Rabbi Hoshaya and the unlearned man

About: Rabbi Hoshaya

The story

Retold here from 2 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

An unlearned man asked Rabbi Hoshaya whether he would repeat a chiddush of his in his name, and Rabbi Hoshaya said he would if it was fitting for the congregation. The man explained that the verse in Tehillim says the kings will 'return' a gift to Moshiach because Esav still holds Yaakov's gift and will have to give it back. Rabbi Hoshaya praised it and repeated it in his name, and it entered the Midrash.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
A Deeper Understanding of יעקב's Present to עשו 1 וישלח תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 24:29
רשע וטוב לו - יש לו חרטה אחר העבירות אבל לא עשה תשובה. רשע ורע לו - נשמות שמסר יעקב לעשו - אבל יש להם נקודת יחידה ומצטרפים למנין. 25 TANYA ENGLISH not known English 10:26