This שבת Finalizes פורים
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פרה no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 66 תש"ס (1999–2000) English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Parshas Parah, the Shabbos after Purim, continues Purim's lesson of a conduct above understanding, and that this is the merit through which Hashem can bring the Geulah in Nisan despite the Satan's accusations.
The Rav opens with Parshas Parah as the last Shabbos of the old year and explains that Haman erred in thinking Adar was the end, since for Jews the end touches the beginning. The sin of the Eitz HaDaas was the demand to understand everything; Parah Adumah, a chok that even Shlomo HaMelech could not understand, repairs it and partly atones for the Egel. Purim reflects Hashem's conduct with Jews as children, which is beyond reason, and Parah continues it. Turning to the year 5760, he explains the difference between a year fit for redemption and the fixed final time, describes how the Satan's accusations brought the decrees of Tach v'Tat and the world wars, and urges teshuvah. Parshas Parah, read before Nisan and before the three weeks, answers the Satan. Through the Gemara in Yoma about the race to the Mizbeach and the lottery, he shows that the goral reflects a conduct beyond merits. He closes with the higher purity of sprinkled water that comes from above.
Topics: The Four Parshiyos · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · Purim · The Reasons and Power of the Mitzvos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The last Shabbos of the year and Haman's error listed in the guide
The Rav explains that every Shabbos feeds the coming week and that Parshas Parah is the last Shabbos of the old year. Haman rejoiced that his lot fell on Adar, the end, but for Jews the end touches the beginning like a circle. He then defines the sin of the Eitz HaDaas as the wish to understand everything.
-
6:03 Parah Adumah, a mitzvah beyond understanding
The Rav presents Parah Adumah as the one mitzvah that teaches not to expect to understand, which even Shlomo HaMelech could not grasp. He explains that the Eitz HaDaas brought death, Matan Torah removed it, and the Egel, the same sin of wanting to understand, brought it back; Parah atones for the Egel partially by removing tumas meis.
-
11:23 Purim: Hashem's conduct with His children listed in the guide
The Rav distinguishes Hashem's two ways of leading the Jews, as servants and as children, and explains that the miracle of Purim came not through merit but because Jews are children of Hashem. Since this bond is above reason, Purim calls for surrendering one's da'as, and Parah, which follows Purim, continues it.
-
17:20 A year fit for Geulah and the fixed time
The Rav defines emunah as believing what one does not understand and calls the year 5760 especially fit for Moshiach. Through the passuk 'b'itah achishenah' he distinguishes years that are fit for Geulah from the fixed final time that no prophet may know, which was hidden even from Yaakov Avinu, and he explains that at every such time the Satan accuses the Jews.
-
24:04 Missed years of redemption and the call to teshuvah
The Rav describes the decrees of Tach v'Tat, the Malbim's calculation for 1914 when the First World War began, and the expectation for the year Tav-Shin when the Second World War started, which he remembers from his boyhood. He points to this year's many tragedies as signs of the Satan's accusation and calls for Torah, teshuvah, tefillah and tzedakah.
-
28:28 Parah answers the Satan before Nisan and the three weeks
The Rav explains that the Satan argues there is no reason to bring Moshiach, and the answer is a mitzvah that itself has no reason, Parah. Nisan, a time of Geulah through chesed, and the three weeks, a time of rachamim through the Churban, are each preceded by the reading of Parah, so that Hashem may bring the Geulah without reasons.
-
34:55 The goral and the race to the Mizbeach
The Rav explains that the Purim miracle came through a goral, which like a lottery win cannot be explained. He brings the Gemara in Yoma on the kohanim racing up the Mizbeach and the lottery after a tie, and asks why all the kohanim enter the lottery and how a race could decide the avodah. From Koheles he answers that in the Beis HaMikdash there was no hester panim, so whoever reached first did so through merit.
-
42:24 A tie shows a day of children; Parah after Purim listed in the guide
The Rav asks how two kohanim can arrive together when no two Jews are on the same level, and answers that a tie shows that on that day Hashem was leading as with children, beyond merits, so a goral decides. Parshas Parah, the Shabbos after Purim, uses this same root of the goral before Nisan, and he begins to distinguish purity of the body from purity of the soul.
-
46:26 Purity sprinkled from above
The Rav explains that whoever hears Parshas Parah receives a purity of the soul from Hashem, preparing him for the Korban Pesach. He contrasts the mikveh, which requires one's own act and cannot remove tumas meis, with the water of Parah, sprinkled from above, which can, and he closes by asking listeners to stand ready with humility and teshuvah when the parshah is read.
The shiur, written up
The last Shabbos of the year and Haman's error
Citing the Ohr HaChaim, the Rav explains that every Shabbos renews creation for the coming week. Parshas Parah is in effect the last Shabbos of the old year, since next Shabbos, Parshas HaChodesh, already feeds the new one. Haman rejoiced that his lot fell on Adar, the last month, thinking it meant the end of the Jews. a,b
He did not know that for Jews time is a circle, where the end touches the beginning and everything starts over. The Rav then defines the sin of the Eitz HaDaas: Adam and Chava wanted to understand everything, while a creation must accept that some matters are beyond its mind.
Parah Adumah, beyond understanding
Purim: the conduct of children
The Rav explains that Hashem leads the Jews either as servants, rewarded by their service, or as children. A servant can be dismissed; a child, who comes from the very root of the parent, remains a child forever.
A year fit for Geulah
Emunah, the Rav says, means believing what one does not understand, and Parah is a mitzvah of emunah. He calls the year 5760 one with the strongest signs of Moshiach's coming, and notes that the Zohar said Moshiach would come in the year Tach. j
He explains this through the passuk 'b'itah achishenah' and the Gemara in Sanhedrin: there are years fit for Geulah, when effort can hasten it, and one fixed time when Moshiach must come. That time no prophet may know; according to Rashi it was hidden even from Yaakov Avinu when he wished to reveal it. At every such time the Satan brings the Jews' sins as accusations. l,m,n
Missed years and the call to teshuvah
Because of such accusations, the year Tach brought the decrees of Chmielnicki instead of Geulah. The Malbim calculated that Moshiach must come in 1914, and that year the First World War began; the year Tav-Shin, which the Rav remembers awaiting as a boy, brought the Second.
He points to this year's illnesses, plane crashes and floods as signs of the Satan's accusation, and says one must learn Torah, do teshuvah, daven and give tzedakah. Those placed in Torah families must carry the burden for the many who know nothing.
Parah answers the Satan
The Satan argues there is no reason to send Moshiach, given the Jews' sins. The counsel is a mitzvah that itself has no reason, Parah, which Jews keep and learn about without understanding. The Gemara says the future redemption is in Nisan, so before Nisan Parshas Parah is read, and Hashem can tell the Satan that the Geulah too may come without reasons, unlike the Eitz HaDaas. o
The goral and the race to the Mizbeach
The Purim miracle came through a goral, which, like winning a lottery rather than earning wages or an inheritance, cannot be explained. The Gemara in Yoma relates that kohanim raced up the Mizbeach for the avodah, and when two tied, all the kohanim entered a lottery. r
The Rav asks why the lottery is not just between the two, and how a race could decide the avodah: the aged Chafetz Chaim, a kohen, would lose to young athletes. He answers from Koheles that the race is not to the swift. In this world that is hidden by hester panim, but in the Beis HaMikdash, with its daily miracles, whoever reached first had the merit, and the Chafetz Chaim would have arrived first. s,t
A tie shows a day of children
How, then, can two arrive together, when no two Jews are on one level, each holding his place on a rope from top to bottom? The Rav answers that a tie shows that on that day Hashem was leading as with children, where merits do not count, so all the kohanim enter the goral.
So too Parshas Parah, the Shabbos after Purim, draws on the root of the goral, asking Hashem not to weigh sins or merits before Nisan.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- c apparently Megillah 13b 2:19 index
- i apparently Megillah 7b index In the write-up: 14:33
- k Gemara Megillah (place not identified) 19:49 index
- m apparently Sanhedrin 98a index In the write-up: 20:20
- o apparently Rosh Hashanah 11a index In the write-up: 28:43
- r apparently Yoma 22a index In the write-up: 34:58
- v apparently Sukkah 38b index In the write-up: 47:49
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:44 For Jews time runs in a circle, so the end of the year touches its beginning; Haman, who rejoiced that his lot fell on Adar, did not understand this.
- 4:37 The sin of the Eitz HaDaas was the insistence on understanding everything, and Parah Adumah, a mitzvah kept without understanding, is its repair.
- 12:28 Hashem leads the Jews either as servants, according to their deeds, or as children, unconditionally; the miracle of Purim came through the conduct of children, which is above understanding.
- 23:16 When a time fit for Geulah arrives, the Satan accuses the Jews of their sins, and if they are not worthy, troubles come instead.
- 33:47 Parshas Parah is read before Nisan, a time of chesed, and Parshas Chukas before the three weeks, a time of rachamim, to answer the Satan's reasoning with a mitzvah done without reasons.
- 43:09 A goral reflects a conduct above merits; in the Beis HaMikdash a tie in the race showed that on that day the conduct was as children, so all the kohanim entered the lottery.
- 46:54 Parah Adumah brings a purity that comes from above, without the person's own act, and on Shabbos Parshas Parah Hashem grants every Jew a purity of the soul in preparation for Nisan.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:44 Why was Haman happy that his lot fell on Adar?
Answer: 2:30 He thought Adar, the last month, meant the end of the Jews, not knowing that for Jews the end touches the beginning.
-
Question: 10:28 If Parah atones for the Egel, why is there still death in the world?
Answer: 10:40 It atones only partially: it removes tumas meis, which death brings, even if it does not remove death.
-
Question: 33:40 Why is Parshas Parah read before Nisan and Parshas Chukas before the three weeks?
Answer: 34:10 Both are times when the Geulah can come, through chesed or rachamim, and the Satan accuses then; a mitzvah done without reasons shows that his reasoning should not be accepted.
-
Question: 38:51 How could the Beis HaMikdash decide who does the avodah by a race, as if athletic ability mattered more than tzidkus?
Answer: 41:12 In the Beis HaMikdash there was no hester panim; whoever reached the Mizbeach first did so because he had the merit.
-
Question: 38:25 When two kohanim tie, why do all the kohanim enter the lottery and not just the two, and how can two arrive together if no two Jews are equal?
Answer: 43:09 The tie itself shows that on that day Hashem was leading as with children, where merits do not count, so the decision goes by a goral among everyone.
Insights
- 2:30 Haman took Adar, the last month, as the end of the Jews, but for Jews time is a circle: the end touches the beginning and everything starts over.
- 9:37 The Egel was the same sin as the Eitz HaDaas, acting on one's own understanding, and therefore it brought back the death that Matan Torah had abolished; Parah only partly atones, removing tumas meis but not death itself.
- 28:43 The Satan's argument against the Geulah is that there is no reason for it, and Parah, a mitzvah with no reason that Jews keep anyway, answers him in kind.
- 33:16 Parah is read before both seasons of potential Geulah: before Nisan, when chesed is aroused, and as Parshas Chukas before the three weeks, when rachamim is aroused through the Churban.
- 41:12 In the Beis HaMikdash there was no hester panim, so even the aged Chafetz Chaim would have reached the Mizbeach first if he had the merit; the race measured merit, not strength.
- 42:31 Since no two Jews stand on the same level, a tie in the race was a sign that on that day merits did not count and Hashem was leading as with children, so the whole group entered the goral.
- 47:49 Mikveh requires one's own act of immersion and cannot remove tumas meis, while the water of Parah is sprinkled on a person by someone else, from above, and purifies even tumas meis.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 26:09 The Rav says that in a year fit for Geulah one must learn Torah, do teshuvah, daven and give tzedakah, so that Moshiach comes without troubles.
- 27:43 The Rav says that those whom Hashem placed in Torah-observant families must carry the burden for the many Jews who know nothing.
- 28:50 The Rav says that against the Satan's argument one should do mitzvos, or at least learn about the mitzvah of Parah, which is believed without being understood.
- 50:10 The Rav asks his listeners to stand ready with humility and a heart of teshuvah when Parshas Parah is read, to receive the purity Hashem sprinkles on every Jew.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Chava, Chmielnicki, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Chofetz Chaim, the Malbim, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Shach, Vashti, Yaakov Avinu
Terms בין המצרים, בעתה אחישנה, גורל, הסתר פנים, חוקה, חטא העגל, טומאת מת, עד דלא ידע, עץ הדעת, פקידה, פרה אדומה, קטרוג