פרה אדומה - A מצוה that is Above our Understanding

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פרה no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 66 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Parah Adumah, the chok no one can understand, is the cure for the sin of Adam HaRishon, who wanted to understand beyond his reach, and that its lesson of faith and waiting prepares the Jewish people for Nisan and the Geulah.

The Rav opens with the halachos of Parah Adumah: since we have no red heifer, all are tamei, yet hearing Parshas Parah removes the inner tumah. He links Parah to Purim: Purim comforts those left outside the camp, while Parah purifies them and brings them in, preparing for Parshas HaChodesh and Nisan. On Rosh Chodesh Nisan the Satan argues that the Jews are unworthy of redemption; Parah, a chok done without reason, answers that Hashem may redeem without reason. He traces tumah to the Nachash, who is the Satan, and to Adam and Chava's desire for intellect beyond their reach, which brought death, the highest tumah, into the world. Doing a mitzvah without understanding is the tikkun. Two things are closed to the mind: how Parah works and when Moshiach will come. Judaism is built on waiting, since the first sin, the golden calf and Shaul's failure were all failures to wait, while Dovid waited.

Topics: The Four Parshiyos · Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Adam HaRishon and Gan Eden · The Reasons and Power of the Mitzvos · Awaiting Moshiach

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Tumah today and the reading of Parah listed in the guide

    The Rav describes the red heifer and explains that without it everyone today is tamei and cannot go up on Har HaBayis. He says that hearing Parshas Parah with faith removes the inner tumah, as a body has a neshamah, so tumah has an outer and an inner part.

  2. 7:03 Parah as the completion of Purim listed in the guide

    The Rav ties Parah to Pur through the gematria and brings that Parshas Parah continues Purim, since Shabbos lifts up the week. Purim saves those expelled from the camp but leaves them outside; Parah purifies them and brings them in, so they enter Parshas HaChodesh renewed.

  3. 13:37 Nisan and the Satan's accusation listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Nisan is the month of birth and redemption, and that on Rosh Chodesh Nisan kings are appointed in Heaven. The good malachim move that Hashem become King and Moshiach come, but the Satan argues the Jews are not worthy and the matter is put off.

  4. 20:25 A chok beyond understanding answers the Satan listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Parah is a chok that even Shlomo HaMelech could not understand, and that keeping it shows Klal Yisrael's deep emunah. Since Jews do a mitzvah without a reason, Hashem can redeem them without a reason. Parshas Parah is the deepest Shabbos of the year, the last one feeding the week of Adar.

  5. 26:05 The Nachash, the Satan and the lure of intellect

    The Rav asks where the yetzer hara comes from and explains that Adam and Chava had no inner desires before the sin. The Nachash and the Satan are one, as their gematria shows; he could only tempt them with higher understanding, the knowledge of good and bad.

  6. 33:33 Death is tumah listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that death, the punishment for the sin, is really tumah, which is why a corpse is the highest level of tumah. Life is the G-dliness in a person; the malach hamaves pulls it out and injects tumah, and Parah Adumah is the antidote to that venom.

  7. 37:35 A mitzvah without understanding as the tikkun listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that tumas meis came because Adam and Chava wanted understanding beyond them, so its cure is a mitzvah done without understanding. Understanding is a fringe benefit, not a condition for keeping mitzvos; Parah brings life, as its mayim chaim and the passuk about the tzaddik living by his emunah show.

  8. 41:03 Two closed doors: Parah and the time of Moshiach listed in the guide

    The Rav says we are in ikvesa d'meshicha and names two things the mind may not enter: how Parah works and when Moshiach will come. He brings Yaakov Avinu, Daniel and Achashverosh's miscalculation, and compares the Jews' disappointment then to the disappointment after the Holocaust.

  9. 48:37 Judaism is built on waiting

    The Rav says a Jew must wait, and contrasts a gentile served breakfast in bed with a Jew who must wash, daven and make hamotzi before eating. He brings the Ohr HaChaim that the Eitz HaDaas was a vine whose grapes Adam was meant to keep for Kiddush on Shabbos, so the first sin was not waiting.

  10. 54:38 The egel, Shaul and Dovid: waiting for Moshiach listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that at Matan Torah death could have ended, but the golden calf came from not waiting for Moshe Rabbeinu. Shaul lost his kingdom for not waiting for Shmuel, while Dovid waited for the sound in the treetops, so Moshiach comes from him. He ends that waiting for Moshiach is waiting for the world to be sprinkled with Parah.

The shiur, written up

Tumah today and the reading of Parah

0:56

The Rav opens with the red heifer, whose ashes mixed with water remove the tumah of contact with the dead, a tumah too strong for a mikvah alone. Since there is no Parah Adumah today, everyone is tamei, for no one has never been under one roof with a dead person. This is why, following the Rambam, one cannot go up on Har HaBayis, though the Raavad differs; most authorities follow the Rambam, and we must wait for Moshiach.

4:22

Yet the Torah's reading works inwardly. The Midrashim teach that hearing Parshas Parah from a kosher Sefer Torah frees a person of tumah and prepares him for Nisan and Pesach, provided he listens attentively and believes it is happening. Just as a body without its neshamah is a corpse, tumah has an outer part, which remains until Moshiach, and an inner part, which blocks a person from kedushah and leaves with the reading. a

Parah as the completion of Purim

7:14

The Rav notes that Parah and Pur sound alike and, with the kolel, share a gematria. The Zera Kodesh and Likutei Moharan teach that Parshas Parah continues Purim, and he explains that this is clear anyway, since Shabbos lifts up all that happened during the week. b,c

9:17

Purim, he recalls, is for those expelled from the camp, like the hooks that stuck out of the Mishkan where Amalek could reach them. They were outside because they were tamei, as the passuk commands sending the tamei out of the camp. Purim is balm for their hearts, but Parah takes them by the hand: it purifies them and brings them in, so a renewed person enters Parshas HaChodesh. d

Nisan and the Satan's accusation

13:53

Parshas HaChodesh heralds Nisan, the month in which the Jewish nation was born and freed to serve Hashem, and the Gemara teaches that the final redemption will also come in Nisan. On Rosh Chodesh Nisan kings and the malachim over the nations are appointed in Heaven, and the Rav relates that the Ba'al Shem Tov would depose rulers he did not want. e

17:06

Each year the good malachim move that Hashem become King and Moshiach come, but this depends on whether the Jews are worthy. The Satan protests that they are sinful and need more preparation, and the heavenly court defers it, unless Hashem decides to judge alone.

A chok beyond understanding answers the Satan

20:25

To neutralize this accusation, Parah is read the week before. Its halachos contradict each other: the water purifies the tamei yet makes tamei the tahor man who carries it. Only Moshe Rabbeinu understood it; even Shlomo HaMelech tried and gave up. The parsha calls it a chok, and Rashi brings that the nations taunt the Jews for it, so its keeping expresses deep emunah. f,g

23:29

Then, when the Satan says there is no reason to redeem the Jews, Hashem can answer that they do a mitzvah without knowing the reason, so He can redeem them without one. The Rav adds that Parah is the deepest Shabbos of the year, the last one feeding a week of Adar, the lowest month.

The Nachash, the Satan and the lure of intellect

26:06

The Rav asks where sin and the yetzer hara come from. Before eating from the Eitz HaDaas, Adam and Chava had no inner desires; they were intellect, tied to the neshamah, not the body. The Torah calls the tempter the Nachash, and he is the Satan: the two words share a gematria, and the Gemara teaches that the Satan, the yetzer hara and the one who punishes are one angel. h,i

29:36

As the Nachash his opening faces down, and as the Satan the ches inverts into a tes, open upward; together they spell chet, sin. Unable to tempt Adam and Chava with bodily desire, he offered intellect: their eyes would open to know good from bad. That is the highest wisdom, which is why havdalah is said in the bracha of Chonen HaDaas, and Chava saw the tree was good for understanding. j,k,l

Death is tumah

33:58

The punishment was death, and the Rav explains that death really is tumah, which is why a corpse is the highest degree of tumah. Life is G-dliness: the Gemara counts Hashem as the partner who gives the neshamah. The malach hamaves pulls out that spark and injects tumah in its place, and Parah Adumah is the antidote to the Nachash's venom. m

A mitzvah without understanding as the tikkun

37:49

Why does Parah cure it? Tumas meis came because Adam and Chava wanted understanding beyond their reach, so its tikkun is a mitzvah done without understanding. The Rav says understanding is only a fringe benefit, not a condition for keeping mitzvos. So Parah brings life, which is why it needs mayim chaim, living spring water, and why the tzaddik lives by his emunah. n,o

Two closed doors: Parah and the time of Moshiach

41:19

In the depths of Adar we read a parsha of emunah, and the Rav ties it to the Geulah, when the malach hamaves will be dismissed. We are in ikvesa d'meshicha, as the Tanya and the Chofetz Chaim wrote. Two things are closed to the mind: how death will leave the world, which is how Parah works, and when Moshiach will come. p

44:06

The Rambam writes in his last perek that no one knows the time. Chazal relate that when Yaakov Avinu wanted to reveal the end it was hidden from him, and Daniel did not understand the year the malachim told him. The Gemara in Megillah says Achashverosh miscalculated the seventy years, so the Jews, disappointed, joined his feast. q,r,s

47:05

The Rav compares this to the disappointment after the Holocaust, when the Geulah did not come. Like the secret of Parah, the time when Hashem will sprinkle pure waters on us, as in this week's haftarah, is unknown. t

Judaism is built on waiting

48:47

At these two points the intellect meets a red light: a Jew must have faith and wait. The Rav finds waiting at the base of all the mitzvos. A gentile in a hotel has breakfast in bed; a Jew must wash, daven, wash again, make hamotzi and dip in salt, nearly three hours before his first bite.

52:45

Why? Because the first sin was not waiting. The Ohr HaChaim brings from the mekubalim that the Eitz HaDaas was a vine whose grapes Adam was to press and use for Kiddush on Shabbos, but he ate on Friday. This is why we taste nothing Friday night before Kiddush. u

The egel, Shaul and Dovid: waiting for Moshiach

54:51

At Matan Torah the Jews could have repaired that sin and abolished death, but the golden calf ruined it, and Hashem told them, in the words of Tehillim, that they would die like Adam. They thought Moshe Rabbeinu was late, having miscounted the forty days, and the Satan showed them he was dead. Again, they did not wait. v

58:04

Shmuel told Shaul to wait seven days, but seeing the Pelishtim charge, Shaul offered without him and lost the kingdom. Dovid was told to wait for the footsteps of the malachim on the treetops and held back as the enemy came close; because he waited, Moshiach comes from him. The Rav ends that waiting for Moshiach is waiting for the world to be sprinkled with Parah, bringing life and emunah. w,x

Sources

Torah

  1. d Bamidbar 5:2 text index In the write-up: 9:17
  2. f Bamidbar 19:2 text index In the write-up: 20:25
  3. h apparently Bereishis 3:1 index In the write-up: 26:06
  4. j apparently Bereishis 3:5 index In the write-up: 29:36
  5. k apparently Bereishis 3:6 index In the write-up: 29:36
  6. n apparently Bamidbar 19:17 index In the write-up: 37:49

Nevi'im

  1. o apparently Chavakuk 2:4 index In the write-up: 37:49
  2. t Yechezkel 36:25 text index In the write-up: 47:05
  3. w apparently Shmuel I 13:8-14 index In the write-up: 58:04
  4. x apparently Shmuel II 5:24 index In the write-up: 58:04

Kesuvim

  1. r Daniel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 44:06
  2. v apparently Tehillim 82:6 index In the write-up: 54:51

Talmud Bavli

  1. e apparently Rosh Hashanah 11a index In the write-up: 13:53
  2. i apparently Bava Basra 16a index In the write-up: 26:06
  3. m apparently Niddah 31a index In the write-up: 33:58
  4. s apparently Megillah 11b index In the write-up: 44:06

Midrash

  1. a Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:22

Rishonim

  1. g apparently Rashi, Bamidbar 19:2 index In the write-up: 20:25
  2. q apparently Rambam, Hilchos Melachim ch. 12 index In the write-up: 44:06

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b Zera Kodesh (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:14
  2. c Likutei Moharan (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:14
  3. p Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 41:19
  4. u apparently Ohr HaChaim, beginning of Parshas Vayechi index In the write-up: 52:45

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. l apparently Shemoneh Esrei, bracha of Chonen HaDaas index In the write-up: 29:36

Key points

  1. 1:29 Without a red heifer everyone today is tamei from contact with the dead, but hearing Parshas Parah removes the inner tumah that blocks a person from kedushah.
  2. 10:07 Parshas Parah completes Purim: Purim comforts those outside the camp, while Parah purifies them and lets them enter.
  3. 20:25 Parah, a chok kept without understanding, answers the Satan's claim on Rosh Chodesh Nisan that the Jews have no reason to be redeemed.
  4. 33:58 Death, brought by the sin of the Eitz HaDaas, is itself tumah, and Parah Adumah is the antidote to the venom of the Nachash.
  5. 38:36 The sin of Adam was wanting to understand beyond his reach, and doing a mitzvah without understanding is its tikkun.
  6. 49:14 Judaism is built on waiting, because the first sin was a failure to wait.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 8:44 Why does Parshas Parah come right after Purim?

    Answer: 12:08 Because it completes Purim: Purim comforts those outside the camp, and Parah purifies them so they may enter.

  2. Question: 20:07 Why is Parah read the week before Parshas HaChodesh?

    Answer: 23:29 To neutralize the Satan's claim that there is no reason to redeem the Jews: since they keep a chok without a reason, Hashem can redeem them without one.

  3. Question: 26:06 Where does the yetzer hara come from?

    Answer: 26:45 From the sin of the Eitz HaDaas; before it Adam had no inner yetzer hara, and the Nachash, who is the Satan, brought it in.

  4. Question: 37:39 Why is Parah Adumah the antidote to tumas meis?

    Answer: 37:49 Tumas meis came from Adam and Chava's desire to understand beyond them; a mitzvah done without understanding repairs that sin.

  5. Question: 52:42 Why is Judaism built on waiting?

    Answer: 52:49 Because the first sin was not waiting: Adam ate from the vine on Friday instead of waiting to make Kiddush on Shabbos.

Stories

  1. 15:30 The Ba'al Shem Tov on Rosh Chodesh Nisan

    The Rav relates that on Rosh Chodesh Nisan, when rulers are appointed in Heaven, the Ba'al Shem Tov was very active. If he did not want a certain ruler, or the malach over a nation, he would say so and that one would be deposed.

    In the story: the Baal Shem Tov

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 58:46 Dovid HaMelech waits for the sound in the treetops

    The Rav tells that when Dovid HaMelech went to war against the Pelishtim, the navi told him not to attack until he heard the footsteps of the malachim on the treetops. The Pelishtim charged so close that he saw the pupils of their eyes, yet he kept his sword at his side. Only when he heard the footsteps did he charge, and because he waited, Moshiach comes from him.

    In the story: Dovid HaMelech

Insights

  1. 7:29 Parah and Pur are equal in gematria with the kolel, and Parshas Parah is a step beyond Purim: Purim comforts those left outside the camp, while Parah purifies them and brings them inside.
  2. 20:25 Parah is read just before Parshas HaChodesh so that when the Satan claims there is no reason to redeem the Jews, Hashem can answer that as they keep a chok without a reason, He can redeem them without one.
  3. 27:56 Nachash and Satan share a gematria; the ches of the Nachash, open below, inverts into the tes of the Satan, open above, and the two letters together spell chet, sin.
  4. 30:53 The Nachash could not tempt Adam and Chava with bodily desire, only with a higher intellect, and so the cure for the death he brought is a mitzvah kept without understanding.
  5. 42:34 How Parah Adumah works and when Moshiach will come are the two related matters where the mind meets a red light, since both concern the end of death in the world.
  6. 53:28 The Eitz HaDaas was a vine whose grapes Adam was meant to keep for Kiddush on Shabbos; the golden calf and Shaul's offering repeated that failure to wait, while Dovid, who waited, is the root of Moshiach.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 5:03 The Rav says a person must listen attentively to Parshas Parah and believe that while listening he is being freed from the tumah that blocks him from the kedushah of Nisan and Pesach.
  2. 39:43 The Rav says understanding is not a condition for keeping mitzvos; what one does not understand one still does, out of pure emunah.
  3. 42:27 The Rav says one should not try to figure out how Parah works or when Moshiach will come, but have faith and wait.
  4. 59:37 The Rav says we must wait for Moshiach, for the time when the whole world will be sprinkled with Parah and purified.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Adam HaRishon, Chava, Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, Shlomo HaMelech, Shmuel HaNavi, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Raavad, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu

Terms החודש הזה לכם, ווי העמודים, זוהמא, חבלי משיח, חוקה, טומאת מת, יצר הרע, מחנה, מלאך המות, ענני הכבוד, עץ הדעת, עקבתא דמשיחא, פרה אדומה, קטרוג, קץ, רבונו של עולם, שטן

Report an error on this page