A Deeper Understanding of יעקב's Present to עשו
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) וישלח no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 12 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the 580 animals Yaakov sent Esav are Jewish souls handed to Esav's rule, and that this gift, like Dina who was taken by Shechem, must return to Yaakov's flock.
He opens with the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching that a person's belongings hold sparks of his soul, which is why Yaakov risked his life for small jars. Counting the gift to Esav with the Ohr HaChaim, he finds 580, the value of Seir and of the names of the two chiefs of evil, so the gift resembles the Yom Kippur goat: a bone thrown to Esav. The animals were Jewish souls who volunteered, surpassing Eliyahu's ox. Through the Midrash of Rabbi Hoshaya and the unlearned man who explained 'they will return a gift', he shows that these are the Jews ruled by the yetzer hara, that this man's letter in the Torah lay in these verses, and that his wish to be quoted was his soul seeking redemption. He closes with Dina, owed to Esav in place of Leah, who returned via Osnas, Shechem and Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon.
Topics: Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos · The Greatness of Every Jew
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sparks of the soul in one's belongings
The Rav recalls that Yaakov's animals are Jewish souls and that Yaakov endangered himself on a dangerous night for small jars. He explains with the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person's belongings hold sparks of his soul, and that every creature is guided by individual providence.
-
6:37 The birds, the donkey and the small jars
The Rav brings Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, who saw that no bird is caught without a heavenly decree, and the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair that would not eat untithed oats because it held sparks of its master's soul. From here he explains why Yaakov crossed back for the jars.
-
11:36 580 animals: a bone thrown to Esav listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim, who counts the gift as 580, the value of Seir, and shows that the names of the chief of evil and his mate also total 580. The gift is like the Yom Kippur goat, as the Zohar connects it, and he asks why Yaakov would give away animals that were Jewish souls.
-
19:29 Eliyahu's ox and Yaakov's volunteers listed in the guide
The Rav tells how the ox chosen for the Baal at Eliyahu's contest refused to move until Eliyahu told it that it too would sanctify Hashem's name. Yaakov's animals stood higher: they volunteered to go to Esav, exactly 580 of them.
-
24:04 Rabbi Hoshaya and the unlearned man's chiddush Story listed in the guide
The Rav tells the Midrash of an unlearned man who asked Rabbi Hoshaya to repeat his chiddush in his name: the verse in Tehillim says the kings 'will return' a gift to Moshiach because Esav must give back Yaakov's gift. Rabbi Hoshaya agreed, and the chiddush entered the Midrash.
-
27:22 Every Jew's letter in the Sefer Torah
The Rav explains that every Jew has his own letter in the Sefer Torah, his channel of blessing, and brings the teaching that one who sees his letter at hagbah is lit up by it. He then notes that the animals sent to Esav are now managed by Esav.
-
31:01 Who judges the tzaddik, the beinoni and the rasha
The Rav brings the Gemara that the angel of Esav is the Satan, the yetzer hara and the angel of death, and describes his three roles. With the Gemara on three judges in the heart, he explains that the yetzer hara is the judge of the wicked, and these are the animals that went to Esav.
-
35:52 Why Esav had to receive something listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Yaakov pacified Esav, who complained about the brachos, because Hashem runs the world with a balanced scale and Esav's complaint would otherwise have prevailed. He digresses about the house of David coming through Rus in a hidden way, then returns: this is why some Jews are under Esav's dictates.
-
40:59 The unlearned man's letter among Esav's animals listed in the guide
The Rav explains that without Torah, the only antidote to the yetzer hara, the unlearned man must often have fallen, so his letter is likely among the animals sent to Esav. Since every letter is alive and gives light, every Jew says a chiddush at least once, even without realizing its depth.
-
46:24 The returned gift is returning souls listed in the guide
The Rav asks what 580 animals could mean to Moshiach, king of the whole world, and answers that they are Jewish souls, each a world, so their return means that all who strayed will return. He then asks why the unlearned man wanted his chiddush repeated, rejecting that it was for honor.
-
50:30 The soul's request for redemption listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the Ba'al Shem Tov and his disciples heard the soul's plea behind a person's physical request. The unlearned man's wish was his soul's: since repeating Torah in the speaker's name brings redemption, he sought redemption from Esav's rule, and his declaration that he will return speeds his return.
-
56:41 Why Yaakov was faulted for hiding Dina listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi that Yaakov hid Dina in a box from Esav and was punished, since she might have brought Esav back to his roots; Dina was then taken by Shechem. He asks why Yaakov is faulted, when no tzaddik ever sought a rasha for his daughter.
-
1:00:50 Leah's tears and the debt to Esav listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Leah was destined for Esav and escaped through her weeping and tefillah, so Yaakov took what was Esav's and owed it back. Dina, the extension of Leah, should have been the 581st gift; withheld, she went to Esav anyway through Shechem.
-
1:05:47 Osnas, Shechem and the gift's return listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that Dina's daughter Osnas was saved by Yaakov, brought to Mitzrayim and married Yosef, who was given Shechem and buried there. With the Ohr HaChaim he shows that Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon descended from this episode, and closes that the whole gift, every Jewish soul, will return, as the present drizzle of teshuvah shows.
The shiur, written up
Sparks of the soul in one's belongings
The Rav recalls that Yaakov had extracted Jewish souls from Lavan in whatever form they took: oxen, donkeys, sheep, even servants. In this week's parsha, Yaakov remained alone, as the verse says, crossing back on a dangerous night, when Esav's angel was powerful, because he had forgotten small jars. a
To explain this, he brings the Ba'al Shem Tov: a person's belongings hold sparks of his own soul, and even half an apple he gives away passes on by Hashem's individual providence. That providence, the Rav stresses, reaches every creature, from a leaf to a particle of dust.
The birds, the donkey and the small jars
The Rav brings the Midrash that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, leaving his cave, heard a heavenly voice decide each bird's capture, and concluded that the king of Rome could not catch him without a decree. He then brings the Gemara's donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, which refused untithed oats because it held sparks of its master's soul. So too, Yaakov's jars held sparks of future Jewish souls, and he could not let them be lost. b,c
580 animals: a bone thrown to Esav
The Torah records exactly how many animals Yaakov took for Esav, and the Ohr HaChaim counts them as 580, the value of Seir, Esav's name. The Rav adds that the name of the chief of the forces of evil, without the letters of Hashem's name that sustain him, together with the name of his mate Lilis, also comes to 580. d,e
The gift is therefore like the Yom Kippur goat: a bone thrown to the dog so that it leaves the meal alone. The Zohar read on Rosh Hashanah, he explains, links Yaakov's sending to Esav with that offering. f
Since the animals were Jewish souls, the Rav asks why Yaakov, who toiled twenty years to gather them, would hand any to Esav, and how he would choose which.
Eliyahu's ox and Yaakov's volunteers
To answer, the Rav brings the contest of Eliyahu in Melachim. The Gemara relates that the ox chosen for the Baal refused to move, until Eliyahu told it that by failing to draw fire it too would sanctify Hashem's name. Yaakov's animals, on a higher level, needed no persuasion: exactly 580 volunteered to go to Esav. g,h
Rabbi Hoshaya and the unlearned man
Every Jew's letter in the Torah
Every Jew, the Rav explains, has his own letter in the Sefer Torah, his channel of blessing. He brings the Arizal that one whose eye catches his letter at hagbah is lit up by it. Yaakov's animals, now with Esav, are managed by Esav.
Who judges the tzaddik, the beinoni and the rasha
Why Esav had to receive something
Esav cried and complained over the brachos, and Yaakov pacified him with these animals. Had he given nothing, the Rav explains, Esav's accusation would have prevailed, because Hashem keeps good and evil in balance until Moshiach, as the verse says a king establishes the land with justice. m
After a digression on how the house of David came through Rus in a hidden way, he returns: this is why some Jews live under Esav's dictates.
The unlearned man's letter among Esav's animals
The unlearned man also had a letter, the Rav explains, but without Torah, which the Gemara calls the only antidote to the yetzer hara, he surely fell often. His letter must be among the animals sent to Esav, which is why he was unlearned. n
Yet each letter is alive and gives light, so every Jew says a chiddush at least once, through which Hashem renews creation, often without grasping its depth.
The returned gift is returning souls
The Rav asks what 580 animals could mean to Moshiach, to whom gold and gems will be brought. These animals are Jewish souls, each a world: all who strayed will return and become tzaddikim. He then asks why the man wanted his chiddush repeated; honor alone, he says, the Midrash would not record.
The soul's request for redemption
The Rav explains that the Ba'al Shem Tov and his disciples, when someone asked for a salvation, heard his soul asking at the same time for teshuvah. So too, the man's wish was his soul's request: the Gemara teaches that repeating Torah in the speaker's name brings redemption, and he, in exile under Esav, sought it. o
Rabbi Hoshaya obliged, since this chiddush holds the key to redemption. By declaring he will return, the man hastens his return; the fortunate return before Moshiach, the rest when he comes.
Why Yaakov was faulted for hiding Dina
Leah's tears and the debt to Esav
The Rav answers that Leah was destined for Esav, but her weeping and tefillah freed her to marry Yaakov. Yaakov had thus taken what was Esav's and owed it back, so Dina, Leah's extension, should have been the 581st gift.
Osnas, Shechem and the gift's return
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- c apparently Chullin 7a index In the write-up: 6:42
- h Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:40
- k apparently Bava Basra 16a index In the write-up: 31:14
- l apparently Berachos 61b index In the write-up: 33:40
- n apparently Kiddushin 30b index In the write-up: 41:08
- o apparently Megillah 15a index In the write-up: 50:37
- q apparently Kiddushin 18a index In the write-up: 57:09
- v Gemara Chagigah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:09:04
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:56 According to the Ba'al Shem Tov, every belonging of a person holds sparks of his soul, and he must use it to elevate them; this is why Yaakov went back for small jars.
- 12:19 The gift of 580 animals equals Seir and the combined names of the chief of evil and his mate, so it was an appeasement thrown to Esav like the Yom Kippur goat.
- 35:22 The animals sent to Esav stand for the unlearned and the wicked among Jews, whose judge is the yetzer hara.
- 26:20 When Moshiach comes, Esav must return Yaakov's gift, meaning that every Jew who strayed will return to Yaakov's flock.
- 28:30 Every Jew has a letter in the Sefer Torah from which he draws his life, and so every Jew says a chiddush in Torah at least once.
- 57:26 Yaakov was faulted for hiding Dina because, having married Leah who was destined for Esav, he owed Esav a wife; Dina was taken by Shechem and later returned through her descendants.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 18:14 Why would Yaakov, who toiled twenty years for his flock, give 580 animals that were Jewish souls to Esav, and how would he choose them?
Answer: 23:02 The animals were devoted to Yaakov and volunteered to go, on a higher level than Eliyahu's ox, which agreed only after being persuaded.
-
Question: 25:52 Why does the verse say the kings will 'return' a gift to Moshiach rather than give one?
Answer: 26:09 Because Esav still holds Yaakov's gift and will have to give it back when Moshiach comes.
-
Question: 47:48 What value could 580 animals have for Moshiach, king of the whole world, to whom gold and gems will be brought?
Answer: 48:05 They are Jewish souls, each an entire world, and their return means that all who strayed will become tzaddikim.
-
Question: 49:55 Why did the unlearned man insist that Rabbi Hoshaya repeat his chiddush in his name?
Answer: 52:19 Not for honor: his soul, in exile under Esav, sought redemption, and repeating Torah in the speaker's name brings redemption.
-
Question: 36:58 Why could Yaakov not withhold any gift at all from Esav?
Answer: 37:13 Hashem keeps the world on a balanced scale until Moshiach, so Esav's complaint about the brachos would have prevailed had he received nothing.
-
Question: 59:54 Why is Yaakov faulted for hiding Dina from Esav, when no tzaddik ever looked for a rasha to marry his daughter?
Answer: 1:02:36 Leah was destined for Esav, so Yaakov had taken what was Esav's and owed it back; Dina, Leah's extension, was the repayment.
Stories
-
6:42 Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and the hunter's birds
Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai hid in a cave for thirteen years from the Roman king. When he came out he saw a hunter catching birds and heard a heavenly voice announce for each bird whether it would be caught. He concluded that if a bird is not caught without a decree from Hashem, he would certainly not be caught by the king of Rome without one, and he went out.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
-
9:28 The donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
At an inn, the donkey of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair refused to eat the oats it was served. When the innkeeper complained, Rabbi Pinchas asked whether the tithe had been taken; once it was, the donkey ate. The Rav notes that a donkey may eat untithed food, especially where the obligation was only a doubt, but this donkey held sparks of its master's soul and would not transgress.
In the story: Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
-
20:51 Eliyahu's two oxen
At Eliyahu's contest with the worshippers of the Baal, two oxen were prepared, one for Hashem and one for the Baal. The ox chosen for the Baal refused to move, arguing that it and its companion had eaten from the same trough. Eliyahu told it that by being offered to the Baal, with no fire descending, it too would sanctify Hashem's name by proving the negative, and the ox agreed to go.
In the story: Eliyahu HaNavi
-
24:29 Rabbi Hoshaya and the unlearned man
An unlearned man asked Rabbi Hoshaya whether he would repeat a chiddush of his in his name, and Rabbi Hoshaya said he would if it was fitting for the congregation. The man explained that the verse in Tehillim says the kings will 'return' a gift to Moshiach because Esav still holds Yaakov's gift and will have to give it back. Rabbi Hoshaya praised it and repeated it in his name, and it entered the Midrash.
In the story: Rabbi Hoshaya
-
1:06:23 Osnas and Yosef in Shechem
Dina bore a daughter to Shechem, and the brothers wanted to kill her. According to the Midrash, Yaakov carried her to the desert and placed her on a thorn bush, which is where her name came from, and the angel Gavriel carried her to Mitzrayim. She became Osnas, who married Yosef; Yosef was given Shechem and is buried there with his two sons at his sides.
In the story: Dina, Shechem ben Chamor, Osnas, Yaakov Avinu, the angel Gavriel, Yosef HaTzaddik, Ephraim, Menashe
Insights
- 14:07 The names of the chief of evil, without the divine letters that sustain him, together with his mate Lilis, equal 580, the count of Yaakov's gift; so the gift is like the Yom Kippur goat, a bone thrown to the forces of evil to leave Yaakov alone.
- 23:02 Unlike Eliyahu's ox, which had to be persuaded, Yaakov's animals volunteered to go to Esav, because Yaakov's level raised his animals above those of Eliyahu.
- 43:23 The unlearned man's chiddush concerned Esav's gift because his own letter in the Torah lay in the verses of the animals sent to Esav; that is why he was unlearned, and why this chiddush belonged to his soul.
- 52:19 The unlearned man's wish to be quoted was his soul's hidden plea: since repeating Torah in the speaker's name brings redemption, he sought redemption from his exile under Esav, and his public declaration that he will return itself speeds his return.
- 1:02:59 Yaakov was not faulted for failing to seek a rasha for his daughter; he owed Esav a wife because he married Leah, who was Esav's match, so Dina should have been the 581st animal of the gift.
- 1:07:22 What Esav took through Shechem he had to give back: Osnas married Yosef, who was given Shechem and buried there, and Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon came from this episode, a sign that the whole gift will return.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 42:25 The Rav says that one who claims to overcome his evil inclination without Torah is, according to the Gemara, not telling the truth; Torah is the only antidote.
- 29:34 The Rav says that those who know and are not lazy crowd around the Sefer Torah at hagbah to try to see their own letter.
- 57:54 The Rav says every man to whom it applies must know that his spiritual life depends on the wife he marries.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Boaz, Dinah, Eliyahu HaNavi, Ephraim, Esav, Lavan, Leah Imeinu, Menashe, Osnas, Rabbi Chanina ben Teradyon, Rabbi Hoshaya, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Rus, Shechem ben Chamor, the angel Gavriel, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בינוני, גאולה, גימטריא, השגחה פרטית, זיווג, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, ניצוצות, עם הארץ, עשרה הרוגי מלכות, קידוש השם, קליפה, שעיר לעזאזל