צדיק ורע לו - עוד יש לו שייכות אל הרע. “ראיתי בני עליה והמה מועטים” - זה צדיק וטוב לו. ביאור ענין יחוד קובהו"ש.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י no. 24 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 48 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapters 10 and 11, the Rav explains the levels of tzaddikim, why the highest are called 'bnei aliyah', the meaning of uniting Hashem with the Shechinah, and the many levels of the 'rasha v'tov lo'.
The Rav continues Tanya chapter 10. A tzaddik who never sins but keeps a tiny residue of evil is a 'tzaddik she'eino gamur', and this level divides into countless levels; these are the 18,000 tzaddikim of the Gemara. Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai's 'bnei aliyah', who are few, transformed their evil into good. The Tanya gives a second reason for the name: they serve only for Hashem's need, not even to quench their own thirst for closeness. The Rav explains 'l'shem yichud': the Shechinah in Klal Yisrael is the kallah, Hashem the chassan, and the tzaddik reunites them. He develops the pattern of mashpia and mekabel in creation, the Sitra Achra's temporary snatching of a destined union, Eretz Yisrael, and David and Bathsheba. Then, in chapter 11, he explains the 'rasha v'tov lo', why a thought of sin can be worse than a sin, and the many levels of this rasha.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Shechinah and Galus HaShechinah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The 18,000 tzaddikim and the few bnei aliyah listed in the guide
The Rav reviews the tzaddik gamur and the tzaddik who still carries a dormant trace of evil, whose level divides into countless levels. He brings the Gemara's 18,000 tzaddikim and Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai's statement that the bnei aliyah are few, and resolves them: the 18,000 still have a trace of evil, while Rabbi Shimon had none.
-
5:29 Turning darkness into light listed in the guide
The Rav explains the first reason for the name bnei aliyah: they raise and transform their evil into good. He brings the Zohar about Rabbi Chiya, who could not enter Rabbi Shimon's chamber without having turned darkness into light, and notes that the Tanya, which calls itself a book for beinonim, describes this level only so the reader knows what he is not.
-
9:03 L'shem yichud: uniting chassan and kallah listed in the guide
The Rav describes the tzaddik who does nothing for himself, not even for Gan Eden or his own attachment to the Shechinah, and explains 'l'shem yichud': the Shechinah in Klal Yisrael is the kallah, Hashem the chassan, and through mitzvos the tzaddik reunites them and relieves the Shechinah of its exile. He reads 'chassid mitchased im kono' as kindness to Hashem's nest, and explains that acting for oneself would mean ego.
-
15:01 For Hashem's need, not to quench a thirst listed in the guide
Reading the Tanya's text, the Rav explains that the bnei aliyah serve for the need above, not to quench their own thirst for Hashem as in the passuk 'Hoy kol tzamei'. He brings the Tikkunei Zohar on the chassid and the Raya Mehemna's parable of a son who gives his life for his parents, then sums up the two explanations of bnei aliyah and notes that the Tanya's bracketed Kabbalistic passage unites them.
-
20:53 Mashpia and mekabel throughout creation listed in the guide
To explain the yichud, the Rav shows that all of creation comes as giver and receiver, sun and moon, day and night, as a parable for Hashem and Knesses Yisrael. The Sitra Achra tries to block this union and at times snatches the kallah away, but only temporarily, like a destined match taken by another, and like Eretz Yisrael, first held by Canaan and then returned to Klal Yisrael.
-
25:42 David, Bathsheba and the hidden union listed in the guide
The Rav explains that David and Bathsheba were the destined match of Adam and Chavah and the true parable of Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, from whom Moshiach comes through Shlomo, and that David's desire was spiritual. Asked why it came about in such a roundabout way, he answers that the Satan always tries to block Moshiach's coming, so it is hidden, like a diamond hidden in a garbage can, and he says these pesukim cannot be understood at the surface level.
-
31:21 Chapter 11: the rasha v'tov lo
The Rav reviews the levels learned so far and begins chapter 11 on the rasha v'tov lo: at the moment he sins his good is subordinate to the kelipah in the left chamber of the heart, yet he is no complete rasha, since his yetzer tov remains strong. This too divides into countless levels, the lightest being one whose evil overcomes him only rarely and briefly in a small matter.
-
37:05 Why a thought of sin is worse than a sin
The Rav explains why thoughts of sin can in a sense be worse than the sin itself: thought reaches far higher than speech and action, so it brings impurity into a higher sphere. He illustrates with a grease spot that is nothing on the street but disgraceful in the king's palace, mentions wasting free time that could be used for Torah, and explains that at the moment of such a lapse the person is a rasha v'tov lo until his good prevails.
-
43:14 Many levels of the rasha v'tov lo
The Rav describes a lower rasha v'tov lo who sins several times a day, like one who learns, davens and gives tzedakah but habitually speaks lashon hara, and brings Chazal that reshaim are full of regret. He stresses that no one is sold to the yetzer hara beyond return, and closes that every person has a deep chamber in the heart that is a tzaddik gamur, which truly means 'l'shem yichud'.
The shiur, written up
The 18,000 tzaddikim and the few bnei aliyah
Continuing Tanya chapter 10, the Rav reviews two levels: the tzaddik gamur, who has transformed his yetzer hara entirely, and the tzaddik who never sins but keeps a dormant residue of evil, 'in remission'. Since evil stems from the four elements, this second level divides into tens of thousands of levels. a
Turning darkness into light
They are called bnei aliyah because they raise their evil to holiness. The Rav brings the Zohar's introduction: when Rabbi Chiya sought to enter Rabbi Shimon's chamber, a voice declared that only one who had turned darkness into light and bitterness into sweetness could enter. The Ba'al HaTanya, who on the title page calls his work a book for beinonim, describes this level only so the reader knows what he is not. d,e
L'shem yichud: uniting chassan and kallah
The second reason concerns a tzaddik who does nothing for himself: not for Olam Haba, not for Gan Eden, not even to be united with the Shechinah, but only for Hashem's need. To explain, the Rav turns to the 'l'shem yichud' said before a mitzvah. The Shechinah, Hashem's presence dwelling in Knesses Yisrael below, is the kallah and Hashem the chassan, and sins separate them.
The Shechinah is in exile, sustaining even the wicked. By doing mitzvos below, the tzaddik does kindness to it and gives it a proper nest. The Rav reads 'chassid ha'mitchased im kono' as kindness with Hashem's nest. Such a tzaddik is entirely nullified to Hashem; acting for himself would mean ego and a separation.
For Hashem's need, not to quench a thirst
The Tanya's words say the service of the bnei aliyah is for the need above, not to quench their own thirst for Hashem. The passuk 'Hoy kol tzamei', the Rav says, speaks of great tzaddikim who satisfy that thirst through closeness to Him. The ben aliyah has the thirst, but does his mitzvos only for Hashem's sake. a,f
He brings the Tikkunei Zohar on the chassid who acts for Hashem's nest, and the Raya Mehemna, Moshe Rabbeinu's teachings in the Zohar, on Ki Seitzei: like a son who loves his parents more than himself and would give his life to redeem them. Summing up, bnei aliyah has two explanations, transforming evil and acting only for Hashem, which the Ba'al HaTanya's bracketed Kabbalistic passage unites; the Rav does not go into it. g,h
Mashpia and mekabel throughout creation
To explain the yichud, the Rav brings the Zohar that the last of the ten utterances is that each person should have his match. All creation comes as giver and receiver: sun and moon, as in 'shemesh u'magen Hashem', day and night, even positive and negative in electricity. All are a parable for Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, the moon that has only what it receives. i,j
The Sitra Achra fights this union and sometimes snatches the kallah away, but only temporarily. A destined match may first go to another, yet must return; so Eretz Yisrael first went to Canaan and was then returned to Klal Yisrael.
David, Bathsheba and the hidden union
David HaMelech carried the soul of Adam, and Bathsheba was Chavah, his destined match; the Gemara in Sanhedrin calls her fitting for David. She was first with another, as Eretz Yisrael was first occupied. From this union of Hashem and Knesses Yisrael comes Moshiach, through Shlomo, as the Rambam writes. David's desire was spiritual. k
Asked why it came about in such a roundabout way, the Rav answers that the Satan always tries to block Moshiach, so it is hidden, like a diamond hidden in a garbage can from a thief. The Gemara says whoever thinks David sinned is mistaken, and these pesukim cannot be understood at the surface. l
Chapter 11: the rasha v'tov lo
After reviewing the levels, the Rav notes that the questions of the first chapter are being answered one by one, and opens chapter 11 on the rasha v'tov lo. This is someone really a tzaddik who sometimes slips; at that moment his good is subordinate to the kelipah in the heart's left chamber, so he is a rasha, even if it happens once in ten years. m
Yet he is no complete rasha: his yetzer tov is still strong and he can do teshuvah. This also divides into countless levels by how much the good is subordinate; the lightest is one whose evil prevails only rarely and briefly, conquering a small part of the city.
Why a thought of sin is worse than a sin
The lapse may be only a thought of sin, which in a sense is worse than the sin. The deed is severe and carries punishment, but thought reaches far above speech and action, so it brings impurity into the higher world of thought. Someone with a grease spot on his jacket is fine on the avenue but liable before the king in his palace.
For punishment and teshuvah the deed may be worse, the Rav notes. Another lapse is wasting free time that could be used for Torah. This can happen even to a great person; at that moment he is a rasha v'tov lo, until his strong yetzer tov prevails and he does teshuvah.
Many levels of the rasha v'tov lo
A lower level sins several times a day, like one who learns, davens and gives tzedakah but habitually speaks lashon hara, and has thoughts of teshuvah in between. Chazal say the wicked are full of regret, and the levels range from once in ten years to several times an hour. No one is sold to the yetzer hara beyond return.
Every person has a deep chamber in his heart that is a tzaddik gamur, the Rav concludes, and when he says 'l'shem yichud', that chamber says it with all it implies.
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:43 A tzaddik who never sins but still has a dormant trace of evil is a tzaddik she'eino gamur, and the Rav identifies these with the Gemara's 18,000 tzaddikim.
- 5:13 The 'bnei aliyah' whom Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai called few are those who transformed their evil into good and raised it to holiness.
- 9:19 A second reason for the name is that the bnei aliyah do everything only for Hashem's need, not for themselves, not even to satisfy their own thirst for closeness to Him.
- 10:15 Doing a mitzvah 'l'shem yichud' means uniting the Shechinah dwelling in Klal Yisrael, the kallah, with Hashem, the chassan, and so relieving the Shechinah of its exile.
- 33:56 A 'rasha v'tov lo' is a person whose good is temporarily subordinate to his evil at the moment he sins, but whose strong yetzer tov will bring him to teshuvah.
- 45:30 The rasha v'tov lo has countless levels, from one who slips once in ten years to one who sins several times a day and is full of regret.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:22 How can Rabbi Shimon say the bnei aliyah are very few, when the Gemara says 18,000 tzaddikim stand before Hashem?
Answer: 4:48 The 18,000 still have a tiny dormant trace of evil, while the bnei aliyah transformed their evil into good entirely.
-
Question: 5:58 Why are the highest tzaddikim called 'bnei aliyah'?
Answer: 7:33 First, because they raise their evil and transform it into good; second, because they do everything only for Hashem's need and nothing for themselves.
-
Question: 27:55 Why did David's union with Bathsheba, from which Moshiach would come, have to happen in such a roundabout way that looks like sin?
Answer: 28:36 The Satan always tries to block anything that leads to Moshiach, so it is hidden in an unlikely way, like a diamond hidden in a garbage can, until it is too late to interfere.
-
Question: 38:38 How can a thought of sin be worse than the sin itself, when the deed carries a severe punishment and the thought does not?
Answer: 38:55 Thought reaches far higher than speech and action, so it brings even a tiny impurity into the higher world of thought; in that respect it is worse, though for punishment and teshuvah the deed may be more severe.
Insights
- 4:50 The Rav resolves the apparent contradiction between the 18,000 tzaddikim before Hashem and Rabbi Shimon's 'bnei aliyah are few': the 18,000 still hold a tiny dormant trace of evil, while the bnei aliyah transformed it entirely.
- 12:41 He reads 'chassid ha'mitchased im kono' with 'kono' as 'his nest': the true chassid does kindness with Hashem's nest, the Shechinah in the lower world, giving it a proper place to rest.
- 9:39 Even the desire for closeness to Hashem, if served for its own sake, still points to the self; the ben aliyah has that thirst but does his mitzvos only for Hashem, since any act for himself would mean ego and a separation from Him.
- 23:48 The Sitra Achra can snatch a destined union only temporarily; the Rav sees this pattern in a person's match, in Eretz Yisrael first held by Canaan, and in Bathsheba first married to another before coming to David.
- 28:36 Because the Satan tries to block Moshiach's coming, everything leading to Moshiach comes about in a hidden, roundabout way, like a diamond hidden in a garbage can so the thief will not look there.
- 38:55 A thought of sin can be worse than the deed because thought reaches the higher world where speech and action cannot, like a small grease spot that is nothing on the avenue but an offense in the king's palace.
- 47:00 Every person has a deep chamber in his heart that is a tzaddik gamur, and when he says 'l'shem yichud' that chamber means it with all that it implies.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 47:00 The Rav says that when a person says 'l'shem yichud' before a mitzvah, the deep chamber of his heart, which is a tzaddik gamur, says it fully and truly.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Bas Sheva, Chava, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nasan HaNavi, Rabbi Chiya, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, Yehudah (son of Yaakov)
Terms ארבע יסודות, בינוני, זיווג, חלל השמאלי, יצר הרע, כנסת ישראל, לשם יחוד, מחשבות זרות, משפיע ומקבל, סטרא אחרא, צדיק גמור, צדיק ורע לו, רעיא מהימנא, שכינה