“וישלח יעקב מלאכים” - עדות לגדלותו' שנשאר צדיק בסביבת רשעים

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וישלח no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 7 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 40 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 40 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Yaakov sent Eisav the very angels he had restored to heaven, as living witnesses that he remained a tzaddik even in Lavan's place of tumah.

The Rav opens with Targum Yonasan: the angels who escorted Yaakov to Charan were the angels of Sedom, banished from heaven for saying 'ki mashchisim anachnu', and they returned only now. Why now, and why send such angels to escort Yaakov? Using the Arizal on why Hashem Himself went down to Mitzrayim, he explains that Sedom was a place of tumah that blemished the angels. Following the Derech Hashem, those who are not perfect tzaddikim are repaired by attaching themselves to a tzaddik; the angels needed a tzaddik who could live amid tumah unharmed. Yaakov, trained by Shem and Ever, kept his level at Lavan, so escorting him restored them, and he later sent them to Eisav as witnesses. The Rav then turns to Dinah, Leah's tears that freed her from being Eisav's zivug, Lavan's plan in switching the sisters, and the power of tears.

Topics: Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · Friends and Environment · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The banished angels of Sedom

    The Rav brings Targum Yonasan that the angels escorting Yaakov were the angels of Sedom, kept out of heaven for saying 'ki mashchisim anachnu'. He asks why they were readmitted now, why such angels were sent to escort Yaakov, and how angels could sin at all.

  2. 5:02 Tumah of Mitzrayim and Sedom blemishes angels

    The Rav brings the Arizal that Hashem Himself went down to Mitzrayim for makas bechoros because its tumah would have blemished an angel. He applies this to Sedom, which Lot saw was 'like the land of Mitzrayim', and concludes that the angels were blemished by entering it and so could not return to heaven.

  3. 8:39 Tikkun through attaching to a tzaddik

    The Rav brings the Derech Hashem that the world was created for complete tzaddikim, and others gain a tikkun by attaching to a tzaddik, serving and supporting him. The angels likewise needed a tzaddik who had been in a place of tumah and remained unharmed, and they waited until Yaakov came.

  4. 13:20 Yaakov in Charan and the yeshiva of Shem and Ever listed in the guide

    The Rav describes Charan and the land of Kedem as the center of avodah zarah, kishuf and tumah, where Yaakov nevertheless remained a tzaddik and even grew. In the name of Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky he explains that Yaakov first learned fourteen years at the yeshiva of Shem and Ever, which taught how to serve Hashem among goyim, something he could not gain in Yitzchak's house.

  5. 19:00 The restored angels as witnesses to Eisav listed in the guide

    Heaven sent the angels to escort Yaakov; by serving a tzaddik who could stand in a place of tumah unharmed, they were repaired and readmitted to heaven. When Yaakov returned, the same angels met him, and he sent them to Eisav as trustworthy witnesses that he had lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos.

  6. 23:18 Dinah in the box and Leah's tears

    The Rav brings Rashi that Yaakov hid Dinah in a box from Eisav and was punished for withholding chesed from his brother, and asks why a Jew should have to give his daughter to a rasha. He answers with 'kol hamon k'kol Shakai': people said Lavan's older daughter would marry Yitzchak's older son, Leah cried because it was so in her mazal, and a zivug is truly part of a person.

  7. 29:11 A zivug, tefillah, and Lavan's trick

    The Rav explains that a zivug is decreed before birth, yet through tefillah one can take another's zivug, which will not last; so he says one should daven for a good shidduch, not for a specific person. Lavan, who wanted to destroy Yaakov, switched Leah for Rachel, reckoning that Yaakov would not divorce her and would have to die so that Leah could reach her true zivug.

  8. 34:59 The power of tears and Yaakov's debt to Eisav

    Lavan did not know the power of tears: the Rav brings the Ohr HaChaim that Eisav's crying opened the gates of heaven and earned him a new brachah, and Leah's tears likewise changed her root from Eisav to Yaakov. Since she had been bound to Eisav, Yaakov owed him Dinah, which is why he was faulted; the Rav ends without time to explain the good that came of it.

The shiur, written up

The banished angels of Sedom

0:31

The Rav brings the Targum Yonasan that the angels who escorted Yaakov to Charan were the angels of Sedom. Because they said 'ki mashchisim anachnu', taking the honor for themselves, they were not let back into heaven, and only when they escorted Yaakov did they go up. He asks why their sin was forgiven just then, why heaven sent such angels to escort Yaakov, and how angels can sin at all. a,b

Tumah that blemishes angels

5:25

To answer, he brings the Arizal on why Hashem Himself went down to Mitzrayim for makas bechoros: its tumah was so great that an angel there would have been blemished. Sedom, which Lot saw was 'like the land of Mitzrayim', was the same, and the Rav adds that this is not praise but means it was as impure as Mitzrayim. Entering it blemished the angels. d

Tikkun through a tzaddik

9:06

He then brings the Derech Hashem: the world was created for complete tzaddikim, and others gain a tikkun by attaching themselves to a tzaddik, serving him and supporting him, so that he brings them with him in the next world. The angels needed such a tzaddik, one who had been in a place of tumah and stayed unblemished, and they waited until Yaakov Avinu came. e

Yaakov in Charan

13:38

Charan, the Rav explains, was the stronghold of tumah: the Midrash calls it the place of Hashem's anger, Rashi calls Rivka's home a place of reshaim, and the land of Kedem, where Avraham sent the concubines' sons with names of tumah, was full of kishuf and avodah zarah. Eisav did not chase Yaakov there, sure that Lavan would destroy him. Yet Yaakov stayed a tzaddik and even grew. g,h,j

16:59

In the name of Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky he explains how Yaakov prepared: Yitzchak learned in a sheltered holy place, while Shem and Ever, Bnei Noach living among goyim, taught how to serve Hashem among goyim. Yaakov learned there fourteen years with mesirus nefesh before going to Lavan.

The angels as witnesses

19:04

Heaven sent the angels to escort Yaakov, a great benefit as the Gemara teaches. Because they served a tzaddik who could stand in tumah unharmed, he could repair them, and they were readmitted to heaven. When Yaakov returned, Rashi says these same angels came to meet him, and he sent them to Eisav as the most reliable witnesses: blemished by tumah, they had been restored through Yaakov, who stayed whole at Lavan and kept the mitzvos. Eisav had better not start with him. m,n,k

Dinah and Leah's tears

23:49

Rashi says Yaakov hid Dinah in a box so Eisav would not take her, though she might have brought him to teshuvah, and the Midrash says he was punished for withholding chesed from his brother. The Rav asks why a Jew should give a fine daughter to a rasha. p,q

26:12

He answers with 'kol hamon k'kol Shakai', attributed to Ben Sira: what people say holds truth. Rashi says Leah's eyes were soft from crying because people said Lavan's older daughter would marry Yitzchak's older son; her crying shows it was in her mazal. A zivug, he explains, is part of a person. r,s

A zivug and Lavan's trick

29:33

A zivug is announced before birth, as the Gemara says, yet through tefillah one can take another's zivug. Such a marriage cannot last: he must divorce or die, and her true zivug marries her. So the Rav says one should ask Hashem for a good shidduch, not daven for a specific person. t,u

32:04

Lavan, a rasha who wanted to destroy Yaakov, knew Rachel was his zivug and switched Leah for her. Leah conceived at once, and Yaakov would not divorce her once she became a mother of the shevatim, so Lavan reckoned Yaakov would have to die. x

The power of tears

35:09

Lavan's mistake was not knowing the power of tears. The Ohr HaChaim explains that Yitzchak blessed only when heaven granted a brachah, and had none for Eisav until Eisav's tears opened the gates of heaven. Leah's tears likewise tore her from Eisav's mazal into Yaakov's. But since she had been Eisav's in potential, Yaakov owed him Dinah, which is why he was faulted for hiding her. The Rav ends without time to explain the good that came of it. y

Sources

Torah

  1. b Bereishis 19:13 text index In the write-up: 0:31
  2. d Bereishis 13:10 text index In the write-up: 5:25
  3. f Bereishis 28:10 13:34 text index
  4. i Bereishis 29:1 14:04 text index
  5. o Bereishis 32:4 22:50 text index
  6. v Bereishis 49:3 33:05 text index
  7. w Bereishis 29:31 33:32 text index
  8. z Bereishis 27:38-39 35:59 text index

Targum

  1. a apparently Targum Yonasan on Bereishis 28:12 index In the write-up: 0:31

Talmud Bavli

  1. m Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:04
  2. t apparently Sotah 2a index In the write-up: 29:33
  3. u apparently Moed Katan 18b index In the write-up: 29:33
  4. aa apparently Berachos 32b 37:07 index

Midrash

  1. g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 13:38
  2. q Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 23:49
  3. x Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 32:04

Rishonim

  1. h apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:20 index In the write-up: 13:38
  2. j apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:6 index In the write-up: 13:38
  3. k apparently Rashi on Bereishis 32:5 index In the write-up: 19:04
  4. l apparently Rashi on Bereishis 28:11 18:04 index
  5. n apparently Rashi on Bereishis 32:2 index In the write-up: 19:04
  6. p apparently Rashi on Bereishis 32:23 index In the write-up: 23:49
  7. s apparently Rashi on Bereishis 29:17 index In the write-up: 26:12

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Derech Hashem (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:06
  2. y apparently Ohr HaChaim on Bereishis 27 (Parshas Toldos) index In the write-up: 35:09

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. c Haggadah shel Pesach (place not identified) 4:34 index

Other

  1. r Ben Sira (place not identified) index In the write-up: 26:12

Key points

  1. 0:31 The angels who escorted Yaakov to Charan were the angels of Sedom, who had been kept out of heaven after saying 'ki mashchisim anachnu'.
  2. 5:30 A place of great tumah, like Mitzrayim or Sedom, blemishes even a holy angel who enters it.
  3. 8:49 Following the Derech Hashem, those who are not complete tzaddikim gain their tikkun by attaching themselves to a tzaddik and serving and supporting him.
  4. 15:07 Yaakov remained a tzaddik in Charan, the stronghold of tumah, and he prepared for this by learning at the yeshiva of Shem and Ever how to serve Hashem among goyim.
  5. 21:13 Yaakov sent these same restored angels to Eisav as witnesses that he had lived with Lavan without being harmed.
  6. 27:49 Leah was destined as Eisav's zivug, but her tears uprooted her from his mazal and brought her into Yaakov's.
  7. 38:42 Because Leah had belonged in potential to Eisav, Yaakov owed him, and this is why he was faulted for hiding Dinah from Eisav.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:59 Why were the angels of Sedom readmitted to heaven only now, and why were such angels sent to escort Yaakov?

    Answer: 19:00 They were blemished by the tumah of Sedom and needed a tzaddik who had lived in tumah unharmed; by escorting Yaakov they were repaired.

  2. Question: 5:05 Why did Hashem Himself have to go down to Mitzrayim for makas bechoros rather than send an angel?

    Answer: 5:25 The Arizal explains that Mitzrayim was so full of tumah that an angel going there would have been blemished.

  3. Question: 15:13 Why did Eisav not chase Yaakov when he went to Lavan?

    Answer: 15:23 Eisav knew Lavan was so wicked that Yaakov would not get away from him, and Lavan would do a better job against Yaakov than Eisav could.

  4. Question: 24:51 Why should Yaakov have had to give his daughter Dinah to a rasha like Eisav?

    Answer: 28:00 Leah had been destined as Eisav's zivug and her tears took her from him; since Leah had been his in potential, Yaakov owed Eisav, and Dinah, Leah's daughter, was the repayment.

  5. Question: 36:15 How did Yitzchak bless Eisav after saying he had no brachah left for him?

    Answer: 36:25 Following the Ohr HaChaim, Yitzchak blessed only when heaven granted a brachah; Eisav's tears opened the gates of heaven and a new brachah came down.

Insights

  1. 7:58 The angels of Sedom were not punished only for the words 'ki mashchisim anachnu'; entering the tumah of Sedom itself blemished them, as the Arizal explains about Mitzrayim.
  2. 7:30 The Rav suggests that 'k'eretz Mitzrayim' in the passuk about Sedom is not praise of its fertility but a statement that it was as impure as Mitzrayim.
  3. 12:04 Only a tzaddik who had himself lived in a place of tumah without being blemished could repair the blemished angels, which is why they waited until Yaakov.
  4. 17:10 Yaakov went to Shem and Ever rather than staying with Yitzchak because Yitzchak learned in a sheltered holy place, while Shem and Ever, living among goyim, taught how to serve Hashem in such surroundings.
  5. 32:04 Lavan switched the sisters as a plan to kill Yaakov: a man married to someone else's zivug must eventually divorce or die, and he knew Yaakov would not divorce Leah.
  6. 37:16 Tears can change what even tefillah cannot: as Eisav's tears opened the gates of brachah, Leah's tears changed her very root from Eisav to Yaakov.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 30:51 The Rav says one should not daven that a specific person become one's shidduch, which he calls dangerous, but should ask Hashem to send a good shidduch.
  2. 30:07 The Rav says that when a fitting shidduch is proposed one should not delay but conclude it quickly.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Dinah, Esav, Ever, Lavan, Leah Imeinu, Lot, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky, Reuven, Shem, the Arizal, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms זיווג, לויה, תיקון

Report an error on this page