לבינוני אין לו כח לעקור הרע לגמרי אבל יכול י"ד לשלוט עליו בפועל ממש. ביאור איך העבירה הוא שטות. לבינוני יש תאוות לדברים גשמיים אבל מצד שורשו בקדושה הוא מואס ברע.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH no. ⁨30⁩ Pocket Guide p. 76 English 58 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 58 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that the beinoni's mind can rule over his yetzer hara in deed but cannot uproot it, except in times of revealed love between Hashem and the Jew, such as davening and the month of Adar.

The Rav continues the Tanya on the beinoni: he never sins, but the evil in the left chamber of the heart remains at full strength, and only Hashem's help lets him overcome it. This answers the Tanya's question from the first chapter: he is called 'like a rasha' because he could fall. He warns that the yetzer grows stronger with age and indulgence, and that constant learning is no sign it is gone. The mind rules the heart in thought, speech and deed, yet cannot expel the yetzer, except in times of revealed love, as in davening. From here he speaks of Hashem's hidden love for every Jew: the Ruzhiner's story, the father and son, the sin of the Golden Calf, and Purim, where the salvation was prepared at Achashverosh's party. He explains hester panim, the struggle of Yaakov and Esav, Yerushalayim and Rome, and Adar Sheni.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The beinoni and the three judges listed in the guide

    The Rav reviews the difference between the tzaddik, who has eliminated his yetzer hara, and the beinoni, whose yetzer remains at full strength in the left chamber of the heart. He explains that Hashem is the third judge who stands at the right of the 'pauper' and gives him the added strength to win.

  2. 4:47 Why the beinoni is 'like a rasha' listed in the guide

    The Rav shows how this answers the Tanya's question from the first chapter: why someone who never sins should see himself 'like a rasha'. Since the yetzer is fully present, he could fall, so he must not believe those who call him a tzaddik.

  3. 8:07 The yetzer grows stronger with age listed in the guide

    The Rav stresses the importance of the years of youth with the mashal of grapes and of a young sapling, and explains that indulgence makes a person coarser as he ages. Even constant learning for the sake of the mitzvah is no sign that the yetzer has left.

  4. 12:32 The mind rules the heart, but cannot uproot listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Hashem created the mind with power over the heart, so the beinoni keeps his thought, speech and deed from serving the yetzer, and there is no excuse of 'I couldn't help it'. But the mind cannot expel the yetzer itself, except in special times when the love of Hashem is revealed.

  5. 16:38 Times of favor and the Ruzhiner's story

    The Rav explains that during davening, an eis ratzon, the beinoni is like a tzaddik, and mentions Rosh Chodesh Adar and Adar Sheni as such times. He tells how the Ruzhiner told a chassid that Hashem's love for a notorious sinner in the town far exceeds the Rebbe's love for his chassidim.

  6. 21:14 A father's love and the Golden Calf

    The Rav contrasts a master, who loves servants by their devotion, with a father, whose love for his child has no reason and no conditions. He explains why Moshe Rabbeinu stressed how great the sin of the Golden Calf was: like a child who broke a leg, the damage itself arouses the father's mercy.

  7. 28:11 Achashverosh's party and the hidden salvation

    The Rav explains that the Golden Calf brought out the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, culminating on Yom Kippur, and that Purim is like it. He brings the Gemara on Achashverosh's miscalculation of the seventy years and the Chasam Sofer's point that at the very party where the Jews sinned, Hashem was already preparing their salvation through Vashti's removal.

  8. 34:50 Hester panim and the month of Adar

    The Rav explains the double concealment of 'haster astir' with the Ba'al Shem Tov's mashal of a child who knows or does not know his father is near. Adar is a time of hester, and its task is to uncover in the Megillah Hashem's love; Adar and Nissan are months of favor.

  9. 39:22 The beinoni during davening listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that only the beinoni is freed from the yetzer during davening, while someone who often stumbles is disturbed by bad thoughts even in Shema. Even then, the beinoni's mind only controls the yetzer and does not uproot it.

  10. 43:01 Yaakov and Esav, Yerushalayim and Rome listed in the guide

    The Rav explains the Tanya's verse about the constant struggle of Yaakov and Esav, where one rises as the other falls, in soul, place and time. Yerushalayim faces Rome, a kingdom of many nations, and he brings the Bluzhever Rebbe's teaching on Yerushalayim written with or without a yud.

  11. 49:44 Adar Sheni, outside the count

    The Rav says the subject needs more time to explain. He then explains that Adar Sheni, like Dan at the rear of the camp, stands outside the twelve combinations of Hashem's name, so its hester is stronger and its miracle greater. He adds that Esav, like the pig showing its split hooves, displays virtues he lacks.

  12. 53:32 On pronunciation and old customs

    In a partly garbled exchange the Rav speaks about pronunciation of loshon hakodesh: no community today has the exact original havara, yet Hashem accepts our speech like parents who understand a small child. He ends advising to stick to the established halachos and customs of Klal Yisroel and not take on new chumros that leave a person nervous.

The shiur, written up

The beinoni and the three judges

0:54

The Rav reviews the difference between the tzaddik and the beinoni, the 'intermediate' person. The tzaddik has exterminated his yetzer hara and no longer even desires to sin; the beinoni never sins, but the Tanya says the evil in the left chamber of the heart remains as strong as at his birth, lusting for the pleasures of this world. a

3:35

Two judges voice their opinion in him, the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara. He wins because of a third judge: Hashem stands at the right of the pauper, as in Tehillim 109:31, and once he does all he can, Hashem gives him the added strength. b

Why the beinoni is 'like a rasha'

4:47

This, the Rav says, answers the question the Tanya raised in its first chapter on the Gemara's words in Niddah 30b: even if all say he is a tzaddik, he should see himself 'like a rasha'. He is no rasha, but with the yetzer at full strength he could fall, so he must not believe those who call him a tzaddik. c,d

The yetzer grows stronger with age

8:07

The yetzer does not weaken with time; it grows stronger. The Rav stresses the years of youth: as grapes depend on the start of the season, and as the Rambam's mashal of a young sapling that can still be straightened, a young person can mold himself.

9:39

Indulging in food and drink makes a person coarser, which is why, as the Gemara in Shabbos 152a says, the ignorant grow worse with age. Even learning day and night for the mitzvah's sake is no sign that the yetzer has left. e

The mind rules the heart, but cannot uproot

12:37

The Rav explains that Hashem created the mind stronger than the heart's lusts, so the G-dly soul in the mind rules the 'small city' of the body, as the Tanya says, keeping thought, speech and deed from serving the animal soul. There is no excuse of 'I couldn't help it'. f

15:51

Yet the mind can only hold back the urges; it cannot expel the yetzer itself, except in special times when the love of Hashem is revealed in his heart. g

Times of favor and the Ruzhiner's story

16:38

While davening, an eis ratzon, a time of favor, the beinoni is like a tzaddik and the yetzer is quiet. Such times are also seasonal, like the present Rosh Chodesh Adar, especially Adar Sheni. Just as every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem, Hashem has a hidden love for every Jew.

18:45

The Rav tells of a chassid who traveled days just to see the Ruzhiner. The Rebbe told him that his fondness was nothing next to the Rebbe's love for his chassidim, and that this was nothing next to Hashem's love for Yankel, the town's notorious rasha.

A father's love and the Golden Calf

21:17

This love is concealed; were a Jew aware of it, he would run after Hashem like a lion. In times of favor Hashem reveals it, and it is a father's love, which needs no reason. A master values servants by their devotion, but a child remains a child even when he behaves badly, because he is an extension of the father.

24:55

Sometimes bad behavior itself brings this love out. The Rav asks why Moshe Rabbeinu, pleading after the Golden Calf, said the people had done a great sin, as in Shemos 32:31, instead of minimizing it. He answers that sins are forbidden for our own good. A father may discipline a child who keeps scratching himself on glass, but when the child falls from the roof and breaks a leg, his mercy is aroused; so Moshe said the people had 'broken a leg' and must be healed. h

Achashverosh's party and the hidden salvation

28:36

After the Calf Hashem gave the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, which as Rashi on Shemos 33:19 explains, come even when undeserved, culminating on Yom Kippur. Purim is like Yom Kippur, because the Jews benefited from Achashverosh's feast. i

30:51

The Rav brings the Gemara in Megillah that Achashverosh, fearing the Jews' return to Yerushalayim after seventy years, miscalculated and made a party celebrating that the Beis HaMikdash was not rebuilt; joining it was denying the Geulah. The Chasam Sofer points out that at that very party Vashti was removed to make place for Esther. Hashem prepared the salvation during the sin itself, like a father. j,k

Hester panim and the month of Adar

35:04

The period of the Megillah is hester panim, concealment, and the Rav reads Devarim 31:18 as a double hiding. The Ba'al Shem Tov compares it to a child in the jungle who sees a lion and cries for his father; he knows the father is near. Far worse is a child who does not know the father is there: the hiding itself is hidden. l

37:29

The task of Adar is to see in the Megillah Hashem's love, preparing salvation even during the falls of the Jewish people. Adar and Nissan, Rashi says, are months of favor. m

The beinoni during davening

39:22

When one davens, the Rav says, Haman, the yetzer hara, becomes powerless. This applies to the beinoni, who never sins; someone who often stumbles is disturbed by bad thoughts even during Shema. Even for the beinoni, the mind only controls the yetzer, revealing the love of Hashem at special times, without uprooting it.

Yaakov and Esav, Yerushalayim and Rome

43:33

The Tanya brings the constant struggle of Yaakov and Esav. The Rav explains that everything exists in soul, place and time: Yaakov is the tzaddik and his place is Yerushalayim, while Esav is the yetzer hara and his place is Rome. Unlike Bavel or Yavan, Rome is many nations, as Tidal 'king of nations' among the four kings in Bereishis 14:1. n,p

46:30

Rashi brings the Gemara on Yechezkel 26:2: when one is full the other is destroyed. Yerushalayim seldom carries a yud; one such place is the Megillah, Yerushalayim's victory over Esav. The Bluzhever Rebbe taught that without the yud Yerushalayim belongs to Rome; with it, Rome belongs to Yerushalayim. The person, the 'small city', can be ruled by either. n,o

Adar Sheni, outside the count

49:44

The Rav says this needs time, so he hopes to continue later. Holiness filters down from Nissan to Adar, and Adar Sheni, like Dan at the rear of the camp, stands outside: Hashem's four-letter name has only twelve combinations. Its concealment is stronger, so its miracle is greater.

52:06

Esav displays virtues he lacks, like the pig, which the Torah calls impure for showing split hooves. q

On pronunciation and old customs

53:58

In a partly garbled exchange the Rav says no community keeps the exact original pronunciation, perhaps except the Teimanim. None are fully correct, but Hashem accepts the speech of Jews as parents understand a small child, for Jews are His dear children.

56:51

He ends with advice: stick to the halachos and customs of Klal Yisroel and do not take on every new chumra, which can leave a person a nervous wreck.

Sources

Torah

  1. h Shemos 32:31 text index In the write-up: 24:55
  2. l Devarim 31:18 text index In the write-up: 35:04
  3. p Bereishis 14:1 text index In the write-up: 43:33
  4. q Vayikra 11:7 text index In the write-up: 52:06

Nevi'im

  1. o Yechezkel 26:2 text index In the write-up: 46:30

Kesuvim

  1. b Tehillim 109:31 text index In the write-up: 3:35

Talmud Bavli

  1. d Niddah 30b text index In the write-up: 4:47
  2. e apparently Shabbos 152a index In the write-up: 9:39
  3. j apparently Megillah 11b-12a index In the write-up: 30:51

Rishonim

  1. i apparently Rashi, Shemos 33:19 index In the write-up: 28:36
  2. m apparently Rashi, Taanis 29a index In the write-up: 37:29
  3. n apparently Rashi, Bereishis 25:23 index In the write-up: 43:33, 46:30

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 0:54
  2. c apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 4:47
  3. f apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 12:37
  4. g apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 15:51
  5. k Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 30:51

Key points

  1. 1:57 The beinoni never sins, but the yetzer hara in the left chamber of the heart remains as strong as at birth; he wins only because Hashem stands at his right side and helps him.
  2. 5:24 He is called 'like a rasha' because the potential to sin is fully alive in him, so he must not believe people who call him a tzaddik.
  3. 13:29 The mind was created with power to rule the heart's urges in thought, speech and deed, but not to uproot the yetzer itself.
  4. 16:20 In times of favor, above all during davening, the love of Hashem is revealed and the beinoni is temporarily like a tzaddik.
  5. 20:59 Hashem's love for every Jew is the unconditional love of a father for a child, concealed but revealed in times of favor, even through the people's sins.
  6. 34:12 Adar is a time of hester panim within which Hashem's hidden love is uncovered, as the Megillah shows the salvation being prepared during the sin itself.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 5:05 How can someone who knows he never sins consider himself like a rasha, and why does it say 'like a rasha' rather than 'a rasha'?

    Answer: 5:20 He is not a rasha, but since the yetzer hara is in him with all its strength, he could fall if he is not on guard.

  2. Question: 11:39 If he learns and davens all day for the sake of the mitzvah, does that show his yetzer hara is gone?

    Answer: 11:54 No; it is no sign at all, the yetzer is still in the left chamber with all its power.

  3. Question: 25:32 Why did Moshe Rabbeinu tell Hashem that the people did a great sin, instead of minimizing it?

    Answer: 27:27 Like a child who disobeyed and broke a leg, the greater the damage the more it arouses the father's mercy to heal him.

Stories

  1. 18:45 The Ruzhiner and the chassid who came to see him

    A chassid felt a strong urge simply to see the Ruzhiner and traveled several days to reach him. As he entered the courtyard, the Rebbe called him over and asked whether he was fond of him, and the chassid answered that this was why he came. The Ruzhiner told him that his fondness bears no comparison to the Rebbe's love for his chassidim, and that this in turn bears no comparison to Hashem's love for Yankel, a notorious rasha of that town.

    In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Yankel

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 5:10 The Tanya says 'like a rasha' and not 'a rasha' because the beinoni is not wicked; he only carries the full potential to become one if he is not on guard.
  2. 24:40 Sometimes it is precisely the sin and its damage that reveals Hashem's hidden love, as a child's broken leg turns the father from discipline to mercy; this is why Moshe stressed that the sin of the Calf was great.
  3. 33:48 At the very party where the Jews sinned by joining Achashverosh's celebration, Hashem was already preparing their salvation through Vashti's removal, showing a father's love even in the worst state.
  4. 36:17 The worse concealment is not when the father hides but when the child does not even know he is there; the work of Adar is to reveal the hiding.
  5. 51:12 Adar Sheni has no combination of the four-letter name of its own, since only twelve are possible, so its concealment is greater, and for that reason the Purim miracle in it was greater.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 6:17 The Rav says the beinoni should not believe people who call him a tzaddik, and should know that the yetzer hara is in him and he must be careful.
  2. 8:07 The Rav says the years of youth are very important, since then a person can still mold himself, like a young sapling that can be straightened.
  3. 13:59 The Rav says there is no excuse of 'I couldn't control myself', since Hashem gave the mind power over the heart.
  4. 37:29 The Rav says the task of Adar is to see in the Megillah Hashem's love for us, that even during our falls He is preparing our salvation.
  5. 56:51 The Rav advises sticking to the halachos and ways of Klal Yisroel rather than taking on every new chumra, which can leave a person nervous all day.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbi Nosson Adler, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rashi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Tzvi LaTzaddik (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Bluzhov), Vashti, Yaakov Avinu

Terms בינוני, הסתר פנים, חלל השמאלי, י"ג מדות הרחמים, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, מוח שליט על הלב, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, עיר קטנה, עת רצון, צירוף, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page