הסבר על מה שקורא התניא למצוות דרבנן דברי סופרים. חילוק בין שידין נוכראין ושידין יהודאין. עונש דברים בטלים' ומאכלי תאווה.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ח no. ⁨19⁩ Pocket Guide p. 74 English 52 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 52 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains why the Tanya calls rabbinic laws 'divrei soferim', how the Chachamim saw the root of every letter of the Torah, and then the Tanya's distinction between non-Jewish and Jewish shedim and the punishments for forbidden food, food of desire and idle talk.

The Rav opens by noting that the Tanya treats a rabbinic prohibition as coming from the klipos, and that it calls the Rabbis 'soferim', after the Gemara that the early sages counted the letters of the Torah. To them every letter was a 'davar shebeminyan', something important in itself, because they saw the root of the Torah; Rabbi Akiva expounded even the crowns of the letters, and Rabbi Meir could write a Megillah by heart because he copied from the Torah's root in heaven. From there he speaks of tzaddikim who read the Torah in the world itself, and of turning the ayin of 'kosnos or' and of the forest swine into an aleph. Returning to Tanya chapter eight, he explains the two kinds of shedim, the severity of chalav akum, two stories about it, and the punishments the sefarim describe for food eaten from desire and for idle talk.

Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Kashrus and Kedushas HaAchilah · Kedushah and Kelipah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why rabbinic laws are 'divrei soferim' listed in the guide

    After a quick review of the text, the Rav notes that the Tanya treats a rabbinic prohibition as coming from the klipah, stresses how precise the Tanya is in every word, and brings the Gemara that the early sages were called soferim because they counted the letters. He introduces the idea of a 'davar shebeminyan', using potatoes and oranges to explain it.

  2. 5:31 Every letter is a root listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that ordinary learning needs a phrase that carries a thought, while the Chachamim expounded single letters, and Rabbi Akiva even the crowns on the letters. A letter teaches as the root of a tree feeds its fruit, and the Chachamim could see everything contained in that root.

  3. 9:00 Rabbi Meir and reading the Torah in the world listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara that a Sefer Torah may not be written by heart, and asks how Rabbi Meir wrote a Megillah by heart; he answers that Rabbi Meir saw the Torah's root in heaven. Since the world was created through the Torah, tzaddikim could read the Torah in the world, and he tells of a tzaddik who looked at a cut apple every motzaei Shabbos.

  4. 14:44 Turning the ayin into an aleph listed in the guide

    From the garments of skin given to Adam and Chava, the Rav explains that the inner point was 'or' with an aleph, light, and that a Jew's work is to turn the ayin into an aleph. He applies this to the suspended ayin in 'chazir miyaar' and to the middle of Tehillim, where the impure can become pure, after a disclaimer that he speaks of matters above his own level.

  5. 21:46 Shedim and refined speech listed in the guide

    The Rav returns to the Tanya: the Rabbis see the root, so they know a rabbinic prohibition comes from the klipos. He reads the Tanya's words that a desire for forbidden food is a shed of the non-Jewish shedim, and explains why refined Jews avoid saying the word 'shed' and speak in refined language, because what a person says is drawn upon him.

  6. 26:55 Non-Jewish and Jewish shedim; the Russian censor listed in the guide

    The Rav defines the two kinds: the shedim nukhraim stir a desire for what is forbidden, while the shedim yehudaim stir a desire for something kosher but unnecessary. Noting that the passage was altered by the censor, he digresses on how Russian censors changed words in seforim, Gemaras and siddurim.

  7. 31:19 Why chalav akum is worse than chazir listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that a desire from the shedim yehudaim can return to holiness through teshuvah or through Torah and avodah, while the shedim nukhraim reach the root of the goy. Therefore chalav akum is in one sense worse than chazir, and he brings the Tzemach Tzedek that chalav akum, chametz on Pesach and niddah touch that root and can block a Jew's readiness for mesiras nefesh.

  8. 36:08 The old wine merchant in Tosafos Story listed in the guide

    The Rav says that in recent generations people who ate these things lost their readiness for mesiras nefesh. He brings Tosafos' story of an old man who drank wine a goy had touched only to cause him a loss, relying on the ruling that this is not yayin nesech, and who was later killed; the Rav explains that his death al kiddush Hashem showed his ruling was correct.

  9. 39:40 Chalav akum, doubts in emunah, and Rav Moshe's milk Story listed in the guide

    The Rav tells of a man who complained to the Ba'al HaTanya about doubts in emunah and was told it came from drinking chalav akum. He mentions the dispute over supervised milk in America and tells how Rav Moshe Feinstein, who was lenient for others, vomited up milk without a hechsher served to him. He adds that teshuvah helps, yet until then the thing still tilts toward the other side.

  10. 43:13 The residue of food eaten from desire listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that food eaten only for enjoyment leaves a residue even if one then learns with its strength, comparing it to dust on a mattress that must be beaten out; the musar sefarim call this the beating in the grave, while forbidden food is a real stain that needs the laundering of Gehinnom. Only someone like Rebbi, who had no pleasure from this world, is spared, and he tells of a tzaddik who made a siyum every day so that every meal was a seudas mitzvah.

  11. 48:44 The punishment for idle talk listed in the guide

    The Rav describes a lighter punishment the sefarim give for idle talk, in which the soul is thrown back and forth. He distinguishes the talmid chacham, who is asked why he did not speak words of Torah, from the am haaretz, who is asked why he enjoyed this world, which was made only for the service of Hashem.

The shiur, written up

Why rabbinic laws are 'divrei soferim'

2:11

After a quick review of the text in Tanya chapter eight, the Rav notes that the Tanya holds a rabbinic prohibition to be a real prohibition, carrying the life-force of the klipah. The Tanya, he stresses, is exact in every word; the Ba'al HaTanya went back and forth for six months over whether to add a single vav. a

3:43

The Tanya calls the Rabbis 'soferim', a term from the Gemara: the early sages were called soferim because they counted the letters of the Torah. Counting alone does not make one a sofer, so the Rav explains the idea of a 'davar shebeminyan': an orange sold by count is important and is not nullified, while a potato sold by the pound is. b

Every letter is a root

5:53

Normally a word alone carries no thought; one needs a phrase. The Chachamim, though, expounded extra or missing letters, and Rabbi Akiva expounded even the thin crowns on the letters. To them every letter was a davar shebeminyan, because a letter is like the root of a tree: it is not the apple, yet it is its very source. c

Rabbi Meir and reading the Torah in the world

9:03

The Rav brings the Gemara that a Sefer Torah written by heart is invalid even without mistakes, since it must be copied from a text, and asks how Rabbi Meir could write a Megillah by heart. He answers that every word of the Torah corresponds to delicate lights rooted in heaven, which become letters on the way down; Rabbi Meir saw that root and was copying from it. d

11:47

Since the world was created with the Torah as its blueprint, tzaddikim could read the Torah in a tree or a leaf. He tells of a tzaddik who every motzaei Shabbos cut an apple across and saw a star of ten points, the ten utterances of creation, which gave him strength for the week.

Turning the ayin into an aleph

15:00

Hashem made Adam and Chava garments of skin, and the Zohar calls it the snake's skin. After cautioning that one should not speak of things above his level and that he is only describing how tzaddikim act, the Rav explains that inwardly it remained 'or' with an aleph, light. A Jew's work is to turn the ayin into an aleph: with an aleph it is holiness, with an ayin impurity. e,g

17:54

Esav is compared to a chazir, and in 'chazir miyaar' the ayin is suspended, as Rashi notes, as if it could be replaced with an aleph. The aleph is the Master of the world; one who sees it inside the ayin sweetens all impurity. This ayin is the middle of Tehillim, and the center, the point of origin, is where things can be changed. h,i,j

Shedim and refined speech

21:59

Returning to the Tanya, the Rav asks how it knows a rabbinic prohibition comes from the klipos and is not just a warning around the Torah law. The Rabbis look into the root of things and read even the letters of the Torah, so they know. He then reads that a desire for forbidden food is a shed of the non-Jewish shedim. a

23:47

Refined Jews avoid saying the word 'shed', because what a person speaks is drawn upon him; chassidishe Jews likewise speak with refined words about eating or sleeping. Someone who wants a pure mind, he says, will rather think of something that only suggests an impure thing.

Non-Jewish and Jewish shedim

27:01

The shedim nukhraim are the desire for what is forbidden. The shedim yehudaim are a desire for something kosher but unnecessary: a Jewish desire, not truly a goy's. a

27:54

The Rav notes that this passage was censored, since the Tanya was printed in Russia, where censors were usually apostate Jews with little knowledge who made odd mistakes. Their changes appear in printed Gemaras and old siddurim, while fathers taught their children the true wording.

Why chalav akum is worse than chazir

31:57

A desire from the shedim yehudaim can return to holiness through teshuvah, or by using its strength for Torah and avodah. The shedim nukhraim reach the root of the goy, so chalav akum is in a sense worse than chazir: chazir is only chazir, while chalav akum carries the connection to the goy who milked it.

34:43

Every Jew is ready to give his life against avodah zarah, but the Tzemach Tzedek writes that one who eats chalav akum, chametz on Pesach, or is with a niddah is connected to the goy's root. Chametz is like avodah zarah, as the juxtaposed verses show, and such a person clouds the Jewish point in himself. l,m

The old wine merchant in Tosafos

36:10

That is why, in recent generations, people who ate such things lacked mesiras nefesh. Tosafos tells of an old wine merchant whose barrel a goy touched to cause him a loss; he drank from it, holding it was not yayin nesech, and was later killed. The Rav explains Tosafos mentions this as proof: had the wine been forbidden, he would not have merited to die al kiddush Hashem. n

Chalav akum and doubts in emunah

39:46

A man complained to the Ba'al HaTanya that doubts in emunah gave him no rest, and was told that he must have drunk chalav akum. The Rav mentions Rav Moshe Feinstein's view on supervised milk in America and tells how Rav Moshe, served unsupervised milk by a talmid, made himself vomit it up: lenient for others, strict for himself. Teshuvah helps, but until then the thing tilts the other way. o

The residue of food eaten from desire

43:41

Food eaten only for pleasure, even if one learns with its strength, leaves a residue. Correcting his first image of a stain, the Rav compares it to dust on a mattress, which stays on the surface and is beaten out. The musar sefarim, Maseches Gehinnom and Reishis Chochmah, describe angels beating a person in the grave: chibbut hakever. r,s

47:19

Forbidden food is a real stain, needing the hot laundering of Gehinnom. Only one like Rebbi, who raised his ten fingers to show he had no pleasure from this world, is spared; one tzaddik made a siyum daily so every meal was a seudas mitzvah. t

The punishment for idle talk

49:39

For idle talk there is a lighter punishment, in which angels throw the soul back and forth. A talmid chacham is asked why he did not speak words of Torah; an am haaretz, who perhaps cannot learn, is asked why he enjoyed this world, which was made only for the service of Hashem.

Sources

Torah

  1. e Bereishis 3:21 text index In the write-up: 15:00
  2. m Shemos 34:17-18 text index In the write-up: 34:43

Kesuvim

  1. i Tehillim 80:14 text index In the write-up: 17:54

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Kiddushin 30a text index In the write-up: 3:43
  2. c Menachos 29b text index In the write-up: 5:53
  3. d Megillah 18b text index In the write-up: 9:03
  4. t Kesubos 104a text index In the write-up: 47:19

Midrash

  1. f Midrash (place not identified) 14:46
  2. k apparently Midrash Tehillim 1:2 20:28 index

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. g Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:00

Rishonim

  1. h apparently Rashi on Bereishis 26:34 index In the write-up: 17:54
  2. j apparently Rashi on Tehillim 80:14 index In the write-up: 17:54
  3. n Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:10

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Tanya ch. 8 text index In the write-up: 2:11, 21:59, 27:01
  2. l Derech Mitzvosecha (place not identified) index In the write-up: 34:43
  3. q Chasam Sofer (place not identified) 40:42 index
  4. s Reishis Chochmah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 43:41

Other

  1. o Igros Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 39:46
  2. p Pri Chadash (place not identified) 40:42 index
  3. r Maseches Gehinnom (place not identified) index In the write-up: 43:41

Key points

  1. 2:11 The Rav explains that the Tanya holds a rabbinic prohibition draws its life from the klipah, and that the Rabbis know this because they see into the root of things.
  2. 7:39 He teaches that to the Chachamim each single letter of the Torah was a 'davar shebeminyan', a thing of importance, because every letter taught them new halachos.
  3. 10:17 Rabbi Meir could write a Megillah by heart because he saw the Torah's root in heaven and was in effect copying from a written text.
  4. 16:57 The Rav describes the Jew's task as turning the ayin into an aleph: seeing the Master of the world inside what looks like impurity, which sweetens it.
  5. 27:03 Shedim nukhraim are the desire for forbidden things, while shedim yehudaim are a desire for permitted things that are not needed; the latter can be raised back to holiness through teshuvah or through using the strength for Torah and avodah.
  6. 43:41 Food eaten only for pleasure leaves a residue even when its strength is used for learning, and the sefarim describe a purging in the grave for it; idle talk brings a different, lighter punishment.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 3:26 Why does the Tanya call rabbinic laws 'divrei soferim'?

    Answer: 7:39 Because the Rabbis counted the letters of the Torah: to them every single letter was a 'davar shebeminyan' that taught new halachos, since they saw the root of the Torah.

  2. Question: 9:26 How could Rabbi Meir write a Megillah by heart, when it must be copied from a written text?

    Answer: 10:20 He saw the root of the Torah in heaven, so he was copying from that writing.

  3. Question: 22:08 How does the Tanya know that a rabbinic prohibition comes from the klipos, and is not merely a warning to keep away from the Torah prohibition?

    Answer: 22:18 The Rabbis look into the root of things and read even the letters of the Torah, so they know.

  4. Question: 33:28 Which is worse, chalav akum or chazir?

    Answer: 33:37 Chalav akum, because besides being forbidden it carries a connection to the goy, which reaches the root of the shedim nukhraim.

  5. Question: 38:29 Why does Tosafos mention that the old man was later killed?

    Answer: 38:38 To prove his ruling: had the wine been true yayin nesech he would not have merited to give his life al kiddush Hashem.

  6. Question: 51:28 Why is idle talk judged differently for a talmid chacham and an am haaretz?

    Answer: 51:36 The talmid chacham is asked why he did not speak words of Torah; the am haaretz, who may be unable to learn, is asked why he enjoyed this world, which was made only for the service of Hashem.

Stories

  1. 13:06 The tzaddik and the apple on motzaei Shabbos

    The Rav tells that he saw in a sefer the day before about a great tzaddik who, every motzaei Shabbos, took an apple, cut it across its width and looked at it. Cut that way, an apple shows a star with ten points, which corresponds to the ten utterances of creation. Leaving the spiritual world of Shabbos for the physical weekday, he saw the ten utterances in a physical thing, and that gave him strength to start the new week.

  2. 36:56 The old man and the wine the goy touched

    Tosafos brings a story of an old man, a wine merchant, who had a large barrel of wine he needed for his livelihood. A goy stuck his hand into the wine in order to make it forbidden and cause the Jew a loss. The old man took some of the wine and drank it, relying on the ruling that touching done only to cause damage does not make it yayin nesech. Tosafos adds that this old man was later killed.

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  3. 39:40 The Ba'al HaTanya and the man with doubts

    A man came to the Ba'al HaTanya and complained that he could not free himself from doubts in emunah, which gave him no rest. The Ba'al HaTanya told him that he had surely drunk chalav akum, which causes doubts in emunah because it goes to the root of the shedim.

    In the story: the Ba'al HaTanya

  4. 40:59 Rav Moshe Feinstein and the cup of milk

    Rav Moshe Feinstein once visited a talmid, who offered him a cup of milk. After tasting it he found out that the milk had no hechsher and asked why he was given it; the talmid answered that the Rav himself had permitted it in the Igros Moshe. Rav Moshe answered that he had said one may be lenient, but he himself does not do so, and he went and made himself vomit up the milk. The Rav notes that Rav Moshe was lenient for others but strict with himself.

    In the story: Rav Moshe Feinstein

  5. 48:21 The tzaddik who made a siyum every day

    The Rav tells of tzaddikim who were careful that all their eating be in holiness. One never ate a meal unless it was a seudas mitzvah, so he managed to complete a masechta every day and ate his meal as the meal of the siyum.

Insights

  1. 7:43 The Rav reads the Tanya's term 'divrei soferim' for rabbinic law as a claim about the Rabbis' vision: because single letters were 'davar shebeminyan' to them, they saw the root of things and could know that a rabbinic prohibition draws from the klipos and is not merely a fence.
  2. 10:17 Rabbi Meir's writing a Megillah by heart did not break the rule of copying from a text, because he saw the Torah's root in heaven and copied from it.
  3. 16:52 The difference between 'or' with an ayin, skin, and 'or' with an aleph, light, describes the whole avodah of a Jew: to see the aleph, the Master of the world, inside the ayin, which sweetens all impurity.
  4. 21:12 The suspended ayin of 'chazir miyaar' stands at the middle of Tehillim because the center, the point of origin, is the place where things can be changed, so even the swine, the counterpart of the serpent, can turn from ayin to aleph there.
  5. 33:30 Chalav akum can be worse than chazir: chazir is forbidden only as itself, while chalav akum carries a connection to the goy, which reaches the root of the shedim nukhraim.
  6. 38:29 Tosafos records that the old man who drank the wine was later killed in order to prove his point: had the wine truly been yayin nesech, he would not have merited to give his life al kiddush Hashem.
  7. 46:07 Food eaten for pleasure is like dust on a mattress that stays on the surface and is beaten out, while forbidden food is absorbed like a real stain that needs the hot laundering of Gehinnom.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 26:16 The Rav says that one who wants to keep his mind pure will not even think about impure things directly, but rather about something that only suggests them, as tzaddikim behave.
  2. 52:08 The Rav says this world was not made for enjoyment, but only for the service of Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adam HaRishon, Chava, Esav, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rashi, Rav Moshe Feinstein, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Tzemach Tzedek

Terms דברים בטלים, חיבוט הקבר, חלב עכו"ם, יין נסך, כתנות אור, מאכלות אסורות, מסירות נפש, קליפה, שורש, תגין

Report an error on this page