תיקון לפגם הברית ע"י קר"ש שעל המטה. ביאור בהא דאין אומרים ברכה על דבר איסור.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ז no. 18 Pocket Guide p. 74 English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
Continuing Tanya chapters 7 and 8, the Rav explains why the sin of wasted seed, though the gravest, can be repaired through teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime, and why no brachah is made on forbidden food.
The Rav reviews which energies can be elevated and turns to the sin the Shulchan Aruch calls the worst, wasted seed, whose repair is nevertheless close at hand. He explains that both kedushah and klipah have a male and female side, illustrated by the Names Havayah and Adnus, by the numerical value of Amen, and by Yaakov's gift of 580 animals to Esav. Wasted seed is influence without a receiver, so it can be gathered back. In the Sitra Achra the female side is the stronger, which he shows from the Ohr HaChaim's dream and from Rashi on Esav, and he digresses on how the nations follow their angel's left-sided order. He then shows that the repair comes through teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime, contrasts forbidden relations and a mamzer, speaks of Hashem's ways above the order of judgment, and explains every sin as separation. He closes with Tanya chapter 8 and the Tzemach Tzedek's reason that no brachah is made on forbidden food.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Shmiras HaBris · Kedushah and Kelipah · Teshuvah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Review, and the gravest sin listed in the guide
The Rav reviews the previous week: energy from permitted food can later be elevated, while energy from forbidden food cannot. He then introduces wasted seed, called in Shulchan Aruch Even HaEzer the worst sin, whose repair is nevertheless available right away.
-
4:34 Male and female in kedushah and klipah
The Rav explains that kedushah has a male aspect, the Name Havayah, and a female aspect, the Name Adnus, whose union is alluded to in Amen; the Sitra Achra has its counterparts. He shows that Yaakov's 580 animals sent to Esav match the numerical value of Esav's force and neutralized it.
-
9:33 Influence without a receiver listed in the guide
The Rav explains that in all forbidden relations there is a giver and a receiver, but wasted seed has no receiver, so it can be gathered back. He tells the Ohr HaChaim's dream of two dogs to show that in the Sitra Achra the female is stronger, and brings Rashi on Esav placing his wives first.
-
13:13 The nations, their angel, and the left side
The Rav digresses: each of the seventy nations is guided by its angel, so the nations put the female first, button left over right and write from left to right, while Jews do the opposite. The Arabs, the refuse of Avraham's chesed, write from right to left and keep a purely lunar calendar, while Jews blend moon and sun with a leap month.
-
22:10 Teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime listed in the guide
The Rav returns to the Tanya: wasted seed can be gathered back through teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime, the weakest and strongest of the daily Shemas. He notes the Torah never writes it as an explicit prohibition, bringing Rav Tzadok's reason that it is often involuntary, and explains the Gemara that Krias Shema at bedtime is like a double-edged sword against the harmful forces clothed in those drops.
-
27:28 Forbidden relations and a mamzer
The Rav explains that forbidden relations strengthen the klipah more, since the energy is held by its female side, and ordinary teshuvah does not help unless it turns sins into merits. A mamzer cannot be repaired by the mechanics of teshuvah, though the seforim hakedoshim say that through a great teshuvah the mamzer dies and the repair is complete.
-
32:40 Hashem's ways above the order of judgment
The Rav explains the mamzer's death as a release for the suffering neshamah, like a neshamah in a cat, and answers a listener about the future. He then says Hashem is not bound by the order of judgment: at times He purifies a mamzer and keeps him alive, Moshiach comes from such a line, and He will bring the geulah even without teshuvah.
-
38:47 Every sin is separation
Answering a question, the Rav explains that the essence of every sin is separation, as in 'yispardu kol po'alei aven', and that division was created on the second day. Amalek's tumas keri means chance, and he brings Rav Tzadok that its repair is to believe in Hashem's oneness, that nothing simply happens.
-
43:42 Tanya chapter 8: no brachah on forbidden food listed in the guide
Beginning chapter 8, the Rav explains that forbidden food eaten unknowingly for the sake of Heaven still has no ascent, even a rabbinic prohibition. He brings the Tzemach Tzedek that this is why no brachah is made on it, with the Gemara on stolen wheat, the Bnei Yissaschar's inquiry on the brachah over the mann, and the Taz who differs.
The shiur, written up
Review, and the gravest sin
The Rav reviews the previous week's lesson: energy that comes from permitted food can later be elevated, while energy that comes from forbidden food has no ascent. He then turns to one sin which the Shulchan Aruch in Even HaEzer, siman 23, calls the worst in the Torah, wasted seed. Even so, he says, its repair is more accessible, even nowadays, without waiting for the days of Moshiach or for teshuvah out of love. b
Male and female in kedushah and klipah
To explain this, the Rav sets out that both kedushah and klipah have a male and a female aspect. In kedushah the Name Havayah is the male, the giver, and the Name Adnus, as it is pronounced, is the female, the receiver; their union brings down holy bounty, and Amen equals both Names together, 91. Every chassan and kallah, he adds, become a seat for these two Names.
Whatever Hashem made in kedushah has its counterpart in tumah, and there too there is a male and a female force, whose names the Rav does not want to utter in full. Yaakov's gift to Esav came to 580 animals, the numerical value of that force; sent from the side of kedushah, it neutralized Esav's power. c
Influence without a receiver
Every sin, like every mitzvah, brings down bounty through a giver and a receiver. In all forbidden relations there is both, but wasted seed is influence with no receiver. So although it casts holy seed to tumah, it was never absorbed, and it is easy to gather it back to kedushah.
The Rav relates that the Ohr HaChaim, in Parshas Vayechi, dreamt he fought the Sitra Achra as two dogs: he overcame the male at once, but the female he threw down without nullifying her fully, for there the female is stronger. So too Rashi notes that Esav put his wives first, while Yaakov put the males first. d,e,f
The nations, their angel, and the left side
From here the Rav digresses. Each of the seventy nations has a ruling angel above, and its people follow his order by intuition without knowing why. So among the nations it is ladies first, while for Jews the male goes first. They button left over right, the side of Sama"el; Jews button right over left, and they write left to right while Jews start from the right, from chesed.
The Arabs, the refuse of Avraham's chesed, write right to left and count by the moon alone, the white of chesed, never adding a month, so Ramadan wanders through the seasons. Jews blend moon and sun, adding a second Adar so that Nisan falls in spring.
Teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime
Returning to the Tanya, the Rav says wasted seed can be gathered back with teshuvah and with Krias Shema at bedtime. Of the Shemas said each day, he notes, this is the weakest and yet the strongest. The Torah never writes it as a prohibition, though Er and Onan died for it; Rav Tzadok in Tzidkas HaTzaddik explains that it often comes involuntarily, and Hashem does not make a sin of what a person cannot control. a,h,g
Forbidden relations and a mamzer
Forbidden relations, the Rav continues, fortify the klipah more, because the energy is caught by its female side. Ordinary teshuvah does not help there, unless it is so great that sins become merits; then even forbidden relations are like eating forbidden meat.
But what is warped cannot be repaired: if a mamzer was born, even great teshuvah cannot raise that energy, which has become a person. The seforim hakedoshim say that with a truly great teshuvah the mamzer dies and the repair is complete; the Tanya does not say this because it speaks of the mechanics of teshuvah, and Hashem may still grant the full repair. j
Hashem's ways above the order of judgment
The mamzer's death, the Rav explains, is like execution by beis din, which is a merit for the soul. The neshamah in a mamzer, though it comes from a Jew, suffers, as a neshamah suffers in a cat, and through the teshuvah it is released.
Yet no computer can figure out Hashem's ways. At times He purifies a mamzer and keeps him alive; the Rav speaks of Lot's daughters, whose intent was for the world's survival, and Moshiach comes from there. What was said until now is Hashem's order of judgment, like laws of nature, but He reserves the right to rise above it, and He will bring the geulah even if Jews do not do teshuvah.
Every sin is separation
Answering a question, the Rav explains that the essence of every sin is separation: the Sitra Achra claims to be an entity of its own, and the verse in Tehillim calls evildoers those who separate. Division was created on the second day, departing from the oneness of the first; the greater the tumah, the wider the separation. k
Tanya chapter 8: no brachah on forbidden food
Beginning chapter 8 of the Tanya, the Rav urges anyone who misses a chapter to hear it, since each builds on the one before, up the hill without skipping rungs. Forbidden food, he explains, is tied down with chains, more than taught last week: even eaten unknowingly, for the sake of Heaven, its energy cannot ascend through the Torah and tefillah it fuels, unlike permitted food; even a rabbinic prohibition, since the words of the Sofrim are more stringent. m
The Tzemach Tzedek in his glosses on the Tanya uses this to explain why no brachah is made on forbidden food. The Gemara says one who steals wheat and bakes it is not blessing but provoking, and the Shulchan Aruch follows. A brachah, the Tzemach Tzedek explains, elevates the holy sparks in the food; when they cannot rise, there is no brachah. n,o,p
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- l Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 41:34
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 7 index In the write-up: 22:18
- b apparently Shulchan Aruch Even HaEzer 23 index In the write-up: 2:12
- d Ohr HaChaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:13
- g Tzidkas HaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:18
- m apparently Tanya ch. 8 index In the write-up: 43:42
- p Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:11
- q Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 50:38
Other
Key points
- 3:56 Wasted seed is the gravest sin, yet its repair is accessible even now, without waiting for the days of Moshiach or for teshuvah out of love.
- 4:38 Every flow of bounty, in kedushah and in the Sitra Achra alike, needs a giver and a receiver, a male and a female aspect.
- 10:20 Because wasted seed is influence without a receiver, the holy energy thrown to impurity was not absorbed and can be gathered back to kedushah.
- 22:18 The repair comes through teshuvah and Krias Shema at bedtime, which the Rav calls the weakest of the daily recitals of Shema and yet the strongest.
- 28:21 Forbidden relations are harder to repair, because the energy is held by the female side of the klipah; a mamzer cannot be undone by the mechanics of teshuvah.
- 39:03 The essence of every sin is separation from Hashem's oneness, and the repair of tumas keri is to believe that nothing is mere chance.
- 48:11 Following the Tzemach Tzedek, the Rav explains that no brachah is made on forbidden food because a brachah elevates the holy sparks in food, and forbidden food has no ascent.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:00 If wasted seed is the worst sin, why is its repair so accessible?
Answer: 10:20 Because it is influence without a receiver: the female side of the klipah did not absorb it, so it can be gathered back to kedushah.
-
Question: 23:17 Why does the Torah never write wasted seed as an explicit prohibition?
Answer: 24:13 Because it is in a different category; or, as Rav Tzadok says, because it often comes involuntarily, and Hashem does not make a sin of what a person cannot control.
-
Question: 30:23 Why can the mechanics of teshuvah not repair a mamzer?
Answer: 31:05 Because the energy has already become a person; unlike other sins it cannot turn into merits, though the seforim say a great teshuvah causes the mamzer to die and the repair to be complete.
-
Question: 48:34 Why may one not make a brachah on forbidden food eaten unknowingly?
Answer: 49:41 The Tzemach Tzedek explains that a brachah serves to elevate the holy sparks in the food, and the sparks in forbidden food cannot ascend.
Stories
-
11:13 The Ohr HaChaim's dream of two dogs
The Rav relates that the Ohr HaChaim, in Parshas Vayechi, tells of a dream in which he confronted the Sitra Achra in the form of two dogs, a male and a female. He overcame the male very quickly. With the female he had a great struggle; he threw her down but could not nullify her completely, because in the Sitra Achra the female is stronger than the male.
In the story: the Ohr HaChaim
Insights
- 10:40 The gravity of a sin and the ease of its repair are separate questions: wasted seed is the worst sin, yet because its influence found no receiver, it can be gathered back more easily than forbidden relations.
- 7:52 Yaakov's gift to Esav totaled 580 animals, the numerical value of Esav's force in the Sitra Achra with its female counterpart, so sending it from the side of kedushah neutralized that force.
- 14:29 The customs of the nations, like putting the woman first, buttoning left over right and writing left to right, follow unknowingly from their angel's left-sided order, while Jews start from the right.
- 19:00 The Jewish calendar blends the moon of chesed with the sun of din through the leap month, unlike the Arabs' purely lunar calendar of uncontrolled chesed, so Nisan always falls in spring.
- 41:32 Tumas keri is linked by the Midrash to Amalek's 'chance', so its repair, as Rav Tzadok says, is faith in Hashem's oneness, that nothing simply happens.
- 49:41 Following the Tzemach Tzedek, the halachah that no brachah is said on forbidden food rests on the inner purpose of a brachah: to elevate the holy sparks, which forbidden food cannot release.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 22:18 The Rav says that wasted seed can be gathered back with teshuvah and with Krias Shema at bedtime.
- 43:05 The Rav says the repair of tumas keri is to believe in Hashem's oneness, that there is no mere chance.
- 44:00 The Rav strongly recommends that whoever misses a chapter of Tanya hear it on tape, since each chapter builds on the one before.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Amalek, Avraham Avinu, Esav, Haman, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Raavad, the Rambam, the Taz, the Tzemach Tzedek, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms זכר ונקבה, זרע לבטלה, מאכלות אסורות, סטרא אחרא, פירוד, קליפה, קריאת שמע, שם אדנות, שם הוי"ה, שנה מעוברת, שר של מעלה