Thanking Hashem - An Endless Endeavor

מזמור לתודה

Catalog entry: TEFILA (English) no. ⁨16⁩ Pocket Guide p. 79 English 37 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 37 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Starting from Mizmor l'Sodah, the Rav shows that thanking Hashem is an endless task: every breath, every hidden miracle and every rescue calls for thanks, and Hashem even arranged the miracle at the Yam Suf so that Jews could come back and thank Him there.

The Rav opens with Mizmor l'Sodah and calls the chance to thank Hashem one of His greatest gifts. That is why each person says Modim d'Rabbanan himself, and why it ends with thanks for being able to thank. David HaMelech closes Tehillim with praise for every breath, and Nishmas admits that we could not thank even for one of His countless favors; the body alone is a daily miracle. The four who must thank in Tehillim 107 are only samples, and the Gemara requires ten people, two of them Rabbanan, for Birkas HaGomel: a wise man is needed to explain the kindness, and a second one shows there is always more to say. The short eating time of the korban todah increases pirsumei nisa, which leads to Chanukah, women's obligation in it, and gratitude as the root of avodas Hashem. He ends with the Chasam Sofer on why the Egyptians drowned in the Yam Suf and not the Nile.

Topics: Thanks and Praise to Hashem · Pesukei DeZimra

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Mizmor l'Sodah and Modim d'Rabbanan listed in the guide

    After a brief exchange before the shiur, the Rav opens with Mizmor l'Sodah and calls the chance to thank Hashem one of His greatest gifts. He explains why each person says Modim d'Rabbanan himself, and that it ends with thanks for being able to thank.

  2. 5:40 For every breath: Tehillim and Nishmas listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Tehillim is mostly hoda'ah, and that David HaMelech ends it feeling he must thank for every breath. He brings Nishmas, that one cannot thank even for one favor, and describes the human body as a daily miracle.

  3. 10:43 The four who must thank are only samples listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the kapitel of Tehillim with the four who are rescued and must thank, and explains that they are only samples for thanking for everything. He brings the Gemara that Birkas HaGomel is said before ten with two Rabbanan, and says people notice their teeth only when they ache.

  4. 15:48 Why two Rabbanan at Birkas HaGomel listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that only a chacham who works on hakaras hatov sees Hashem's kindness in everything, even in what seems bad. Two are needed so that the second shows there is more to say after the first finished: thanking Hashem never ends.

  5. 19:43 The korban todah and pirsumei nisa listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the korban todah, unlike other shelamim, may be eaten only for a day and a night until chatzos, and brings the mefarshim that this makes the owner invite more people and publicize Hashem's kindness. He concludes that mitzvos of pirsumei nisa outweigh other mitzvos.

  6. 22:56 Chanukah, hidden miracles and gratitude listed in the guide

    With Chanukah approaching, the Rav explains that owing thanks makes a person subordinate to his benefactor, that only Hashem knows the miracles He does daily, and that gratitude is the greatest obligation in avodas Hashem. He explains why women are obligated in Chanukah lights and the four cups, and begins the case of choosing between Kiddush wine and Chanukah lights.

  7. 29:06 The Chasam Sofer: why the Yam Suf and not the Nile listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer's question why the prohibition of returning to Mitzrayim is mentioned at the Yam Suf, and why the Egyptians were not drowned in the Nile, measure for measure. The answer: one makes a bracha at the place of a miracle, and since Jews may not return to Mitzrayim, Hashem made the miracle where they could come and thank Him.

The shiur, written up

Mizmor l'Sodah and Modim d'Rabbanan

0:33

The Rav opens with Mizmor l'Sodah and says that one of Hashem's greatest gifts is the chance to thank Him. In the chazzan's repetition one listens and answers, but at Modim each person says Modim d'Rabbanan himself, a gathering of the thanks the Sages of the Gemara used to say. Thanking Hashem brings such closeness that one wants to say it with his own mouth. a,b

3:06

He reads the close of Modim d'Rabbanan as thanks for the very ability to thank: Hashem put the desire into the heart, and realizing that this is a privilege is itself a reason to bow and thank Him. b

For every breath

5:45

Tehillim, the Rav explains, is tefillah and hoda'ah, mostly hoda'ah. Yet after 150 kapitlach David HaMelech felt he was not finished, since every breath would need its own kapitel; so Tehillim ends with praise for every breath, as the Gemara expounds. Nishmas likewise says that even with boundless faculties one could not thank Hashem for one of His countless daily favors. c,d

8:28

The body alone shows this. Brain, heart, digestion and lungs run for seventy to a hundred years in a machine of flesh and bone with its own repair system, and when something goes wrong Hashem corrects it. These are miracles we do not even know about.

The four who must thank

10:43

The Rav turns to the kapitel that Chassidim say Erev Shabbos before Mincha, with four people who are rescued and must thank. These four, he says, are only samples of every kind of deliverance, and the kapitel ends by asking who is wise enough to take this to heart: one must thank for everything. f

13:15

The Gemara says such a person bentches Gomel before ten, two of them Rabbanan. People take Hashem's kindness for granted; nobody thanks for his teeth until he has a toothache. A rescue is a reminder to thank for all the troubles one never faced. g

Why two Rabbanan

15:54

Not everyone understands this, the Rav says. It takes a chacham who works on hakaras hatov, who sees Hashem in whatever happens and knows that even the undesirable is for his good. Two are needed: after one chacham explains Hashem's kindness at the seudah, people think all has been said, but a second shows there is more. Thanking Hashem never ends.

The korban todah

20:02

A korban todah, though a shelamim, may be eaten only for a day and a night until chatzos, not two days. The mefarshim explain that the owner must then invite more people to finish it, which brings more honor to Hashem. Mitzvos of pirsumei nisa, the Rav concludes, outweigh other mitzvos.

Chanukah and gratitude

22:57

With Chanukah approaching, the Rav explains that owing thanks makes a person subordinate to his benefactor. Few could say what miracle Hashem did for them today, yet in Shemoneh Esrei we state it as a truth: He heals the body unnoticed and provides for every creature, down to an ant. e

25:38

Knowing what one owes Hashem, what one can return for all His kindness, is the greatest obligation in avodas Hashem; the more a person appreciates, the more of a tzaddik he becomes. Therefore women are obligated in Chanukah lights and the four cups, though these are time-bound, because they too must recognize the miracle. He then raises a case of having money only for Kiddush wine or Chanukah lights. h,i,j,k

The Chasam Sofer on the Yam Suf

29:06

The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer on the verse at the Yam Suf that the Egyptians seen today will never be seen again, a prohibition against returning to Mitzrayim, followed by 'Hashem will fight for you.' Why mention this prohibition now, when the Jews stood at the sea, panicking? l,m,n

31:57

Hashem punishes measure for measure: the Egyptians threw Jewish babies into the Nile, so they should have drowned there. But the Gemara says one makes a bracha at the place of a miracle, and Jews may not return to Mitzrayim. So Hashem drowned them in the Yam Suf, where a Jew can come and make a bracha. l,o

35:52

This, the Rav says, is what Hashem told those who feared the sea would not split: it happens here so that you can thank Him.

Sources

Torah

  1. m Shemos 14:13 text index In the write-up: 29:06
  2. n Shemos 14:14 text index In the write-up: 29:06

Kesuvim

  1. a Tehillim 100:1 text index In the write-up: 0:33
  2. c apparently Tehillim 150:6 index In the write-up: 5:45
  3. f apparently Tehillim 107 index In the write-up: 10:43
  4. h apparently Tehillim 116:12 index In the write-up: 25:38

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Sotah 40a index In the write-up: 0:33, 3:06
  2. g apparently Berachos 54b index In the write-up: 13:15
  3. i apparently Shabbos 23a index In the write-up: 25:38
  4. j apparently Pesachim 108b index In the write-up: 25:38
  5. k apparently Shabbos 23b index In the write-up: 25:38
  6. o apparently Berachos 54a index In the write-up: 31:57

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. l apparently Chasam Sofer on Shemos 14:13 index In the write-up: 29:06, 31:57

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. d Nishmas (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:45
  2. e Shemoneh Esrei (Modim) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:57

Key points

  1. 1:06 The Rav says the opportunity to thank Hashem, and the realization that it is a privilege, is itself one of Hashem's greatest gifts.
  2. 6:17 Thanks can never be finished: Tehillim ends with praise for every breath, and Nishmas says one cannot thank even for a single favor among thousands.
  3. 11:52 The four kinds of people who must thank are only samples, reminders that one must thank Hashem for everything.
  4. 15:54 Recognizing Hashem's hidden kindnesses takes a chacham who works on hakaras hatov, which is why Birkas HaGomel needs two Rabbanan.
  5. 22:43 Mitzvos of pirsumei nisa, publicizing a miracle, outweigh other mitzvos, and even women are obligated in them.
  6. 25:38 Gratitude is the greatest obligation in avodas Hashem: the more a person appreciates, the more of a tzaddik he becomes.
  7. 35:13 Hashem drowned the Egyptians in the Yam Suf and not in the Nile so that Jews could come to the place of the miracle and make a bracha.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:47 Why does each person say Modim d'Rabbanan himself instead of listening to the chazzan?

    Answer: 3:27 Because thanking Hashem gives such closeness that one wants to say it with his own mouth.

  2. Question: 17:22 Why are ten people not enough for Birkas HaGomel, so that two Rabbanan are needed?

    Answer: 18:05 A chacham is needed to explain the kindness, and a second one shows that there is always more to say: thanks never ends.

  3. Question: 20:02 Why is the korban todah eaten only for a day and a night, unlike other shelamim?

    Answer: 21:06 So that the owner must invite more people to finish it, which increases the honor of Hashem.

  4. Question: 30:58 Why did Hashem drown the Egyptians in the Yam Suf and not in the Nile, where measure for measure would call for it, and why is the prohibition of returning to Mitzrayim mentioned there?

    Answer: 34:39 One makes a bracha at the place of a miracle; since Jews may not return to Mitzrayim, Hashem made the miracle at the Yam Suf, where they can come and make a bracha.

Insights

  1. 1:47 Although one normally listens to the chazzan's repetition and answers, at Modim each person says Modim d'Rabbanan himself, because thanking Hashem brings such closeness that one does not let another do it for him.
  2. 3:04 The Rav reads the close of Modim d'Rabbanan as thanks for the very ability and desire to thank, which Hashem places in a person's heart.
  3. 15:23 The rescue that obligates thanks is a reminder: being delivered from one trouble should make a person thank Hashem for all the troubles he was never put into.
  4. 18:12 Birkas HaGomel needs two Rabbanan: one chacham to explain Hashem's kindness, and a second to show that after the first seemed to finish, there was still more to say.
  5. 21:21 The korban todah's short eating time forces its owner to invite more people, so the thanksgiving becomes a greater kiddush shem shamayim.
  6. 23:25 Knowing that one owes thanks makes a person subordinate to his benefactor; therefore the more he appreciates Hashem's goodness, the more he becomes a tzaddik who cannot bring himself to displease Him.
  7. 35:13 Following the Chasam Sofer, the Rav explains that Hashem gave up the fitting punishment at the Nile so that the miracle would happen where Jews could return and make a bracha.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 10:01 The Rav says one should thank Hashem for every big thing, every small thing and every breath.
  2. 14:28 The Rav says a person must contemplate the salvations and miracles done for him every day, which people take for granted.
  3. 15:54 The Rav says one should work on hakaras hatov so as to see Hashem in whatever happens and to thank Him even for what seems undesirable.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, the Chasam Sofer

Terms הכרת הטוב, חזרת הש"ץ, מדה כנגד מדה, נר חנוכה, פרסומי ניסא, קרבן תודה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page