A Time to reaffirm our Acceptance of the תורה
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) יתרו no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 58 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Shabbos Yisro is a renewed Matan Torah for those who came late, and that one who truly gives himself over to Torah stands, like the Kodesh HaKodashim, above all calculation.
The Rav opens with Rashi's question of what Yisro heard, and says every Shabbos is unique, so that Shabbos Yisro is a rerun of the acceptance of the Torah, driven by Shabbos itself. Yisro lacked the preparation of the Exodus, Sefirah and the war with Amalek; what gave him courage? The Rav brings the Midrash that Dasan and Aviram, who stayed in Egypt, came late to the sea and Hashem split it again for them, and Rashi's account of the Bnei Dan, left outside the clouds of glory and attacked by Amalek, for whom Hashem still wages war. Hearing that Hashem does not reject latecomers, Yisro came. The Rav then reads the Rambam that any person who devotes himself to Torah becomes like shevet Levi. He asks why the Masorah counts 72 pesukim in Yisro when he counted 75, rejects one answer, and concludes that, like the Aron in the Kodesh HaKodashim, Torah is beyond arithmetic; so too the sincere ben Torah's parnassah, though this is not for everyone.
Topics: Matan Torah at Har Sinai · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Each parsha and each Shabbos is unique
The Rav opens with Rashi's question of what Yisro heard, then says the parsha is a cloth woven of its pesukim in which everything that happens can be found, that parshiyos may not be mixed, and, citing the Lechovitcher, that every Shabbos is unique and each Jew has his own Shabbos.
-
4:41 Shabbos Yisro and Yisro's missing preparation listed in the guide
The Rav says Shabbos Yisro is a rerun of the acceptance of the Torah, perhaps stronger than Shavuos, then asks how Yisro could come to accept the Torah without the Exodus, Sefirah and the war against Amalek that prepared everyone else.
-
8:58 The sea split again for Dasan and Aviram listed in the guide
On the passuk that Pharaoh would say of the Jews that they are confused, the Rav brings Rashi and the Targum that Dasan and Aviram stayed in Egypt, and a Midrash cited by the Be'er Mayim Chaim that they came late and Hashem split the sea for them alone, which explains why Tehillim says Hashem rebuked the sea.
-
16:02 Amalek and the Bnei Dan left behind listed in the guide
On the passuk that Amalek struck the stragglers, the Rav explains with Rashi that some of the tribe of Dan fell outside the clouds of glory and were attacked, that Hashem never evicts a child, and that His war against Amalek still burns because Amalek attacked His children who were late.
-
22:05 Never too late: Matan Torah again listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that these two stories gave Yisro the courage to come though late, and that Parshas Yisro is Matan Torah for those not ready on Shavuos; he then begins the Rambam at the end of Hilchos Shemitah v'Yovel about shevet Levi.
-
26:22 Not only shevet Levi: the Rambam
After noting how many seforim and roshei yeshiva come from Kohanim and Leviim, the Rav reads the Rambam that not only shevet Levi but any person whose spirit moves him to stand before Hashem is sanctified and provided for, and brings Dovid HaMelech's passuk as proof.
-
32:07 The Masorah's 72 pesukim and the count of 75
The Rav notes that the Masorah at the end of Yisro gives 72 pesukim with the sign Yanadav, yet he counted 75; he suggests the Aseres HaDibros are counted by the ta'am elyon as ten dibros, then rejects it, since a pasuk or an aliyah cannot be that short.
-
42:37 Above arithmetic like the Kodesh HaKodashim
The Rav brings the Gemara that the place of the Aron took up no space, and says that in the realm of Torah arithmetic does not apply, so 72 against 75 is no question, just as the Torah given on the fifty-first day counts as fifty; he adds the Bnei Yissaschar's demonstration that people spend more than they earn.
-
48:15 Yanadav: the volunteer above calculation listed in the guide
Returning to the Rambam, the Rav links the sign Yanadav to the one whose spirit volunteers and who casts off the yoke of calculations, becoming holy of holies with his parnassah assured; he warns, with the dispute of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and Rabbi Yishmael and the Ba'al Shem Tov, that this is only for the sincere, not for those following peer pressure.
The shiur, written up
Each parsha and each Shabbos is unique
The Rav opens with Rashi's question on the parsha's first words: what did Yisro hear? Before answering, he says the parsha is a cloth whose threads are its pesukim, and everything that happens in the world, and to each person, can be found in it. So parshiyos may not be mixed: this Shabbos belongs to Yisro alone. a
He brings the Lechovitcher, who said a Jew should greet Shabbos as if there never was and never will be another. Hashem made 600,000 Shabbosos for 600,000 souls, and each Jew has his own Shabbos with a special elevation, though he does not know which it is.
Shabbos Yisro and Yisro's missing preparation
Shabbos Yisro, the Rav says, is a rerun of the acceptance of the Torah, perhaps stronger than Shavuos. On Shavuos the Aseres HaDibros are read because it is the fiftieth day of Sefirah; on Shabbos Yisro they are read because of the Shabbos itself.
Klal Yisrael prepared for forty-nine days with kedushah, and even the war with Amalek, the root of heresy, was a preparation. Yisro had none of this. What, then, gave him the courage to come?
The sea split again for Dasan and Aviram
To answer, the Rav turns to last week's passuk that Pharaoh will say of the Jews that they are confused. Rashi reads it as speaking about the Bnei Yisrael, since they had already left Egypt. The Targum says something striking: Pharaoh said it to Dasan and Aviram, who stayed behind in Egypt. b,c,d
Amalek and the Bnei Dan left behind
Never too late: Matan Torah again
These two stories, the Rav concludes, gave Yisro courage. He had not started counting Sefirah with the Jews, but hearing that Hashem split the sea and went to war for latecomers, he understood he would be welcomed too.
Not only shevet Levi: the Rambam
The Rav remarks that a disproportionate share of seforim and roshei yeshiva come from Kohanim and Leviim. Shevet Levi was separated from war and from a portion in the land, and the Torah provided for them through the matnos kehunah.
Yet the Rambam says not only shevet Levi: any person whose spirit moves him to separate himself and serve Hashem, casting off the yoke of the calculations people make, is provided with what he needs, if not a villa in Florida. The proof is Dovid HaMelech, no Levi, who said Hashem is his portion. k,l
The Masorah's 72 pesukim and the count of 75
The Rav turns to the Masorah note printed at the end of each sedra. At the end of Yisro it says there are 72 pesukim, with the sign Yanadav, whose gematria is 72. Being curious, the Rav counted and found 75. m
He first suggests that the Aseres HaDibros, which are read publicly in a special cantillation, are divided not by pesukim but by dibros, each a separate parsha in the Sefer Torah. Counted that way they lose three pesukim, and the same three are missing in Va'eschanan.
Above arithmetic like the Kodesh HaKodashim
The Rav brings the Gemara, fitting as Purim nears, on the Aron in the Kodesh HaKodashim. The room was twenty amos, yet there were ten amos from each side of the Aron to the wall. The Gemara answers that the Aron took no space: the Kodesh HaKodashim, a piece of Heaven on earth, is not subject to mathematics. o
So too the Aseres HaDibros: 72 against 75 is no question. Likewise the Torah came on the fifty-first day yet counts as the fiftieth. The Bnei Yissaschar would show people they spent more than they earned; one who takes on Torah need not project his finances.
Yanadav: the volunteer above calculation
Returning to the Rambam, the Rav reads that the one whose spirit volunteers becomes holy of holies, and this is the sign Yanadav. He frees himself of all calculations, as in the Kodesh HaKodashim, and Hashem guarantees his parnassah. k,m
But this is not for everyone, only for serious people with yiras Shamayim. The Gemara records the dispute of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and Rabbi Yishmael, and that many who acted like Rabbi Shimon did not succeed. The Ba'al Shem Tov explained they only wanted to compare themselves, like peer pressure. p
One who truly means it for Heaven will be helped; one who merely imitates, the Rav says, should go to work. Most of the tribes worked their fields and supported the Kohanim, while those set aside to learn can remain learning.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 3:20 Every Shabbos is unique, and Shabbos Yisro is a renewal of the acceptance of the Torah, read because of the Shabbos itself.
- 7:28 Yisro lacked the preparation the rest of Klal Yisrael had for Matan Torah, and his courage came from hearing that Hashem does not reject those who come late.
- 12:51 Dasan and Aviram, who came late to the sea, and the Bnei Dan, who fell behind the clouds of glory, are two cases where Hashem stood by latecomers because they are His children.
- 23:23 Parshas Yisro is a second chance at Matan Torah for those who were not ready on Shavuos.
- 44:26 Just as the Aron in the Kodesh HaKodashim took up no space, Torah is not bound by arithmetic, which answers why the Masorah counts 72 pesukim where the Rav counted 75.
- 48:51 According to the Rambam, anyone who sincerely devotes himself to Torah becomes holy of holies and is provided for, but the Rav stresses this is only for genuine, G-d-fearing people.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:28 Without the preparation of the Exodus, Sefirah and the war with Amalek, how did Yisro find the courage to come and accept the Torah?
Answer: 22:22 He heard that Hashem split the sea for the latecomers Dasan and Aviram and waged war against Amalek for the stragglers of Dan, and understood that he too would be welcomed though late.
-
Question: 9:46 Why does the passuk say Pharaoh will speak 'to' the Bnei Yisrael when they had already left Egypt?
Answer: 9:57 Rashi reads it as 'about' the Bnei Yisrael; the Targum says Pharaoh spoke to Dasan and Aviram, who had stayed behind in Egypt.
-
Question: 13:48 Why did Hashem need to rebuke the sea to split it?
Answer: 14:08 The sea's condition from creation was already fulfilled at the first splitting, so it did not want to split again for Dasan and Aviram, and Hashem commanded it.
-
Question: 35:22 How can the Masorah say Parshas Yisro has 72 pesukim when the Rav counted 75?
Answer: 45:13 After rejecting an answer from the ta'am elyon, the Rav answers that in Torah, as in the Kodesh HaKodashim, arithmetic does not apply, so the discrepancy is no question.
-
Question: 43:42 How could there be ten amos from each side of the Aron to the wall in a Kodesh HaKodashim of twenty amos?
Answer: 44:21 The Gemara answers that the Aron miraculously took up no space, because the Kodesh HaKodashim is not subject to the laws of mathematics.
Stories
-
47:03 The Bnei Yissaschar's accounting
The Rav tells that the Bnei Yissaschar used to sit with people and have them reckon how much they spent in a year and how much they earned. He showed them that they had spent more than they earned. The Rav uses this to show that a Jew's parnassah does not follow calculation.
In the story: the Bnei Yissaschar
Insights
- 4:55 On Shavuos the Aseres HaDibros are read because it is the fiftieth day of Sefirah, but on Shabbos Yisro they are read because of the Shabbos, so that Shabbos Yisro may be an even more powerful acceptance of the Torah than Shavuos.
- 22:22 Rashi's question of what Yisro heard is answered by two stories of latecomers, Dasan and Aviram at the sea and the Bnei Dan outside the clouds, from which Yisro learned that he too, though late, would be welcomed.
- 13:53 Hashem had to rebuke the sea because its original condition from creation had already been fulfilled; splitting a second time for Dasan and Aviram was outside that condition.
- 21:02 Hashem's war against Amalek in every generation stems from Amalek's attack on His children who were late and outside the clouds; nearly four thousand years later His anger still burns over it.
- 45:37 The Masorah's sign for the count of Yisro, Yanadav, alludes to the Rambam's one whose spirit volunteers, and the discrepancy between 72 and 75 itself shows that Torah, like the Kodesh HaKodashim, stands above arithmetic.
- 46:23 Just as the Torah given on the fifty-first day is still counted as the fiftieth, a person who takes on the yoke of Torah is not subject to the calculations of income and expenses.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 3:24 Citing the Lechovitcher, the Rav says a Jew should welcome Shabbos with the excitement that there never was and never will be another Shabbos like it.
- 23:23 The Rav says it is never too late: through Parshas Yisro one can start over and accept the Torah anew.
- 49:27 The Rav says giving oneself entirely to Torah without worrying about parnassah is only for genuine, G-d-fearing people; one who merely imitates others should go to work.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Asaf, Aviram, Dasan, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, Rashi, the Baal Shem Tov, the Be'er Mayim Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Tchernovitz), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, Yisro
Terms מחיית עמלק, מסורה, מקום ארון אינו מן המדה, מתן תורה, נחשלים, ספירה, ענני הכבוד, עשרת הדברות, פרנסה, קודש הקדשים, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם