאה 7 אמונה א' not known Yiddish 12:50
Miracles Enlighten the Darkness of עוה”ז 9 EMUNAH #1 (English) not known English 25:32