A Month of תחיית המתים
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) ניסן no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 66 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 52 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains Nisan as the month of revival, in which Hashem renews His plan for a perfect world again and again, and shows how matzah, as a key of chesed from a world above time and space, opens a Jew to that renewal.
The Rav opens on Chaf-Hei Adar, recalling the Gemara's dispute whether the world was created in Tishrei or Nisan, and notes that Hashem's 'regret' is language for our understanding, since everything was in His plan. He then describes Nisan as a series of attempts at a perfect world: Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu the 'spring neshama' and Yetzias Mitzrayim spoiled by the Egel, the Mishkan spoiled by Nadav and Avihu, and a fourth Nisan of Moshiach that will succeed. From the Mishkan built and taken apart for seven days he draws the message never to despair after a fall. Nisan is a month of chesed, harnessed chesed, which he illustrates through the right hand, the lunar calendar balanced by the solar year, and Shabbos in the middle. Matzah is the key that opens the doors of chesed; its gematria of three times Mah shows it comes from a world above time and space, unlike bread. He closes with Pesach as the beginning, the bris of the Jew with Hashem, and a story about davening for a kosher Pesach.
Topics: Chodesh Nissan · Matzah, the Food of Emunah · Avraham Avinu
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Creation day and Hashem's first plan
On Chaf-Hei Adar the Rav recalls the Gemara's dispute whether the world was created in Tishrei or Nisan, and explains that when the Torah speaks of Hashem 'regretting', it speaks in our terms, since even Adam's sin was in His plan. He describes the world Hashem intended with Adam HaRishon on Rosh Chodesh Nisan: a Gan Eden without death, spoiled by the sin of the Eitz HaDaas.
-
5:14 Avraham Avinu, the spring neshama listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every person has his time, and Avraham Avinu's time is Nisan, the spring. He paints spring as a revival from the shrouds of winter, brings Shir Hashirim's call to wake up, and lists the events of Avraham's life that took place on Pesach.
-
10:15 The second and third Nisan listed in the guide
The Rav describes Hashem's second attempt, localized to one nation descended from Avraham and brought out of Mitzrayim in Nisan, which the Egel spoiled. The third attempt, localized to the Mishkan, was spoiled by Nadav and Avihu, and Rashi on 'Mishkan haEidus' hints that the two Batei Mikdash would be destroyed.
-
14:31 The fourth Nisan and never despairing listed in the guide
The Rav describes the promised fourth Nisan with the third Beis HaMikdash, when death will end, as the Rambam describes at the end of Hilchos Melachim. He connects this to the Haftarah of the dry bones read on Pesach, and draws from the Mishkan built and taken apart for seven days that a person who falls must get up and try again.
-
19:22 Nisan, the month of chesed
The Rav explains that Nisan is a month of chesed because it is Avraham Avinu's month, and that creation in Nisan reflects building the world with chesed rather than din. Jews always raise chesed over din: washing the right hand first, putting on the right shoe first but tying the left, binding tefillin on the left, and writing from the right.
-
22:56 Harnessed chesed: moon, sun and Shabbos
The Rav contrasts Esav, who writes from the left and follows the sun of din, with Yishmael, the refuse of Avraham's chesed, whose unbridled chesed turns to immorality. Jews count by the moon of chesed but harness it to the solar year through the leap year, while the Arabs' months drift through the seasons; likewise Shabbos stands in the middle between Friday and Sunday.
-
28:08 Matzah, the key that opens listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Nisan goes straight, like the aleph-beis, and opens with chesed: maos chittim and 'whoever is hungry, come and eat'. Matzah, which Targum calls 'patira', is the key that opens the doors of chesed; on Pesach night the storehouses of tal open, as the Targum Yonasan says about Yitzchak's brachos, and tal in gematria joins the Name of Hashem and brings down the tal of techiyas hameisim.
-
32:43 Matzah, Mah and the night of questions
The Rav explains that Pesach comes from a world beyond understanding, the world of 'Mah', and that matzah equals three times Mah (45) while bread equals three times the Name Havaya (26). That is why the Haggadah begins with questions, and why Pesach is renewal, when people buy new clothing and take out vessels unused for a year.
-
38:44 Matzah above time and space
The Rav explains that this world is bound by time and space, as shown by how witnesses are examined on when and where, while bread needs both to rise. Matzah is given no time and takes no space, because it belongs to a higher world, and on Pesach a Jew is to rise above them. He ends with the two pieces of matzah at the Seder, the Afikoman pointing to the future redemption.
-
45:47 Pesach as the beginning and the bris
The Rav explains that although Shavuos and Sukkos are higher, Pesach is the beginning, when a Jew ties himself to Hashem, so chametz carries kares, the opposite of that bond, and an arel may not eat the korban Pesach. He brings the Radbaz's question why chametz is treated more strictly than any other aveirah.
-
48:58 The tzaddik's kernel of wheat Story
The Rav tells a story he heard from the Klausenberger Rebbe about a tzaddik who prepared a perfectly chametz-free Pesach and found a kernel of wheat in his soup. Through a she'eilas chalom he learned that he had not davened for a kosher Pesach, and that a bird had dropped the kernel through the chimney. The Rav closes with a brachah for a kosher Pesach in Yerushalayim.
The shiur, written up
Creation day and Hashem's first plan
The Rav opens on Chaf-Hei Adar, the first day of creation, recalling the Gemara's dispute whether the world was created in Tishrei or in Nisan; Tosafos explains that Tishrei was creation in thought. He first notes that when the Torah says Hashem regretted creating man, or crowning Shaul, it speaks in our terms. The Midrash Tanchuma says Adam's sin had to be: it was all in Hashem's plan. a,b,c,d,e
Hashem's intention with Adam HaRishon, the Rav says, was a Gan Eden with no death, where bread and clothing would grow on trees. Adam ate from the Eitz HaDaas and that world did not come to be, so, as we grasp it, Hashem decided to try again.
Avraham Avinu, the spring neshama
Every person has his time, the Rav explains, and Avraham Avinu's time is Nisan, the spring. Until spring everything is dead, the trees wrapped in white shrouds; then they put on green, the birds return with new songs, and Shir Hashirim calls on all of creation to wake from its winter slumber. f
Avraham is the spring neshama of Klal Yisroel, the first Jew and the first promise of revival, so the main events of his life, the Bris Bein HaBesarim, his victory over the kings and Yitzchak's birth, were all on Pesach.
The second and third Nisan
The fourth Nisan and never despairing
A fourth Nisan is promised, the Rav says, with the third Beis HaMikdash: the whole world will return to how it was before Adam's sin, death will be abolished, and Jews will have all they need to serve Hashem, as the Rambam describes at the end of Hilchos Melachim. This is why the Haftarah of Yechezkel reviving the dry bones is read on Pesach. i,j
For seven days the Mishkan was built and taken apart, and only on the eighth did it stand. From this he draws a message: a person who falls in his relationship with Hashem must not give up but get up again, as Hashem tried again.
Nisan, the month of chesed
Harnessed chesed: moon, sun and Shabbos
Esav writes from the left and strengthens din; Yishmael, the refuse of Avraham, is chesed gone astray, and the Gemara links the Arabs with immorality. The moon is white, chesed, and the sun is red, din, as Rashi explains 'chum' means red. p,q
There is no pure chesed, the Rav explains: unharnessed it turns to immorality. So Jews count by the moon but align it with the sun through the leap year, while the Arabs' Ramadan drifts between summer and winter and the gentiles follow the sun alone. Likewise the Arabs rest on Friday, the Christians on Sunday, and Jews in the middle, on Shabbos.
Matzah, the key that opens
Matzah, Mah and the night of questions
If a heart is clogged, the Rav says, the rays of Pesach cannot pierce it, for Pesach comes from a world beyond understanding that one can only ask about. That is the world of 'Mah', the Name worth 45. Bread is three times the Name Havaya, 78, but matzah is three times 45.
Matzah above time and space
With Moshiach, the Rav says, the fourth and final attempt will succeed. The child asks first about matzah because it is 'Mah', from a higher world. This world needs time and space; above there is neither. Life does not come from bread itself but from the word of Hashem in it, which on Pesach rises into the matzah. aa
Bread needs both: given time, dough rises and takes more space. Matzah is rushed, never reaching the eighteen minutes in which dough becomes chametz, so it does not rise. Witnesses too are examined on when and where. So on Pesach a Jew is to rise above time and space to Torah and mitzvos. ab
The Seder is divided by the Afikoman, as the redemption has two parts, from Mitzrayim and in the future. The larger Afikoman matzah, eaten when we open the door for Eliyahu, is hidden, as we do not know when Moshiach will come.
Pesach as the beginning and the bris
Shavuos and Sukkos are higher, the Rav says, but Pesach is the beginning, when we tie ourselves to Hashem, like Avraham among the Avos. Chametz therefore brings kares, the opposite of that kesher; matzah is a bris, so an arel may not eat the korban Pesach. The Radbaz asks why chametz is treated more strictly than any aveirah. ac,ad
The tzaddik's kernel of wheat
The Rav tells a story from the Klausenberger Rebbe about a tzaddik who labored days and nights for a chametz-free Pesach, rejoiced at the Seder, then found a kernel of wheat in his soup. In a she'eilas chalom he learned that he had not davened for a kosher Pesach, and that a bird had dropped the kernel down the chimney. The Rav blesses all with a kosher Pesach in Yerushalayim.
Sources
Torah
- c apparently Bereishis 6:6 index In the write-up: 0:09
- n Devarim 6:8 text index In the write-up: 21:33
- o apparently Bereishis 22 index In the write-up: 21:33
- v Shemos 13:2 text index In the write-up: 28:50
- aa apparently Devarim 8:3 index In the write-up: 38:57
- ac Shemos 12:48 text index In the write-up: 46:11
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- f apparently Shir Hashirim 2:11-13 index In the write-up: 5:28
- g Tehillim 82:6 text index In the write-up: 10:44
- l Tehillim 89:3 text index In the write-up: 19:28
- t Tehillim 118:19 text index In the write-up: 28:50
- y Shir Hashirim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:20
- z Tehillim 31:13 text index In the write-up: 35:20
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 5:00 Nisan is the month of renewal in which Hashem 'tries again' for a perfect world: with Adam HaRishon, with Yetzias Mitzrayim, with the Mishkan, and finally with Moshiach.
- 9:02 Avraham Avinu is the 'spring neshama' of Klal Yisroel, and the main events of his life took place on Pesach.
- 19:28 Nisan is a month of chesed, the midah of Avraham, but Jewish chesed is harnessed and balanced by din.
- 29:16 Matzah is the key that opens the doors of chesed and brachah on Pesach; Targum renders matzah as 'patira', opening.
- 41:23 Matzah comes from a world above time and space, which is why it may not be given time to rise, while bread depends on both.
- 46:29 Pesach is the beginning, the bris that ties a Jew to Hashem, so eating chametz brings kares, the opposite of that bond.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 22:07 Why do we put on the right shoe first but tie the left shoe first?
Answer: 22:18 Because tying is binding down the midas hadin, the left side, just as tefillin are bound on the left hand and Yitzchak, the midah of din, was bound at the Akeidah.
-
Question: 41:12 Why may bread rise while matzah may not be given any time?
Answer: 42:13 Bread belongs to this world, which needs time and space, while matzah comes from a higher world above time and space.
-
Question: 47:09 Why does chametz on Pesach carry kares when violating Shavuos or Sukkos does not?
Answer: 47:29 Because Pesach is the beginning, when a Jew ties himself to Hashem through a bris, and kares is the opposite of that kesher.
-
Question: 50:36 In the story, why did the tzaddik deserve to find chametz, and how did it get there?
Answer: 51:03 He had not davened for a kosher Pesach, and a bird dropped a kernel of wheat through the chimney into the pot.
Stories
-
48:58 The kernel of wheat in the tzaddik's soup
The Rav tells a story he heard from the Klausenberger Rebbe about a tzaddik who resolved to have a perfectly chametz-free Pesach. He cleaned and scoured for days and nights and made his matzos with great stringency, and at the Seder he rejoiced that his Pesach was kosher. Then he was served soup and saw a kernel of wheat floating in it. In a she'eilas chalom he asked why he deserved this and how it could have happened; he was answered that he had done everything except daven for a kosher Pesach, and that a bird flying over the chimney had dropped the kernel into the pot.
In the story: the Klausenburger Rebbe
Insights
- 10:31 The Rav reads the history of Nisan as successive, ever more localized attempts at the perfect world of creation: the whole world with Adam, one nation at Yetzias Mitzrayim, one place in the Mishkan, until the fourth Nisan restores it on the large scale.
- 17:57 The seven days in which the Mishkan was built and taken apart mirror Hashem's own repeated attempts in Nisan, teaching that a disappointment in one's relationship with Hashem is a reason to get up and try again.
- 26:03 Chesed must be harnessed: the Jewish lunar calendar of chesed is aligned with the solar year of din, while the Arabs' purely lunar year lets their festival drift through the seasons, and the gentiles use the sun alone.
- 34:56 Matzah equals three times Mah (45) while bread equals three times Havaya (26), showing that matzah belongs to the world of Mah, a world one can only ask about; this is why the Seder opens with Mah Nishtanah.
- 41:23 Bread needs time to rise and so takes up space, while matzah is allowed no time and does not rise, so it stands above the two dimensions that define this world, the same 'when and where' on which witnesses are examined.
- 47:27 Kares for chametz is the opposite of the kesher, the bond with Hashem, that Pesach creates as the beginning of the year's festivals, which is why only one with a bris may eat the korban Pesach.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 18:58 The Rav says that a person who falls and feels a disappointment in his relationship with Hashem should not give up hope but get up and try again.
- 33:09 The Rav calls on a person whose heart is closed to open it on Pesach and let the rays of Pesach permeate him.
- 43:33 The Rav says that on Pesach a Jew should rise above the pull of time and space and live for Torah and mitzvos.
- 51:05 From the story the Rav concludes that one must daven in order to have a kosher Pesach.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avihu, Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nadav, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Klausenburger Rebbe, the Radbaz, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yechezkel HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אפיקומן, גן עדן, חטא העגל, כרת, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, משכן, עולם התיקון, פסולת, שאלת חלום, שם הוי"ה, שנה מעוברת, תחיית המתים