יעקב's Tremendous Accomplishment in Taking the Sheep of לבן
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) ויצא no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשס"ה (2004–05) English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Yaakov's taking of Lavan's sheep was not trickery but the redemption and cleansing of great souls, a forerunner of Yetzias Mitzrayim and of the Jewish people's history in golus.
The Rav opens with bechirah: each person is measured by Hashem according to his own nature, and the hardest test is to act against one's own character. Each of the Avos had his midah, and the Akeidah tested Avraham and Yitzchak against theirs; Yaakov's midah was emes, so his test was to say sheker at Rivka's prophetic command. He then explains why Hashem wanted Yitzchak to bless Yaakov thinking he was Esav. Turning to the sheep, he traces the great souls of the Dor HaMabul through the Dor HaHaflagah, a stage as Lavan's sheep, and Mitzrayim, explaining along the way why Noach was meant to be Moshe. Yaakov extricated these souls from Lavan; his sticks, says the Zohar, were the mitzvah of tefillin, done in secret against the Satan. Vayeitzei is the parsha of golus: Yaakov brought blessing to Lavan, who still claimed everything was his, as Jews have brought blessing to every land of their exile.
Topics: Yaakov, Lavan and the Imahos · Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos · Galus as Preparation for Geulah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Bechirah is measured by each person's nature
The Rav explains that the Torah gives every person bechirah, but Hashem measures each one by what is expected of his own nature: not killing earns nothing for one who cannot kill, and a natural masmid is asked why he did not learn even more.
-
4:29 The midos of the Avos and the Akeidah
The Rav describes Avraham's midah of chesed and Yitzchak's midah of din, and explains that the Akeidah tested each of them against his own midah. Yaakov's midah was emes, so pure that he would rather have died than say sheker.
-
8:15 Why Yaakov had to say sheker listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every creation, even sheker, has a purpose, with a mashal of an artist offended by criticism of his painting. Rivka commanded Yaakov through prophecy to deceive Yitzchak; like Eliyahu at Har HaCarmel, a navi may command a one-time aveirah, and breaking his midah of emes was Yaakov's greatest avodah. He then explains why Hashem wanted Yitzchak to bless Yaakov while thinking he was Esav, and introduces the sheep of this week's parsha.
-
16:59 The Dor HaMabul and Noach who should have been Moshe
The Rav explains that the Dor HaMabul were choice neshamos whom Hashem wanted to give the Torah; since Torah is like water and they refused it, the water came instead, forty days like the forty days of Matan Torah. Through the Zohar he explains the Gemara that finds Moshe in the Torah in the words 'beshagam hu basar': Noach was meant to be Moshe, failed to daven for his generation, and was replanted as Moshe Rabbeinu.
-
24:10 Mei Noach, the Haflagah and Mitzrayim
The Rav explains why the Navi calls the flood 'the waters of Noach' and how Moshe's 'mecheini na' repaired Noach's failure. The same souls returned in the Dor HaHaflagah, were scattered instead of destroyed thanks to their unity, and came back again as the Jews in Mitzrayim, where they were purified.
-
28:08 The souls as Lavan's sheep; the benefit of golus listed in the guide
The Rav adds the stage he left out: between the Haflagah and Mitzrayim these souls were Lavan's sheep, which Yaakov domesticated, and the Midrash hints that he had 600,000 sheep, like the 600,000 who left Mitzrayim. Vayeitzei is a parsha of golus, and the Rav explains that Klal Yisrael accomplishes more in golus, as Torah reached its completion in Bavel.
-
32:03 Gedolim from golus and the sheep remembered listed in the guide
The Rav lists Rabbanim of Yerushalayim and the Beis Yosef as products of golus, then returns to Yaakov extricating the sheep and bringing them to Eretz Yisrael and Mitzrayim. He describes the great souls sent down in the time of the Ba'al Shem Tov and tells of the Yismach Moshe, who remembered being Yaakov's sheep, and of a Rebbe who sang the niggun Yaakov played for his sheep.
-
37:33 Yaakov's sticks were tefillin listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi that angels brought the sheep to Yaakov, and the Zohar's different account of the sticks. With the mashal of breakfast that works without our understanding it, he explains that mitzvos work even when we do not know how. The Avos made the same tikkunim before Matan Torah, and the Zohar says Yaakov's sticks were the mitzvah of tefillin, which recall Yetzias Mitzrayim, since he was redeeming these souls from Lavan.
-
42:53 A hidden battle with the Satan listed in the guide
The Rav stresses that Yaakov did not trick Lavan; it was a battle of kedushah against tumah, as the Zohar shows in explaining why Esav never pursued Yaakov to Charan. Such a battle must be fought in secret so the Satan does not catch on, which is why the Torah presents it as a trick. He then calls Vayeitzei a parsha of deep golus and gives Lavan's complaint that Yaakov takes everything.
-
46:31 Yaakov's blessing to Lavan and the story of golus listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Yaakov took only what was his, yet Lavan claimed everything belonged to him, although Yaakov brought blessing to his house, as Lavan himself admitted. This, he says, is the story of golus: Jews brought prosperity to every land, as seen in Spain's decline after the expulsion and in America, while the nations accuse them of sucking their blood, as in Shakespeare's Shylock. He ends that Yaakov does leave Lavan and the world will yet acknowledge the truth.
The shiur, written up
Bechirah is measured by each person's nature
The Rav opens with bechirah: the Torah tells a person to choose life, to be a servant of Hashem. Yet Hashem measures each person by what is expected of his own nature. One who could never bring himself to kill earns nothing for not killing; he is measured by whether he rose in time to daven with kavanah and avoided the failings within his reach. a
Every person has his own red line. A natural masmid who learned twelve hours will be asked why not thirteen, while a lazy person will be asked why he did not learn even one.
The midos of the Avos and the Akeidah
Each of the Avos had his midah. Avraham overflowed with chesed and drew people close to Hashem; Yitzchak was din, staying at home and holding back. The hardest test, the Rav explains, is to act against one's own character, and that was the Akeidah: Avraham of chesed had to slaughter his son, and Yitzchak of din had to give up his life out of love of Hashem. Yaakov's midah was emes; he would have died rather than say sheker. b
Why Yaakov had to say sheker
Everything Hashem created has a purpose. To call an ugly animal ugly is like criticizing a painting in front of the artist. The Torah tells us to keep far from sheker, more than from any other aveirah, yet Hashem created sheker too, and sometimes it must be used. d
Yaakov's test was to say sheker. Rivka, a prophetess as Chazal say of Sarah, told him with prophecy to go and say it. The Rav explains that when a navi commands a one-time aveirah one must listen, as Rashi brings on 'elav tishma'un', like Eliyahu offering at Har HaCarmel. Yaakov could have received the brachos honestly, but breaking his midah of emes at Hashem's word was the greater avodah. e,g,h,i
Why did Hashem want Yitzchak to bless Yaakov thinking he was Esav? So that Jews are blessed even when they act like Esav, and to show that Hashem, not Yitzchak, chooses whom to bless. In Vayeitzei, the Rav notes, Yaakov again faces seeming deception, with the sticks and Lavan's sheep.
The Dor HaMabul and Noach who should have been Moshe
To explain the sheep, the Rav goes back to the Dor HaMabul. They were choice neshamos who soiled themselves with aveiros, and Hashem wanted to cleanse them by giving them the Torah. Torah is like water; since they would not take it, the water came down instead, forty days like the forty days of receiving the Torah.
Mei Noach, the Haflagah and Mitzrayim
The Navi calls the flood 'the waters of Noach' because it was his fault. As Moshe, he davened 'mecheini na', and so repaired what he spoiled as Noach. The same souls returned in the Dor HaHaflagah and failed again; but because they were united, Hashem scattered rather than destroyed them. They came once more as the Jews in Mitzrayim, where they were purified. n,o
The souls as Lavan's sheep
Between the Haflagah and Mitzrayim, the Rav adds, these souls were Lavan's sheep. Yaakov tended them until they were domesticated, and the Midrash Rabbah hints that he had 600,000 sheep, like the 600,000 Jews who left Mitzrayim. q
Vayeitzei is a parsha of golus, and Yaakov accomplished more there than in Eretz Yisrael. So too Torah reached its completion in Bavel, producing the Talmud Bavli.
Gedolim from golus and the sheep remembered
The Rav notes that the great Rabbanim of Yerushalayim came from golus, as did the Beis Yosef, who fled Spain. Yaakov extricated the sheep from Lavan and brought them to Eretz Yisrael and then to Mitzrayim, where they were born again as Jews.
The Ba'al Shem Tov and his disciples, great souls, lifted Jews with emunah. The Yismach Moshe showed a mark from Yaakov's stick when he was his sheep, and a Rebbe sang a niggun Yaakov had played for his sheep, since tzaddikim remember.
Yaakov's sticks were tefillin
A hidden battle with the Satan
Yaakov's blessing to Lavan and the story of golus
Yaakov took only what was his, yet Lavan claimed everything. When Yaakov came there was too little water, but then the well gave plenty, and Lavan admitted Hashem had blessed him because of Yaakov. w,x,y
This is the story of golus. Jews brought prosperity wherever they went; Spain sank after expelling them, and Jewish immigrants made America great. Yet the nations accuse them of draining their blood, as in Shakespeare's Shylock. In the end Yaakov leaves Lavan, and the world will acknowledge the truth.
Sources
Torah
- a Devarim 30:19 text index In the write-up: 0:22
- b apparently Bereishis 22:10 index In the write-up: 4:36
- c apparently Bereishis 22:7 7:16 index
- d apparently Shemos 23:7 index In the write-up: 8:15
- e apparently Bereishis 27:8 index In the write-up: 11:39
- f apparently Bereishis 27:19 12:13 index
- g apparently Devarim 18:15 index In the write-up: 11:39
- l apparently Bereishis 6:3 index In the write-up: 21:10
- o apparently Shemos 32:32 index In the write-up: 24:10
- p apparently Bereishis 11:4 25:39 index
- v apparently Bereishis 28:10 45:48 index
- w apparently Bereishis 29:2-3 index In the write-up: 46:41
- x apparently Bereishis 30:27 index In the write-up: 46:41
- y apparently Bereishis 31:43 index In the write-up: 46:41
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Key points
- 2:46 Bechirah is measured individually: Hashem judges each person by what is expected of his nature, and the hardest test is one that goes against a person's own character.
- 7:42 Yaakov's midah was emes, so his great test was to say sheker because Rivka told him so through prophecy.
- 19:06 The great souls of the Dor HaMabul returned in the Dor HaHaflagah, then as Lavan's sheep, and then as the Jews of Mitzrayim, being cleansed at each stage.
- 28:31 Yaakov extricated these souls from Lavan and brought them toward Eretz Yisrael and Mitzrayim, a redemption like Yetzias Mitzrayim.
- 41:57 According to the Zohar, Yaakov's carved sticks were the mitzvah of tefillin, and he did not trick Lavan at all.
- 45:37 Vayeitzei is the parsha of golus: Yaakov brought blessing to Lavan's house, yet Lavan claimed everything was his, as the nations say of the Jews who enriched them.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 11:09 How could Yaakov, whose midah was emes, say sheker to obtain the brachos?
Answer: 12:00 Rivka commanded it through prophecy, and a navi may command a one-time aveirah, as Eliyahu did at Har HaCarmel; breaking his own midah at Hashem's word was Yaakov's greatest avodah.
-
Question: 14:14 Why did Hashem want Yitzchak to bless Yaakov while thinking he was blessing Esav?
Answer: 14:51 To show that Jews receive the blessing even when they act like Esav, and that Hashem, not Yitzchak, chooses whom to bless.
-
Question: 21:10 Why does the Gemara find an allusion to Moshe in the words 'beshagam hu basar' said about the Dor HaMabul?
Answer: 21:52 Because, as the Zohar says, Noach was meant to be Moshe and give that generation the Torah; when he failed, he was replanted as Moshe Rabbeinu.
-
Question: 24:10 Why is the flood called 'the waters of Noach'?
Answer: 24:22 Because it was Noach's fault for not davening for his generation; Moshe's 'mecheini na' later repaired it.
-
Question: 43:42 Why did Esav not pursue Yaakov to Charan during his twenty-two years with Lavan?
Answer: 43:56 According to the Zohar, Lavan was such great tumah, the Satan's headquarters, that Esav assumed Lavan would destroy Yaakov for him.
-
Question: 44:42 If Yaakov did not trick Lavan, why does the Torah describe it as a trick?
Answer: 44:49 A battle with the Satan must be fought in secret so he does not catch on, so Yaakov did it in a way that hid what he was accomplishing.
Stories
-
36:07 The Yismach Moshe's mark from Yaakov's stick
The Rav tells that the Yismach Moshe, whom he identifies as an ancestor of the Satmar Rav, showed a mark on his shoulder. He said he remembered when he was a sheep with Yaakov Avinu, and Yaakov once gave him a small tap on the shoulder with a stick, and the mark remained.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu
-
36:49 The niggun Yaakov played for his sheep
The Rav tells that a Rebbe sang a niggun for his chassidim and said that Yaakov Avinu had played this niggun on his flute for them when they were sheep with him. He remembered it, the Rav explains, because tzaddikim remember what happened to them before. The Rav adds that this niggun is known today and that he knows it.
In the story: Yaakov Avinu
Insights
- 6:09 The Akeidah was the hardest test because it required each of the Avos to act against his own midah: Avraham of chesed had to slaughter, and Yitzchak of din had to give himself up out of love.
- 14:51 Hashem arranged that Yitzchak bless Yaakov thinking he was Esav, to show that Jews are blessed even when they act like Esav, and that Hashem, not Yitzchak, chooses whom to bless.
- 19:40 Since Torah is compared to water, the Dor HaMabul, who refused the Torah meant for them, received it as the waters of the flood, over forty days like the forty days of Matan Torah.
- 21:52 The Gemara's derivation of Moshe from 'beshagam hu basar' is explained by the Zohar: Noach was meant to be Moshe, and Moshe's plea 'mecheini na' repaired Noach's failure to daven for his generation, which is why the flood is called 'mei Noach'.
- 28:13 Lavan's sheep were a stage in the cleansing of the souls of the Dor HaMabul and Dor HaHaflagah, between the Haflagah and Mitzrayim; the Yismach Moshe remembered being one of them.
- 42:01 Yaakov's sticks were the mitzvah of tefillin, which recall Yetzias Mitzrayim, because extricating these souls from Lavan was itself a redemption like Yetzias Mitzrayim; it was concealed as a trick so that the Satan would not interfere.
- 48:25 Lavan's claim that everything Yaakov had was his, though Yaakov had brought him blessing, is the pattern of all golus: the nations prosper through the Jews and then accuse them of draining them.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 38:44 The Rav says that when someone demands to know how a mitzvah works, one should answer that he also does not know how his breakfast nourishes him; Hashem knows, and mitzvos work even without our understanding.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Lavan, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbi Yehoshua Leib Diskin, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, Sarah Imeinu, the Baal Shem Tov, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמת, בחירה, גלות, דור המבול, דור הפלגה, טומאה, יציאת מצרים, נסיון, עקידה, רבונו של עולם, שלימות, תיקון, תפילין