הקב"ה עוזר לבינוני - “כי יעמוד לימין אביון.” י"ג ביאור מאמר חז"ל "אפ' כל העולם וכו' היה בעיניך כרשע." בינוני כצדיק בעיתות רצון. ביאור ענין עתות רצון.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH no. 29 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 52 min
Listen
About this shiur
Starting from the beinoni who uproots every grudge against a fellow Jew, the Rav shows how the unity of Klal Yisrael reaches the level of keser on Yom Kippur and Purim, and then begins Tanya chapter thirteen: Hashem is the third judge who helps the beinoni.
The Rav finishes the Tanya's description of the beinoni, who rejects every grudge against another Jew and neutralizes anger with compassion, repaying bad with good as Yosef did with his brothers. He then asks how love for every Jew fits with loving Hashem with the whole heart, and answers that a Jew is a part of G-d and all souls are one. That collective soul, beyond the reach of sin, is keser: Moshe Rabbeinu, the half-shekel, the goral of Yom Kippur and of Purim. Haman drew on the keser of impurity, and Esther's counsel to gather all the Jews answered him with unity, which Purim renews through shared food. After explaining why Yosef tested his brothers, the Rav opens chapter thirteen: in the beinoni both inclinations are judges, and Hashem, the third judge, decides for the good.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Yisroel and Achdus
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The beinoni uproots grudges
The Rav continues the Tanya's account of the beinoni, who rejects any hatred or grudge against a Jew as soon as it surfaces. He explains that compassion neutralizes anger, and that one should repay those who wronged him with good.
-
5:34 Yosef's test with his brothers
The Zohar learns this from Yosef and his brothers. The Rav cites his father-in-law's explanation that the brothers' enmity was sent from Heaven so that Yosef would be tested whether he would bear a grudge, and that he passed it in their merit.
-
8:48 Can love be divided?
The Rav raises the question that love cannot be divided, so how can one love Hashem with all one's heart and also love every Jew. He answers that a Jew is a part of G-d and all Jews are one soul, and brings a sefer that ties the half-shekel to the skull.
-
12:40 The collective soul and Moshe Rabbeinu
Citing the Noam Elimelech, the Rav describes a height where all souls fuse into one, called Yisrael, which no sin can reach. Moshe Rabbeinu is that collective soul, and the half-shekel and the sockets made from it represent every Jew.
-
16:07 The goral of Yom Kippur and keser
The Rav brings the Mishnah that the two goats of Yom Kippur must be equal, and Rav Tzadok's explanation: at times Yaakov and Esav cannot be told apart, and only Hashem knows the hidden root where every Jew is a tzaddik. That level is keser, revealed on Yom Kippur and Purim through a goral.
-
22:54 Haman, Mordechai and the keser of impurity
The Rav explains that Parshandasa is the keser of the klipah and that Haman sought to fight Mordechai's keser of holiness, even preventing him from saying Shema. When Haman rose higher in impurity, Esther's counsel to gather all the Jews answered him with unity, and so he is called the 'binder' of the Jews.
-
30:55 Purim unity through food
The Rav contrasts the unity in Shushan alone with that of all the Jews on Purim. Using the eiruv, where shared food makes people one household, he explains that mishloach manos joins all of Klal Yisrael, just as a grudge spoils Yom Kippur.
-
35:37 Why Yosef tested his brothers
Returning to the Tanya, the Rav links Yosef to the power of unity and to the month of Adar. He then explains that Yosef pressed his brothers so their suffering would complete the repair of his sale, and that he could not hold back the few more moments needed.
-
43:32 Hashem, the third judge listed in the guide
Opening Tanya chapter thirteen, the Rav explains Chazal's saying that in the beinoni both inclinations judge: each voices an opinion, and Hashem, who stands at the right of the needy, is the deciding judge. He brings the Maggid Meisharim on the verse 'Hashem will not leave him in his hand'.
The shiur, written up
The beinoni uproots grudges
The Rav continues the Tanya's picture of the beinoni, the 'intermediate' person who has the potential for evil but ignores it. Whenever hatred, a grudge or resentment against another Jew rises in his mind, he refuses to accept it, rejects it and neutralizes it with love of Israel, since bearing hatred toward a Jew is itself a sin. a
The sefarim explain, the Rav says, that compassion neutralizes anger: if a person behaves badly, one should feel pity that he is so far from Hashem, and the hatred goes away. Likewise, one who is wronged should answer with good deeds and repay a bad turn with a good one.
Yosef's test with his brothers
The Zohar learns this from Yosef and his brothers. The Rav brings his father-in-law's explanation: Yosef told his brothers that the sale was arranged from Heaven to test whether he would bear them a grudge, and that it was in their merit that he passed. Hatred toward a Jew, the Rav adds, separates a person from Hashem. b
Can love be divided?
The Rav raises a question: love cannot be divided, and the Torah commands loving Hashem with the whole heart, so how can there be room to love another Jew? He answers that a Jew is a part of G-d above, so loving him is loving the G-dliness in him. Preferring one Jew over another comes from the body; from the side of the soul, all Jews are one soul. c,d
He adds from a sefer that each mitzvah strengthens one limb, and that the half-shekel is tied to the skull.
The collective soul and Moshe Rabbeinu
Citing the Noam Elimelech, the Rav describes a height at which all souls fuse into one, called Yisrael. It is the inner point of every Jew, and no sin reaches it. Moshe Rabbeinu, who the Gemara says was equal to six hundred thousand, is that collective soul. The sockets of the Mishkan, made from the half-shekel of all of Israel, represented every Jew, and Moshe is the 'skull' of Klal Yisrael. e,f
The goral of Yom Kippur and keser
This level, the Rav says, is revealed on Yom Kippur and on Purim. The Mishnah in Yoma requires the two goats of Yom Kippur to be identical, one for Hashem and one for Azazel. Rav Tzadok explains that there are times when Yaakov and Esav cannot be told apart, since Esav also does kind deeds; yet every Jew has a hidden root where he is a tzaddik, and only Hashem knows where it is. h
Of the Mishnah's ten levels of holiness, the highest is the Holy of Holies, which corresponds to keser, the crown above wisdom and understanding. The verse 'before Hashem you shall be purified' uses titharu, which equals keser in gematria. The goral, like the skull above the brain, is beyond understanding, and the miracle of Purim also came through a goral. i,j
Haman, Mordechai and the keser of impurity
Opposite holiness, the Rav explains, impurity also has a keser: Parshandasa, the first of Haman's sons. A Midrash says the gallows Haman built came from Parshandasa's house, which is why Haman could fight Mordechai's keser of holiness. The word Shema, with its enlarged ayin, equals keser in gematria, and the Midrash says Haman wanted to keep Mordechai from saying Shema. l,m
Bringing a sefer, the Rav says Mordechai stood higher in holiness than Haman in impurity, until Haman, on Zeresh's advice to build a gallows fifty cubits high, reached a level above him. Esther answered with 'go gather all the Jews': unity reaches the top of keser. That is why Haman is called tzorer haYehudim, from a root that means to bind; he made the Jews bind together. n,o,p
Purim unity through food
At the decree only the Jews of Shushan united, the Rav notes, but on Purim it was all the Jews. Food joins people: the Gemara says that where a person's eiruv is, there he lives, and one challah makes several families one household. Through mishloach manos, every person's meal comes from another's table, and all of Klal Yisrael becomes one. Just as a grudge spoils Yom Kippur, Purim is a day of unity. q,r
Why Yosef tested his brothers
Returning to the Tanya, the Rav finds it fitting that the Zohar learns forgiveness from Yosef and his brothers, since a sefer explains that Yosef's strength, the strength of unity, belongs to Adar, the month of Yosef. a,b
He then asks why Yosef caused his brothers such distress. Yosef wanted their suffering to complete the repair of the sin of his sale, the cause of the whole exile, so that the repair would come without chains. When Yehudah offered himself as a slave in place of Binyamin, the repair was nearly complete, but Yosef could not restrain himself a few moments longer. The verse saying so is, in the Rav's reading, the Torah's lament. s
Hashem, the third judge
The Rav now opens chapter thirteen with Chazal's saying that in tzaddikim the good inclination judges, in resha'im the evil one, and in beinonim both. A judge only states his opinion, like a court where one judge acquits and another convicts. The Tanya explains that Hashem, who stands at the right of the needy, is the deciding third judge. t,u,v
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
- n Esther 5:14 text index In the write-up: 28:35
- o Esther 4:16 text index In the write-up: 28:35
- p apparently Esther 9:24 index In the write-up: 28:35
- r Esther 9:22 text index In the write-up: 31:09
- v Tehillim 109:31 text index In the write-up: 43:36
- y Tehillim 37:32-33 text index In the write-up: 49:27
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 1:32 The beinoni lets no grudge against another Jew settle in his mind; he rejects it and neutralizes it with love of Israel and compassion.
- 10:02 Love for every Jew does not divide the love of Hashem, because a Jew's soul is a part of G-d and all Jewish souls are one.
- 12:58 There is a level, called keser, where all souls fuse into one and no sin reaches; Yom Kippur and Purim, both decided by a goral, come from there.
- 24:02 Haman drew on the keser of impurity, and Esther answered him with unity, gathering all the Jews, which reaches the top of keser in holiness.
- 43:59 In the beinoni both the good and the evil inclination are judges voicing opinions, and Hashem is the third judge who tips the scale toward the good.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 9:04 If love cannot be divided, how can one love Hashem with all one's heart and also love every Jew?
Answer: 10:02 A Jew is a part of G-d, so loving him is loving the G-dliness in him, and all Jews are one soul.
-
Question: 16:52 Why must the two goats of Yom Kippur be identical, when one is for Hashem and one for Azazel?
Answer: 17:25 Following Rav Tzadok, there are times when Yaakov and Esav look the same; only Hashem knows the hidden root where every Jew is a tzaddik, so it is decided by a goral.
-
Question: 29:47 How did Mordechai counter Haman once Haman had risen higher in impurity?
Answer: 30:07 Through Esther's counsel to gather all the Jews: unity reaches the top of keser.
-
Question: 36:50 Why did Yosef cause his brothers such distress?
Answer: 37:38 He wanted their suffering to complete the repair of the sin of his sale, so the exile would not be needed.
-
Question: 43:51 Why do Chazal call the evil inclination of the beinoni a judge, if it does not rule him?
Answer: 45:48 A judge only voices an opinion; with two judges disagreeing, Hashem is the third judge who decides.
Insights
- 7:33 The Rav cites his father-in-law: Yosef told his brothers that their enmity was arranged by Heaven to test whether he would bear a grudge, so it was through their merit that he passed the test.
- 10:34 Loving one Jew more than another is only from the side of the body; from the side of the soul all Jews are one soul, so love of Israel does not divide the love of Hashem.
- 21:13 The word titharu equals keser in gematria, and the goral, like the skull above the brain, is above understanding; both Yom Kippur and Purim come through a goral and reach keser.
- 26:10 Shema, with its enlarged ayin, equals keser in gematria, which is why Haman, drawing on the keser of impurity, wanted to stop Mordechai from saying Shema.
- 30:38 Haman is called tzorer haYehudim because tzorer means to bind: by threatening them he caused the Jews to unite against him.
- 33:29 Just as an eiruv makes several families one household through shared food, mishloach manos on Purim makes all of Klal Yisrael one table.
- 39:20 Yosef pressed his brothers so that their suffering would finish the repair of his sale; had he held back a few more moments the repair would have been complete, and the Torah's words that he could not restrain himself are a lament.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 2:56 The Rav says the best way to neutralize anger at someone is to have compassion on him for his bad state.
- 4:24 The Rav says that when someone does bad things to a person, he should respond by doing good things for him.
- 27:58 The Rav says that on Erev Yom Kippur one must forgive others and bear no grudge, so nothing interrupts the unity of Klal Yisrael.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Binyamin, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Parshandasa, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yosef HaTzaddik, Zeresh
Terms אהבת ישראל, אחדות, בינוני, גורל, חלל השמאלי, חלק אלוק ממעל, כתר, מחצית השקל, מכירת יוסף, משלוח מנות, קודש הקדשים, קליפה, תיקון